REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 126 OF 2011
AGGREY ATSIAVULA MWANZI ………………………. 1ST PLAINTIFF
SOFIA NABANGALA NDOLO ……………………….…. 2ND PLAINTIFF
(Both Trading as Kayole Hekima Academy Educational Centre)
VERSUS
BEN JOSEPH MWANGI ……………………………….. 1ST DEFENDANT
BISHOP JUSTUS WANJALA
Sued as Representative and Trading as
LIGHT HOUSE CHURCH …………………………….. 2ND DEFENDANT
CITY COUNCIL OF NAIROBI ……………………….. 3RD DEFENDANT
SAMUEL NDUMBE NJOROGE …………………….. 4TH DEFENDANT
STEPHEN ODOYO T/A
BROOKFIELD ACADEMY ………………………….… 5TH DEFENDANT
JUDGEMENT
1. The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide a plaint dated 28th March 2011 and amended on 8th July 2015. They contended that they are the registered and proprietary owners 0f Plot No. Block A, Komarock South, Kayole vide allocation by the 3rd Defendant in 1991. Further, that for more than twenty (20) years, they have been operating Kayole Hekima Educational Academy thereon, which is a school that offers basic and primary education to more than five hundred (500) orphans and underprivileged students within Kayole.
2. They averred that the 1st and 2nd Defendants and their agents unlawfully entered the suit plot and commenced construction with intent to evict them. Further, that the 4th and 5th Defendants have also trespassed and encroached onto the suit plot and the adjacent road reserve.
3. They therefore prayed for judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally for;
a) Permanent and injunctive orders restraining the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th Defendants whether by themselves, agents, servants and or any other person claiming title or whatsoever interest from interfering, demolishing, alienating, erecting any structures, trespassing, erecting structures, occupying, obtaining titles and or in whatsoever manner interfering with the suit property known as Kayole Hekima Educational Academy on Plot No. Block A, Komarock South, Corner Shop located at Masimba Road, off Spine Road, Kayole Nairobi.
b) Declaratory orders directing and declaring the Plaintiffs as rightful owners entitled to operate Kayole Hekima Educational Academy on the suit premises Plot No. Block A, Komarock South, Corner Shop to the exclusion of the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 5th Defendants and or other third parties or agents.
c) Costs and Interest of the suit.
Responses
4. The suit was opposed by the 1st and 2nd Defendants who filed a joint statement of defence. They denied allegations levelled against them in the plaint and contended that they have no intention of encroaching on the suit plot or evicting the Plaintiffs as alleged. They also contended that the 1st Defendant is the registered owner of Plot No. Block B. Komarock South, Corner Shop, and that the suit is res judicata Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005, which concerned similar subject matter, and which was dismissed for want of prosecution.
5. In opposition, the 3rd Defendant filed an amended statement of defence. It admitted that the suit plot was allocated to the Plaintiffs and that a school is erected thereon. On a without prejudice basis, it averred that it is non-suited as the Plaintiffs did not plead any infringement against it.
6. On his part, the 4th Defendant filed a defence and counterclaim in opposition. He denied encroaching onto the Plaintiffs’ plot and contended that he is the lawful proprietor of Plot No. 544 Patanisho Phase II which boarders the suit plot and that the two plots are separated by a perimeter wall and age-old trees. Further, that he leased his property to the 5th Defendant who runs Brookfield Academy thereon and that the Plaintiffs threatened him with eviction on allegation that he has encroached on a road reserve purely because the said school is their competitor. He counterclaimed for Orders that:
a) Declaration that the 4th Defendant is the lawful owner of all that parcel of land known as Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase II.
b) A permanent injunction restraining the Plaintiffs by themselves, servants and or agents from trespassing and or interfering or dealing in any other manner with all that parcel of land known as Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase II.
c) Such other or further relief as this Honourable Court may deem fit.
7. The 5th Defendant also filed a statement of defence. He averred that he operates a school known as Brookfield Academy on Plot No. 50A (Now Plot No. 544 Patanisho Phase II), which borders the Plaintiffs’ school. Further, that the Plaintiffs would want his school closed because they are rivals.
8. The Plaintiffs filed a reply to the 5th Defendants’ defence and the 4th Defendant’s defence and counterclaim. They insisted that the said parties have interfered with the suit plot and contended that the alleged Plot No. 544 Patanisho Phase II is a non-existent unlawful creation of the 4th and 5th Defendants in collusion with third parties.
9. The record indicates that on 3rd February 2020, the Plaintiffs withdrew the suit against the 2nd Defendant.
10. The suit was heard through viva voce evidence.
The Plaintiffs’ Evidence
11. The 1st Plaintiff as PW1 testified that in 1989, he moved into the suit plot upon being issued with a license by the 3rd Defendant, after he had reclaimed it from a swamp. He took possession and started running his business and he was subsequently issued with a Letter of Allotment. In 1993, together with his wife (2nd Plaintiff), they sought assistance from well-wishers and donors and established Kayole Hekima Education Centre thereon, which is a school approved by the Ministry of Education.
12. It was his testimony that in 2005, the 1st Defendant, who is a former councilor had attempted to forcefully enter the suit plot but children in the school and the local community resisted his attempts through peaceful demonstrations. However, in 2011, the 1st and 2nd Defendants and their agents forcefully entered the suit plot and erected a church structure known as Light House Church, which he confirmed vacated the suit plot following this Court’s issuance of an interlocutory injunction.
13. He pointed out that Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005 which this suit is alleged to be res judicata on account of, involves different parties, issues and it was dismissed for want of prosecution due to his then advocates’ negligence. He produced thirty (36) documents from the Plaintiffs’ list and bundle of documents dated 15th February 2018 as P. Exhibit No. 1-36.
14. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the 1st Defendant, PW1 confirmed that the suit plot has since been surveyed as Block 167 Plot 643 and that it measures 0.178 hectares. He was categorical that the 1st Defendant first issued him with a temporary allocation license dated 30th June 1991, which is not on its letter head. Further, it subsequently issued him with a Letter of Allotment dated 22nd November 1993 and later a Beacon Certificate dated 16th July 2012. He claimed that Kayole Hekima Education Centre was registered in 1992 as a business name and its particulars were later changed in 2008. When probed on why the certificate of change of particulars states the said business name was originally registered on 13th January 2002, he insisted that it existed at the time of allocation of the suit plot.
15. When tasked on the reason why there were two competing Letters of Allotment to Plot No. A Komarock, dated the 22nd November 1993, he was emphatic that the one in the Plaintiffs’ bundle is addressed to Kayole Hekima Education Centre and the one in the 1st Defendant’s bundle is addressed to him. Further, that for the one addressed to him, he was given a copy by the 1st Defendant who was the then area councilor, but he did not give him the original, and on the same day, Kayole Hekima Education Centre was issued with an original one by the 3rd Defendant.
16. He was also pointed to the 3rd Defendant’s Housing Development and Management Committee’s minutes at page 18-20 of the 1st Defendant’s bundle and he stated that they relate to plot B, whose Allotment Letter was issued to Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealer. He confirmed that he pays rates and insisted that he has not encroached onto the 1st Defendant’s plot. He explained that the sketch map at page 59 of the 1st Defendant’s bundle which bears Plot A, B, C, D was a proposed subdivision which he rejected.
17. In cross-examination by Counsel for the 4th and 5th Defendants, he was categorical that there is no permanent fence between the 4th Defendant’s plot and theirs as alleged. He reiterated that he joined the 4th and 5th Defendants in this suit because they have encroached on a road reserve, blocked the entrance to his school and encroached on the suit plot by about 10 x 50 feet.
18. In re-examination, PW1 insisted that the Plaintiffs have been in occupation of the suit plot since 1989. Further, that the purported Letter of Allotment that is in his name was a ploy by the 1st Defendant to steal his plot. He clarified that the 3rd Defendant’s minutes contained in his bundle of documents confirm his ownership of the suit plot and that the survey map at page 59 of the 1st Defendant’s bundle is not reflective of what is on the ground.
Evidence of the 1st Defendant
19. Three witnesses testified in the case for the 1st Defendant. The 1st Defendant as DW1 stated that Solomon Mwangi Muthoni owns Plot No. C Komarock South Corner Shop and that Plot No. B Komarock South Corners Shop belongs to Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealer, a business he owns, while Plot No. A was allocated to the 1st Plaintiff, a waste paper collector. It was his testimony that Plot No. D belonged to Florence Makelete Mutinda and Plot No. E was given to Mutinda Muthama and Florence Makelete Mutinda, by temporary allocation by the area chief in 1990 and that in 1993, the 3rd Defendant formalized the said allocation vide Allotment Letters. He claimed that in 2001, he decided to start a business together with the owner of Plot No. B so they decided to fence the said plots together (B and C).
20. He confirmed knowing the Plaintiffs for more than twenty (20) years and explained that in 2009, the area where the suit plot is situated was re-planned and given the name Patanisho Phase II. He insisted that the plot the Plaintiffs claim was issued to Hekima Educational Center, does not exist on the ground, as it is the one allocated to the 1st Plaintiff measuring 0.03 hectares that exists on the ground. He claimed that the Plaintiffs are in occupation of Plot Nos. A, B and C. Further, that Kayole Hekima Academy was registered on 13th January 2002 while Nyangi Scrap Metal (alleged owner of Plot B) was registered in February 1991. He produced the 1st Defendant’s bundle of documents dated 16th December 2011 as D. Exhibit 1-14.
21. In cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiff, DW1 confirmed that the Plaintiffs’ Plot is No. A, that was occupied by Light House Church, which moved out in 2011 following this Court’s injunction. He admitted that the Beacon Certificate exhibited in his bundle of documents does not tally with the 3rd Defendant’s. He also confirmed that the certificate of registration of Nyangi Scrap metal exhibited at page 54 of his bundle of documents indicates that the said Nyangi Scrap Metal carries on business at Plot No. Kayole A2 and he has no counterclaim pertaining to his alleged Plot No. B.
22. In re-examination, he reiterated his evidence and averred that he has letters from the 3rd Defendant indicating that Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealers were allocated Plot B.
23. DW2 was Solomon Mwangi Muthoni, the alleged owner of Plot C measuring 0.03 ha Komarock South Corner Shop, which he alleged is the same measurement as the one the 1st Plaintiff was allocated. He testified that Plot No. B measuring 0.08 ha belongs to Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealer and that they decided to start a business together thus they fenced their two plots together.
24. Upon cross- examination by Counsel for the Plaintiffs, DW2 stated that owners of plot A-E were on their respective parcels from 1991 but they got Allotment Letters in 1994, then fenced the said plots with iron sheets in 2001 but the Plaintiffs started encroaching on the 1st Defendant’s plot, of which he just put a gate on plot B that had been fenced and set up kids’ leisure activities thereon.
25. In cross- examination by Counsel for the 3rd Defendant, he insisted that in 1993, owners of the subject plots applied for allocation to the 3rd Defendant who sent a surveyor in 1994 and that the said surveyor showed them their beacons together thus they know each other’s beacons. He confirmed that he was then issued with an Allotment Letter but he did not have it in Court. He insisted that the Plaintiffs have built a school on his plot and in Plot B, they have a children’s play area and a gate thus the school has two (2) gates.
26. When cross-examined by Counsel for the 4th and 5th Defendants, DW2 stated that the 3rd Defendant issued him with a Plot Card in respect of Plot. C, at the time it was formalizing the plots in 2010 and that they returned the said Plot Cards and got Allotment Letters in exchange. He confirmed that Brookfield Academy is opposite plot A and that there is a road in between the two plots.
27. DW3 was Charles Gathari Kaniaru, a Surveyor and a former employee of the 3rd Defendant’s land survey section. His testimony was that in mid-February 1994, he received a phone call from his boss, the Chief Land Surveyor Mr. Jacob Oyatto directing him to assist the 1st Defendant, then councilor of Kayole ward, who had a PDP containing some eight (8) plots, which he wanted surveyed. He claimed that the 1st Defendant was accompanied by some two (2) other men who had been allocated plots within the same PDP area, who also wanted their plots surveyed. Further, that after two (2) days, he did survey the said eight (8) plots A-H including; Plot A to 1st Plaintiff, Plot B to Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealers associated with the 1st Defendant and Plot C belonging to Solomon Mwangi Muthoni. He produced the subject PDP as an exhibit.
28. In cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiffs, DW3 admitted that he did not prepare the impugned PDP, but he got it from the 1st Defendant. He also confirmed that it did not have a signature/stamp of the 3rd Defendant, and contended that his survey was a simple demarcation, it was not formal, as it was done pending a cadastral survey.
29. In cross examination by Counsel for the 4th and 5th Defendants, DW3 confirmed that the impugned PDP was prepared in late 1993, a survey was carried out in early February 1994, and he was not aware of a further subdivision of same land. He explained that where squatters occupy government or county government land and build structures and later on they are recognized and settled officially, the process is referred to as Formalization. Further, that upon formalization, plot numbers do not change as owners remain the same. He explained that while the impugned properties are located in Kayole, the Director of City Planning called them Komarock South to add value to the plots, which fall between Komarock, a middle-class estate and Kayole, a lower income neighborhood. He explained that the area was later renamed as Patanisho, to mean a place where the two different neighborhoods intersect.
Evidence of the 3rd Defendant
30. The 3rd Defendant called one witness, DW4 who was Jane Wanjiru Ndonga, its employee, who worked at its Housing and Development department and retired in 2018. She confirmed that from the 3rd Defendant’s records, the suit plot was allocated to the 1st Plaintiff on a temporary basis vide a license dated 30th June 1991. It was his testimony that the said plot was subsequently allotted to Hekima Educational Centre on 22nd November 1993 on condition that the proprietor pays the requisite fees. Further, that by a Council Meeting of 27th October 2011, the 3rd Defendant’s Town Planning Committee approved Hekima Educational Centre as the bona fide owner of the suit plot and upon payment of kshs.38,000/=, a Beacon Certificate was issued on 16th July 2012, a position the 3rd Defendant confirmed vide its letter dated 13th October 2011, addressed to Nyende & co. Advocates, then acting for the Plaintiffs and who were seeking clarification on the lease. She produced the 3rd Defendant’s documents in evidence. They include; a letter of Temporary Allocation dated 30th June 1991, a Letter of Allotment of Plot A addressed to Kayole Hekima Education Centre dated 22nd November 1993 and minutes of the proceedings of council meetings of the 3rd Defendant confirming Hekima Education Center was the owner of the suit plot.
31. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the 1st Defendant, she could not ascertain that a letter dated 27th June 2011 (at page 40 of the 1st Defendant’s bundle), which alleges that the 1st Plaintiff encroached on Plot B, emanated from the 3rd Defendant. She was not aware of the impugned PDP produced by DW3, and asserted that the exact acreage of the suit plot could only be ascertained vide a Beacon certificate.
32. In cross-examination by Counsel for the 4th and 5th Defendants, she confirmed that she visited the ground in 2010 and that Plot A was dump with papers and other waste and there was also a small structure nursery school and there was no issue of encroachment relating to the suit plot then.
33. Upon re-examination, she was emphatic that if the PDP produced by DW3 had emanated from the 3rd Defendant, it would have a PDP number, and indicate the name of the person who approved it and the date. She also confirmed that the suit plot is now titled.
Evidence of the 4th and 5th Defendants
34. The 4th Defendant testified as DW5. His testimony was that he is the lawful owner of Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase II, which is developed with a permanent building and borders the Plaintiffs’ plot, being demarcated by a permanent perimeter wall and age-old trees. He explained that the said plot was formalized by the 3rd Defendant and is not on a road reserve and neither has it encroached on the Plaintiffs’ plot. He confirmed that he leased the said plot to the 5th Defendant who runs a school. He produced a Formalization Card for Patanisho phase II Plot No. 544 which he alleged is part of LR No. 129 Savannah, dated 3rd November 1999 as D. Exhibit 1 and a receipt thereof as D. Exhibit 2.
35. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiffs, DW5 stated that when he took possession of his plot, the Plaintiffs were already on the ground. He had no original of D. Exhibit 1 and he confirmed that D. Exhibit 2 was issued on 20th March 2015 while this suit which was filed in 2011 was in Court. He explained that he was joined in the suit later as his defence is dated 29th June 2015. He claimed that he has been on his alleged plot since 2010, and that he purchased it from one Mr. Obara but he did not produce the said Vendor’s Allotment Letter. He pointed out that his Formalization Card (D. Exhibit 1), does not indicate the size of his plot and he had no Beacon Certificate in Court.
36. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the 3rd Defendant, he was emphatic that his receipt (D. Exhibit2) is not forged.
37. The 4th and 5th Defendant’s second witness, DW6 was the 5th Defendant, director Brookfield Academy. His testimony was that he operates the said school on Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase 11 that he leased from the 4th Defendant and which borders the Plaintiffs’ school. He claimed that the Plaintiffs would maliciously want his school closed because they are business rivals. He produced his evidence which is a certificate of registration of Brookfield Youth Centre.
38. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiffs, DW6 confirmed
that he had no lease or evidence that his first possession was given by
Daniel Obara. He also admitted that he did not get approval to build a school. He contended that he did not encroach on the Plaintiffs’ land, as it is the landlord who may have done so, since he built along the established perimeter wall.
39. In cross-examination by Counsel for the 1st Defendant, DW6 confirmed that he found the Plaintiffs running a school when he first rented his plot which measures 80x50 from Daniel Obara.
40. Parties thereafter filed their written submissions.
Submissions
41. The 1st Plaintiff submitted that the Plaintiffs have proved their case and that their evidence is also corroborated by the 3rd Defendant’s witnesses who confirmed the issuance of an Allotment Letter, Beacon Certificate and Certificate of Lease to Kayole Hekima Academy Educational Centre. Further, that the Plaintiffs’ title was not challenged under Section 26 of the Land Registration Act thus their proprietorship is afforded protection under Article 40(1) of the Constitution and Section 24 of the Land Registration Act. He also submitted that the Plaintiffs’ proved that the 1st, 4th and 5th Defendants have encroached on the suit plot as per the survey maps in the Plaintiffs’ bundle of documents and by the Deputy Registrar's Report based on the site visit held on 11th November 2025.
42. With regard to the 4th Defendant’s Counterclaim for Plot No. 544 –Patanisho Phase II, he submitted that while the 4th Defendant alleged that he bought the said property from Mr. Daniel Obara, he did not produce a sale agreement or Allotment Letter to establish his claim and he did not produce in court a Certificate of Lease or title to substantiate the claim of ownership of the said property.
43. To buttress his averments, the 1st Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Presbyterian Foundation v Kibera Siranga Self Help Group Nursery School (Civil Appeal 64 of 2014) [2023] KECA 371 (KLR) (31 March 2023) (Judgment) and Mbuthia Macharia vs Annah Mutua & Another [2017] eKLR.
44. On her part, the 2nd Plaintiff submitted that the Plaintiffs demonstrated that they are the legal occupiers of the suit plot and that Brookfield School occupies approximately 25ft by 30ft with part of it being on the road reserve.
45. To buttress her averments, the 2nd Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Amolo & 6 others v Chege & another (Environment & Land Case 241 of 2014) [2023] KEELC 189 (KLR) (19 January 2023); Joseph N.K Arap Ng'ok v Moijo Ole Keiwua & 4 others [1997] eKLR; Philma Farm Produce & Supplies & 4 others v Attorney General & 6 others [2012] eKLR; Park Towers Limited v John Mithamo Njika & 7 Others [2014] eKLR, and others which the Court has carefully considered.
46. The 3rd Defendant submitted that the Plaintiffs proved their ownership of the suit plot to the required standard under Section 107 of the Evidence Act and that their evidence was corroborated by the testimony of DW4, thus their root of title is lawful and verified. Further, that they also proved that the 1st, 4th and 5th Defendants encroached and trespassed on the suit plot, adding that the site visit report dated 11th November 2025 confirmed the said encroachment and under Article 40(1) of the Constitution, the Plaintiffs’ rights to property are safeguarded and unlawful occupation of their land is prohibited. It also submitted that the Plaintiffs have neither pleaded nor proved any infringement attributable to it.
47. To buttress its averments, the 3rd Defendant relied on the following decisions: Miller v Minister of Pensions [1947] All ER 372; Hellen Wangari Wangechi v Carumera Muthoni Githua [2015]KEHC 1758(KLR); Roge v Songok & 3 others, Mweka (Interested Party) [2025] KEELC 349 (KLR); Nderitu v Gatiro & 3 others [2022] KEELC 2436 (KLR); Torino Enterprises Limited v Attorney General [2013] KESC 79 (KLR); Kivuti & 2 others v Attorney General & 3 others [2023] KEELC 22462 (KLR); Kirikoni Investments Limited & another v Ngene [2025] KEELC 26 (KLR); Kipruto v County Government of Elgeyo Marakwet [2025] KEELC 3278 (KLR); Taib v Juma & 2 others [2025] KEELC 7305 (KLR); Josephat Mburugu v Silas Mwiti Mugwika [2022] KEELC 1244 (KLR); Siparo v Kantai [2023] KEELC 16704 (KLR), among others which the Court has carefully considered.
48. The 4th and 5th Defendants submitted that since the Plaintiffs did not produce a title in evidence, they are in no position to assert, with the degree of certainty required to found a claim in trespass/encroachment, or prove that the 4th Defendants’ distinct and separately held parcel overlaps theirs. Further, that the site visit conducted on 11th November 2025, alleging that they have encroached on the suit plot, without a licensed surveyor establishing fixed beacons by reference to the Registry Index Map, cannot substitute for the statutory requirement under Sections 18 and 19 of the Land Registration Act, which requires the Land Registrar, acting together with the Government or County Surveyor, to establish, ascertain and fix boundaries of registered land.
49. They also submitted that the 4th Defendant's evidence that his Plot No. 544 – Patanisho Phase II, has been formalized by the 3rd Defendant was uncontroverted and insisted that the 5th Defendant only occupies the said parcel purely as a lessee of the 4th Defendant, running Brookfield Academy thereon, thus the 4th Defendant has proved his Counterclaim on a balance of probabilities. To buttress their averments, the 4th and 5th Defendants relied on the case of Joseph N.K Arap Ng'ok v Moijo Ole Keiwua & 4 Others [1997] eKLR.
Analysis and Determination
50. Upon consideration of the pleadings filed herein, including testimonies of the witnesses, exhibits and rivalling submissions, the following are the issues for determination:
a) Whether the suit is res judicata by virtue of Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005.
b) Whether the Plaintiffs have established ownership to Plot No. A, Komarock South, Corner Shop.
c) Whether the 4th Defendant has proved his counterclaim in respect of Plot No. 544, Patanisho Phase II.
d) Whether the 1st Defendant trespassed upon or encroached onto the suit plot, and whether the 4th and 5th Defendants encroached upon the suit plot or the adjacent road reserve.
51. The Plaintiffs’ case is that they are the lawful proprietors of Plot No. A, Komarock South, Corner Shop. They claim that they entered the said plot in 1989 and were issued with a temporary occupation license by the 3rd Defendant in 1991, then they established Kayole Hekima Educational Academy which was issued with a Letter of Allotment on 22nd November 1993 and the said allocation was subsequently confirmed by the 3rd Defendant with a Beacon Certificate issued on 16 July 2012.
52. They claim that the 1st Defendant, unlawfully trespassed onto the suit
plot and erected a church structure, which was demolished following this Court’s restraining orders. They also contend that the 4th and 5th Defendants have encroached upon part of the suit plot and the adjacent road reserve, obstructing access to their school.
53. The 1st Defendant insists that Plot No. B, Komarock South, Corner Shop, was allocated to Nyangi Scrap Metal Dealers and Plot No. C belonged to Solomon Mwangi Muthoni, with the respective plots having been demarcated and occupied by their allotees. He further contends that the Plaintiffs have encroached onto Plot B and C and fenced with Plot A, which was allocated to the 1st Plaintiff, not Kayole Hekima Educational School as alleged.
54. The 4th and 5th Defendants assert that the 4th Defendant is the lawful proprietor of Plot No. 544, Patanisho Phase II, which borders the Plaintiffs’ property and is separated from it by a perimeter wall and age-old trees. Further, that the said plot had been formalized by the 3rd Defendant, does not encroach on a road reserve nor onto the Plaintiffs’ property and that it had been leased to the 5th Defendant, who operates Brookfield Academy thereon.
55. On the first issue, the 1st Defendant contended that this suit is res judicata Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005, which concerned similar parties including the subject matter and was dismissed for want of prosecution. The Plaintiffs maintained that the said suit involved different parties and issues and that it was dismissed for want of prosecution.
56. Res judicata is anchored on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act which provides that:
“No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such Court.”
57. On res judicata, the Court of Appeal in the case of Uhuru Highway Development Ltd V Central Bank & 2 Others, [1996] KECA 102 (KLR) held that:
‘in order to rely on the defence of res judicata, there must be a previous suit in which the matter was in issue; the parties must have been the same or litigating under the same title; a competent court must have heard the matter in issue and the issue is raised once again in the fresh suit.’
58. On res judicata, the Supreme Court of Kenya in the case of John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another v Cabinet Secretary Transport & Infrastructure & 3 others (Petition 17 of 2015) [2021] KESC 39 (KLR) (Civ) (6 August 2021) (Judgment), had this to say:
‘Hence, whenever the question of res judicata is raised, a court will look at the decision claimed to have settled the issues in question; the entire pleadings and record of that previous case; and the instant case to ascertain the issues determined in the previous case, and whether these are the same in the subsequent case. The court should ascertain whether the parties are the same, or are litigating under the same title; and whether the previous case was determined by a court of competent jurisdiction. This test is summarized in Bernard Mugo Ndegwa v James Nderitu Githae & 2 others, (2010) eKLR, under five distinct heads: (i) the matter in issue is identical in both suits; (ii) the parties in the suit are the same; (iii) sameness of the title/claim; (iv) concurrence of jurisdiction; and (v) finality of the previous decision.’ Emphasis Mine
59. In this instance, Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005 was not heard or determined on merit but dismissed for want of prosecution. It is trite that a suit dismissed for want of prosecution has not been determined on merits and hence does not give rise to a judgement on merit. In the case of John Florence Maritime Services Limited, cited above the Supreme Court was emphatic that for a suit to be deemed as res judicata the previous suit has to have been between the same parties, dealt with similar issues and was heard and determined on merit. At this juncture, I find that since the Milimani CMCC No. 4909 of 2005 was not heard nor determined on merit, this suit is hence not res judicata as claimed.
60. On the second issue, the Plaintiffs claim ownership of the suit plot. PW1 confirmed that the suit plot has since been surveyed as Block 167 Plot 643 and that it measures 0.178 hectares. He explained that the 1st Defendant first issued him with a temporary allocation license dated 30th June 1991, then subsequently issued him with a Letter of Allotment dated 22nd November 1993 and later a Beacon Certificate dated 16th July 2012. He claimed that Kayole Hekima Education Centre was registered in 1992 as a business name and its particulars were later changed in 2008. This places the Plaintiffs with the burden of demonstrating the root of their ownership, given that it is challenged by the 1st Defendant and the 4th Defendants, who also had the burden of impeaching the Plaintiffs’ alleged ownership.
61. DW4 confirmed in her testimony that as per the 3rd Defendant’s records, the suit plot was allocated to the 1st Plaintiff on a temporary basis vide a license dated 30th June 1991. Further, that the said plot was subsequently allotted to Hekima Educational Centre on 22nd November 1993 on condition that the proprietor pays the requisite fees. She explained that at a Council Meeting held on the 27th October 2011, the 3rd Defendant’s Town Planning Committee approved Hekima Educational Centre as the bona fide owner of the suit plot and upon payment of kshs.38,000/=, a Beacon Certificate was issued on 16th July 2012. I note that vide a letter dated the 13th October, 2011, addressed to Nyende & co. Advocates, the 3rd Defendant indeed confirmed that the Plaintiffs were the proprietors of the suit plot.
62. I further note the 4th and 5th Defendants claimed ownership of their plot, which the Plaintiffs insist encroached on their plot. It is worthnoting that the Surveyor they brought as a witness could not confirm whether the PDP was genuine. The Plaintiffs produced various documents which included Letter of Allotment, Beacon Certificate, Search Certificates, Area Map, and proof of payment of rates for Kayole Hekima Academy Education Centre, to prove ownership of the suit plot.
63. The Court conducted a site visit and it is worthnoting that in the said site visit report, it confirms that the 4th and 5th Defendants have indeed encroached on the suit plot with the 5th Defendant having a permanent structure on a portion of the suit plot.
64. On validity of title, Section 26 of the Land Registration Act provides that:
“Certificate of title to be held as conclusive evidence of proprietorship
(1) The certificate of title issued by the Registrar upon registration, or to a purchaser of land upon a transfer or transmission by the proprietor shall be taken by all courts as prima facie evidence that the person named as proprietor of the land is the absolute and indefeasible owner, subject to the encumbrances, easements, restrictions and conditions contained or endorsed in the certificate, and the title of that proprietor shall not be subject to challenge, except—
(a) On the ground of fraud or misrepresentation to which the person is proved to be a party; or
(b) Where the certificate of title has been acquired illegally, unprocedurally or through a corrupt scheme.”
65. In Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others, Pet. No. E010 of 2021, the Supreme Court stated that:
“…where the registered proprietor’s root title is under challenge, it is not enough to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership. It is the instrument that is in challenge and therefore the registered proprietor must go beyond the instrument and prove the legality of the title and show that the acquisition was legal, formal and free from any encumbrance including interests which would not be noted in the register.”
66. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited as well as associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Plaintiffs have indeed demonstrated the root of their title and proprietorship over the suit plot which position is confirmed by the 3rd Defendant that was the allotting authority.
67. On the third issue, the 4th Defendant contends that Plot No. 544, Patanisho Phase II, is a distinct parcel separated from the Plaintiffs' plot by a perimeter wall and trees and that he leased it to the 5th Defendant who operates Brookfield Academy as a tenant thereon. On their part, the Plaintiffs contend that Plot No. 544, Patanisho Phase II, is an unlawful creation intended to facilitate encroachment onto their land. Given that the said parcel is not registered, the Court will wade through the 4th Defendant’s documents to establish whether he has proved ownership.
68. The 4th Defendant as DW5 in his testimony insisted that he was the lawful owner of Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase II, which is developed with a permanent building and borders the Plaintiffs’ plot, being demarcated by a permanent perimeter wall and age-old trees. He explained that the said plot was formalized by the 3rd Defendant and is not on a road reserve and neither has it encroached on the Plaintiffs’ plot. He confirmed that he leased the said plot to the 5th Defendant who runs a school. He produced a Formalization Card for Patanisho phase II Plot No. 544 which he alleged is part of LR No. 129 Savannah, dated 3rd November 1999 as D. Exhibit 1 and a receipt thereof as D. Exhibit 2. During cross-examination DW5 claimed that he has been on his alleged plot since 2010, and that he purchased it from one Mr. Obara but he did not produce the said Vendor’s Allotment Letter. Further, the Formalization Card (D. Exhibit 1), does not indicate the size of his plot and there was no Beacon Certificate produced in Court.
69. DW6 confirmed he operates a school on Plot No. 544-Patanisho Phase 11 that he leased from the 4th Defendant and which borders the Plaintiffs’ school. He produced a certificate of registration of Brookfield Youth Centre. He had no lease with the 1st Defendant or evidence that his first possession was given by Daniel Obara. He also admitted that he did not get approval to build a school. He further confirmed that he found the Plaintiffs running a school when he first rented his plot which measures 80x50 from Daniel Obara.
70. In Mohamed v Duba & another [2022] KECA 442 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated as follows on proof of ownership where land is not registered:
“Our analysis has been guided by the principles that apply to evidence of title in respect of unregistered land as provided in the text by Kevin Gray and Susan Francis Gray on Elements of Land Law, 5th Edition at page 185 as follows: “Evidence of title to an unregistered estate in land usually exists only in the form of a chain of documentary records (or title deeds) which detail successive transactions with that land over the course of time. These historic documents of title (or 'deeds bundles’) are privately controlled, being retained normally within the custody of the proprietor of the estate to which they relate. These deeds provide the “essential indicia of title” since the information contained in them, when coupled with the fact of undisturbed possession, generally identifies the person who currently has the best 'title' to any relevant estate in the land. Title to an estate can also be claimed, however, by one who holds no supporting documentary evidence but relies instead on the sheer fact of his ow possession.” Emphasis Mine
71. Further, in the case of Caroline Awinja Ochieng & another v Jane Anne Mbithe Gitau & 2 others [2015] eKLR, it was stated as follows:
“Unlike registered land where ownership is domiciled
and founded in the register of titles, ownership of unregistered land and the ascertainment or confirmation thereof involves the intricate journey of wading through documentary history……It is the delivery of deeds or documents which assist in proving not only dominion of unregistered land but also ownership. The deeds must establish an unbroken chain that leads to a good root of title or title paramount. A good compilation of the documents or deeds relating to the property and concerning the claimant as well as any previous owners leading to the title certainly proves ownership. It is such documents which are basically ‘the essential indicia of title to unregistered land’’: per Nourse LJ in Sen v Headley [1991] Ch 425 at 437. The documents in my view are limitless. It could be one, they could be several. They must however establish the claimant’s beneficial interest in the property. Examples of the deed or documents include, at least in the Kenyan context: sale agreements, Plot cards, Lease agreements, allotment letters, payment receipts for outgoings, confirmations by the title paramount, notices, et al.”
72. From the evidence presented in Court which includes the exhibits, while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the 4th Defendant has failed to demonstrate proprietorship over Plot No. 544, Patanisho Phase II which he leased to the 5th Defendant. In my view, the said Brookfield School indeed occupies approximately 25ft by 30ft which part is on the road reserve and part is on the suit plot.
73. From my findings above, I find that the 1st Defendant trespassed upon and encroached onto the suit plot. Further, that the 4th and 5th Defendants have also encroached upon the suit plot as well as the adjacent road reserve. In my view, the survey maps which were produced by the Plaintiffs as well as the Deputy Registrar's Report based on the site visit held on 11th November 2025 has revealed this encroachment.
74. In the foregoing, I hence find that the Plaintiffs are entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint. I however find that the 4th Defendant is not entitled to the Orders as sought in the Counterclaim and will dismiss it with costs to the Plaintiff. I also however find that the Plaintiffs did not demonstrate a cause of action against the 3rd Defendant and will exonerate it, from these proceedings.
75. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiffs have proved their case on a
balance of probability and will proceed to enter judgement in their favour as against all the Defendants save for the 3rd Defendant, in the following terms:
i. Permanent and injunctive orders be and is hereby issued restraining the 1st, 4th and 5th Defendants whether by themselves, agents, servants and or any other person claiming title or whatsoever interest from interfering, demolishing, alienating, erecting any structures, trespassing, erecting structures, occupying, obtaining titles and or in whatsoever manner interfering with the suit property known as Kayole Hekima Educational Academy on Plot No. Block A, Komarock South, Corner Shop located at Masimba Road, off Spine Road, Kayole Nairobi.
ii. Declaratory orders be and are hereby issued directing and declaring the Plaintiffs as rightful owners entitled to operate Kayole Hekima Educational Academy on the suit premises Plot No. Block A, Komarock South, Corner Shop to the exclusion of the 1st, 4th and 5th Defendants and or other third parties or agents.
iii. The costs of this suit is awarded to the Plaintiffs to be jointly borne by the 1st, 4th and 5th Defendants.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 26TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Wangui holding brief for Mungai for 1st Plaintiff
Amisi for 2nd Plaintiff
Ayieko for 1st Defendant
Ogada for 3rd Defendant
Gachie 4th and 5th Defendant
Court Assistant: Joan