Land law

Ranford Holdings (Company) Ltd v Kana & 5 others [2026] KEELC 7120 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
23 October 2026
Judge(s)
T. Murigi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Notice of Motion dated 23rd January 2026, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 6, and 18(1) of the Civil Procedure Act, Practice Direction Number 15 of the Commercial & Admiralty Division (Practice Direction on Case Management) dated 25th July 2014, and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiff/ Applicant seeks the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

He contended that transferring the present suit would be futile, as the Defendants had applied to strike out ELC Case No. E584 of 2025 and a ruling on that application was pending. He further contended that the Plaintiff had offered no good reason for filing multiple suits, and that adding parties would not change the facts, since the issue of ownership had been conclusively determined and no appeal had been preferred against that…

Paragraph 7 →

Reasoning passage

In light of the foregoing, this Court finds that the plea of res judicata cannot be determined in this application. The 1st and 2nd Defendants are at liberty to raise it in the appropriate forum.

Paragraph 35 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC NO. E618 OF 2025

RANFORD HOLDINGS (COMPANY) LIMITED ………………… PLAINTIFF

-VERSUS-

PARESH LALIT KANA …………………………………………1ST DEFENDANT

THE ESTATE OF LALIT BABA KANA &

MANJULA LALIT KANA ……………………………………2ND DEFENDANT

THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR ………………………………3RD DEFENDANT

DIRECTOR OF SURVEY ………………………………………4TH DEFENDANT

HAFAYA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED ………....5TH DEFENDANT

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL………………6TH DEFENDANT

RULING

1. By a Notice of Motion dated 23rd January 2026, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 6, and 18(1) of the Civil Procedure Act, Practice Direction Number 15 of the Commercial & Admiralty Division (Practice Direction on Case Management) dated 25th July 2014, and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiff/ Applicant seeks the following orders:

a. Spent.

b. That the two suits in ELC No. E618 of 2025: Ranford Holdings Company Limited vs Paresh Lalit Kana & 5 Others and ELCLC/E584/2025: Ranford Holdings Limited vs Paresha Lalit Kana be consolidated and heard together, as both suits arise from the same facts.

c. That the mention date for the Plaintiff's Application currently fixed for 29 January 2026 before this Honourable Court be vacated, and both matters be scheduled for mention and inter partes hearing on 29th January 2026 before Hon. Justice Mohamed N. Kullow in ELCLC/E584/2025: Ranford Holdings Limited Vs Paresha Lalit Kana

d. That the costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of Noor Haji Ali sworn on even date.

THE APPLICANTS CASE

3. The deponent averred that on 18th November 2025, the Applicant filed ELC Case No. E584 of 2025, Ranford Holdings Limited v Paresha Lalit Kana, before Mohamed N. Kullow J, relating to L.R. Nos. 1870/1/620 (formerly L.R. No. 1870/1/451) and 1870/1/621. He further averred that on 8th December 2025, the Applicant filed ELC Case No. E618 of 2025 relating to the same property before this Court.

4. The deponent contends that the two suits raise substantially identical questions of law and fact and involve the same parties. He further contends that proceeding with the application separately would waste judicial time, expose the parties to duplicative litigation, and risk inconsistent decisions, contrary to the overriding objective set out in Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act. He contends that the suits should be heard together to avoid duplication, sub judice issues, and conflicting decisions. He maintains that no party would suffer prejudice. Accordingly, he urges the Court to grant the application as prayed.

THE 1ST DEFENDANT’S CASE

5. The 1st Defendant filed a replying affidavit dated 2nd March 2026 in opposition to the application. He averred that in an earlier suit, ELC No. 574 of 2017, this Court held that his late parents were the legitimate owners of L.R. Nos. 1870/1/451 and 1870/1/452, and ordered the cancellation of L.R. Nos. 1870/1/620 and 1870/1/621. He further averred that the Plaintiff became aware of the suit and the decree in October 2025 but nonetheless filed ELC Case No. E584 of 2025 and the present suit, which, in his view, constitutes an abuse of the Court's process.

6. He contended that the present suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata and therefore raises a jurisdictional issue. He further averred that the Court could not order the consolidation or transfer of the suit before determining that issue. He argued that a suit that is sub judice cannot be consolidated, as doing so would leave a party with two plaints in the same matter. He maintained that the Plaintiff’s only option was to withdraw one of the suits, since consolidation would amount to the Court facilitating an illegality.

7. He contended that transferring the present suit would be futile, as the Defendants had applied to strike out ELC Case No. E584 of 2025 and a ruling on that application was pending. He further contended that the Plaintiff had offered no good reason for filing multiple suits, and that adding parties would not change the facts, since the issue of ownership had been conclusively determined and no appeal had been preferred against that decision. He averred that the titles relied upon by the Plaintiff were the same as those held by Hafaya Construction Company Limited in ELC Case No. 574 of 2017.

8. He averred that the surveyor denied preparing the deed plans for L.R. No. 1870/1/620 and L.R. No. 1870/1/621, while the Nairobi City County Government denied authorising any change of use.

9. He averred that the Plaintiff had used hired persons to evict the Defendants’ people from the suit premises, contrary to a court order, despite the Defendants' ownership of the property since 1981. He further alleged that certain officers in the offices of the 3rd and 4th Defendants were acting in concert with the Plaintiff, since search certificates over the same property could not otherwise have been issued to both the Plaintiff and the 5th Defendant. He urged the court to hold the 3rd and 4th Defendants liable for disobedience of court orders. In conclusion, he urged the court to dismiss the application with costs.

10. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

THE APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS

11. The Plaintiff filed its submissions dated 2nd March 2026. On behalf of the Applicant, Counsel submitted that Article 159(2) of the Constitution requires justice to be administered expeditiously, fairly and without undue regard for procedural technicalities. Counsel further submitted that consolidating suits raising common questions of law and fact is consistent with that mandate. Counsel argued that Order 11 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the court to consolidate suits to avoid unnecessary costs, duplication of proceedings and conflicting decisions. Counsel further submitted that the Court’s discretion is reinforced by the overriding objective and the court's inherent power under Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act.

12. Counsel relied on Law Society of Kenya v Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 others [2014] KESC 29 (KLR), where the Supreme Court held that the essence of consolidation is to facilitate the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes and to provide a framework for the fair and impartial dispensation of justice. Counsel also relied on Benson G. Mutahi v Raphael Gichovi Munene Kabutu & 4 others [2014] KEELC 660 (KLR), Korean United Church of Kenya & 3 others v Seng Ha Sang [2014] eKLR, and Selecta Kenya GmbH & Co. KG v Chase Bank Kenya Limited & 2 others [2018] KEHC 10025 (KLR), to submit that consolidation saves costs, time and effort, avoids multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting decisions, and ought to be ordered where it serves the interests of justice without prejudicing any party. Counsel further cited Langat & 2 others v Atticon Limited & 7 others; Kitany (Interested Party) [2025] KEHC 4718 (KLR) to emphasize the court’s inherent power to manage cases so as to avoid delay and ensure fairness in accordance with Articles 50 and 159 of the Constitution.

13. Counsel submitted that the requirements for consolidation had been met as the two suits raised substantially similar questions of law and fact, arose from the same transaction, concerned the same property, involved identical or closely connected parties, and would rely on substantially overlapping evidence. In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to allow the application as prayed.

THE 1ST AND 2ND DEFENDANT’S SUBMISSIONS

14. The 1st and 2nd Defendants filed two sets of submissions dated 3rd March 2026 and 20th April 2026.

15. Counsel submitted that the present suit is barred by the doctrines of sub judice and res judicata, as both suits were instituted by the same party and sought the same relief. Counsel further argued that the Plaintiff had not disputed the applicability of the doctrine of sub judice and had relied solely on the court's inherent powers, which must be exercised in accordance with the law and cannot override Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.

16. Counsel submitted that filing a second suit did not change the fact that the issues in the two suits were directly and substantially the same, and that the Plaintiff could have obtained what it sought in the second suit by amending its pleadings in the first suit, so that filing the second suit was an abuse of the court's process. To support this point, Counsel relied on Dante Bruba (K) Limited & 2 others v Dante Burba Diesel Workshop (1981) Limited & 2 others (High Court Case No. 42 of 2016).

17. Counsel further relied on Malika & another v Bidii International Company Limited & another [2023] KEHC 21394 (KLR), where the Court held that consolidation is impermissible where a suit offends the doctrine of sub judice, as consolidation is not meant to cure sub judice or an abuse of the process of the court. Counsel also relied on Morop Distributors (K) Limited v Chebon [2022] KEELC 2968 (KLR), to submit that the suit in that matter was struck out on the ground of sub judice.

18. Counsel submitted that the present dispute concerns ownership between the Plaintiff and the 1st and 2nd Defendants, who are parties to both suits. Counsel further submitted that consolidating the two suits would offend the doctrine of sub judice and leave the Plaintiff with two plaints seeking substantially the same relief in a single matter.

19. Counsel further submitted that the Plaintiff had concealed material facts in its plaint by asserting that no other suit concerning the subject matter was pending, despite knowing that it had filed another suit. Counsel relied on Uhuru Highway Development Ltd v Central Bank of Kenya & 2 others (Civil Application No. NAI 140 of 1995), in which Omolo JA held that a party who deceives the court to obtain an order cannot claim to have a meritorious case. Counsel also relied on Rev. Madam Evans Okanga Dondo v Housing Finance Company of Kenya, in which Kimaru J held that a plaintiff’s concealment of material facts was dishonest, constituted an abuse of the court’s process, and warranted the court’s sanction.

20. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff is not entitled to the relief sought because the suit contravenes the doctrines of sub judice and res judicata. Relying on Muchanga Investments Limited v Safaris Unlimited (Africa) Ltd & 2 others, Counsel further submitted that the suit constitutes an abuse of the judicial process.

THE 3RD, 4TH AND 6TH DEFENDANT’S’ SUBMISSIONS

21. The 3rd, 4th and 6th Defendants filed their submissions dated 14th April 2026.

22. Counsel submitted that the Defendants did not oppose the consolidation of the two suits, as public policy favors the prudent use of judicial time and public resources.

23. Counsel further submitted that the power to consolidate derives from the overriding objective and the Court’s inherent powers under Sections 1A, 1B, and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, as well as Order 11 Rule 3(1)(h) of the Civil Procedure Rules. Counsel relied on Prem Lala Nahata & another v Chandi Prasad Sikaria (2007) 2 SCC 551, in which the Supreme Court of India held that consolidation is intended to save costs, time, and effort by treating several actions as one. The Court further held that consolidation may be ordered where common questions of law or fact arise, or where the reliefs claimed arise from the same transaction or a series of transactions.

24. Counsel submitted that the decision to consolidate suits is discretionary and depends on whether the same questions of law or fact arise; whether the relief sought stems from the same transaction or subject matter; whether any party would be prejudiced; whether the parties are identical; whether consolidation would prevent a multiplicity of suits; and whether it would promote the efficient administration of justice.

25. Applying those principles, Counsel submitted that the two suits involved identical parties and property and raised common questions of law and fact. Counsel further submitted that failure to consolidate the suits could lead to inconsistent findings between the same litigants regarding the same land. Counsel also submitted that ELC Case No. E584 of 2025 concerned ownership of the suit parcels, whereas the present suit concerned their possession and use.

26. Counsel further submitted that consolidation would prevent duplicative proceedings and inconsistent decisions, and that no party would be prejudiced, as all parties would have a full opportunity to be heard and their respective claims and defences would be preserved.

27. Counsel further relied on Law Society of Kenya v Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 others [2014] KESC 29 (KLR), Nyati Security Guards & Services Ltd v Municipal Council of Mombasa [2000] eKLR and Kinuthia v Ndiritu (Miscellaneous Civil Application E456 of 2022) [2024] KEHC 5772 (KLR) to submit on the principles governing consolidation and the Court's discretion.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

28. Having considered the application, the responses and the rival submissions, the following issues arise for determination:

a. Whether this suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata

b. Whether this suit offends the sub judice rule

c. Whether the application for consolidation is merited

WHETHER THE SUIT IS BARRED BY THE DOCTRINE RES JUDICATA

29. The 1st Defendant contends that the present suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. This doctrine is founded on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which provides as follows:

“No court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court.”

30. In Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 others [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal established the elements that must be satisfied for the doctrine of res judicata to apply:

“a) The suit or issue was directly and substantially in issue in the former suit.
b) That former suit was between the same parties or parties under whom they or any of them claim.

c) Those parties were litigating under the same title.

d) The issue was heard and finally dete
rmined in the former suit.
e) The court that formerly heard and determined the issue was competent to try the subsequent suit or the suit in which the issue is raised.”

31. The 1st Defendant relied on Kana & another v Director of Survey & 3 others (Environment & Land Case 574 of 2017) [2023] KEELC 21875 (KLR) to contend that the present suit is res judicata. In that suit, Lalit Baba Kana and Manjula Lalit Kana sued the Director of Survey, the Chief Land Registrar, the Attorney General and Hafaya Construction Company Limited. The Court found that the Plaintiffs’ titles to L.R. Nos. 1870/1/451 and 1870/1/452, and the titles to L.R. Nos. 1870/1/620 and 1870/1/621 claimed by Hafaya Construction Company Limited, related to the same physical parcels. The Court declared the Plaintiffs to be the lawful owners of the suit premises. It directed the cancellation of any document, title or name registered against those titles other than the Plaintiffs’ names and dismissed Hafaya Construction Company Limited’s counterclaim.

32. The ownership of the suit parcels was therefore directly and substantially in issue in ELC No. 574 of 2017 and was heard and determined by a competent court. However, the Plaintiff was not a party to ELC No. 574 of 2017. The 1st Defendant’s case is that the titles held by the Plaintiff are the same as those held by Hafaya Construction Company Limited, with only the proprietor's name changed. This, however, is contested. The Plaintiff’s root of title has not been shown to be linked to Hafaya Construction. Whether the Plaintiff claims under Hafaya Construction Company Limited remains a contested question of fact that can only be resolved on evidence.

33. It is well established that a matter requiring factual ascertainment cannot be determined summarily. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the Court held that an objection requiring factual ascertainment is not a pure point of law.

34. The 1st Defendant contends that an application to strike out ELC No. E584 of 2025 is pending and that the suit is now being handled alongside matters arising from the former suit. That forum is better placed to determine the relationship between the Plaintiff’s titles and the decree in ELC No. 574 of 2017.

35. In light of the foregoing, this Court finds that the plea of res judicata cannot be determined in this application. The 1st and 2nd Defendants are at liberty to raise it in the appropriate forum.

WHETHER THIS SUIT OFFENDS THE SUB JUDICE RULE

36. Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act provides:

“No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceeding in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed.”

37. In Kenya National Commission on Human Rights v Attorney General; Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 16 others (Interested Parties) [2020] KESC 54 (KLR), the Supreme Court stated that:

“The purpose of the sub judice rule is to stop the filing of a multiplicity of suits between the same parties or those claiming under them over the same subject matter so as to avoid abuse of the Court process and diminish the chances of courts, with competent jurisdiction, issuing conflicting decisions over the same subject matter. This means that when two or more cases are filed between the same parties on the same subject matter before courts with jurisdiction, the matter that is filed later ought to be stayed in order to await the determination to be made in the earlier suit. A party that seeks to invoke the doctrine of res sub judice must therefore establish that: there is more than one suit over the same subject matter; that one suit was instituted before the other; that both suits are pending before courts of competent jurisdiction and lastly, that the suits are between the same parties or their representatives.”

38. The record shows that the Plaintiff commenced ELC No. E584 of 2025 against the Defendant, Paresh Lalit Kana, by a plaint dated 18th November 2025. The Plaintiff claims ownership of the suit properties, alleges trespass, and sets out the particulars of the alleged trespass. The reliefs sought include a declaration that the Plaintiff is the lawful owner of the suit properties and a permanent injunction restraining the Defendant from trespassing on or otherwise dealing with the suit properties.

39. The Plaintiff also commenced the present suit by a plaint dated 8 December 2025. The Defendants are Paresh Lalit Kana, the Estate of Lalit Baba Kana, Manjula Lalit Kana, the Chief Land Registrar, the Director of Survey, Hafaya Construction Company Limited, and the Honourable Attorney General.

40. The Plaintiff seeks a declaration of ownership; a permanent injunction restraining the Defendants from tampering with the land records for the suit properties, trespassing, transferring or interfering with the suit properties; an order compelling the Defendants to cancel any document, title or name registered against the suit properties other than the Plaintiffs' names and to restore the Plaintiffs' names; a declaration that the Defendants' actions amount to trespass, fraud and unlawful interference; an order of eviction and damages for trespass, among other relief.

41. Both suits are pending before this Court, which is competent to grant the reliefs sought in each. Both suits relate to L.R. Nos. 1870/1/620 and 1870/1/621, formerly L.R. Nos. 1870/1/451 and 1870/1/452.

42. A comparison of the pleadings shows a substantial overlap between the two suits. In both proceedings, the Plaintiff seeks to establish its proprietary interest in the same properties and to obtain protection against alleged trespass. Ownership is central to both claims and is likely to be a material issue in determining the respective claims for trespass and for injunctive relief.

43. The fact that the present suit introduces additional Defendants and allegations of fraud does not by itself remove the substantial overlap between the proceedings.

44. The present suit raises additional issues concerning fraud, misrepresentation, and irregularities in the land records, which may require the participation of parties who are not defendants in ELC 584 of 2025. These allegations may also raise further questions regarding the conduct of the relevant public officers and other parties. However, the allegations are not established merely because they have been pleaded. Their existence does not automatically render the entire suit sub judice, just as their inclusion does not automatically defeat the objection.

45. In the circumstances, I find that the issues of ownership and trespass raised in the present suit are directly and substantially in issue in ELC E584 of 2025.

46. The next issue for determination is whether the appropriate course is to stay the present suit or to consolidate the two suits.

47. In Law Society of Kenya v Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 others [2014] KESC 29 (KLR), the Supreme Court stated:

“The essence of consolidation is to facilitate the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes, and to provide a framework for a fair and impartial dispensation of justice to the parties. Consolidation was never meant to confer any undue advantage upon the party that seeks it, nor was it intended to occasion any disadvantage towards the party that opposes it.”

48. The Supreme Court reiterated in Omoke v Kenyatta & 83 others [2021] KESC 27 (KLR) that consolidation may be ordered where two or more suits raise common questions of law or fact and it is desirable for all related matters to be disposed of concurrently.

49. In the present case, the substantial overlap between the ownership and trespass claims favours determining the common issues in a coordinated manner. At the same time, the additional allegations of misrepresentation, fraud, and irregularities, as well as the participation of defendants who are not parties to ELC 584 of 2025, require the Court to ensure that their distinct claims and defences are preserved and that each party is afforded a fair opportunity to be heard.

50. In light of the foregoing, I find that the present suit is sub judice to the extent that it seeks to determine ownership and trespass issues that are directly and substantially in issue in ELC 584 of 2025. However, I am not satisfied that the mere existence of these common issues justifies staying every claim against every defendant without considering the additional matters raised. This Court must ensure that any order does not circumvent Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.

51. Accordingly, this Court makes the following orders

a) The objection based on the doctrine of sub judice succeeds to the extent that the present suit raises ownership and trespass issues directly and substantially in issue in 584 of 2025.

b) The parties shall appear before Hon Ochieng for directions on the appropriate management of the overlapping issues and the distinct claims against the additional defendants, consistent with Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.

c) The question of consolidation or stay shall be determined after those directions, having regard to the pleadings, the reliefs sought and the need to avoid parallel determination of the common issues.

d) Costs shall abide the outcome of the application.

RULING SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

…………………………………….

HON. T. MURIGI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Bosire holding brief for Omwanza for the Plaintiffs

Were for the 1st and 2nd Defendants

Vena – Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder