REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELCLC NO.E006 OF 2025
JOHN WACHIRA MWANGI……….................................PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
MARY WAMBUI MWANGI........................................1ST DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
MURIITHI KOGI……………..........…….............…...2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT.....................................3RD DEFENDANT
CHARLES WOKABI MWANGI.................................4TH DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
JANE WANJIRU GACHARIRA….......................…....5TH DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR,
NAIROBI LANDS REGISTRY…………......................…………………..6TH DEFENDANT
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 16th June 2026, filed by the 1st, 4th and 5th defendants/applicants, expressed to be brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 22 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 5 Rules 17 and 22 and Order 16 Rules 1 and 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and Sections 107,109,112 and 146 of the Evidence Act seeking the following orders:-
1. Spent.
2. That leave be and is hereby granted to the 1st, 4th and 5th defendants to serve the 2nd defendant with the mention notice for 18th June, 2026 and/or any other date that may be fixed by this honourable court for case management conference, by way of substituted service through advertisement in a newspaper of nationwide circulation.
3. That a witness summons do issue to the director general, immigration services or such officer as may be duly authorized, requiring him to produce and verify records relating to passport no. A109338 and/or passport no. 109338 allegedly belonging to the 2nd defendant (Michael) Muriithi Kogi; and
4. That costs of this application be in the cause.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of the 1st defendant/applicant sworn on even date. On behalf of the 4th and 5th defendants/applicants, the 1st defendant/applicant deposed that this matter was brought forward for mention on 18th June, 2026 particularly in relation to the participation of the 2nd defendant/respondent and verification of certain documents relied upon by the plaintiff in support of his claim to the suit property.
3. The 1st defendant/applicant deposed that on 21st October 2025, the 2nd defendant/respondent filed a notice to act in person dated 16th October 2025, together with a statement of defence and witness statement, both dated 21st October 2025, and that in the said notice he provided the email address kogimuriithi@gmail.com as his address for service in the proceedings. According to the 1st defendant/applicant, the 2nd defendant/respondent’s statement of defence contains material averments concerning the ownership and alleged transfer of the suit property. In particular, he claims that sometime in or about 1990, he purchased the suit property from the then City Council of Nairobi, for a consideration of Kshs.50,000/-, which he subsequently sold to the plaintiff at Kshs.60,000/-.
4. The 1st defendant/applicant raises concerns regarding the authenticity and validity of the passport particulars appearing in the sale agreement and deed of assignment, which are purported to belong to the 2nd defendant/respondent. She deposed that verification of those particulars is material to the determination of the dispute, given that the documents form part of the foundation upon which the plaintiff asserts ownership of the suit property. In this regard, she deposed that the continued absence of the 2nd defendant/respondent from the proceedings, coupled with the questions arising from the documents attributed to him, makes it necessary for the passport particulars to be independently authenticated by the director general, immigration services, as the lawful custodian of passport records in Kenya.
5. On the question of the 2nd defendant/respondent participation in the proceedings, the 1st defendant/applicant deposed that in a ruling delivered on 22nd July 2025, the court found the 2nd defendant/respondent to be a necessary party whose participation was required for the fair and effectual determination of the matters in controversy. She nevertheless deposed that, notwithstanding his filing of pleadings and his expressed intention to act in person, the 2nd defendant/respondent has never attended any court proceedings or responded to subsequent notices served upon him. Further, that all efforts to trace the 2nd defendant/respondent and effect personal service upon him have proved futile and that his present whereabouts remain unknown.
6. In her view, his continued absence raises questions that ought to be resolved before the matter proceeds further. Specifically, she deposed that the court should ascertain whether an individual bearing the name Michael Muriithi Kogi, as identified by the passport particulars or otherwise, exists and, if so, require him to attend court personally to confirm or deny the transactions through which the plaintiff allegedly acquired ownership of the suit property. The 1st defendant/applicant deposed that in the prevailing circumstances, substituted service through an advertisement in a newspaper of nationwide circulation is necessary to facilitate the 2nd defendant/respondent’s participation in the proceedings.
7. The plaintiff/respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 29th June, 2026 challenging the application on the following grounds:-
i. There is no requirement whatsoever for leave to be granted to the defendants for purposes of serving the 2nd defendant by way of substituted service because the 2nd defendant entered appearance on 16th October, 2025 and has filed his statement of defence dated 21st October, 2025.
ii. Additionally, there is no requirement whatsoever for substituted service because the 2nd defendant has provided his phone number and email address in his pleadings which contact details can be used to effect service as provided under Order 5 Rule 22B and Order 5 Rule 22C of the Civil Procedure Rules.
iii. The responsibility of serving mention notices or any other court notices rests on the plaintiff and not the defendants.
iv. There is equally no need whatsoever to issue witness summons to the director general immigration services because his attendance is not required in this matter noting that the 2nd defendant has entered appearance and filed his pleadings in court.
v. Any clarifications required with regard to the 2nd defendant’s passport and/or any other issues can be clarified during the hearing of the matter as the defendants will have the liberty to cross-examine the 2nd defendant.
vi. The applicants are guilty of laches as the application has been brought after an inordinate delay.
vii. The passport numbers indicated in the agreement for sale and assignment filed before court are the same hence the defendant’s allegation that there are two passports is devoid of any merit.
viii. The application is misconceived, incurably defective and bad in law.
ix. The application is an abuse of the process of this court and should be dismissed with costs.
8. The 2nd defendant/respondent filed his replying affidavit sworn on 30th June, 2026. He confirmed his identity as Michael Muriithi Kogi and acknowledged having filed a notice to act in person and a statement of defence. He deposed that his non-attendance of court sessions is due to his advanced age and difficulties accessing virtual court proceedings from his residence in Nyeri. He further explained that the difference in passport numbers arose from the omission of the letter “A” in one of the documents.
9. The 1st defendant/applicant filed a further affidavit sworn on 20th July, 2026. She maintained that there is need to verify the 2nd defendant/respondent particulars since the matter would be dismissed once it is established that the 2nd defendant/respondent does not bear the said passport numbers.
10. This court directed the application to be canvassed by way of written submissions. By the time of writing this ruling, neither of the parties had filed their written submissions. Be that as it may, I have considered the application and the replies thereof. The issue for determination is whether the 1st, 4th and 5th defendants/applicants have established grounds for substituted service and whether a witness summons should issue to the director general, immigration services, for verification of the disputed passport particulars.
11. On substituted service, Order 5 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the court to authorize alternative service where ordinary service cannot reasonably be effected. In Khaminwa v Spiga & 6 Others [2023] KECA 678 (KLR), the court of appeal reiterated that substituted service must be founded upon sufficient material demonstrating the difficulty of effecting ordinary service. In this case, the 2nd defendant/respondent has entered appearance, filed a defence and expressly acknowledged receipt of court documents through electronic means. The notice to act in person also provides an email address through which he may be contacted.
12. In the circumstances, the court is not persuaded that the existing means of service has become ineffective or that advertisement is necessary. More importantly, the purpose of service is to bring proceedings to the attention of the person concerned. The 2nd defendant/respondent by filing his statement of defence has demonstrated actual knowledge of these proceedings. His alleged failure to attend court is a distinct question which cannot justify substituted service.
13. Turning to the second issue, Order 16 Rules 1 and 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules empower the court to summon a person to give evidence or produce documents relevant to matters in controversy. The power must be exercised judiciously, having regard to the relevance and necessity of the proposed evidence and the requirements of a fair hearing. It also permits a person summoned to produce documents to comply through their production without attending personally. The 1st, 4th and 5th defendants/applicants contend that the discrepancy in the particulars of the 2nd defendant/respondent’s passport raises serious questions concerning the identity of the alleged vendor and the authenticity of the sale agreement and the deed of assignment upon which the plaintiff’s claim is founded. On the other hand, the 2nd defendant/respondent maintains that the discrepancy is merely an omission of the letter “A”.
14. I have considered the identification documents presented. The 2nd defendant/respondent has exhibited a Kenyan national identity card identifying him as Michael Muriithi Kogi. He has also produced a copy of a Kenyan passport issued in March 2019 and expiring in March 2029. These documents provide prima facie evidence of the identity of the person participating in these proceedings. They do not, however, establish the historical passport particulars appearing in the documents allegedly executed in 1990. Conversely, the omission of the letter “A” from one of the passport numbers does not, without further evidence, establish fraud, impersonation or forgery. Those remain disputed allegations requiring proof. The court cannot infer dishonesty merely from a discrepancy in documentary particulars.
15. I note that the 1st, 4th and 5th defendants have pleaded particulars of fraud against the plaintiff/respondent in their amended counterclaim dated 28th November, 2025 challenging his ownership of the suit property. The same alleged ownership having arisen out of a sale agreement, I am of the view that the particulars of the passport are sufficiently connected to the pleaded dispute to warrant limited verification. The director general, immigration services, is the appropriate public officer to clarify whether the historical numbers in question were issued and, if so, the particulars of their registered holder. Let me quickly add that such verification would not necessarily amount to a determination of the merits of the suit. It would facilitate the production of potentially relevant evidence for consideration at the hearing.
16. Nevertheless, I am mindful that the 2nd defendant/respondent current passport is different from those appearing in the disputed documents. The verification must therefore be confined to the historical passport records and should not be treated as an invitation to undertake an unrestricted investigation into the 2nd defendant/respondent personal affairs. In the circumstances, I find that the 1st, 4th and 5th defendants/applicants have established sufficient grounds for limited production and verification of the passport records.
17. From the above, I find merit in the notice of motion dated 16th June 2026, and it is hereby allowed in part as follows:-
i. The 1st, 4th and 5th defendants/applicants are granted leave to serve the Director General, Immigration Services, with witness summons requiring production of such official records as may be available concerning passport numbers A109338 and 109338 referred to in the sale agreement dated 2nd October, 1990 and the assignment dated 6th December, 1990.
ii. The Director General, Immigration Services, or a duly authorized officer, shall within thirty (30) days of service produce a certified report or relevant records.
iii. For clarity, the prayer for substituted service is declined, and the 2nd defendant will continue to be served through the elected address provided in his pleadings, subject to any further directions of the court.
iv. Costs shall be in the cause.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
22/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant
Mrs. Mwendwa for the 1st, 4th & 5th Defendants/Applicants
Ms. Ndambuki holding brief for Mr. Otieno for the Plaintiff/Respondent
Ms. Ambasa for the 3rd Defendant/Respondent