Background
The matter is coming up for determination of the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 19th March 2026 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The matter is coming up for determination of the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 19th March 2026 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →That the Respondents failed to participate in the same hearing and the court gave a ruling on the 19th March 2024 and a certificate issued which certificate they sought to have adopted as an order of the court in a judgement that was delivered on the 1st July 2025 having complied with all the legal processes including issue of service.
Paragraph 6 →In the present circumstances, I find that service was not proved to the required legal standard, thereby rendering the ex parte judgment irregular.
Paragraph 22 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLMISC NO E102 OF 2023
MUSYOKA WAMBUA & KATIKU ADVOCATES...................................APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
KIHINGO VILLAGE (WARIDI GARDENS LIMITED.......................1ST RESPONDENT
KIHINGO VILLAGE (WARIDI GARDENS)
MANAGEMENT LIMITED.....................2ND RESPONDENT/JUDGEMENT DEBTOR
RULING
Introduction
1. The matter is coming up for determination of the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 19th March 2026 seeking the following orders;
a) Spent
b) THAT pending hearing of the application inter parte an order be issued for stay of execution of the decree given on 1st July 2025 and published on 5th November 2025 and the warrant of attachment of moveable property and warrant of sale of moveable all dated 13th March 2026 issued to Benbee Auctioneers and proclamation of attachment dated 16th March 2026 by Benbee Auctioneers pending the hearing and determination of this application.
c) THAT pending inter parte hearing of this application , a temporary injunction do issue against the decree holder, his auctioneers , agents, servants, employees and or any person claiming or working on his behalf restraining them from selling by public auction or in any manner advertising for sale , disposing of, transferring , selling by public auction or in any manner whatsoever dealing with the properties set out in the proclamation of attachment dated 16th March 2026 by Benbee Auctioneers.
d) Pending hearing and determination of this application, this honourable court be pleased to issue an order for stay of execution of the decree given on 1st July 2025 and published on 5th November 2025.
e) This honourable court be pleased to set aside the judgement entered on 1st July 2025 against the Respondents / judgement debtors and the resultant decree published on 5th November 2025.
2. The application was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit of Parit Meha.He deponed that the Applicant never served the Respondents with the bill of costs dated 30th October 2023 and neither were they served with notice of taxation dated 7th December 2023.
3. That the court went ahead to issue a ruling on the bill of costs on the 19th March 2024 without the Respondent’s participation. That further the Respondents filed a notice of motion application dated 5th December 2024 seeking to have the said certificate of taxation adopted as a judgement for extraction of an enforceable decree which notice of motion the Respondent contend was also not served upon them.
4. The Respondents discredited the mode of service via email indicating the Applicants had not proven the email addresses belonged to the Respondents and further there was no read receipts in the email to actually confirm that the Respondents received the pleadings
5. The Applicant in response filed a replying affidavit sworn by John Katiku.He deponed that the Respondents had neglected to apply legal fees having been represented by the Applicant in ELC 1225 of 2013 causing for the filing of the bill of costs which he stated was served on the Respondents together with the notice of taxation.
6. That the Respondents failed to participate in the same hearing and the court gave a ruling on the 19th March 2024 and a certificate issued which certificate they sought to have adopted as an order of the court in a judgement that was delivered on the 1st July 2025 having complied with all the legal processes including issue of service.
7. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions with the Respondents filing submissions dated 17th June 2026 whereas the Applicant filed submissions dated 17th September 2026
Respondent’s submissions
8. Counsel for the Applicant submitted as in their supporting affidavit asking the court to set aside the ruling dated 19th March 2024, the judgement of 1st July 2025 and the subsequent decree on the basis of non-service in contravention of order 5 rule 22B on the mode of using electronic email as a way of service. That email having no delivery receipt should not be deemed as proper relying on the case of BOD County Referral Hospital Kitale & another Vs DN (Suing through her next friend & Grandmother SK) (Civil Appeal E043 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 5344 (KLR)
9. Counsel argued that having shown the service was irregular therefore the judgement is irregular and must be set aside. Counsel further insisted that a matter coming up for mention cannot be heard in its finality unless on consent which was the case here judgement having been entered when it came for mention
10. The Respondents further submitted that the execution orders coming from the said judgement were unlawfully and, in this case, having failed to serve the notice of entry to the Respondents as per order 22 rule 6 of the civil procedure rules relying on Shaffique Allibhai Vs William Ochanda Onduru t/a Ochanda Onguru & Company Advocates & another [2014] eKLR,
11. Counsel for the Respondent submitted that the attachment of the tools of trade was also unlawful and in contravention of section 44(1)(ii) of the civil procedure Act 2010
Applicant/Decree Holder’s submissions
12. Counsel reiterated that all the legal procedure leading up to the extraction of the decree was followed by the Applicant including the issue in contention which is service. That the mere absence of a delivery receipt attached to the affidavit of service does not indicate lack of service, more so the email addresses of the Respondents had not been denied by the Respondents and in the absence of such denial service was effected.
13. That the Respondents had not met the principles for setting aside ex parte judgement being that there was no merited defence filed in opposition to the bill of costs.
14. Counsel further indicated that the Respondents had not followed the right provisions of the law to seek the setting aside of the certificate of taxation as it should have been through a reference under order 11 of the advocates remuneration order and not a notice of motion application relying on several case laws including Machira & Co. Advocates Vs Magugu [2002] 2 EA 428 and Odera Obar & Co. Advocates Vs Aly Enterprises Limited & 3 others [2015] KEHC 1903 (KLR),
Analysis and determination
15. Having looked at the application, the responses thereto, the submissions and cited authorities, the principle issues are;
a) Whether service of the application and summons was effected in accordance with Order 5 Rule 22B so as to render the ex parte order regular; and
b) If service was irregular, whether the ex parte judgement should be set aside
16. The applicable principles governing service of process are that service of process is fundamental to the right to a fair hearing and courts must be satisfied that service has been properly effected before permitting ex parte relief as provided by Order 5, Civil Procedure Rules and constitutional guarantees of fair hearing.
17. Order 5 Rule 22B permits service by electronic mail to a last confirmed and used email address. It contemplates objective proof of delivery for example a delivery receipt, SMTP delivery confirmation or mailbox headers. A mere copy of a sent email without delivery confirmation is weak evidence of actual receipt.
18. The court has a judicial discretion to set aside ex parte orders obtained in default where service was not properly effected or where justice requires; where a prior order is regular the Applicant would normally need to show a prima facie or triable defence.
19. On the material before the Court the Applicant has produced affidavits asserting electronic service and annexed copies of sent emails and related correspondence. These affidavits do not, however, include an electronic delivery receipt, SMTP headers or server logs conclusively demonstrating successful delivery to the Defendant’s mailbox. The Respondents have sworn that they did not receive the emailed documents, that it only became aware of the ex parte order when their advocated were mapped on the CTS and had the documents downloaded.
20. On Proof of electronic delivery, Order 5 Rule 22B requires reliable evidence of delivery where service is effected electronically. The annexed sent emails, absent delivery receipts or server header evidence, do not establish delivery to the Respondent’s inbox to the civil standard required in the face of an express denial of receipt. Consequently, the Applicant’s evidence as presently constituted is not sufficiently conclusive to preclude the Court from reassessing the matter.
21. The importance of strict compliance with the requirement of service was emphasized in Sifuna & Sifuna Advocates Vs Patrick Simiyu Khaemba [2021] eKLR, where the Court held that mere sending of an email is insufficient without proof of delivery. Similarly, in Commission for Human Rights & Justice v Jacob Kimutai Torutt & 5 Others [2021] eKLR, the Court found service defective where delivery receipts were not provided.
Further in Lihanda & Another Vs Bboxx Capital Kenya Ltd (Civil Appeal E092 of 2021) [2025] KEHC 11192, the Court (Mabeya J), adopting the position expressed in B.O.D County Referral Hospital Kitale & Another vs Dorcas Naliaka KTL HCCA No. E043 of 2023 UR, reaffirmed that an email delivery receipt—not merely a sent email—is required to establish valid electronic service. The learned judge stated that:“ Returning to Order 5 Rule 22B (4) of the Civil Procedure Rules an affidavit for service is supposed to attach an Electronic Mail Service delivery receipt as the cofirmation of service. What then is an email delivery receipt? Simply put, an email delivery receipt is a notification confirming that an email message was delivered to the recipient’s mailbox. It must, however, be understood that an email delivery receipt is different from an email read receipt. The latter is a nnotification confirming that the email message was opened and/or read by the recipient.”
22. In the present circumstances, I find that service was not proved to the required legal standard, thereby rendering the ex parte judgment irregular.
23. On the issue of whether the judgement should be set aside, the grounds for setting aside an ex parte judgment are well settled. The court must be satisfied that:
a) either the Defendant was not properly served with summons; or
b) the Defendant failed to appear in court at the hearing due to sufficient cause.
24. It is trite that where a default judgment is entered without proper service, such judgment is irregular and must be set aside ex debito justitiae. In Remco Ltd Vs. Mistry Jadva Parbat & Co. Ltd [2002] 1 EA 233, the Court held that failure of proper service renders a judgment irregular and the court has no discretion but to set it aside. This principle has been consistently affirmed including in Winnie Wambui Kibinge & 2 Others vs Match Electricals Ltd [2012] eKLR, where the Court stated that such a judgment must be set aside as a matter of judicial duty.
25. Accordingly, once the Courts finds that service was not proper, the question of discretion does not arise.
Final disposition
Accordingly, I find the present application merited and make the following orders;
i. The Judgement of 1st July 2025 is hereby set aside together with the subsequent decree published on the 5th November 2025.
ii. There is hereby issued a stay of execution of warrant of attachments of moveable property, warrant of sale dated 13th March 2025 and proclamation of attachment issued to Benbee Auctioneers
iii. That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, an order of temporary injunction be and is hereby issued against the decree holder, his auctioneers , agents , servants, employees and or any person claiming or working on his behalf restraining them from selling by public auction or in any manner advertising for sale , disposing of, transferring , selling by public auction or in any manner whatsoever dealing with the properties set out in the proclamation of attachment dated 16th March 2026 by Benbee auctioneers
iv. Each party shall bear its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 22nd day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Otieno for the Judgment Debtor
Mr. Wanjohi for the Decree Holder
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant