REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCLC NO. E146 OF 2023
REGISTERED TRUSTEE OF
ARCHDIOCESE OF KISUMU...............................PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
AWAD AUTO LIMITED……………..........……..............................DEFENDANT
AND
PETER MAINA KINGORI......INTENDED INTERESTED PARTY/APPLICANT
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 28th October, 2025 filed by the intended interested party/applicant, and it is expressed to be brought under Articles 50 (1) and 159 (2)(d) of the Constitution, Sections 1A,1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 11, Order 16 Rules 1,3,5,and 6, Order 18 Rule 11, Order 19 Rule 2 and Order 50 Rule 6 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 68,69,78A, 106B, 176 and 177 of the Evidence Act seeking the following orders:-
1. Spent.
2. That pending the hearing and determination of this application, all further steps towards formal proof and/or entry of judgment be stayed to allow the court to give directions on the participation sought herein.
3. That the court’s directions sending the matter to formal proof be set aside, and the suit be re-opened for hearing on the merits with targeted case-management under Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
4. That Mr. Peter Maina King’ori, the sole shareholder and sole director of the defendant, a single member limited liability company, be joined as an interested party and actively participate at the trial on the issues raised in this case.
5. That upon such joinder, leave be granted to the interested party to;
a. File and serve within 7 days a witness statement and a list of documents regarding payment instructions/ transmittals and relevant correspondence he authored or received with respect to the purchase of L.R. 3525/12 and L.R 3525/13.
b. At trial, to lead examination in chief and give viva voce evidence with attendance for cross-examination and re-examination.
6. That in alternative to order 4, the interested party be granted leave to file and serve within 7 days, an affidavit together with a list of documents/annexures and that such affidavit to stand as his evidence in chief at the hearing pursuant to Order 18 Rule 2, with attendance for cross-examination.
7. That upon the intended party lodging the annexed draft summons and paying requisite fees, the court do invoke Order 16 of the Civil Procedure Rules and issue witness summons to the records/compliance officer at Ecobank Kenya Limited to attend court and produce certified banking/assignment records namely; the Deed of Assignment of proceeds dated 19th October 2018, the notice of assignment served on 24th October 2018, facility account ledgers, inward credit advices and internal application/reconciliation of the assigned proceeds, each accompanied by a certificate under Section 106B (4) of the Evidence Act and, where applicable, Banker’s books certification under Section 176-177 of the Evidence Act;
i. That service to be effected by the intended interested party with reasonable conduct money tendered under Order 16 Rule 5.
ii. That where personal attendance is unnecessary, the court directs documents-only production under Order 16 Rule 6 on the same certification terms, and
iii. That liberty to apply on short notice in the event of non- compliance or insufficient certification.
8. That upon the intended party lodging the annexed draft summons and paying requisite fees, the court do invoke Order 16 of the Civil Procedure Rules and issue witness summons to the records/compliance officer at ABC Bank Limited Kisumu Branch, Equity Bank Limited and Cooperative Bank Limited to attend court and produce certified banking/assignment records namely; account ledgers, inward credit advices and internal application/reconciliation of the assigned proceeds, each accompanied by a certificate under Section 106B (4) of the Evidence Act, and where applicable, Bankers’ Books certification under Section 176-177 of the Evidence Act;
i. That service to be effected by the intended interested party with reasonable conduct money tendered under Order 16 Rule 5.
ii. That where personal attendance is unnecessary, the court directs documents-only production under Order 16 Rule 6 on the same certification terms, and
iii. That liberty to apply on short notice in the event of non- compliance or insufficient certification.
9. That if the court finds that the window contemplated by Order 16 rule 1 has lapsed, time be enlarged pursuant to Section 95 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules to permit issuance and service of the witness summons directed in Order 6 and compliance therein.
10. That upon compliance with orders above, the matter be fixed for hearing on priority date, with time-allocation of the court summoned/order 16 witness, and
11. That the costs of this application be in the cause.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of the intended interested party/applicant sworn on even date. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that he is the sole director and shareholder of the defendant, and that this court struck out the defendant’s defence following non-compliance to produce receipts for the particulars referenced in the pleadings.
3. He further deposed that vide the sale agreement dated 10th October 2017, the plaintiff/respondent agreed to sell the suit properties i.e. LR. 3525/12 and 3525/13 whose purchase price was Kshs.228,430,000/. He deposed that while acting for the defendant, he made several payments to the plaintiff/respondent, and that given the passage of time and mixed channels of communication, the statutory mode of payment is maker-produced certified records.
4. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that the cleanest and fairest way to place such evidence before the court without reviving pleadings is through court-issued witness summons under Order 16 directed to Ecobank’s records/compliance officer. That should this court consider that the timing contemplated by Order 16 Rule 1 has lapsed, he prays that the court enlarges the time under Section 95 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules to permit such issuance and service of summons with the production timelines.
5. That being the sole shareholder of the defendant, a decree against the defendant would diminish the value of his sole shareholding and expose him to potential contempt processes to aid execution. Further, it was deposed that as the maker and custodian of key documents, and instructions, excluding him from this case prevents the court from receiving firsthand testimony critical to accurate reconciliation. That if he is not enjoined, the adjudication risks omitting mandatory credits resulting in an inaccurate decree that would occasion real prejudice.
6. The intended interested party deposed that the plaintiff/ respondent suffers no prejudice beyond ordinary case-management compliance. Further, that the directions sought will prevent double recovery.
7. The plaintiff/respondent filed its grounds of opposition dated 13th November, 2025 challenging the instant application on the following grounds:-
1. The applicant, Peter Kingori has been participating in these proceedings as a director of the defendant and his application seeking to be enjoined to this suit in his personal capacity is an abuse of the court process.
2. The defendant is a duly incorporated company and therefore distinct legal entity separate from the applicant who lacks locus standi to be joined in these proceedings as an interested party.
3. The issues raised in the application are res judicata.
8. The intended interested party filed his supplementary affidavit sworn on 24th November, 2025. He reiterated the contents of his supporting affidavit and deposed that there is no provision in the Civil Procedure Act and the Rules or the Evidence Act that bars a witness from being joined as an interested party. That by virtue of his position as the sole shareholder and director of the defendant, he occupies two separate roles. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that from the records of payment in respect of the purchase of the suit property, he injected capital to the defendant, and paid the entire purchase price. He maintained that his presence in the matter is necessary to place before the court maker-authenticated documents.
9. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that this application is entirely different from the earlier application made to add Ecobank as an interested party, and thus the issues in this application have not been determined.
10. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The intended interested party filed his written submissions dated 24th November 2025, while the plaintiff/respondent filed its written submissions dated 16th December, 2025. I have considered the application, the replies thereof and the written submissions filed. In my view, the following issues are for determination:
a. Whether the intended interested party has met the threshold for joinder.
b. Whether the court should set aside the directions sending the matter to formal proof and reopen the suit.
c. Whether the intended interested party should be granted leave to adduce evidence in the manner proposed.
d. Whether the orders for issuance of witness summonses and enlargement of time should issue.
e. Whether the plaintiff/respondent has proved res judicata.
f. Who should bear the costs of the application.
10. Joinder of parties in ordinary civil proceedings is governed principally by Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. The court may, at any stage of the proceedings, add a person whose presence is necessary to enable it effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit. The court of appeal has held that the essential consideration is whether the proposed party has an identifiable stake, legal interest or duty in the proceedings and whether his presence is necessary for the court to completely adjudicate the issues before it. See Onesmus Sintole Saidimu v Sane Ole Saidimu Nkikoora & 5 others [2021] KECA 1079 (KLR).
11. The supreme court in Muruatetu & another v Republic; Kenya National Commission on Human Rights & 2 others (Interested Parties); Death Penalty Project (Intended Amicus Curiae) [2016] KESC 12 (KLR), held as follows:-
“The personal interest or stake that the party has in the matter must be set out in the application. The interest must be clearly identifiable and must be proximate enough, to stand apart from anything that is merely peripheral. The prejudice to be suffered by the intended interested party in case of non-joinder, must also be demonstrated to the satisfaction of the court. It must also be clearly outlined and not something remote.”
12. In this case, the intended interested party/applicant relies on two considerations. First, that he is the sole shareholder and director of the defendant and therefore stands to suffer diminution in the value of his shareholding if judgment is entered against the defendant. Secondly, that he personally made payments towards the purchase price and possesses information and documents relevant to the alleged payments.
13. The first consideration does not meet the threshold for joinder. The fact that a shareholder may suffer an economic consequence from a judgment against a company does not convert the shareholder into a party to the company’s contractual dispute. The principle of separate corporate personality remains fundamental. A company is a legal person distinct from its shareholders and directors, even where one person is the sole shareholder and director. Thus, the defendant’s liability under the sale agreement, if any, is not automatically the personal liability of its shareholder or director. In addition, the interested party/ applicant has not demonstrated that the plaintiff/respondent seeks a personal remedy against him, or that any issue concerning his personal rights or obligations must necessarily be determined before the dispute between the parties can be completely adjudicated.
14. The second consideration demonstrates that the intended interested party/applicant personally participated in the transaction giving rise to these proceedings, including issuing payment instructions and making payments towards the purchase of the suit properties. His contention is that he possesses material information and documents necessary to establish the payments made to the plaintiff/respondent and to facilitate a proper reconciliation of the purchase price. The interested party/applicant asserted that he may be exposed to contempt proceedings during execution.
15. While at this stage this concern remains speculative, the same cannot be ignored. I note that the interested party/applicant proposed participation is essentially to place before the court evidence which, according to him, would establish payments made by him on behalf of the defendant. I am alive to the fact that the defence was struck out, and being a director of the defendant, allowing him to place his evidence on record would be akin to reopening the defendant’s case.
16. Upon careful evaluation of the circumstances of this case, I find that the interested party/applicant has demonstrated an identifiable interest arising not merely from his shareholding, but also from his alleged personal involvement in the transactions forming the subject matter of this dispute. His participation would to an extent avail him the opportunity to be present in court in the event adverse orders are issued against the defendant. However, such joinder will only allow limited participation during formal proof as will be directed later. Let me emphasize that the joinder of the interested party/applicant does not have the effect of reinstating the defendant’s struck-out defence or conferring upon him an independent cause of action. I further note that no prejudice has been demonstrated by the plaintiff/respondent should the said joinder be allowed.
17. On the second issue, the interested party/applicant seeks to set aside the directions sending the matter to formal proof and to reopen the suit for hearing on the merits. The foundation for this prayer is that important evidence concerning payment of the purchase price has not been placed before the court. There is no dispute that the defendant’s defence was struck out following non-compliance with an order of the court. The effect of striking out the defence is material. It does not merely regulate the manner in which the defendant participates in the proceedings; it removes the defence from the record and consequently limits the issues that can properly be litigated at the formal proof stage.
18. The interested party/applicant now seeks, through his personal joinder, to introduce a witness statement, documents and viva voce evidence concerning the very matters that formed the subject of the defendant’s defence, namely payments towards the purchase price. In my view, allowing the application in the manner proposed would substantially circumvent the consequence of the order striking out the defendant’s defence. It would permit the sole director and shareholder of the defendant to step into the proceedings in a different capacity and introduce evidence for the purpose of establishing the defendant’s pleaded case after that defence has ceased to be on record.
19. While Article 50(1) of the Constitution guarantees a fair hearing, Article 159(2)(d), however, does not operate as a licence to disregard substantive procedural orders or to reopen concluded interlocutory steps merely because a party considers a different procedural route more advantageous. The overriding objective provisions likewise require the court to facilitate the just, expeditious and proportionate resolution of disputes, while protecting parties from procedural prejudice.
22. The court’s inherent jurisdiction under Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act is intended to meet the ends of justice and prevent abuse of the process. It cannot properly be invoked to defeat a specific order previously made by the court in circumstances where no sufficient basis has been demonstrated for setting that order aside. More importantly, the evidence sought to be introduced is not evidence relating to a new and independent personal claim by the interested party/applicant. It is evidence intended to support the defendant’s position concerning payment of the purchase price. In substance, therefore, the application seeks to revive a defence which has already been struck out. I find no basis for setting aside the directions sending the matter to formal proof or for reopening the suit on the terms sought.
23. The interested party/applicant alternatively seeks leave to file an affidavit which would stand as his evidence-in-chief, with attendance for cross-examination. The difficulty with this prayer is not the admissibility or otherwise of affidavit evidence in the abstract. The difficulty is the purpose for which the evidence is sought to be introduced. In an ordinary suit such as this one, the interested party/applicant is not a party to the suit. He cannot, by describing himself as an interested party, acquire a right to introduce evidence on behalf of a defendant whose defence has been struck out. If he is a material witness to matters properly before the court, the procedural mechanism for procuring his attendance is witness summons, subject to the applicable rules. Joinder is not a necessary precondition to a person being summoned as a witness. I find that the interested party/applicant has not established a basis for the orders sought under prayers 5 and 6.
24. On the fourth issue, the interested party/applicant seeks summons directed to Ecobank Kenya Limited, ABC Bank Limited Kisumu Branch, Equity Bank Limited and Co-operative Bank Limited for production of specified banking and assignment records. Order 16 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides the mechanism by which a person may be summoned to attend court to give evidence or to produce documents. The fact that the interested party/applicant is not joined as a party does not preclude the witness summons being sought where the proposed evidence is relevant to the issues properly before the court. However, the summons procedure cannot be used to introduce matters which are outside the issues remaining for determination after the defendant’s defence was struck out. The documents sought must relate to matters properly falling for determination at the formal proof.
25. Further, the interested party/applicant has not sufficiently demonstrated, from the material presently before the court, that every category of document sought from each of the named banks is necessary for the determination of the plaintiff's claim. The application makes broad reference to payment instructions, ledgers, inward credit advices and internal reconciliations, but the court must guard against converting formal proof into a fresh discovery exercise or reopening the defendant’s case through third-party records. The prayer for witness summonses is in my view premature in its present form. This does not mean that relevant third-party documents can never be produced. It means only that the proposed summons must be considered within the confines of the issues that remain alive for determination and the applicable evidentiary rules.
26. Prayer 9 seeks enlargement of time under Section 95 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules in the event that the court finds that the period contemplated by Order 16 Rule 1 has lapsed. This court undoubtedly possesses jurisdiction to enlarge time. Section 95 of the Civil Procedure Act permits enlargement of a period fixed or granted by the court, while Order 50 Rule 6 empowers the court to enlarge time even after expiry of the prescribed period. Since the court has declined the proposed witness summons in their present form, there is no useful purpose in enlarging time for their issuance.
27. On the issue of res judicata, I note that the earlier application concerned the proposed joinder of Ecobank Kenya Limited, whereas the present application concerns the personal participation of the defendant’s sole director and shareholder. The plaintiff/respondent has not demonstrated that the specific question of his joinder was directly and substantially in issue and finally determined in the earlier application. I therefore find that the doctrine of res judicata does not bar the present application.
28. From the above, I find merit in the notice of motion dated 28th October, 2025 only to a limited extent, and I grant the following orders:-
i. Mr. Peter Maina King’ori is hereby joined in these proceedings as an interested party.
ii. For clarity, his participation in the formal proof hearing is only limited to cross-examination of the plaintiff’s witnesses and not in production of any documents.
iii. Costs of the application shall be in the cause.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
22/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant
Mr. Ahomo holding brief for Mr. Amuga for the Plaintiff/Respondent
Ms. Anyango Opiyo for the Intended Interested Party/Applicant
Ms. Awiti for the Defendant/Respondent