Land law

Abdille v Ndungi [2026] KEELC 6797 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion dated 17 December 2025 seeking to have the Respondent found in contempt and committed to civil jail was dismissed as without merit. Costs of the application were awarded to the Respondent, payable by the Applicant.

Supporting judgment passages

i. The Application dated 17th December 2025 is without merit and the same is hereby dismissed.

Passage 48 →

ii. The costs of this application shall borne by the Applicant.

Passage 49 →
Issue 1Whether the court was functus officio and therefore barred from entertaining the contempt application after delivering judgment in the appeal.

Held. No. The functus officio doctrine did not apply because the Applicant was not seeking to alter the judgment; he sought enforcement through contempt proceedings for alleged disobedience of that judgment.

Ratio. Functus officio prevents a court from merit-based decisional re-engagement with a matter after final judgment, but does not bar engagement necessary to give effect to an existing judgment where no alteration of its merits is sought.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

16. Before I dive into the merits let me address the issue raise of this court being functus officio . The Court of Appeal discussed this principle in Telcom Kenya LTD v Ochanda (suing on behalf of 996 others) (2014) eKLR. It held as follows:………………. “The functus officio doctrine is one of the mechanisms by means of which the law gives expression to the principle of finality. According to this doctrine, a person who is vested with adjudicative or decision-making powers may, as a general rule, exercise those powers only once in relation to the same matter...The [principle] is that once such a decision has been given, it is (subject to any right of appeal to superior body or functionary) final and conclusive. Such a decision cannot be reviewed or varied by the decision maker.”

Paragraph 16 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

17. I will align myself to the reasoning as above that functus officio doctrine bars the court from a merit based decisional re-engagement with the case. The Applicant in this case is not seeking for alteration to the judgement rather is seeking orders to give effect to the said judgement being that there has been disobedience of the judgement and hence needs the court to intervene. The doctrine of functus officio can therefore not be invoked in this present case.

Paragraph 17 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The doctrine is not to be understood to bar any engagement by a court with a case that it has already decided or pronounced itself on. What it does bar is a merit-based decisional re-engagement with the case once final judgment has been entered and a decree thereon issued. There do therefore exist certain exceptions and these have been captured thus in Jersey Evening Post Ltd Vs Ai Thani [2002] JLR 542 at 550, also cited and applied by the Supreme Court

Passage 32 →

17. I will align myself to the reasoning as above that functus officio doctrine bars the court from a merit based decisional re-engagement with the case. The Applicant in this case is not seeking for alteration to the judgement rather is seeking orders to give effect to the said judgement being that there has been disobedience of the judgement and hence needs the court to intervene. The doctrine of functus officio can therefore not be invoked in this present case.

Paragraph 17 →
Issue 2Whether the Respondent was in civil contempt of the judgment delivered on 9 December 2025 by continuing to receive rent from subtenants.

Held. No. Although the Respondent knew of the judgment, it did not contain a clear, express, positive order requiring maintenance of the status quo or specifically prohibiting her from receiving rent. The Applicant therefore did not prove deliberate and wilful breach of a clear court directive, and the contempt application was dismissed.

Ratio. Civil contempt requires a clear and unambiguous binding order, notice or knowledge of it, breach of its terms, and deliberate conduct. Contempt cannot be founded on implication or inference; where the alleged order is ambiguous, the benefit of doubt goes to the alleged contemnor.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

18. Moving on to the merits of the application ,the basis of the prayer for the Respondent to be cited for contempt is the Applicant’s contention that contrary to the judgement delivered on the 9th December 2025, the Respondent has continued to receive rent from the sub tenants based on communication she wrote to the sub tenants asking for rent to be channelled to her and not the Applicant.The Respondent however submits that there were no positive orders that were issued with directions to either refrain from doing something or to act on something and hence cannot be said to have disobeyed any orders. That further the orders in the judgment were not clear ambiguous hence no prove of deliberate or wilful disobedience.

Paragraph 18 →

19. The elements that must be proved in an application for civil contempt were laid out in Katsuri Limited Vs Kapurchand Depar Shah (2016) KEHC 6447 (KLR) as follows:-

Paragraph 19 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

21. From the above reading, I hold that in as much as the court established that the Applicant’s rights had been infringed and that the tribunal should have issued status quo orders, the Court did not expressly issue an order directing that “status quo” be maintained in general terms. Rather, the acknowledgement that those should have been the orders issued at the tribunal. The Applicant contends that the Court ordered maintenance of the status quo. However, a plain reading of the paragraph 28 reveals that the court gave an expression of what should have been. No positive order as the maintenance of status quo was granted.

