Small Claims

Lengube v Mbwagwa [2026] SCC 30 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Voi
Judgment date
15 May 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Small Claims Court allowed the claimant’s construction-contract claim for Kshs.473,680, being the assessed cost of completing works the respondent had undertaken but failed to complete. Costs were awarded to the claimant.

Supporting judgment passages

15) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 12th March 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=. Costs are awarded to the claimant.

Paragraph 15 →
Issue 1Whether the claim has been proved.

Held. Decided. The claim was proved and allowed for Kshs.473,680. The executed agreement recorded the respondent’s undertaking to complete outstanding works within four weeks, which he did not do. The claimant’s bill of quantities for the unfinished works was accepted, and there was no contrary valuation.

Ratio. The claimant established the respondent’s unperformed contractual undertaking and proved the completion cost through a bill of quantities that pleaded the amount with sufficient certainty. In the absence of contrary valuation evidence, the court accepted the assessed Kshs.473,680 as recoverable.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

a) Whether the claim has been proved.

Passage 17 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

12) I thus agree with the claimant in terms of what she claims from the respondent in the absence of any valuation to the contrary.

Paragraph 12 →

13) Consequently, the claim is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=.

Paragraph 13 →

b) Who bears the costs of the claim.

Passage 27 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

9) In essence therefore there are 2 bills of quantities. One for the entire works to be done and the other for the pending work to be done. The respondent and the claimant have executed an agreement where the respondent in signing the agreement acknowledges that he has not concluded the works that are pending and undertook to complete within 4 weeks. That has not been done.

Paragraph 9 →

11) In arriving at this figure he has allocated each item a specific cost whether it’s a service cost or the purchase price for the various materials that shall be required for the works. I have perused the said bill of quantities and I am satisfied that the amount has been pleaded with some amount of certainty.

Paragraph 11 →

12) I thus agree with the claimant in terms of what she claims from the respondent in the absence of any valuation to the contrary.

Paragraph 12 →
Issue 2Who bears the costs of the claim.

Held. Decided. The respondent bears the costs, which were awarded to the successful claimant.

Ratio. Costs follow the event; because the claimant succeeded, she was entitled to costs.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

b) Who bears the costs of the claim.

Passage 18 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

14) The claimant is successful in her claim and since costs follow events, she is awarded costs of the claim.

Paragraph 14 →

15) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 12th March 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=. Costs are awarded to the claimant.

Paragraph 15 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

14) The claimant is successful in her claim and since costs follow events, she is awarded costs of the claim.

Paragraph 14 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Vide a claim contained in the statement of claim dated 12/3/2026 the claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs.473,680 from the respondent. The claim is not opposed by the respondent.

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

Consequently, the claim is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=.

Paragraph 13 →

Reasoning passage

In arriving at this figure he has allocated each item a specific cost whether it’s a service cost or the purchase price for the various materials that shall be required for the works. I have perused the said bill of quantities and I am satisfied that the amount has been pleaded with some amount of certainty.

Paragraph 11 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the claimant proved her claim for Kshs.473,680 arising from incomplete construction works, and who should bear the costs of the claim.

Material facts

Constance R.S Zale Lengube and Renson Kakucha Mbwagwa entered a construction agreement dated 4 August 2025 for a one-bedroom house at Kshs.984,160. The claimant stated that she had paid Kshs.902,160 by 16 October 2025, supported by Equity Bank Limited slips.…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT VOI

SC COM NO. E027 OF 2026.

CONSTANCE R.S ZALE LENGUBE...............................................................….CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

RENSON KAKUCHA MBWAGWA……………………………..……………….RESPONDENT

JUDGEMENT

BACKGROUND

1) Vide a claim contained in the statement of claim dated 12/3/2026 the claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs.473,680 from the respondent. The claim is not opposed by the respondent.

2) In support of the claim, the claimant states that she entered into a construction agreement dated 4/8/2025 with the respondent for the construction of a 1 bedroomed house at a cost of Kshs.984,160/= and that as t 16/10/2025 the claimant had paid the respondent Kshs.902,160/= and in support thereof relied on the banking slips from equity bank limited.

3) That further the respondent undertook to complete the work within 4 weeks from 5/8/2025 and that to date the works has not been completed despite several notices and opportunities to remedy the default.

4) That following this the claimant engaged another valuer who assessed the work done and issued a report showing that the respondent should refund Kshs.473,680/= and she produced the report as an exhibit.

5) She concludes her case by stating that the respondent’s refusal to conclude the works has forced her to engage another contractor to complete the remaining works and this has forced her to incur more costs and now claims the amount against the respondent.

6) I have considered the said statement and the exhibits produced in the matter.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

7) The following issue is for determination.

a) Whether the claim has been proved.

b) Who bears the costs of the claim.

ANALYSIS.

a) Whether the claim has been proved.

8) The issue at hand as I have understood it from the pleadings, is that works were started but were not concluded by the respondent. Several reminders have been put to him to conclude the work but he has refused to complete the works. The claimant has thereafter engaged another valuer who has drawn up another bill of quantities.

9) In essence therefore there are 2 bills of quantities. One for the entire works to be done and the other for the pending work to be done. The respondent and the claimant have executed an agreement where the respondent in signing the agreement acknowledges that he has not concluded the works that are pending and undertook to complete within 4 weeks. That has not been done.

10) The claimant has thus sought to know how much it would cost to complete the works that are pending. A bill of quantities by Pro Builders of what is pending has been filed and proposes that Kshs.473,680/= is the amount that the claimant shall require to complete the pending works.

11) In arriving at this figure he has allocated each item a specific cost whether it’s a service cost or the purchase price for the various materials that shall be required for the works. I have perused the said bill of quantities and I am satisfied that the amount has been pleaded with some amount of certainty.

12) I thus agree with the claimant in terms of what she claims from the respondent in the absence of any valuation to the contrary.

13) Consequently, the claim is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=.

b) Who bears the costs of the claim.

14) The claimant is successful in her claim and since costs follow events, she is awarded costs of the claim.

DISPOSITION.

15) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 12th March 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.473,680/=. Costs are awarded to the claimant.

16) The file be and is hereby closed.

17) It is so ordered.

Dated and Delivered virtually at Voi Small Claims Court this…15th…day of..May..2026

F.M. MULAMA

ADJUDICATOR/RM

In the presence of:

Vivian Wambui-C/A

Ms. Njogu for the Claimant.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder