Background
The applicant filed the originating summons dated 21st November, 2025 seeking the following orders:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The applicant filed the originating summons dated 21st November, 2025 seeking the following orders:-
Paragraph 1 →In this case, the applicant has placed before the court the lease dated 28th September, 2018. Her evidence is that the lease was executed in the joint names of herself and the deceased and that they acquired the suit property as joint tenants during the subsistence of their marriage. This evidence has not been controverted. In fact, page 5 of the lease reads in part: “To hold the same unto the lessee as joint tenants for the residue…
Paragraph 10 →The court considered whether Lemlem Aregay Negussie and the late Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam held Apartment 4C on LR No. 1870/1/633 as joint tenants; the effect of the deceased’s death on his interest; and whether the apartment formed part of his estate. In…
The applicant stated that she and the deceased acquired Apartment 4C on 28 September 2018 during their marriage. She relied on a lease dated that date, which stated that the lessees were to hold the property as joint tenants for the residue of a 50-year term.…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCLOS NO. E078 OF 2025
IN THE MATTER OF: PROPERTY KNOWN AS APARTMENT NO.4C LR NO. 1870/1/633
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: SECTION 91(4) (B) OF THE LAND REGISTRATION ACT AND ORDER 37 RULE 8 OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES
BETWEEN
LEMLEM AREGAY NEGUSSIE....................................................APPLICANT
VERSUS
ZINASH ZELEKE WOLDERMARIAM………...............…………...RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The applicant filed the originating summons dated 21st November, 2025 seeking the following orders:-
1. That apartment 4C situated on land reference no. 1870/1/633 does not form part of the estate of Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam(deceased).
2. That the deceased and the applicant owned apartment 4C situated on land reference no. 1870/1/633 as joint tenants and therefore the principle of survivorship should apply.
3. That the applicant is now, by virtue of survivorship the registered proprietor of apartment 4C situated on land reference no. 1870/1/633.
2. The application is premised on the grounds inter alia that on 28th September 2018, during the subsistence of their marriage, the applicant and the deceased jointly purchased the suit property known as apartment 4C on LR no. 1870/1/633, and that according to Section 91 (4)(b) of the Land Registration Act, upon the death of a joint tenant, the tenant’s interest shall vest in the surviving tenant.
3. The application was accompanied by the undated verifying affidavit of the applicant. She deposed that she is the spouse and sole beneficiary of the estate of the late Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam, and that pursuant to a ruling delivered on 2nd October 2025 in succession cause no. E360 of 2024, the court directed that the ownership dispute over the suit property be referred to this court. The applicant reiterated that together with the deceased, they own the suit property and a search report could not be generated as the suit property is undergoing conversion.
4. The applicant further deposed that pursuant to Section 91 of the Land Registration Act and following the death of her husband, his proprietary interest should vest in her by virtue of being the only surviving tenant. For this reason, the suit property does not form part of the estate for purposes of succession. In support thereof, the applicant annexed a copy of the lease for the suit property dated 28th September, 2018.
5. The respondent did not file any response. The originating summons was canvassed through written submissions. The applicant filed written submissions dated 3rd September, 2026. Having considered the originating summons, the affidavit in support, the lease annexed and the applicant’s submissions, the issues arising for determination are:
i. Whether the deceased and the applicant held the suit property as joint tenants.
ii. If so, what is the effect of the deceased’s death upon his interest in the suit property.
iii. Whether the suit property forms part of the estate of the deceased.
6. Section 91(1) of the Land Registration Act defines co-tenancy as ownership of land by two or more persons and includes joint tenancy and tenancy in common. Section 91(3) of the Act requires an instrument made in favour of two or more persons to indicate whether they are joint tenants or tenants in common. More importantly, Section 91(4) provides:-
“If land is occupied jointly, no tenant is entitled to any separate share in the land and, consequently—
(a) dispositions may be made only by all the joint tenants;
(b) on the death of a joint tenant, that tenant’s interest shall vest in the surviving tenant or tenants jointly…”
7. The court of appeal in the case of Josephine v Attorney General [2015] KECA 407 (KLR), held as follows:-
“A tenancy in common or tenancy in entirety means that the interest of each registered owner is determinable and severable; in a joint tenancy, the interest of each owner is indeterminable, each owns all and nothing.
35. A joint tenancy cannot be severed unless one of the four unities of title, time, possession or interest is broken. A joint tenant has the right to the entire property or none – since the other joint tenant also has a right to the entire property. This is expressed in latin as totem tenet et nihit tenet, a joint tenant holds everything and nothing (see Re Foley (deceased) Public Trustee -v- Foley & Another (1955) NZLR 702). In Stack -v- Dowden (2007) UKHL 17, the House of Lords expressed itself as follows:-
“The starting point where there is sole legal ownership (a sole name case) is sole beneficial ownership. The starting point where there is joint legal ownership (a joint name case) is joint beneficial ownership. The onus is upon the person who seeks to show that the beneficial ownership differs from legal ownership. The onus of rebutting the presumption is heavier in joint name cases. The amount of interest (s) would be declared on evidence.”
10. In this case, the applicant has placed before the court the lease dated 28th September, 2018. Her evidence is that the lease was executed in the joint names of herself and the deceased and that they acquired the suit property as joint tenants during the subsistence of their marriage. This evidence has not been controverted. In fact, page 5 of the lease reads in part: “To hold the same unto the lessee as joint tenants for the residue now unexpired of the term of fifty (50) years from…” Further, there is no evidence demonstrating that the deceased held a separate or severable interest in the suit property. There is equally no evidence before the court that the joint tenancy was ever severed during the lifetime of the deceased. I am satisfied based on the material before me, that the applicant has established that she and the deceased held the suit property as joint tenants.
11. Having found that the applicant and the deceased were joint tenants, the issue now is whether the suit property survives the applicant. In the case of Mwangi Gakuri v Bernard Kigotho Maina & another [2018] KECA 712 (KLR), the court of appeal considered the doctrine of survivorship and affirmed the applicable law on joint tenancy, holding that upon the death of a joint tenant, the property passes by operation of law to the surviving joint tenant and that a joint tenancy cannot pass under the will or intestacy of a joint tenant, since joint tenants are, in law, considered as a single owner.
12. While I place reliance on the above authorities and there being no evidence that the joint tenancy was severed during the lifetime of the deceased, it is my finding that the death of the applicant’s spouse did not transmit his interest in the suit property to his estate. His interest was extinguished upon his death and, by operation of the doctrine of survivorship pursuant to Section 91(4)(b) of the Land Registration Act, the applicant became entitled to the entirety of the suit property. Further, the applicant’s entitlement to the suit property does not arise because she is a beneficiary of the estate. It arises because she is the surviving joint tenant.
13. Having said the above, it is clear that the suit property does not form part of the estate of the late Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam. I find merit in the originating summons dated 21st November, 2025 and grant the following orders:-
i. Apartment 4C situated on land reference no. 1870/1/633 does not form part of the estate of Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam (deceased).
ii. The deceased and the applicant owned apartment 4C situated on land reference no. 1870/1/633 as joint tenants.
iii. Upon the death of the Aydagne Zelleke Woldermariam, his interest in the suit property vested in the applicant pursuant to Section 91 (4)(b) of the Land Registration Act.
iv. The Land Registrar is hereby directed, upon presentation of the decree and proof of death and completion of the applicable conversion/ registration process, to give effect to the applicant’s entitlement as the surviving joint tenant.
v. I make no orders as to costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
22/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant
Ms. Kahiga holding brief for Mr. Ouko for the Applicant
Mr. Mramba for the Respondent