REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC (OS) NO. E048 OF 2024
OLIVER ONKEO MOENGA............................ PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
MOSES MUTURI MWARIRI &
ALEXANDER JOSEPH GATHII MUTURI.....DEFENDANTS/APPLICANTS
(Administrators of the Estate of
CHARLES MUTURI MWARIRI)
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 12th April, 2026 filed by the defendants/applicants, and it is expressed to be brought pursuant to Articles 25(c), 40(1)(2)(a)(b), 47, 50(1) and 162(2)(b) of the Constitution, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 10 Rule 11, Order 45 Rule (1)(2)(3) and (4) and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-
1. That the honourable court be pleased to set aside the judgment dated 3rd July, 2025 and all consequential orders.
2. That the defendants’ replying affidavit dated 10th April, 2026 be deemed to be properly on record.
3. That the suit be transferred to Thika Environment and Land Court for hearing and determination.
4. That costs be in the cause.
2. The application is premised on the grounds inter alia that the plaintiff/respondent failed to disclose to the court that the defendant died on 13th November, 2016. The application is further supported by the affidavit of Chris Mutugi Kimathi, the learned counsel for the defendants/applicants sworn on 13th April, 2026. On behalf of the defendants/applicants, the learned counsel deposed that the plaintiff/respondent failed to disclose that the original defendant, Charles Muturi Mwariri, died on 13th November 2016, and that the estate of the deceased defendant had no administrators at the time of filing the suit.
3. Further, the learned counsel deposed that the plaintiff/respondent failed to disclose that 12 years had not lapsed from the date of the death of the defendant, that the said death was published severally in the daily nation, and that the suit property is within Kiambu county thus a preserve of Thika ELC. As a result, the service upon the defendant was made posthumously.
4. The application was opposed through the replying affidavit of the plaintiff/respondent sworn on 29th June, 2026. The plaintiff/respondent deposed that the supporting affidavit is defective, having been sworn by an advocate on contentious matters. Further, that the court had already determined that time for adverse possession commenced on 1st September, 2001 and that his rights crystallized on 2nd September 2013, before the deceased’s death. The plaintiff/respondent averred that he was unaware of the death, having dealt exclusively with the deceased’s agents, and that he instituted the proceedings in good faith upon conducting an official search at the land registry. He deposed that substituted service was effected pursuant to the orders of the court and that the application is an attempt to reopen matters conclusively determined.
5. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The plaintiff/respondent filed written submissions dated 29th June, 2026. The defendants/applicants did not file their written submissions. Be that as it may, I have considered the application, the reply thereof and the written submissions filed. The issues for determination are as follows:-
i. Whether the supporting affidavit is competent,
ii. Whether the judgment delivered on 3rd July 2025 should be set aside and transferred to the Environment and Land Court at Thika.
6. On the competence of the supporting affidavit sworn by counsel, the court of appeal in Hakika Transporters Services Ltd v Albert Chulah Wamimitaire [2016] KECA 255 (KLR) affirmed that an advocate may depose to formal and non-contentious matters within his knowledge but should refrain from swearing affidavits on disputed matters of fact. In this case, the material issue concerning the defendant’s death is supported by a certificate of death, while the appointment of administrators is evidenced by the succession court’s directions. These are documentary evidence capable of independent verification. I therefore find no sufficient basis for striking out the affidavit merely because it was sworn by counsel.
7. On the substantive issue, the certificate of death established that Charles Muturi Mwariri died on 13th November, 2016. The defendants/applicants contend that the proceedings were nevertheless instituted against him in 2024. The plaintiff/respondent on the other hand does not dispute the death but maintains that he was unaware of it when he commenced the proceedings. In Geeta Bharat Shah & 4 Others v Omar Said Mwatayari & Another [2009] KECA 126 (KLR), the court of appeal held that:-
“…the court was duty bound to down its tools as it had no jurisdiction to proceed to hear a suit filed against a person who was already dead by the time the suit was filed.”
8. Also, in the case of Viktar Maina Ngunjiri & 4 others v Attorney General & 6 others [2018] KEHC 1972 (KLR), it was held as follows:-
“In the instant case this cannot happen because the deceased died before the suit was filed and the representative of the estate has not been identified. Even if the representative were identified it is not possible to take over a nullity.
In the Indian case of C. Muttu vs. Bharath Match Works AIR 1964 Kant 293 the court observed,
“If he (defendant) dies before the suit and a suit is brought against him in the name in which he carried on business, the suit is against a dead man and it is a nullity from its inception. The suit being a nullity, the writ of summons issued in the suit by whomsoever accepted is also a nullity. Similarly, an order made in the suit allowing amendment of plaint by substituting the legal representative of the deceased as the defendant and allowing the suit to proceed against him is also a nullity. It is immaterial that the suit was brought bona fide and in ignorance of the death of such a person.”
9. The plaintiff/respondent’s explanation that he acted in good faith and relied upon official land records is understandable. However, the court of appeal in Geeta Bharat Shah (supra) made it clear that ignorance of a defendant’s death does not confer legal capacity upon a deceased person. The plaintiff/respondent further contends that his right to the property had crystallized through adverse possession before the deceased’s death. This contention in my view is distinct from the competence of the proceedings. It follows that where proceedings were commenced solely against Charles Muturi Mwariri after his death, the subsequent judgment cannot be sustained. In other words, there are no competent proceedings upon which the judgment can lawfully be founded.
10. As regards the prayer for transfer, there is no doubt that the subject matter is situated in Ruiru, Kiambu county thus within the jurisdiction of Thika ELC. However, if the proceedings were a nullity from inception, there would be no competent suit capable of being transferred for hearing and determination. The prayer for transfer cannot therefore issue in the circumstance. The question of the appropriate forum may arise afresh should competent proceedings be instituted.
11. From the above, I find merit in the notice of motion dated 12th April, 2026 and I grant the following orders:-
i. The judgment of this court delivered on 3rd July 2025 and all consequential orders are all hereby set aside for being a nullity.
ii. I make no orders as to costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
22/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant
Ms. Achieng holding brief for Mr. Okonjo for the Plaintiff/Respondent
Ms. Karongo holding brief for Mr. Gitau for the Defendant /Applicant