Land law

Koin v Mathenge t/a Mathenge Gitonga & Company Advocates & 2 others [2026] KEELC 7023 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case E074 of 2022
Judgment date
26 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Vide the notice of motion application dated 12th October 2026 the Applicant seek the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

I am satisfied that in order to wholly determine all the issues in dispute between the parties herein, it is just and proper that the amendment sought be granted.

Paragraph 16 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO E074 OF 2022

ESTHER AITA KOIN….……….......................………………PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

PETER GITHONGA MATHENGE T/A

MATHENGE GITONGA & CO ADVOCATES…………..……DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

COOPERATIVE BANK OF KENYA……………..1ST INTERESTED PARTY/RESPONDENT

CHARLES MWANGI KINGORI……………….2ND INTERESTED PARTY/RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. Vide the notice of motion application dated 12th October 2026 the Applicant seek the following orders:

a. Spent.

b. THAT an order be issued granting the Defendant leave to file and serve an amended defence and counterclaim in terms of the draft annexed hereto.

c. An order be and hereby issued that upon the grant of leave, the draft amended defence and counterclaim be deemed as duly files and served.

d. The Costs of the application be in the cause.

2. The application was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit of Peter Gitonga Mathenge. He deponed that since the filing of the draft defence dated 9th July 2024 new and material facts had come to his knowledge.

3. That the Defendant owned house no 190 constructed on LR NO 209/1221/77 and sold the same to the Applicant in exchange of 20 cares of land out of land parcel Kajiado/Kaputei North/37800.

4. That the agreement was that the Applicant/Defendant would be in possession of the house until the completion of the transaction when the Applicant receives the land parcel.

5. That before completion of the same, the Plaintiff took unlawful possession of the suit property the house and leased it out for the sum of Kenya Shillings 60,000/= which was below market value despite their agreement that the Defendant would remain in possession of the house and only give vacant possession upon completion.

6. It is on this basis that the Defendant wishes to amend the defence to include a counterclaim for rental income received by the Plaintiff /Applicant for the period between 15th October 2018 and 15th October 2022 for recovery of all rental income unlawfully received by the Plaintiff/Applicant.

7. The matter was heard in a hearing in court on the 15th October 2026 where both parties were heard on their respective arguments with the Applicant asking the court to consider that for justice to be met, all parties have to be heard on merit. The Respondent on the other hand asked the court to dismiss the application as it was meant to delay the hearing and not merited as the facts relied on by the Applicant as new were within the knowledge of the Applicant.

Analysis and Determination

8. I have considered the application, and the arguments raised during the hearing of it. In my considered view, the issue that arises for determination is

Whether this court ought to grant leave to the Defendant to file an amended defence to include the counterclaim

9. Now, Order 8 Rule 5 (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules gives the Court a wide discretion as far as amendment of pleadings is concerned. This Section provides that for the purpose of determining the real question in controversy between the parties or correcting any defect or error in any proceedings, the Court may either of its own motion or on the Application of any party order any document to be amended in such a manner as it directs as to costs or otherwise as are just. This discretion may be exercised at any stage of the proceedings, that is to say, before or at the trial, after the trial, after Judgment or on appeal. This position has been restated in various cases notably; Bosire Ongero Vs Royal Media Services 2015 KLR. “In my considered view, the objection therefore to have the Amended Defence on record as filed is unmerited since the Amended Defence meets the required standard.’’

10. The Courts would normally not grant a request for amendment of pleadings where the proposed amendment would have the effect of creating a new cause of action which is time-barred. This was stated in Nzirane Vs. Lukwago 1971 EA 328.

11. Furthermore, an amendment should ordinarily not be disallowed on the ground that it introduces a new case. However, the Court has no power to substitute a cause for another cause or change the subject matter of the suit as per Sir Kenneth O’Conner J in Eastern Bakery Vs. Castelino 1958 EA 461.

12. The main principle is that an amendment should not be allowed if it will occasion an injustice to the Plaintiff. In Institute for Social Accountability & Another vs Parliament of Kenya and 3 Others 2014 KLR a three Judge bench of Lenaola, Mumbi and Majanja J stated that:-“The object of amendment of pleadings is to enable the parties to alter their pleadings so as to ensure that the litigation between them is conducted not on the false hypothesis of the facts already pleaded or the relief or remedy already claimed but rather, on the basis of the state of facts which the parties really and finally intend to rely on. The power to amend makes the function of the Court more effective in determining the substantive merits of the case rather than holding it captive to form of the action and proceedings.

13. Lastly Amendments should be freely allowed provided they are not done in bad faith and they do not occasion injustice to the other party which cannot be compensated by way of costs. Justice J.B Havelock in the case of Daniel Ngetich & Another Vs. K-Rep Bank Limited [2013] KLR stated that: -

“Normally the Court should be liberal in granting leave to amend pleadings. But it must never grant leave if the Court is of the opinion that the amendment would cause injustice or irreparable loss to the other side or if it is a devise to abuse the process of the Court. “Amendments ought to be allowed when: -

a) They do not work injustice to the other side.

b) They are necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties.

14. In this instant case, I have looked at the draft counterclaim and do note that the issues arising are creating a different cause of action from what was pleaded in the plaint.In the present suit, the issue before the court at the trial would be, whether there was a breach of contract on the part of the Defendant in delivering of the suit property to the Respondent .That being the main issue, I do not see any prejudice if in this very same suit the court is called upon at the trial to establish if the Defendant is actually owed by the Plaintiff. In my view, the two issues are intimately intertwined that they cannot be separated as they touch on the same suit property.

15. I believe that since the issues are intertwined, the documents to be relied will be the same and that the witness may well be the same. In my view, in terms of Section 1A of the Civil Procedure Act, it will be prudent to try the issues between the parties at the same time since that will save judicial time. I am of the view therefore that the Plaintiff will in no way be prejudiced if the amendment sought is allowed.

16. I am satisfied that in order to wholly determine all the issues in dispute between the parties herein, it is just and proper that the amendment sought be granted.

17. I will allow the amendments on the following terms;

i. The Defendant is hereby granted leave to amend his Defence and file the counterclaim and the draft annexed defence is deemed as duly filed and served subject to court payment of cost filing fee.

ii. The Plaintiff do file and serve its Reply to the Defence and Defence to Counterclaim within 14 days of the date hereto

iii. The Defendant to file his Reply to Defence to Counterclaim, if any, within 7 days of service of the same.

iv. The Defendant to pay the Plaintiff thrown away costs of the suit Kshs.10,000/-.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 26th day of

October 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

N/A for the Plaintiff/Respondent

Mr. Irungu for the Respondent/Applicant

Mr. Orwenyo for 1st Interested Party

Mr. Kimani for 2nd Interested Party

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder