Background
The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s notice of Motion dated 29th October 2025 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s notice of Motion dated 29th October 2025 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Having considered the Notice of Motion application, the replying affidavit and the submissions filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
Paragraph 14 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLA E164 OF 2025
FREDRICK ODHIAMBO OLILO
t/a BARBER HACKS & SPA ……………………………………..… TENANT/APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
MAYHOUSE LIMITED ………..……….….………………LANDLORD/ RESPONDENT
(Being an Appeal from the Ruling and Order of the Business Premises Rent Tribunal at Nairobi (Hon. Gad Chemoiyai) dated 14th August 2025 Nairobi BPRT Case Number E368 of 2025 - FREDRICK ODHIAMBO OLILO t/a BARBER HACKS & SPA -vs- MAYHOUSE LIMITED)
RULING
Introduction
1. The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s notice of Motion dated 29th October 2025 seeking the following orders;
1. Spent
2. THAT pending the hearing and determination of this Application, and on interim basis the Honourable Court be pleased to issue an order compelling the Respondent to reinstate the Applicant into the demised premises, return the Applicant’s furniture and fittings carted away and to generally comply with this court’s order issued on 7th October 2025.
3. THAT this court do issue orders compelling the Respondent to reinstate the Applicant into the demised premises, return the Applicant’s furniture and fittings carted away and to compensate the Applicants for the losses and damages as per the attached schedule.
4. THAT pending the hearing and determination of this Application, and on interim basis this court do find Christopher Musau, the Respondent’s Managing Director is in contempt of this court’s orders dated 7th October 2025.
5. THAT this upon making the finding in (4) above, this court do proceed to pass appropriate sentence to the said Christopher Musau including but not limited to committal to jail for a period of six months or any other period that this court deems fit or any other sentence that this court deems fit and appropriate in the circumstances.
6. THAT the OCS Central Police station, Nairobi be ordered to effect the court orders herein.
7. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to give any such other and/or further order(s) as it may deem fit.
8. Costs of this application.
2. The application was premised on grounds that the appellant being dissatisfied with the decision delivered on the 14th August 2025 in the BPRT in case no E368 OF 2025 had preferred this appeal and sough for stay of execution orders which orders were granted on the 7th November 2025 to extend till 25th November 2025.
3. That the said orders were served on the Respondent who preferred another application seeking to set aside the orders but the court directed the application will be heard with the appellants on the 25th November 2025.
4. That despite this stay of execution orders being in force the Respondent broke into the Applicant’s premises disrupting business, carrying away the Applicant’s goods and eventually locking the Applicant out hence this application.
Reply
5. The Respondent opposed the application in a replying affidavit sworn by one Christopher Musau on the 4th February 2026.He deponded that the orders sought after were mandatory in nature which are only granted in clear cases.
6. That the application for contempt was misconceived as the orders which the Applicant is claiming the Respondent’s director is in contempt to, were unambiguous as to what exactly it was staying in regards to the orders of the tribunal. That no positive orders had been issued in the BPRT that could be stayed.
7. He further deponed that the appellant had moved out voluntarily and could not prove that indeed the Respondent were the ones that evicted him and that being the case the orders for reinstatement were overtaken by events, the Applicant having given vacant possession.
8. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions with the appellant/Applicant filing submissions dated 19th January 2026 whereas the Respondent filed submissions dated 2nd June 2026.
9. Counsel for the Applicant reiterated the fact that the Respondent was in contempt of court orders having been served with the said orders yet proceeded to issue a vacation notice to the Applicant and hence subject to punishment for wilfully disobeying the court orders. Counsel relied on several case laws including Board of Governors Moi High Scjhool Kabarak Vs Malcom Bell & Another (supreme court petition no 6 & 7 of 2013)
10. Counsel further submitted that the standard required for proof of contempt had been established which is knowledge of the court orders, which orders were understood and deliberately disobeyed the same relying on Kariuki Mate & Another Vs Martin Nyaga Wambora & Another CA 24/2014
11. The Respondent in rebuttal submissions reiterated the contents of his replying affidavit submitted that the orders of 7th October 2025 were incapable of enforcement since the orders of the BPRT were negative that dismissed a claim and there was nothing that the parties were to refrain from doing relying on the case of Dickson Sinkeet Mapi (Suing as the Personal Representative of Benjamin Mapi Ole Partimo– Deceased) Vs Mutunkei [2021] KECA 235 (KLR),
12. Counsel also submitted that the Applicant had not proved contempt of court to the required standard since the elements required had not been proved being the order was clear and unambiguous, that the Respondent had knowledge of proper notice and that the Respondent acted in breach and deliberately. That the Applicant had not demonstrated forceful eviction by the Respondent
13. Counsel further submitted that the standard of proof in contempt matters was higher due to consequences of it including imprisonment and hence ought to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Analysis and determination
14. Having considered the Notice of Motion application, the replying affidavit and the submissions filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
15. In the instant suit the basis of the prayer for the Respondent to be cited for contempt is the Applicant’s contention that contrary to the orders issued by the court on 7th October 2025, the Respondent had proceeded to evict the
Applicant/tenant from the suit property. The Respondent however denies that they had evicted the Applicant and aver that the Applicant in his own volition to prevent more accumulation of rent vacated on the 25th October 2025.
16. The elements that must be proved in an application for civil contempt were laid out in Katsuri Limited Vs Kapurchand Depar Shah (2016) KEHC 6447 (KLR) as follows:-
a) the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the Defendant;
b) the Defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order;
c) the Defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order; and
d) the Defendant's conduct was deliberate.
17. The first element is that the terms of the order must be clear and unambiguous and must be binding on the Respondent. As the Respondent in this Appeal as well as the present Application, there is no doubt that the interim order of stay was binding on him. As to the clarity of the order, the Respondent claims that the order was ambiguous as it was not clear on what exactly he was restrained from doing. The Respondent further claims that the order sought to be stayed was a negative order that did not need the Respondent to refrain from doing anything.
18. The order that is subject of this present application was made on 7th October 2025. On the said date, the court allowed the application dated 6th October 2025 in terms of prayer (3) which was to the effect that:-
“That pending hearing and determination of this application the honourable court be pleased to stay the execution of orders emanating from the ruling of the BPRT delivered on 14th August 2025 in case no E368 of 2025 Fredrick Odhiambo Olilo t/a Barber Hacks & Spa Vs Mayhouse limited”
19. From a reading of the above order, it was clear that the Respondent was stopped from executing the ruling delivered in the tribunal. There is no ambiguity as to what ruling was the subject of the Application dated 6th October 2025. The Respondent through their director has deponed that indeed there was a ruling actually delivered thus he cannot claim that there was any ambiguity as to the ruling sought to be stayed by the Court’s order.
20. The Respondent also urged that the ruling did not impose any positive obligation on them capable of being executed. However, a stay of execution of the trial court’s ruling in this case would mean that the orders issued were intended to have the Appellant vacate the suit property within 60 days or be evicted at the end of the 60 days by the Respondent were not operational until the Application herein was heard.
21. The second requirement is that the Respondent must have had knowledge of, or proper notice of the terms of the order which notice of order has not been denied by the Respondent.
22. The third limb is that it must be shown that the Respondent has acted in breach of the terms of the order. The act complained of in the instant application is that the Respondent has evicted the tenant from the suit premises and locked him out despite the existence of the court orders of stay. In response to this allegation, the Respondent contends that the appellant /Applicant vacated the suit premises on his own and has not proved that indeed the Respondent is the one that caused the eviction.
23. To determine whether the Respondent has acted contrary to the court’s order, it is necessary to consider what the effect of the stay order. The order prohibited the Respondent from evicting the appellant from the premises until the application was to be heard meaning the entire ruling was to be stayed temporarily. The appellant has alluded that he was evicted whereas the Respondent has indicated that he vacated on his own. The Applicant has not substantiated the claims of eviction by the Respondent. The photographic evidence attached to the supporting affidavit does not shed any light in regards to these allegations. As a result of the foregoing, the Respondent’s conduct cannot be said to have been deliberate, wilful and intentional disobedience of a court order as the act itself has not been proved.
24. In Beijing Industrial Designing & Researching Institute v Lagoon Development Limited (2015) KECA 365 (KLR), the Court of Appeal was clear on the standard of proof in civil contempt, and held that: -
“Contempt of court proceedings are quasi-criminal (see In Re Bramblevale Ltd (1970) CH 128). That explains the reason why in this jurisdiction the standard of proof in contempt of court case has been held to be “higher than proof on the balance of probabilities, almost but not exactly, beyond reasonable doubt.” (See Mutitika v Baharini Farm (1982-88) 1 KAR, 863. Clearly, criminal or quasi-criminal proceedings ought not to be terminated at the exclusive instance or discretion of the party alleged to be a perpetrator of a criminal or
quasi-criminal act.”
25. In this instance, it is the appellants claim as against the Respondent’s claim. As a result, the Appellant has failed to prove his claims to the required standard. Being that contempt has not been proved the others prayers of reinstatement into the suit premises cannot issue as already submitted the issue of eviction has not been proved by the Applicant. The Application must therefore fail.
Final disposition
The upshot of the above is that;
i. The Application dated 29th October 2025 is without merit and the same is hereby dismissed.
ii. The costs of this application shall abide in the appeal.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 22nd day of October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Ouma for the Applicant
Mr. Kipkoech for the Respondent
Philomena W . Court Assistant