REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCL MISC APPL. NO. E176 OF 2024
OYOMBA MOSOTA &
NYAMWEYA ADVOCATES……………….…………ADVOCATE/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
DEBORAH ACHIENG ADUDA
& RENE JOHNY DERKX…......................................CLIENTS/APPLICANTS
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the chamber summons dated 16th September, 2025 filed by the clients/applicants and it is expressed to be brought pursuant to Paragraph 11(2) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order and Sections 1A,1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act seeking the following orders:-
1. That the honourable court be pleased to vacate and set aside in its entirety the ruling and reasoning of the learned taxing officer honourable T. E Marienga (DR) dated and delivered on 19/12/2024, taxing the advocate/respondent’s bill of costs dated 2/09/2024 at KES 1,354,229.64.
2. That the honourable court be pleased to re-assess items no.1,2,204,205,206,207 and 209 the quantum of total fees and value added tax chargeable in the advocate-client bill of costs.
3. That in the alternative to prayer 2 above, the honourable court be pleased to remit the bill of costs dated 2/09/2024 for re-assessment of items no. 1,2,204,205,206,207 and 209 the quantum of total fees and value added tax chargeable before the taxing officer or a different taxing officer with appropriate directions thereof.
4. That the costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of Deborah Achieng Aduda sworn on 16th September, 2025. The clients/applicants deposed that the taxing officer in a ruling delivered on 19th December, 2024 awarded a sum of Kshs.1,354,229.64/- to the advocate/respondent out of which a sum of Kshs.462,000/- comprised instruction fees in respect of services in ELC no. 1047 of 2013-Deborah Achieng Aduda & Another v Florence Seyanoi Kibera. According to them, the taxing officer misdirected herself on the principles of law applicable and awarded fees which is grossly exaggerated and excessive.
3. The clients/applicants deposed that the taxing officer awarded Kshs.462,000/- as instruction fees when the value of the subject matter was not ascertainable from the judgment. Further, that in assessing the bill of costs using an unascertained value, she arrived at wrong instruction fees, wrong getting up fees and the wrong quantum of the total fees and the value added tax payable. For this reason, they seek that the ruling be set aside and remitted for fresh taxation as regards items 1, 2, 204, 205, 206, 207 and 209.
4. The application was opposed through the replying affidavit of Collins Ochieng Oyomba sworn on 9th December, 2025. The advocate/respondent deposed that the taxing officer properly exercised her discretion, having established the value of the subject matter from the sale agreement dated 16th February, 2012 which indicated the purchase price as Kshs.28,000,000/-. He further deposed that the alleged sum of USD 24,226 payments related to other matters undertaken on behalf of the client/applicants, while the admitted payment of Kshs.250,000/- was duly deducted from the taxed costs.
5. In response thereto, the client/applicant filed a further affidavit sworn on 24th March, 2026. While reiterating the contents of the supporting affidavit, the clients/applicants deposed that the judgment in ELC no. 1047 of 2013 required the advocate/respondent to subdivide and excise 1 acre from the mother title at a cost deductible from the balance of the purchase price and in the absence of a government valuer’s report or stamp duty assessment invoice, the purchase price in the sale agreement cannot be the value of the suit property and is not a basis for instruction fees.
6. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The clients/applicants filed their written submissions dated 25th March, 2026 while the advocate/respondent filed written submissions dated 9th December, 2025. I have considered the application, the replies thereof, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether the taxing officer erred in taxing the advocate-client bill of costs dated 2nd September, 2024 to warrant interference of the same.
7. In the case of Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board [2005] eKLR, the court of appeal held that a judge will not ordinarily interfere with a taxing officer's discretion unless an error of principle is demonstrated. Similarly, in First American Bank of Kenya v Shah & Others [2002] 1 EA 64, the high court held that interference is justified where the assessment is founded on an error of principle or is so manifestly excessive as to justify an inference of such error.
8. On instruction fees, the court of appeal in Joreth Ltd v Kigano & Associates [2002] KECA 153 (KLR) held that the value of the subject matter ought to be ascertained from the pleadings, judgment or settlement between the parties. Where the value is not ascertainable, the taxing officer is entitled to exercise discretion, taking into account the nature and importance of the matter, the interests of the parties, the conduct of the proceedings and other relevant circumstances. In this case, the taxing officer pointed out that the bill of costs relates to Nairobi ELC No. 1047 of 2013 and not any other matter. She found that the dispute concerned the enforcement of an agreement for sale of L.R. No. 5892/22 whose purchase price of Kshs.28,000,000 is confirmed in the sale agreement dated 16th February, 2012 and proceeded to assess instruction fees at Kshs.462,000/- under the applicable Advocates (Remuneration) Order.
9. The clients/applicants contend that the taxing officer ought not to have relied on the sale agreement in the absence of a valuation report or an express finding on value in the judgment. I am not persuaded by this argument. The subject matter of the proceedings was the enforcement of the sale agreement itself. The consideration stipulated therein was therefore relevant to the assessment of instruction fees. I find that the taxing officer did not err in assessing the instruction fees. Equally, the clients/applicants have not demonstrated that the figure of Kshs.28,000,000/- was an irrelevant consideration or that the applicable remuneration scale was incorrectly applied.
10. The clients/applicants further challenge the assessment of Kshs.154,000/- as getting-up fees. The impugned ruling establishes that the matter proceeded to hearing and that the taxing officer awarded getting-up fees at one-third of the assessed instruction fees. Having found no demonstrated error in the assessment of instruction fees, and there being no sufficient basis for finding that the requirements for getting-up fees were absent, I find no reason to interfere with this item.
11. Regarding the alleged previous payments, the clients/applicants contend that the advocate/respondent received USD 24,226 between June 2017 and June 2021. The advocate/respondent disputed that the payments related to ELC No. 1047 of 2013 and maintained that they were made in respect of several other proceedings undertaken on the clients/applicants’ behalf. The impugned ruling demonstrates that the taxing officer considered the rival allegations and the material presented in support thereof. She found no sufficient evidence linking the disputed USD payments to the fees payable in ELC No. 1047 of 2013. The burden of establishing that the payments ought to have been credited against the particular bill of costs lay upon the clients/applicants under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act. The mere fact of payment, without sufficient evidence connecting it to the specific matter under taxation, does not establish that the taxing officer erred in declining the proposed deduction.
12. The clients/applicants also contend that Kshs.200,000/- was paid in 2013 and that Kshs.250,000/- was subsequently paid towards legal fees. While admitting payment of the sum of Kshs.250,000/-, the computation in the impugned ruling expressly deducts these amounts from the total assessed costs. I find that the admitted payment was duly accounted for. As regards the disputed sum of Kshs.200,000/-, the clients/applicants have not demonstrated sufficient evidentiary basis for disturbing the taxing officer’s finding.
13. On filing fees, the clients/applicants contend that they paid Kshs.73,800/- directly to the court and that the same ought not to have been allowed in favour of the advocate/respondent. In the ruling, the taxing officer scrutinized the claimed disbursements, allowed the amounts she considered supported and taxed off those not satisfactorily established. There is no demonstration, by reference to a specific court receipt and corresponding taxed item, that the amount awarded constituted a duplicated payment.
14. Finally, the clients/applicants challenge the computation of VAT and the overall amount awarded. The Taxing Master's computation is arithmetically consistent. The 50% enhancement was applied to the assessed fees, and VAT was calculated at 16% of the resulting subtotal. There is no demonstration of a specific misapplication of the relevant remuneration provisions sufficient to warrant interference. Let me say this, a reference is not an invitation to this court to undertake taxation afresh merely because a party is dissatisfied with the amount awarded. The clients/applicants must demonstrate a misdirection in principle or an assessment so unreasonable as to warrant judicial intervention.
15. From the above, it is my finding that the taxing officer properly exercised her discretion in taxing the bill of costs dated 2nd September, 2024. Therefore, the chamber summons dated 16th September, 2025 lacks merit and the same is hereby dismissed. Each party to bear its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
22/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant
Ms. Omamo holding brief for Mr. Oyomba for the Advocate/Respondent
Mr. Kinyanjui holding brief for Mr. Litoro for the Client/Applicant