Paragraph 21 →

24. Contempt is a remedy of last resort and must be exercised with restraint. In the circumstances of this case, I am not satisfied, to the required standard, that there has been willful and deliberate disobedience of the judgement delivered on 9th December 2025. The Applicant has failed to demonstrate that the alleged acts complained of fell within a specific prohibition contained in said judgement and that there was deliberate and wilful breach of a clear and unambiguous directive of this Court.

Paragraph 24 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

a) the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant;

Passage 36 →

d) the defendant's conduct was deliberate.

Passage 39 →

23. The third limb is to establish whether there was wilful disobedience by the Respondent. Having held that there is ambiguity in the order and that it was not clear, I hold the view that contempt cannot be founded on implication or inference. It must be founded upon a clear breach of a specific command of the Court. Where ambiguity exists, the benefit of doubt must be resolved in favour of the alleged contemnor.

Paragraph 23 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 17th December 2025 seeking the following orders;

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

In regards to the issue of contempt the Respondent urged the court to be guided by the principles of what was established in the case Samuel M.N Mweru & Others Vs National Land commission & 2 others

Paragraph 12 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Environment and Land Court was functus officio after its earlier judgment, and whether Joan Njoki Ndungi was in civil contempt of the judgment delivered on 9 December 2025 by continuing to receive rent from subtenants.

Material facts

Hassan Abdille appealed a Business Premises Rent Tribunal decision and obtained judgment on 9 December 2025. He asserted that setting aside the tribunal ruling restored the prior position in which he, as head tenant/sublandlord, collected rent from…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELCLA E176 OF 2024

HASSAN ABDILLE …………………………...……………....… APPLICANT/APPELLANT

-VERSUS-

JOAN NJOKI NDUNGI ………..……….………………………..…………RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 17th December 2025 seeking the following orders;

1. Spent

2. THAT this honourable court do find that the Respondent is in contempt of the orders in the judgement delivered by this court on 9th December 2025

3. THAT upon filing of contempt this honourable court be pleased to commit the Respondent to civil jail for at least 6 months

4. THAT this honourable court be pleased to grant any other such further orders that it may deem fit and expedient to grant in the circumstances

5. Costs of this application be provided for in any case

2. The application was premised on grounds that the Appellant being dissatisfied with the decision delivered on the 14th August 2025 in the BPRT in case no E215 of 2024 had preferred this appeal and sough for setting aside of the orders issued via the ruling of 14th February 2024.In the said appeal, judgement was delivered in his favour on 9th December 2025.

3. That the said judgement in setting aside the ruling placed the parties back in the position they were in before the filing of the reference which was that the Appellant was to be the one receiving rents from the sub tenants of the Appellant and not the Respondent. That the Respondent in disregard of the judgement went ahead to direct the sub tenants to remit rent to him making him in contempt of the orders of the court which action has caused loss of income to the Appellant despite being a judgement in his favour.

4. The Respondent opposed the application by filing grounds of objection dated 17th December 2025, further grounds on 20th February 206 and a replying affidavit sworn on the 29th June 2026.She deponed that the court was functus officio having rendered a decision and could not entertain the application.

5. She further deponed that the judgment of the court had not issued any positive order requiring compliance by the Respondent rather just dismissed the decision of the tribunal and there being no order requiring compliance, then she could not be held in contempt.

6. That the Applicant had met the threshold for contempt being he had not proven that that the conduct of the Respondent was deliberate and that she willfully disobeyed court orders.

7. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions with the Appellant/Applicant filing submissions dated 20th August 2026 whereas the Respondent filed submissions dated 26th September 2026.

8. Counsel for the Applicant reiterated the fact that the Respondent was in contempt of court orders knowing very well that the judgment in the appeal setting aside the ruling of the tribunal, restored the parties into their previous positions, which was that the Applicant had been the one collecting rent from the sub tenants and not the Respondent.

9. Counsel submitted that the Respondent cannot claim there were no orders capable of enforcement as she was seeking to misinterpret the judgement which clearly maintained status quo that he was the one entitled to the rent from the sub tenants.

10. Counsel submitted that the continuous collection of rent by the Respondent amounts to contempt submitting that court orders ought to be obeyed as they are not made in vain relying on Kenya Tea Growers Association Vs Francis Atwoli and 5 others (2012) eKLR.

11. The Respondent reiterated her arguments as in the grounds of objection that the court cannot rewrite or review its orders having entered judgement.

12. In regards to the issue of contempt the Respondent urged the court to be guided by the principles of what was established in the case Samuel M.N Mweru & Others Vs National Land commission & 2 others

13. Counsel also submitted that the Applicant had not proved contempt of court to the required standard since the elements required had not been proved being the order was clear and unambiguous, that the Respondent had knowledge of proper notice and that the Respondent acted in breach and deliberately. That the Applicant had not demonstrated forceful eviction by the Respondent

14. Counsel further submitted that the standard of proof in contempt matters was higher due to consequences of it including imprisonment and hence ought to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.

Analysis and determination

15. Having considered the Notice of motion application, the replying affidavit and the submissions filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.

16. Before I dive into the merits let me address the issue raise of this court being functus officio . The Court of Appeal discussed this principle in Telcom Kenya LTD v Ochanda (suing on behalf of 996 others) (2014) eKLR. It held as follows:………………. “The functus officio doctrine is one of the mechanisms by means of which the law gives expression to the principle of finality. According to this doctrine, a person who is vested with adjudicative or decision-making powers may, as a general rule, exercise those powers only once in relation to the same matter...The [principle] is that once such a decision has been given, it is (subject to any right of appeal to superior body or functionary) final and conclusive. Such a decision cannot be reviewed or varied by the decision maker.”

The doctrine is not to be understood to bar any engagement by a court with a case that it has already decided or pronounced itself on. What it does bar is a merit-based decisional re-engagement with the case once final judgment has been entered and a decree thereon issued. There do therefore exist certain exceptions and these have been captured thus in Jersey Evening Post Ltd Vs Ai Thani [2002] JLR 542 at 550, also cited and applied by the Supreme Court

17. I will align myself to the reasoning as above that functus officio doctrine bars the court from a merit based decisional re-engagement with the case. The Applicant in this case is not seeking for alteration to the judgement rather is seeking orders to give effect to the said judgement being that there has been disobedience of the judgement and hence needs the court to intervene. The doctrine of functus officio can therefore not be invoked in this present case.

18. Moving on to the merits of the application ,the basis of the prayer for the Respondent to be cited for contempt is the Applicant’s contention that contrary to the judgement delivered on the 9th December 2025, the Respondent has continued to receive rent from the sub tenants based on communication she wrote to the sub tenants asking for rent to be channelled to her and not the Applicant.The Respondent however submits that there were no positive orders that were issued with directions to either refrain from doing something or to act on something and hence cannot be said to have disobeyed any orders. That further the orders in the judgment were not clear ambiguous hence no prove of deliberate or wilful disobedience.

19. The elements that must be proved in an application for civil contempt were laid out in Katsuri Limited Vs Kapurchand Depar Shah (2016) KEHC 6447 (KLR) as follows:-

a) the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant;

b) the defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order;

c) the defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order; and

d) the defendant's conduct was deliberate.

20. The first element is that the terms of the order must be clear and unambiguous and must be binding on the Respondent. I have perused the said judgement and do note the court indicated as below at paragraph 28;

“Regarding the application for injunctive orders, and having established that the Appellant’s rights as sublandlord/head tenant were infringed , the appropriate order would have been to maintain status quo .Now the court has determined the main appeal ,I find the application is moot and I see no need to examine it further’’

21. From the above reading, I hold that in as much as the court established that the Applicant’s rights had been infringed and that the tribunal should have issued status quo orders, the Court did not expressly issue an order directing that “status quo” be maintained in general terms. Rather, the acknowledgement that those should have been the orders issued at the tribunal. The Applicant contends that the Court ordered maintenance of the status quo. However, a plain reading of the paragraph 28 reveals that the court gave an expression of what should have been. No positive order as the maintenance of status quo was granted.

22. The next issue to consider is whether the Respondent knew the order. There is no dispute that the parties were present during the delivery of the judgement and the Respondent had not disputed the same. On this limb, the Applicant has satisfied the requirement.

23. The third limb is to establish whether there was wilful disobedience by the Respondent. Having held that there is ambiguity in the order and that it was not clear, I hold the view that contempt cannot be founded on implication or inference. It must be founded upon a clear breach of a specific command of the Court. Where ambiguity exists, the benefit of doubt must be resolved in favour of the alleged contemnor.

24. Contempt is a remedy of last resort and must be exercised with restraint. In the circumstances of this case, I am not satisfied, to the required standard, that there has been willful and deliberate disobedience of the judgement delivered on 9th December 2025. The Applicant has failed to demonstrate that the alleged acts complained of fell within a specific prohibition contained in said judgement and that there was deliberate and wilful breach of a clear and unambiguous directive of this Court.

Final disposition

The upshot of the above is that;

i. The Application dated 17th December 2025 is without merit and the same is hereby dismissed.

ii. The costs of this application shall borne by the Applicant.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 22nd day of October 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Mwangi for the Appellant/Applicant

Ms. Nasamba for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder