Background
The application before this court is the one dated 24th April 2026 which seeks the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The court allowed the 24 April 2026 motion. It set aside the interlocutory judgment and consequential orders against the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th, 10th and 11th defendants; deemed their draft defence duly filed; directed that the suit proceed on its merits and that status quo be maintained pending determination. The applicants were to pay the plaintiff’s costs incurred so far, with costs otherwise in the cause.
24. In the premise, I exercise my discretion in favour of allowing the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th April 2026 on the following terms;
Paragraph 24 →
i. That the interlocutory judgement entered on the 26th January 2026 against the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th ,10th and 11th Defendants the Applicants herein together with all the consequential orders are and hereby set aside.
Passage 57 →
ii. That the draft defence annexed to the supporting affidavit shall stand as duly filed, and the suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits
Passage 58 →
Held. Decided. The threshold was met. The court found service was not proved for all applicants except the 9th applicant, who signed for the documents. It further held that the default was excusable, the applicants had a triable defence, and reopening the matter would not prejudice the plaintiff. The court therefore set aside the interlocutory judgment and consequential orders against the applicant defendants, permitted the draft defence to stand as filed, and ordered the suit to proceed to a merits hearing.
Ratio. Under Order 10 rule 11, the court may set aside a default judgment on just terms. A judgment entered without service is set aside as of right; where discretion applies, it must be exercised judicially to avert injustice from excusable default rather than assist deliberate delay. Relevant considerations include the explanation for default, existence of a triable defence, delay, and prejudice. On these facts, the applicants’ excusable default, triable defence, and absence of prejudice justified relief.
Issue
14. I have reviewed and considered the application, the Supporting Affidavit, further affidavit and the Replying Affidavit. I have also considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties. The singular issue for determination is whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for setting aside the judgment entered on 29th January 2026.
Paragraph 14 →
Held
23. In the present case, I hold that reason given for the default is excusable, that the Applicants/Defendants have a triable defence and that reopening the case will not cause any harm/prejudice to the Plaintiff/Respondent.
Paragraph 23 →
i. That the interlocutory judgement entered on the 26th January 2026 against the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th ,10th and 11th Defendants the Applicants herein together with all the consequential orders are and hereby set aside.
Passage 57 →
ii. That the draft defence annexed to the supporting affidavit shall stand as duly filed, and the suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits
Passage 58 →
Ratio
“Where judgment has been entered under this Order, the court may set aside or vary such judgment and any consequential decree or order upon such terms as are just.”
Passage 46 →
18. A distinction must be drawn between a regular and an irregular judgment. In James Kanyita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that where a judgment is irregular for want of service, the court will set it aside ex debito justitiae. However, where the judgment is regular, the court exercises discretion and considers, inter alia, whether there is a plausible defence and whether there has been undue delay.
Paragraph 18 →
22. The principle that emerges from the above decision Shah Vs Mbogo & Another (supra)is that while courts have wide discretion to set aside judgments made in the absence of one party (ex parte judgments), that discretion must be exercised judiciously (not arbitrarily) based on sound legal reasoning and fairness. The decision further shows that the purpose of the discretion is to prevent injustice where a party failed to act due to a genuine mistake or excusable error but it should not be used to help those who are intentionally negligent, dishonest, or trying to delay justice.
Paragraph 22 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The application before this court is the one dated 24th April 2026 which seeks the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →I have reviewed and considered the application, the Supporting Affidavit, further affidavit and the Replying Affidavit. I have also considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties. The singular issue for determination is whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for setting aside the judgment entered on 29th January 2026.
Paragraph 14 →Whether the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th, 10th and 11th Defendants/Applicants met the threshold for setting aside the interlocutory judgment entered in their absence, principally in light of their denial of service of pleadings.
The Applicants sought leave for new advocates to come on record, stay of execution, cross-examination of the process server and commissioner for oaths, setting aside of the interlocutory judgment, leave to defend out of time, and preservation of the status…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO E481 OF 2024
JOSHUA GITAU GACENGECI …….…………….………..… PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
-VERSUS-
SAMMY KYALO ….……………………………………….………………1ST DEFENDANT
PETER MWANGI ……………………………………………………..….2ND DEFENDANT
PAUL KIODODI ………………………..………………3RD DEFENDANT /1ST APPLICANT
LEONARD KIARIE …………………….……………………….…………4TH DEFENDANT
JOSEPH NJUGUNA ………………………….……………..……………5TH DEFENDANT
JOSEPH KURIA ………………………………………6TH DEFENDANT /2ND APPLICANT
JAVAN BUKAULI ……………………………..………7TH DEFENDANT/3RD APPLICANT
ISAAC NGARE ……………………………..……………………………..8TH DEFENDANT
HENRY KAMAU ……………………..…..…….…….9TH DEFENDANT/4TH APPLICANT
ELIJAH KINUTHIA ………..……………..…………10TH DEFENDANT/5TH APPLICANT
DAVID MBITHI …………………………..……..……11TH DEFENDANT/6TH APPLICANT
STEPHEN KIMEI NDAMBUKI ….………………..……….……………12TH DEFENDANT
RULING
Background
1. The application before this court is the one dated 24th April 2026 which seeks the following orders;
1. Spent.
2. THAT upon hearing ex parte the firm of Messer N. Githinji, Kariuki 7 Company Advocates be granted leave to come on record for the 3rd, 6th ,7th ,9th, 10th and 11th Defendants who are the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th Applicants.
3. THAT the honourable court be pleased to issue an order of stay of execution of the decree issued by this court on the 29th January 2026 pending hearing and determination of this application.
4. THAT on the hearing date of this application herein the honourable court be pleased to direct the process server Mr. Harrisson Sila Nzioka to be availed in court for cross examination on the contents of the affidavits of service sworn on 12th December 2024.
5. THAT on the hearing date of this application herein the honourable court be pleased to direct the commissioner of oaths one Ms. Sarah Wanja Kabochi to be availed in court for cross examination on her attestation to the affidavit of service sworn on the 12th December 2024.
6. THAT the interlocutory judgement entered against the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th,, 10th and 11th Defendants the Applicants herein together with all the consequential orders be set aside and the Defendants/Applicants be granted leave to file their statement of defence out of time.
7. THAT the status quo on the suit property be maintained until hearing and determination of the main suit.
2. The Motion is based on the grounds outlined on the face of it and the Supporting Affidavit sworn by Javan Bukauli the 7th Defendant. He depones that judgement was entered ex parte as against the Applicants who were not accorded a chance to be hard on merit as they were never served with the pleadings in this matter.
3. That the affidavit of service sworn on the 12th December 2024 fails to provide evidence of service to the Defendants.
4. That the Plaintiff has commenced the execution of the decree dated 12th February 2026 and if the orders sought for in this application are not issued eviction is imminent to the Applicants.
5. The Plaintiff/Respondent filed a Replying Affidavit in opposition to the Application. The Plaintiff asserted that the Applicants were duly served but failed to enter appearance nor file any defence. That the 9th Applicant was served and acknowledged receipt by signing on his copy of the summons. Whereas the other Defendant failed to acknowledge receipt of the pleadings.
6. That the process server engaged the area OCS during the said visit to serve and attached photographic evidence pointing out to the same.
7. The Applicants filed a further affidavit disputing the contents of the replying affidavit that the 9th Defendant had been served. That the person who served and the 9th Defendant are two completely different persons and further the photographic evidence do not point to the fact that the people on the photographs are any of the Applicants.
8. The application was canvassed by way of Written Submissions. The Applicants submissions are dated 8th June 2026 while those of the Plaintiff/Respondent are dated 18th September 2026.
Applicant submissions
9. The Applicant reiterated the arguments in their application, and further affidavits indicating that they were not served with the pleadings hence did not participate in the hearing. That the Plaintiff had not substantiated service was effected which is good ground for setting aside of the judgement orders and issuance of stay orders.
10. Counsel further submitted that they had met all the requirements for issuance of the injunctive orders as prayed for being proof of a prima facie case based on the fact that they have been on the suit property for many years and the judgment was entered without their participating due to non-service of pleadings.
11. That irreparable loss will be occasioned to them as the Plaintiff would carry out execution and evict them from the suit premises and lastly counsel submitted that balance of convenience tilted in their favour relying in the case of Alice Awino Okello Vs Trust Bank & Anor LLR N0 625(CCK).
Respondent’s submissions
12. The Respondent submitted that they had tendered in evidence that service was effected through the affidavit of service of 12th December 2024. That the Applicants had not substantiated their claims that the affidavit contained false records to discredit service upon themselves.
13. Counsel further submitted that the discretion to set aside judgement was not arbitrary and that the Applicants had not met the threshold required for setting aside of the judgement being that they had failed to demonstrate sufficient cause. Counsel relied on the case of King'ang'i & 2 Others Vs King'ang'i & 3 Others [2026] KEELC 1397 (KLR) where the court indicated an Applicant in such a case should give a satisfactory explanation for default.
Analysis and determination
14. I have reviewed and considered the application, the Supporting Affidavit, further affidavit and the Replying Affidavit. I have also considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties. The singular issue for determination is whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for setting aside the judgment entered on 29th January 2026.
15. The power of the Court to set aside a default judgment is conferred by Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which provides:
“Where judgment has been entered under this Order, the court may set aside or vary such judgment and any consequential decree or order upon such terms as are just.”
16. The principles guiding the exercise of that discretion are settled. In Patel v E.A. Cargo Handling Services Ltd [1974] EA 75, the Court of Appeal held that the discretion to set aside is wide and is intended to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence or excusable mistake, but not to assist a person who has deliberately sought to obstruct or delay the course of justice.
17. Further, in Shah v Mbogo & Another [1967] EA 116, the Court stated that the discretion is to be exercised to prevent injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence or excusable error.
18. A distinction must be drawn between a regular and an irregular judgment. In James Kanyita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that where a judgment is irregular for want of service, the court will set it aside ex debito justitiae. However, where the judgment is regular, the court exercises discretion and considers, inter alia, whether there is a plausible defence and whether there has been undue delay.
19. The Defendants/Applicants contend that they were unaware of the suit as they were not served with the pleadings. The record, contains the affidavit of service of 12th December 2024 sworn by Harisson Nzioka attaching photographic evidence of service being effected. The Applicants have disputed this evidence claiming the people the photographs are not any of the Applicants and more so the 9th Defendant Henry Kamau who allegedly received summons is a different person from Henry Gitau who signed on the summons.
20. I am not persuaded that service to the all the Defendants/Applicants was effected save for the 9th Defendant/Applicant who affixed his signature on the documents as why else would he accept and receive and legal documents that are not addressed to him? The process server herein has had not demonstrated personal service as the photographic evidence does not point out who the people in the photographs are.
21. The Applicants have applied to cross-examine the process server and raised arguments that seek to challenge the authenticity of the affidavit of service.
22. The principle that emerges from the above decision Shah Vs Mbogo & Another (supra)is that while courts have wide discretion to set aside judgments made in the absence of one party (ex parte judgments), that discretion must be exercised judiciously (not arbitrarily) based on sound legal reasoning and fairness. The decision further shows that the purpose of the discretion is to prevent injustice where a party failed to act due to a genuine mistake or excusable error but it should not be used to help those who are intentionally negligent, dishonest, or trying to delay justice.
23. In the present case, I hold that reason given for the default is excusable, that the Applicants/Defendants have a triable defence and that reopening the case will not cause any harm/prejudice to the Plaintiff/Respondent.
Final disposition
24. In the premise, I exercise my discretion in favour of allowing the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th April 2026 on the following terms;
i. That the interlocutory judgement entered on the 26th January 2026 against the 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th ,10th and 11th Defendants the Applicants herein together with all the consequential orders are and hereby set aside.
ii. That the draft defence annexed to the supporting affidavit shall stand as duly filed, and the suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits
iii. That status quo on the suit premises shall be maintained pending hearing and determination of this suit
iv. The 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th ,10th and 11th Defendants the Applicants herein do pay the Plaintiff costs so far incurred in these proceedings.
v. Costs shall be in the cause.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 26th day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Achola for the Plaintiff/Respondent
Mr. Njoroge for the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 6th Respondents/ Applicants
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant