Land law

Owuor v Umagara Wiyonere Company Ltd & 4 others [2026] KEELC 6806 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mbogo C.G.

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The petitioner filed the petition dated 29th April, 2024 seeking the following prayers:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

I find that the evidence before the court establishes on a balance of probabilities, that a portion of the land was reserved for public purposes and, in particular, for a community/social centre. However, the evidence does not sufficiently establish that the entire parcel is public land. Consequently, prayer (a), insofar as it seeks a declaration that the entire parcel of land is public property has not been proved to the required…

Paragraph 19 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLPET NO. E027 OF 2024

IN THE MATTER OF: ARTICLES 1, 2, 10, 19, 20, 22, 23(3), 27, 28, 40, 43(1)(b), 50, 53, 57, 60 & 258 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: CONTRAVENTION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS UNDER ARTICLES 22, 23, 27, 28, 29, 43 & 48 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: THREATENED VIOLATION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS

BETWEEN

BENARD ONYANGO OWUOR........................................................PETITIONER

VERSUS

UMAGARA WIYONERE COMPANY LIMITED…..................……...RESPONDENT

AND

NAIROBI CITY COUNTY…………......................…………..1ST INTERESTED PARTY

THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR……….....................……2ND INTERESTED PARTY

DIRECTOR OF PHYSICAL PLANNING…...................…3RD INTERESTED PARTY

NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION……....................……..4TH INTERESTED PARTY

JUDGMENT

1. The petitioner filed the petition dated 29th April, 2024 seeking the following prayers:-

a. A declaration that all that parcel of land known as land reference no. 28395 situated along Kasarani-Mwiki road, Kasarani Constituency is public property.

b. A declaration that the threatened eviction of the petitioner and the 2000 traders from that parcel of land known as land reference no. 28395 is a violation of the petitioner’s fundamental rights to inherent human dignity, security of the person, right to life, right to equitable access of land guaranteed by Articles 26(1), (3), 28,29(c),(f) and 40 of the Constitution of Kenya.

c. A permanent injunction does issue restraining the respondent whether by itself, agents, employees, servants or any person claiming under or through it from interfering with the petitioner’s occupation, use and utilization of that parcel of land known as land reference no. 28395 situated along Kasarani-Mwiki road.

d. Costs of the petition be provided for.

2. The facts as stated in the petition is that the petitioner and 2000 traders carry on their business at the public market located on LR no. 28395 the suit property along Kasarani-Mwiki road. The suit property is public property which was earmarked for the establishment of a public market. Through the gazette notice 307 vol. CXVIII published on 22nd January 2016, the 4th interested published recommended among others that a portion of the suit property be excised for the social centre which will be held in trust by the 1st interested party for the benefit of Mwiki residents.

3. The petitioner stated that together with the other traders, they have been carrying on their business with the express permission of the 1st interested party, hence their occupation is lawful. Further, that in a letter dated 19th December 2023, addressed to the permanent secretary state department of lands, the 1st interested party confirmed that the suit property is a surrender reserved for public use. The petitioner went on to state that the respondent has been threatening the traders with eviction in blatant violation of their right to the use of the property, and when confronted, the respondent argued that it is private property.

4. Being public, the petitioner asserted, the actions of the respondent are malafides and are aimed at defeating the public interest over the suit property. The petitioner stated that as a result, their right to property under Article 40 has been threatened.

5. The petition was supported by the affidavit of the petitioner sworn on even date on his behalf and behalf of about 2000 traders. He reiterated the facts of the petition which are well noted.

6. The 1st interested party filed its replying affidavit sworn on 24th May, 2024 by Dominic Mutegi, the director, development management. In support of the petition, the 1st interested party deposed that the suit property was hived off from LR no. 8469/4 and measures about 5 acres valued at Kshs.500,000,000/-. Further, that the suit property was set aside by the defunct Nairobi city commission in a meeting held on 16th November, 1983 as public purpose plot and that it has all along been a public utility land.

7. The 1st interested party deposed that the said surrender was done in accordance with the law as evidenced by the letters dated 30th December 1983, 14th August 1984, 24th September 1985, and 30th October, 1989. He deposed that based on the survey plan and the approved scheme plan, the suit property is public land earmarked for the establishment of a public market. The 1st interested party further deposed that being public land, any title held by the respondent or any other private entity is illegal as the procedure for converting public land to private land was not adhered to.

8. The respondent filed its replying affidavit in opposition to the petition sworn on 16th December, 2024 by the director, John William Maina Kamau. The respondent deposed that the petition does not raise constitutional issues, and that the alleged violations or lack thereof, is an active matter before court that is yet to be determined. Further, that the suit is res judicata by virtue of Nairobi ELC case no. E142 of 2023 which is active before the court and which was dealt with by the 4th interested party. Thus, the respondent deposed that this petition is a waste of court’s time and a ploy to forum seek and should be dismissed with costs. Further, that this court has jurisdiction to determine breach of fundamental rights and there is no justification why the same were not raised in ELC no. 142 of 2023.

9. Brian A. Ikol, the director of legal affairs and alternative dispute resolution filed his replying affidavit sworn on 14th March, 2025 on behalf of the 4th interested party in support of the petition. The 4th interested party deposed that the suit property is public land and that they received a complaint from Mwiki residents, carried out a review and made a determination on the suit property dated 2nd November, 2015. That in its determination, the 4th interested party ordered the respondent to surrender one acre from the suit property for a community centre and the same be vested in the 1st interested party to hold in trust for the residents of Mwiki.

10. The petition was canvassed through written submissions. The petitioner filed his written submissions dated 18th September, 2024. The respondent filed its written submissions dated 30th January 2026, while the 1st and 4th interested parties filed their written submissions dated 9th June, 2025 and 24th June, 2026 respectively. I have carefully analyzed and considered the petition, the replies thereof, the evidence and the written submissions. In my view, the following issues arise for determination:

i. Whether the petition is barred by the existence of Nairobi ELC Case No. E142 of 2023.

ii. Whether the petitioner has established that the suit property is public land.

iii. Whether the petitioner has established violation or threatened violation of the constitutional rights pleaded.

11. The respondent contends that the present petition is res judicata by reason of Nairobi ELC Case No. E142 of 2023. Also, and in the same breadth, the respondent stated that the said case is still pending. While I note that this issue was determined in a ruling delivered on 6th November 2025, it is evident that Nairobi ELCC no. E142 of 2023 is pending before Lady Justice Christine Ochieng. More particularly, is that the ruling in paragraph 14 affirmed that the instant petition raises constitutional questions which ought to be determined substantively.

12. On the second issue, Article 62 of the Constitution sets out the categories of public land. The status of a particular land as public land must, however, be established by evidence. The burden lies on the party who asserts the existence of a fact to prove it. The petitioner asserts that the property is public land which has been set aside for public purpose and use as a public market. The 1st interested party supported this position and deposed that the property was set aside as a public purpose plot and has all along been public utility land. The 4th interested party likewise stated that it reviewed the complaint concerning the property and made a determination concerning surrender of one acre for a community centre.

13. These assertions are disputed by the respondent, which maintains that the property is private property, and in any case, it was asked to surrender only one acre. In support of the petition, the 1st interested party annexed a copy of the minutes of proceedings of the commission for the month of November and December 1983. Under minute 70, it was resolved that the application for sub-division in respect of plot LR no. 8469/4 Kasarani be recommended to the government for approval including that public purpose plots and open spaces be surrendered to the government free of cost. The letter by Nairobi city commission dated 30th December, 1983 confirmed the resolution of the meeting held on 16th November, 1983 that all pubic purpose plots coloured red on the deposited plan for primary schools, secondary school, nursery school, and community and shopping centres to be surrendered to the government free of cost. The same was reiterated in a letter dated 14th August, 1984 by the ministry of lands and settlement to M/s Mukinye Enterprises Ltd.

14. In a letter dated 30th October 1989, the subdivision of LR no. 8469 was accorded provisional approval and blanket approvals to subplots A,B and C only. In a letter dated 2nd November, 2015 by the 4th interested party and in respect of the suit property, it was determined that the allocation of the commercial centre was upheld by the respondent was directed to excise a portion of land for a social centre which is a public utility land. The said social centre would be allocated to the County government to hold in trust for Mwiki residents. According to the gazette notice published on 17th July, 2017 published by the 4th interested party, it was determined that the respondent would excise one acre for a community centre.

15. The documentary evidence establishes that, in the course of the subdivision of LR no. 8469/4, provision was made for public-purpose plots and open spaces which were to be surrendered to the government free of cost. This demonstrates that public-purpose land was contemplated and provided for in the subdivision scheme. The letter dated 30th October, 1989 is also material, and read together with the earlier correspondence, the evidence demonstrates that the subdivision was subject to the reservation and surrender of the identified public-purpose plots.

16. More importantly, the subsequent administrative proceedings concerning the suit property provide further evidence of the treatment of the property as land reserved for a public utility. By its determination dated 2nd November 2015, the 4th interested party addressed the complaint concerning the suit property and directed that a portion thereof be excised for a social centre, to be held by the county government in trust for the residents of Mwiki. The gazette notice published on 17th July, 2017 similarly records the determination that the respondent would excise one acre for a community centre.

17. The evidence on record has established the existence of a public-purpose reservation arising from the subdivision of L.R. No. 8469/4 and, more particularly, establishes that a portion of the land comprising the suit property was earmarked for a community/social centre as public utility land. However, the petitioner’s prayer is not limited to a declaration that the one-acre portion reserved for the community centre is public land. It seeks a declaration that all that parcel of land known as LR. no. 28395 is public property. The court must therefore determine that question on the evidence relating specifically to the whole parcel.

18. The fact that the original subdivision scheme required public-purpose plots and open spaces to be surrendered, and that a subsequent determination required one acre of the suit property to be excised for a community centre, does not, establish that the entire parcel subsequently became public land. There must be evidence identifying the suit property as a whole as the land surrendered or vested in the government or otherwise falling within one of the categories of public land under Article 62 of the Constitution.

19. I find that the evidence before the court establishes on a balance of probabilities, that a portion of the land was reserved for public purposes and, in particular, for a community/social centre. However, the evidence does not sufficiently establish that the entire parcel is public land. Consequently, prayer (a), insofar as it seeks a declaration that the entire parcel of land is public property has not been proved to the required standard.

20. From the above, I find no merit in the petition dated 29th April 2024 and the same is hereby dismissed. The respondent is awarded the costs of the petition.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT

THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

22/10/2026.

In the presence of:-

Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant

Mr. Mushe holding brief for Mr. Mutunga for the Petitioner

Mr. Wanyoike for the Respondent

Mr. Duncan Mutie for Mr. Muriuki for the 1st Interested Party

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder