Land law

Dari Ltd & another v East African Development Bank & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6855 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mbogo C.G.

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The preliminary objection was upheld. The Environment and Land Court struck out the notice of motion and petition dated 19 May 2026 for want of jurisdiction, with costs to the respondents.

Supporting judgment passages

15. From the above, I find merit in the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 and it is hereby upheld. The notice of motion dated 19th May, 2026 and the petition of even date are hereby struck out with costs to the respondents.

Paragraph 15 →
Issue 1Whether the Environment and Land Court had jurisdiction to hear and determine the petition and notice of motion challenging the valuation, auction and transfer of charged property.

Held. No. Although the petition invoked constitutional rights and sought remedies affecting registrations and ownership, its predominant substance was whether the respondents complied with statutory obligations, especially section 97 of the Land Act, in exercising a statutory power of sale. The rectification prayers were consequential and did not create an independent title or occupation dispute. The dispute concerned enforcement and realization of a security interest and fell within the High Court's civil jurisdiction. The court therefore upheld the preliminary objection and struck out the motion and petition with costs.

Ratio. Jurisdiction is determined by the true nature of the controversy and reliefs sought, not by the constitutional form in which proceedings are presented. A charge and its realization are dispositions/security interests rather than land use, occupation, or title disputes within the Environment and Land Court's jurisdiction. Invoking constitutional provisions cannot confer jurisdiction where the substance of the dispute lies outside that jurisdiction.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

2. The preliminary objection was canvassed through written submissions. The respondents filed their written submissions dated 24th June, 2026. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 30th June, 2026. I have considered the notice of preliminary objection, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether this court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the petition.

Passage 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

12. In this case, although the petitioners invoke constitutional rights and seek orders affecting the registration and ownership of land, the substance of their complaint is the alleged failure by the respondents to comply with statutory obligations governing valuation and disposal of charged property. The principal question is whether the exercise of the statutory power of sale complied with Section 97 of the Land Act. The court further notes that the petition also seeks rectification of resultant registrations. However, these prayers arise consequentially from the challenge to the valuation and statutory sale. They do not, in the circumstances disclosed in the petition, constitute an independent dispute concerning title or occupation sufficient to alter the predominant character of the proceedings.

Paragraph 12 →

13. The mere invocation of Articles 40, 46 and 47 of the Constitution does not, confer jurisdiction upon a court otherwise lacking jurisdiction over the substance of the dispute. Jurisdiction must be determined by the nature of the controversy and the reliefs sought, rather than the form in which the proceedings are presented. In applying the principles in Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited v Njuguna & 5 Others (supra), I find that the petition predominantly concerns the enforcement of a security interest and the legality of the resultant statutory sale. That dispute falls within the civil jurisdiction of the high court.

Paragraph 13 →

15. From the above, I find merit in the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 and it is hereby upheld. The notice of motion dated 19th May, 2026 and the petition of even date are hereby struck out with costs to the respondents.

Paragraph 15 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

38. Consequently, the assertion that a charge constitutes use of land within the meaning of Article 162 of the Constitution fails. In addition, the cause of action herein was not the validity of the charge, but a question of accounts.”

Paragraph 38 →

13. The mere invocation of Articles 40, 46 and 47 of the Constitution does not, confer jurisdiction upon a court otherwise lacking jurisdiction over the substance of the dispute. Jurisdiction must be determined by the nature of the controversy and the reliefs sought, rather than the form in which the proceedings are presented. In applying the principles in Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited v Njuguna & 5 Others (supra), I find that the petition predominantly concerns the enforcement of a security interest and the legality of the resultant statutory sale. That dispute falls within the civil jurisdiction of the high court.

Paragraph 13 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 filed by the respondents challenging the jurisdiction of this court on the following grounds:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The preliminary objection was canvassed through written submissions. The respondents filed their written submissions dated 24th June, 2026. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 30th June, 2026. I have considered the notice of preliminary objection, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether this court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the petition.

Paragraph 2 →

Reasoning passage

From the above cited authorities, it is clear that for a preliminary objection to succeed, the same must consist of a pure point of law, with the facts not disputed by the opposing party. Also, a preliminary objection should possess the ability to dispose off the issue that is before court without going to trial and lastly, the same ought to stem from and not outside of pleadings. Having carefully evaluated the grounds of the…

Paragraph 7 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Environment and Land Court had jurisdiction to determine the petition and notice of motion challenging the valuation, auction, sale and transfer of charged property. The court also noted that the petitioners’ submissions raised res judicata and…

Material facts

Dari Limited and Hon. Raphael Tuju petitioned over L.R. No. 1055/165, Dari Business Park. They alleged that the respondents violated Articles 40, 46 and 47 of the Constitution and sections 90, 96 and 97 of the Land Act through gross undervaluation, unlawful…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLPET NO. E036 OF 2026

IN THE MATTER OF: ARTICLES 22, 23, 40, 46, 47, 48 AND 50 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: SECTIONS 90, 96 AND 97 OF THE LAND ACT

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: GROSS UNDERVALUATION, ILLEGAL SALE, NEGLIGENCE, BREACH OF STATUTORY DUTY, UNCONSTITUTIONAL DEPRIVATION OF PROPERTY AND VIOLATION OF CONSUMER RIGHTS

BETWEEN

DARI LIMITED..........................................................................1ST PETITIONER

HON. RAPHAEL TUJU…………………………......................………..2ND PETITIONER

VERSUS

EAST AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK…….....................….....1ST RESPONDENT

KNIGHT FRANK VALUERS LIMITED…………......................…2ND RESPONDENT

GARAM INVESTMENTS AUCTIONEERS……...................…….3RD RESPONDENT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 filed by the respondents challenging the jurisdiction of this court on the following grounds:-

1. This court’s jurisdiction is limited by Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act to determining questions relating to the environment and the use and occupation of, and title to land.

2. The petitioners’ dispute does in so far as it relates to the disposal of charged property is only related to a disposition of a security interest and falls within the civil jurisdiction of the high court.

3. Accordingly, this court does not have jurisdiction to determine either the notice of motion or the petition.

2. The preliminary objection was canvassed through written submissions. The respondents filed their written submissions dated 24th June, 2026. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 30th June, 2026. I have considered the notice of preliminary objection, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether this court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the petition.

3. Before I delve into the merits of what is before the court, let me quickly point out that the petitioners attempted to submit on issues not raised in the preliminary objection. The petitioners raised four issues for determination including whether the petition is res judicata and whether it is sub judice. These two distinct issues are not the subject of the preliminary objection and the same cannot be considered.

4. Law, J.A. in Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Company Limited -vs- West End Distributors (1969) EA 696 stated as follows:-

“So far as I am aware, a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point, will dispose of the suit.  Examples are an objection to jurisdiction of the court, a plea of limitation or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the matter to arbitration...”

5. Also, in the case of John Musakali vs. Speaker County of Bungoma & 4 others (2015) eKLR, it was held that:-

“The position in law is that a preliminary objection should arise from the pleadings and on the basis that facts are agreed by both sides. Once raised the preliminary objection should have the potential to disposing of the suit at that point without the need to go for trial.  If, however, facts are disputed and remain to be ascertained, that would not be a suitable preliminary objection on a point of law.”

6. Further, Ojwang, J (As he then was) in Oraro -vs- Mbaja (2005) KLR 141 where after quoting the statement of Law, JA. in the Mukisa Biscuits case (supra) went on to state that:-

“A 'preliminary objection' correctly understood is now well defined as and declared to be a point of law which must not be blurred by factual details liable to be contested and in any event, to be proved through the process of evidence. Any assertion which claims to be a preliminary objection, yet it bears factual aspects calling for proof, or seeks to adduce evidence for its authentication is not, as a matter of legal principle, a true preliminary objection which the court should allow to proceed. Where a court needs to investigate facts, a matter cannot be raised as a preliminary point....Anything that purports to be a preliminary objection must not deal with disputed facts, and it must not itself derive its foundation from factual information which stands to be tested by normal rules of evidence...”

7. From the above cited authorities, it is clear that for a preliminary objection to succeed, the same must consist of a pure point of law, with the facts not disputed by the opposing party. Also, a preliminary objection should possess the ability to dispose off the issue that is before court without going to trial and lastly, the same ought to stem from and not outside of pleadings. Having carefully evaluated the grounds of the preliminary objection, I am satisfied that the grounds in the preliminary objection raise pure points of law concerning the jurisdiction of this court to hear and determine the notice of motion dated 19th May, 2026 and the petition.

8. The petitioners filed the petition dated 19th May, 2026 seeking the following reliefs:-

a. A declaration that the respondents violated Articles 40,46 and 47 of the Constitution.

b. A declaration that the respondents violated Section 97 of the Land Act.

c. A declaration that the purported auction, sale and transfer of the suit properties was unconstitutional, illegal, null and void.

d. An order nullifying and setting aside the purported auction, sale and transfer.

e. An order directing rectification and cancellation of any resultant transfers or registrations.

f. General damages for unconstitutional deprivation of property, loss of business and breach of statutory duty.

g. Exemplary and aggravated damages for oppressive and unconstitutional conduct.

h. Damages for gross undervaluation and unlawful sale below statutory threshold.

i. In the alternative, should restoration of the properties be impracticable, the respondents jointly and severally compensate the petitioners for the full current market value of the properties, developments thereon, loss of business, loss of rental income and consequential losses together with interest.

j. An order directing ISK and/or independent valuers appointed through the professional body to undertake independent valuation under security protection of the OCS Karen Police Station and file the same in court.

k. Costs of the petition.

l. Any further relief this honourable court deems fit.

9. The petitioners instituted the petition alleging violations of Articles 40, 46 and 47 of the Constitution and Sections 90, 96 and 97 of the Land Act. Their grievance arises from the valuation, auction and transfer of L.R. no. 1055/165, Dari Business Park. They contend that the property was grossly undervalued at Kshs.420 million, that the valuation relied on outdated information and failed to account for developments and rental income, and that the resulting sale was unlawful.

10. In Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, the court of appeal emphasized that jurisdiction is everything and that a court without jurisdiction must down its tools. The jurisdiction of this court is derived from Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, which confer jurisdiction over disputes relating to the environment and the use, occupation of and title to land.

11. Also, the court of appeal in Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited v Njuguna & 5 others [2017] KECA 79 (KLR) considered the jurisdictional distinction between disputes concerning land and those arising from charges and the exercise of a statutory power of sale. The court held that:-

“35.Accordingly, for land use to occur, the land must be utilized for the purpose for which the surface of the land, air above it or ground below it is adapted. To the law therefore, land use entails the application or employment of the surface of the land and/or the air above it and/or ground below it according to the purpose for which that land is adapted. Neither the cujus doctrine nor Article 260 whether expressly or by implication recognizes charging land as connoting land use.

36. By definition, a charge is an interest in land securing the payment of money or money’s worth or the fulfillment of any condition (see Section 2 of the Land Act). As such, it gives rise to a relationship where one person acquires rights over the land of another as security in exchange for money or money’s worth. The rights so acquired are limited to the realization of the security so advanced (see Section 80 of the Land Act). The creation of that relationship therefore, has nothing to do with use of the land (as defined above). Indeed, that relationship is simply limited to ensuring that the chargee is assured of the repayment of the money he has advanced the chargor.

37. Further, Section 2 aforesaid recognizes a charge as a disposition in land. A disposition is distinguishable from land use. While the former creates the relationship, the latter is the utilization of the natural resources found on, above or below the land. As seen before, land use connotes the alteration of the environmental conditions prevailing on the land and has nothing to do with dispositions of land. Saying that creation of an interest or disposition amounts to use of the land, is akin to saying that writing a will bequeathing land or the act of signing a tenancy agreement constitute land use. The mere acquisition or conferment of an interest in land does not amount to use of that land. Else we would neither speak of absentee landlords nor would principles like adverse possession ever arise. If a disposition were held to constitute land use, an absentee landlord with a subsisting legal charge over his land would never have to contend with the consequences of adverse possession, for he would always be said to be ‘using’ his land simply by virtue of having a floating charge/disposition over the property.

38. Consequently, the assertion that a charge constitutes use of land within the meaning of Article 162 of the Constitution fails. In addition, the cause of action herein was not the validity of the charge, but a question of accounts.”

12. In this case, although the petitioners invoke constitutional rights and seek orders affecting the registration and ownership of land, the substance of their complaint is the alleged failure by the respondents to comply with statutory obligations governing valuation and disposal of charged property. The principal question is whether the exercise of the statutory power of sale complied with Section 97 of the Land Act. The court further notes that the petition also seeks rectification of resultant registrations. However, these prayers arise consequentially from the challenge to the valuation and statutory sale. They do not, in the circumstances disclosed in the petition, constitute an independent dispute concerning title or occupation sufficient to alter the predominant character of the proceedings.

13. The mere invocation of Articles 40, 46 and 47 of the Constitution does not, confer jurisdiction upon a court otherwise lacking jurisdiction over the substance of the dispute. Jurisdiction must be determined by the nature of the controversy and the reliefs sought, rather than the form in which the proceedings are presented. In applying the principles in Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited v Njuguna & 5 Others (supra), I find that the petition predominantly concerns the enforcement of a security interest and the legality of the resultant statutory sale. That dispute falls within the civil jurisdiction of the high court.

14. Having found that this court lacks jurisdiction, it would be improper to delve into the merits of the allegations of undervaluation, breach of statutory duty or violation of constitutional rights. These matters fall for determination before a court of competent jurisdiction.

15. From the above, I find merit in the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 and it is hereby upheld. The notice of motion dated 19th May, 2026 and the petition of even date are hereby struck out with costs to the respondents.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT

THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

22/10/2026.

In the presence of:-

Mr. Benson Agunga – court assistant

Mr. Kahora for the 1st & 3rd Defendants/Respondents

Mr. Wakhisi holding brief for Mr. Emmanuel Wetangula for the 2nd Defendant/Respondent

No appearance for Mr. Ndege for the Petitioner/Applicant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder