Background
What is before the Court is the application dated 24/6/26 filed by the Applicant seeking the following prayers;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The application dated 24 June 2026 was struck out as an abuse of the court process, with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents. Although the court found that res judicata did not apply because the earlier application had not been heard on the merits, it held that the proper course was to seek reinstatement of that earlier application rather than file a substantially identical fresh application.
15. In the circumstances of this case, the proper course for the Applicant was to move the Court for the reinstatement of the earlier application, rather than to file another application. Accordingly, the application is an abuse of the process of the Court. It is hereby struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Paragraph 15 →
Held. No. The earlier application was dismissed when the Applicant was absent and had not been heard on the merits. It therefore had not conclusively determined the parties' rights in the controversy, and the res judicata objection failed.
Ratio. Res judicata requires an adjudication conclusively determining the parties' rights concerning the matters in controversy. On the circumstances here, dismissal of the earlier application without a merits hearing did not satisfy that requirement.
Issue
11. From the above definition of res judicata, I am of the view that the application is not res judicata because it was not heard on the merits. Although I hold that a dismissal is a judgment of the Court, the circumstances of this case are that it was not heard on the merits. See the case of Shabhal v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 others (Civil Appeal 42 of 2013) [2014] KECA 658 (KLR) (23/04/2014) (Ruling) held that there must be adjudication which conclusively determines the rights of parties in respect of the matters in controversy for res judicata to arise. It was held that:
Paragraph 11 →
Held
12. It is therefore my view that res judicata fails.
Paragraph 12 →
Ratio
11. From the above definition of res judicata, I am of the view that the application is not res judicata because it was not heard on the merits. Although I hold that a dismissal is a judgment of the Court, the circumstances of this case are that it was not heard on the merits. See the case of Shabhal v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 others (Civil Appeal 42 of 2013) [2014] KECA 658 (KLR) (23/04/2014) (Ruling) held that there must be adjudication which conclusively determines the rights of parties in respect of the matters in controversy for res judicata to arise. It was held that:
Paragraph 11 →
Held. Yes. The Applicant filed a new application seeking the same orders after the first application had been dismissed. It should instead have moved for reinstatement of the earlier application. The fresh application was struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Ratio. Filing a similar application after dismissal of an earlier one is an abuse of process; the proper procedural course is to seek reinstatement of the earlier application rather than pursue the same relief through a fresh application.
Issue
15. In the circumstances of this case, the proper course for the Applicant was to move the Court for the reinstatement of the earlier application, rather than to file another application. Accordingly, the application is an abuse of the process of the Court. It is hereby struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Paragraph 15 →
Held
15. In the circumstances of this case, the proper course for the Applicant was to move the Court for the reinstatement of the earlier application, rather than to file another application. Accordingly, the application is an abuse of the process of the Court. It is hereby struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Paragraph 15 →
Ratio
15. In the circumstances of this case, the proper course for the Applicant was to move the Court for the reinstatement of the earlier application, rather than to file another application. Accordingly, the application is an abuse of the process of the Court. It is hereby struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Paragraph 15 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court is the application dated 24/6/26 filed by the Applicant seeking the following prayers;
Paragraph 1 →Whether the Applicant’s application dated 24 June 2026, seeking interim prohibitory and mandatory injunctions concerning construction on the adjoining land, was barred by res judicata following dismissal of an earlier application; and, if not, whether filing…
Rukundo Limited stated that it owns Nairobi/Block 1/625, where Kamiermbe Place stands. Occidental Investments Ltd and Wafi Investments Limited were said to own the adjoining Nairobi Block 19/618 (LR No. 1/626), on which construction was underway. The…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
PET NO E022 OF 2026
_________________________________________________________________
RUKUNDO LIMITED - APPLICANT
VS
OCCIDENTAL INVESTMENTS LTD - 1ST RESPONDENT
WAFI INVESTMENTS LIMITED - 2ND RESPONDENT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY - 3RD RESPONDENT
NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION AUTHORITY - 4TH RESPONDENT
RULING
(In respect of the Applicant's application dated 24/6/26)
1. What is before the Court is the application dated 24/6/26 filed by the Applicant seeking the following prayers;
a. That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue an injunction restraining the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Respondents, whether by themselves, their directors, servants, agents, employees, contractors, sub-contractors or any persons claiming through under or in concert with them, from continuing with any construction works, excavation demolition, scaffolding, erection or any other building operations whatsoever on Land Reference Number Nairobi Block 19/618 [LR NO. 1/626].
b. That pending the hearing and determination of this suit a mandatory injunction do issue compelling the 1st and 2nd defendants/Respondents jointly and severally, forthwith and at their own costs to;
c. Backfill the excavation gap between Land Reference Number Nairobi Block 19/618 (L.R No. 1/626 and Nairobi Block 1/625 with mass concrete or such other suitable structural materials as my be specified by a duly licensed Civil. Structural Engineer, to restore full lateral support to the Plaintiff’s/Applicant’s exposed 600mm x 200mm reinforced concrete strip footing.
d. Remove forthwith all scaffolding platforms, projections and any other structures erected in connection with their construction works which presently encroached upon, project over or overhang the plaintiff’s/Applicant’s land and/or airspace above Nairobi 1/625, Nairobi and
e. Install adequate guarding, catch platforms, debris nets and protective barriers in compliance with Paragraph 474(1) of the National Building Code, 2024, designed to prevent any construction articles, debris, gravel, wet concrete and/or other materials whatsoever from failing onto the Plaintiff’s/Applicant’s property or the public access road thereto.
f. That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, the 4th Defendant/Respondent [National Construction Authority] be and is hereby directed to enforce its closure order issued on the 14th Day of April, 2026 and to ensure that no further construction works are conducted upon Nairobi Block 19/618 [L.R No. 1/626], save with the express leave of this Honourable Court.
g. That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, the 4th Defendant/Respondent [the National Construction Authority] be and is hereby directed to undertake immediate professional supervision and certificate of any remedial works directed by this Honourable Court and to file with this Honourable Court a status report every fourteen (14) days as to compliance.
h. That this Honourable Court do consolidate this suit with Milimani ELC No. E012 of 2024; Rukundo Limited & Another v Occidental Investment Limited & Another for trial and final disposition.
i. That the costs of and incidental to this application be provided for.
j. That the Honourable Court be pleased to issue any other orders or directions as it deems fit to meet the ends of justice.
2. The application is based on the grounds on face of it and the supporting affidavit of Aaron Musiime, a Manager of the Applicant. He deposed that the Applicant is the registered proprietor of Nairobi/Block 1/625, on which Kamiermbe Place is situated. The 1st and 2nd Defendants own the adjoining LR No 19/618 (LR No 1/626), where they are constructing a building. The 1st and 2nd Defendants' construction is encroaching on the Applicant's land; excavation has exposed the Applicant's reinforced concrete on the perimeter wall, leaving it hanging dangerously; the 1st and 2nd Defendants have refused to backfill the excavation and restore the lateral support to the Applicant's perimeter and foundation, thus flouting the safety regulations in the Building Code, 2024. In addition, the 1st and 2nd Defendants have erected structures overhanging the Applicant's property, creating a nuisance and obstructing the open spaces. The effect of the 1st and 2nd Defendants' actions is that the wall has tilted towards the excavation site, with the likely effect of total collapse.
3. In opposing the application, the 1st Respondent raised a preliminary objection on the grounds that the application is res judicata because the Court dismissed it on 25/6/2026; that the Applicant's application is tantamount to inviting the Court to sit on appeal of its own decision; and that the application is an abuse of the process of the Court.
4. The 2nd Respondent opposed the application by the grounds of opposition dated 9/7/26, on the basis that, because of a similar application dated 22/5/26 seeking similar orders to the instant one, the instant application is an attempt to relitigate a dismissed application, and therefore the Applicant is guilty of an abuse of the Court process.
5. The 4th Respondent, in its Replying affidavit sworn by Stephen Mwilu on 13/7/26, deposed that upon receipt of the complaint, its officers inspected the site and suspended the works on the ground of non-compliance. It further deposed that any continuing construction works are illegal and in disregard of the law, and urged the Court to issue orders restraining the 1st and 2nd Respondents from proceeding with any construction works until compliance is ensured.
6. Parties filed written submissions which I have read and considered.
7. The key issues are twofold, namely whether the application is res judicata and, if not, whether it is an abuse of the Court process.
8. It is not in dispute that the Applicant filed an earlier application dated 22/5/26 seeking the same orders, almost word for word. This application was certified for hearing on 9/6/26. On the material date, the Court directed the Respondents to file responses to the application for an inter partes hearing on 15/6/26. On 15/6/26, the Applicant was absent at the hearing of the application. The 1st Respondent moved the Court for dismissal of the application, which the Court allowed. The application was therefore dismissed on 15/6/26.
9. Upon dismissal, the Applicant filed the current application. On the question of whether or not the application is res judicata, the Court refers to the provisions of section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which states as follows;
“No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them can claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such Court.”
10. The learned authors of Mulla, Code of Civil Procedure, 18th Ed. 2012 have observed that the principle of res judicata, as a judicial device on the finality of Court decisions, is subject only to the special scenarios of fraud, mistake or lack of jurisdiction (p.293):
“The principle of finality or res judicata is a matter of public policy and is one of the pillars on which a judicial system is founded. Once a judgment becomes conclusive, the matters in issue covered thereby cannot be reopened unless fraud or mistake or lack of jurisdiction is cited to challenge it directly at a later stage. The principle is rooted to the rationale that issues decided may not be reopened and has little to do with the merit of the decision.”
11. From the above definition of res judicata, I am of the view that the application is not res judicata because it was not heard on the merits. Although I hold that a dismissal is a judgment of the Court, the circumstances of this case are that it was not heard on the merits. See the case of Shabhal v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 others (Civil Appeal 42 of 2013) [2014] KECA 658 (KLR) (23/04/2014) (Ruling) held that there must be adjudication which conclusively determines the rights of parties in respect of the matters in controversy for res judicata to arise. It was held that:
“We accordingly do not find any merit in the appellant’s challenge of the competence of the preliminary objection. Nor do we agree with the appellant that the issue raised in the preliminary objection is res judicata. To constitute res judicata, there must be adjudication which conclusively determines the rights of the parties with regard to all or any of the matters in controversy.”
12. It is therefore my view that res judicata fails.
13. Regarding whether the application is an abuse of the Court process, filing similar applications after the first application was dismissed constitutes abuse of the Court process. Black's Law Dictionary, 10th Edition, defines abuse as “a departure from legal or reasonable use; misuse.” Abuse occurs when one makes an excessive or improper use of a thing, or employs it in a manner contrary to the natural legal rules for its use. Situations that may give rise to an abuse of the Court process are not exhaustive, but they generally involve the Court process not being resorted to fairly, properly, or honestly, to the detriment of the other party. In Patrick Macharia Nderitu vs. Director of Public Prosecutions & 2 Others; Dovey Pharma Limited (Interested Party) [2020] eKLR, the High Court, citing authorities, provided the following examples which constitute abuse of the Court process:
a) Instituting multiplicity of actions on the same subject matter, against the same opponent, on the same issues, or multiplicity of actions on the same matter between the same parties, even where there exists a right to begin the action.
b) Instituting different actions between the same parties simultaneously in different Courts, even though on different grounds.
c) Where two similar processes are used in respect of the exercise of the same right.
d) Where an application for adjournment is sought by a party to an action to bring another application to Court for leave to raise an issue of fact already decided by the Court below.
e) Where there is no iota of law supporting a Court process, or where it is premised on recklessness. The abuse in this instance lies in the inconvenience and inequalities involved in the aims and purposes of the action.
f) Where a party has adopted the system of forum shopping in the enforcement of a conceived right.
g) Where an appellant files an application in respect of a matter which is already the subject of an earlier application. h. Where two actions are commenced, the second asking for relief which may have been obtained in the first.
14. The Court further held as follows;
“Abuse of the Court process creates a factual scenario where a party is pursuing the same matter by two or more Court processes. In other words, a party is involved in some gamble; a game of chance to get the best in the judicial process. Had the Applicant obtained the orders sought in the first application, the second, and the third applications would not have been filed. The Applicant is simply seeking to obtain from the Court the same orders she could not obtain in the first application. Adding the prayer for a conservatory order cannot change the colour or character of the earlier application which was dismissed.”
15. In the circumstances of this case, the proper course for the Applicant was to move the Court for the reinstatement of the earlier application, rather than to file another application. Accordingly, the application is an abuse of the process of the Court. It is hereby struck out with costs to the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
16. Orders accordingly
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J. G. KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered Online in the presence of:
1. Mr. Omondi/Asiimwe for the Plaintiff
2. Ms. Seleke for 1st Defendant
3. Ms. Adano H/B for Ms. Chebet for the 2nd Defendant
4. N/A for the 3rd Defendant
5. N/A for the 4th Defendant
6. CA- Mr Eglon