Land law

Kamau v Athi Water Works Development Agency [2026] KEELC 6839 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Appeal E064 of 2021
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The reference against taxation was allowed. The Taxing Officer’s decision of 6 November 2025 was set aside, and the bill was remitted to a different taxing officer for re-taxation. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

Supporting judgment passages

The upshot of the matter is that the Reference is allowed and make the following orders

Passage 45 →

a. The Taxing Officer’s decision delivered on 6th November 2025 be and is hereby set aside and I direct that this bill be remitted to a different taxing officer for re- taxation accordingly.

Passage 46 →

b. Each party shall bear Its costs.

Passage 47 →
Issue 1What is the effect of not filing an objection before filing a reference, and is it fatal?

Held. The absence of a notice of objection was not fatal and the reference was competently before the court. Where the taxing officer’s ruling itself contains the reasons for taxation, a party need not seek further reasons. Here, the taxation ruling was delivered on 6 November 2025 and the reference was filed on 19 November 2025, within 14 days.

Ratio. Although paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order provides for a written objection and reasons, that process need not be ritualistically followed where the taxing officer has already delivered a self-contained, reasoned ruling. In that circumstance, time for filing the reference runs from the ruling containing those reasons.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

7. The question this court will be asked to gauge is what is the effect of not an objection before filing a reference and is it fatal ?

Paragraph 7 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

12. In the present case, the ruling on taxation was made on 6th November 2025. The Applicant considered the said decision to contain the reasons, and hence filed the reference on the 19th November 2025 well within 14 days from the date thereof and hence competently before this court

Paragraph 12 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

9. From the foregoing it is clear that the reasons for the decision are to be sought for by way of a notice within 14 days of the decision, if the party so wishes to have the same reasons and the reference is to be lodged within 14 days of the receipt of the reasons. The use of the term may suggest it is not mandatory as sometimes the decision of the taxing master is comprehensive with reasons on the face of it and the party desirous of filing a reference need not ask for reasons again.

Paragraph 9 →

10. In most cases, the court is aware that, taxing officers, in their decisions on taxation do deliver comprehensive rulings which are self-contained thus obviating the necessity to furnish fresh reasons, thereafter which is the case in this matter as the taxing master gave the reasons in the said ruling .In such circumstances it would be foolhardy to expect the taxing officer to redraft another “ruling” containing the reasons.

Paragraph 10 →
Issue 2Whether the Applicant made a case for setting aside the taxing officer’s ruling of 6 November 2025.

Held. Yes. The Taxing Officer erred in principle by awarding getting-up fees without the required certification. Further, for the remaining challenged items, the Taxing Officer merely stated that they were drawn to scale and allowed the claimed sum without addressing the individual contested items, identifying the applicable schedule, or giving adequate reasons. The taxation decision was therefore set aside and the bill remitted to a different taxing officer for re-taxation.

Ratio. A court may interfere with taxation where the taxing officer misdirects himself or herself on principle or fails to exercise discretion judicially. Getting-up fees under the applicable appeal provision required certification, and a taxing officer determining a contested bill must provide a reasoned decision identifying the governing schedule and justification for the amounts allowed; a blanket allowance because items were ‘drawn to scale’ is insufficient.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

13. Moving on to address the merits of the application the issue for determination is whether the Applicant has made a case for setting aside of the taxing officer’s ruling of 6th November 2025.

Paragraph 13 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

17. A simple reading and interpretation of the aforementioned provision indicates that it is appeals ‘to’ the High Court rather than ‘from’ the High Court that require certification from the court hearing the appeal, which is the High Court. I am in agreement with the Applicant that there being no certification, there was no basis for awarding the getting up fees and hence the taxing officer erred in principle in awarding the same.

Paragraph 17 →

18. Moving on to the other items as pleaded, I will not address them individually but confine myself to the ruling where the taxing master indicated ‘other items’, where all the items in the chamber summons application fall under. It is apparent that the Taxing Officer did not pronounce himself on all items, choosing to state that they were drawn to scale hence allowed the entire sum claimed. This was not sufficient. He was required to act judiciously by giving a reasoned decision. This was a contested Bill of Costs which called upon the Taxing Officer to identify the schedule under which the decision was based so as to justify the amount granted

Paragraph 18 →

a. The Taxing Officer’s decision delivered on 6th November 2025 be and is hereby set aside and I direct that this bill be remitted to a different taxing officer for re- taxation accordingly.

Passage 46 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

vi. No appeal or reference can be allowed unless the Appellant can show or demonstrate that above mentioned principles have been breached because judges on appeal as a principle do not like to interfere with an assessment of costs by the taxing officer unless the officer has misdirected himself or herself in a matter of principle, but if the quantum of an assessment is manifestly extravagant, a misdirection of principle may be a necessary inference.”

Passage 38 →

17. A simple reading and interpretation of the aforementioned provision indicates that it is appeals ‘to’ the High Court rather than ‘from’ the High Court that require certification from the court hearing the appeal, which is the High Court. I am in agreement with the Applicant that there being no certification, there was no basis for awarding the getting up fees and hence the taxing officer erred in principle in awarding the same.

Paragraph 17 →

18. Moving on to the other items as pleaded, I will not address them individually but confine myself to the ruling where the taxing master indicated ‘other items’, where all the items in the chamber summons application fall under. It is apparent that the Taxing Officer did not pronounce himself on all items, choosing to state that they were drawn to scale hence allowed the entire sum claimed. This was not sufficient. He was required to act judiciously by giving a reasoned decision. This was a contested Bill of Costs which called upon the Taxing Officer to identify the schedule under which the decision was based so as to justify the amount granted

Paragraph 18 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Appellant herein filed party to party bill of costs dated 8th January 2024 in realization of judgement delivered on 26th November 2025.That the said bill of costs was heard and a ruling given by the Deputy registrar on the 6th November 2025 at a sum of Ksh 348,000/= and a certificate of taxation issued.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having looked at the application and submissions the first issue for determination will be on the objection raised by the Appellant as it touches on jurisdiction and without the proper jurisdiction this court cannot entertain the application. The Appellant has pointed that the application is incompetent and, defective and an abuse of the court process being that the Applicant filed the reference without filing a notice of objection as…

Paragraph 6 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the reference against the Deputy Registrar’s taxation ruling was competent despite no notice of objection under paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order; and whether the taxing officer erred in principle in awarding getting-up fees and…

Material facts

Following a party-and-party bill of costs dated 8 January 2024, the Deputy Registrar taxed the bill at Kshs 348,000 and issued a certificate of taxation on 6 November 2025. Athi Water Works Development Agency challenged that ruling by chamber summons dated 19…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC APPEAL E064 OF 2021

SAMUEL MACHARIA KAMAU…………………………..APPELLANT/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

ATHI WATER WORKS DEVELOPMENT AGENCY………RESPONDENT /APPLICANT

RULING

Introduction

1. The Appellant herein filed party to party bill of costs dated 8th January 2024 in realization of judgement delivered on 26th November 2025.That the said bill of costs was heard and a ruling given by the Deputy registrar on the 6th November 2025 at a sum of Ksh 348,000/= and a certificate of taxation issued.

2. The Applicant herein being dissatisfied with the said ruling then filed a reference to the bill vide the chamber summons application dated 19th November 2025 which is for determination. It seeks a review /setting aside of the ruling dated 6th November 2025 Nn the grounds that;

a) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing Item No. 2 and awarding the Appellant getting up fees contrary to Schedule 6 Part A paragraph 3 of the Advocates Remuneration (Amendment) Order of 2014, as no certification was made by this Honorable Court after the conclusion of the proceedings and hence the Appellant should not have been awarded getting up fees for the appeal

b) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by awarding the Appellant Kshs 1,000 on Item No. 3 of the Bill, even though the same does not relate to any fees associated with provisions of the Advocates Remuneration (Amendment) Order of 2014 or any item pleaded by the Appellant.

c) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing the whole amount pleaded at Item No. 5 of the Bill even though the 130 folios of the Record of Appeal were not drawn by the Appellant and therefore, costs could not granted and further having pleaded for costs for items 3 and 4 of the Bill, which pleadings form part of the Record of Appeal, the granting of item 5 would amounted to double taxation. 1

d) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing Item Nos. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19 and 48 of the Bill as pleaded, items that related to the Appellant’s application dated 25th May 2022 and by allowing the aforementioned items, the Honorable Deputy Registrar sat on appeal on this Honorable Court’s Ruling of 23rd February 2023 in which this Honorable Court dismissed the Appellant’s application dated 25th May 2022 with costs to the Applicant (Annexed herewith and marked as “EO-3” is a true copy of this Honorable Court Ruling of 23rd February 2023).

e) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing the costs for drawing for Item Nos. 23 and 31 as pleaded, even though the same was contrary to the provisions of Schedule 6 Part A paragraph 4 of the Advocates Remuneration (Amendment) Order of 2014, as the Appellant herein failed to justify the pleaded costs for the aforementioned items. 1

f) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing Item Nos. 34, 35, 39, 40, and 42 of the Bill as pleaded contrary to the provisions of Schedule 6 Part A paragraph 7(d) of the Advocates Remuneration (Amendment) Order of 2014, as read together with Rule 50A of the Advocates Remuneration Order of 2009, the aforementioned items having been pleaded on the higher scale.

g) THAT the Honorable Deputy Registrar erred in principle by allowing Item Nos. 43, 44, 45, and 46 as pleaded, items that related to the Applicant’s intended appeal to the Court of Appeal, and by allowing the said items, the Honorable Deputy Registrar supervised proceedings at the Court of Appeal contrary to the hierarchy of the Judiciary as prescribed by Article 162 as read together with Article 164 of the Constitution of Kenya.

h) The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Applicant’s supporting affidavit sworn by one Erick Onyancha.

3. The Appellant in opposing the application filed a replying affidavit sworn on the 13th March 2026.He deponed that the application was incompetent and defective being that no notice of objection had been lodged with 14 days of the delivery of the ruling as required by rule 11(1) of the Advocate’s remuneration Order (2017).That further no leave to file the said objection or reference out of time had been sought by the Applicant .That this was not a technicality but a mandatory requirement

4. That the reasons given by the Applicant on error on principle had not shown how exactly the taxing master acted on wrong principle or that the award was manifestly low or excessive and the court cannot interfere with the decision simply because the Applicant wants a different decision.

5. Both Parties have filed their submissions reiterating the arguments in their respective affidavits which submissions I have considered already and in writing this ruling I have paid due attention to their submissions.

Analysis and determination

6. Having looked at the application and submissions the first issue for determination will be on the objection raised by the Appellant as it touches on jurisdiction and without the proper jurisdiction this court cannot entertain the application. The Appellant has pointed that the application is incompetent and, defective and an abuse of the court process being that the Applicant filed the reference without filing a notice of objection as prescribed in rule 11(1) of the ARO.

7. The question this court will be asked to gauge is what is the effect of not an objection before filing a reference and is it fatal ?

8. After the taxation of the bill of costs, the Advocates Remuneration Order provides for the procedure to be followed when a party opposes the taxation of the bill of costs. The procedure for the challenge of the results therefrom is provided under Paragraph 11 of the said Order which states as follows: “Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects. The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by chamber summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection.”

9. From the foregoing it is clear that the reasons for the decision are to be sought for by way of a notice within 14 days of the decision, if the party so wishes to have the same reasons and the reference is to be lodged within 14 days of the receipt of the reasons. The use of the term may suggest it is not mandatory as sometimes the decision of the taxing master is comprehensive with reasons on the face of it and the party desirous of filing a reference need not ask for reasons again.

10. In most cases, the court is aware that, taxing officers, in their decisions on taxation do deliver comprehensive rulings which are self-contained thus obviating the necessity to furnish fresh reasons, thereafter which is the case in this matter as the taxing master gave the reasons in the said ruling .In such circumstances it would be foolhardy to expect the taxing officer to redraft another “ruling” containing the reasons.

11. In Ahmednasir Abdikadir & Co. Advocates vs. National Bank of Kenya Limited (2) [2006] 1 EA 5 Ochieng, J, held as follows: “ Although rule 11(1) of the Advocates Remuneration Order stipulates that any party who wishes to object to the decision of the taxing officer should do so within 14 days after the said decision and thereafter file his reference within 14 days from the date of the receipt of the reasons, where the reasons for the taxation on the disputed items in the bill are already contained in the considered ruling, there is no need to seek for further reasons simply because of the unfortunate wording of subrule (2) of rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order demands so. The said rule was not intended to be ritualistically observed even when reasons for the disputed taxation are already contained in the formal and considered ruling...Therefore the reference having been filed way out of the period prescribed should have been dismissed but having been given due consideration in substance, the same dismissed”.

12. In the present case, the ruling on taxation was made on 6th November 2025. The Applicant considered the said decision to contain the reasons, and hence filed the reference on the 19th November 2025 well within 14 days from the date thereof and hence competently before this court

13. Moving on to address the merits of the application the issue for determination is whether the Applicant has made a case for setting aside of the taxing officer’s ruling of 6th November 2025.

14. The circumstances under which this court may or can interfere with the taxing officer’s exercise of discretion are now well known. The taxing master must be guided by the principles governing taxation as was held in the leading case of Premchand Raichand Ltd Another -vs- Quarry services of East Africa Ltd and Another No. 3 (1972) EA 162. The principles laid out are:-

i. The instruction fee should cover the advocates work including taking instructions and preparing the case for trial or appeal.

ii. The taxing master was expected to tax each bill on its merits;

iii. The value of the subject matter had to be taken into account;

iv. The taxing master’s discretion was to be exercised judicially and not whimsically or capriciously;

v. Though the successful litigant was entitled to a fair reimbursement, the taxing master had to consider the public interest such that costs were not allowed to rise to a level that would confine access to the courts to the wealthy.

vi. No appeal or reference can be allowed unless the Appellant can show or demonstrate that above mentioned principles have been breached because judges on appeal as a principle do not like to interfere with an assessment of costs by the taxing officer unless the officer has misdirected himself or herself in a matter of principle, but if the quantum of an assessment is manifestly extravagant, a misdirection of principle may be a necessary inference.”

15. In applying the above principles to the instant application, this court will access the getting up fees which the Applicant indicates should not have been awarded as it is, since it contrary to Schedule 6 Part A paragraph 3 of the Advocates Remuneration (Amendment) Order of 2014, as no certification was made in the judgement .

16. The issue of Getting up fees in an appeal is governed by Rule 3 of Schedule 6 of the Order titled “fees for Getting up on appeal” which specifically relates to, and provides for appeals filed in the High Court from a Judgment of the Subordinate Court where taxations in such appeals ordinarily provides for Getting up fees on the basis of a Certificate issued by a Judge of the High Court trying the appeal. It provides as follows:

3.Fees for getting up an appeal In any appeal to the High Court in which a Respondent appears at the hearing of the appeal and which the court at the conclusion of the hearing has certified that in view of the extent or difficulty of the work required to be done subsequently to the lodging of the appeal the case is a proper one for consideration of a getting up fee, the taxing officer may allow such a fee in addition to the instruction fee and such a fee shall not be less than one-third of the instruction fee.

17. A simple reading and interpretation of the aforementioned provision indicates that it is appeals ‘to’ the High Court rather than ‘from’ the High Court that require certification from the court hearing the appeal, which is the High Court. I am in agreement with the Applicant that there being no certification, there was no basis for awarding the getting up fees and hence the taxing officer erred in principle in awarding the same.

18. Moving on to the other items as pleaded, I will not address them individually but confine myself to the ruling where the taxing master indicated ‘other items’, where all the items in the chamber summons application fall under. It is apparent that the Taxing Officer did not pronounce himself on all items, choosing to state that they were drawn to scale hence allowed the entire sum claimed. This was not sufficient. He was required to act judiciously by giving a reasoned decision. This was a contested Bill of Costs which called upon the Taxing Officer to identify the schedule under which the decision was based so as to justify the amount granted

Final disposition

The upshot of the matter is that the Reference is allowed and make the following orders

a. The Taxing Officer’s decision delivered on 6th November 2025 be and is hereby set aside and I direct that this bill be remitted to a different taxing officer for re- taxation accordingly.

b. Each party shall bear Its costs.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 22nd day of October 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Onyancha for the Respondent/Applicant

Mr. Kinyanjui for the Appellant/Respondent

Ms., Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder