Background
Vide the Notice of Motion application dated 28th April 2026, the Applicant seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Vide the Notice of Motion application dated 28th April 2026, the Applicant seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →I have read through and carefully considered the Notice of Motion Application dated 25th April 2026, the ground of opposition and the submissions filed and find the following issues for determination.
Paragraph 15 →I find that even with exercise of due diligence the documents availed could have been made available during the trial and basing on the requirements as in the above supreme court case the Applicant has demonstrated the need to consider the evidence hence need for review.
Paragraph 29 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLOS NO. E022 OF 2025
CITY ESTATE COORPORATION LIMITED………………………...………..APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
STANDARD CHARTERED INVESTMENT SERVICES LIMITED...........1ST RESPONDENT
STANDARD BANK NOMINEES (EAST AFRICA) LIMITED …………2ND RESPONDENT
STANDARD CHARTERED BANK KENYA LIMITED …………………3RD RESPONDENT
RULING
Brief facts
1. Vide the Notice of Motion application dated 28th April 2026, the Applicant seeks the following orders:
THAT upon review this honourable court grants the following orders in terms of the Originating Summons;
a. A declaration that the loan secured by the charge registered against LR No 1870/V/118 IR. No 35334 has been fully settled and there are no outstanding obligations arising thereof.
b. An order directing the Respondents to execute and deliver to the Applicant a discharge of charge in respect of the property known as LR No 1870/V/118 IR. No 35334 within 7 days from the date of the order
c. An order that in the event the Respondent fail or neglect to execute the discharge of charge, the deputy registrar of the court be authorized and directed to execute the same.
d. Any other relief the court may deem fit to grant.
e. The costs of the application be borne by the Respondents.
2. The application was grounded on the fact that the Applicant after the ruling of 13th April 2026 had gone back into the archives to look evidence to back the fact that they had actually cleared the loan secured by the charge. That the transaction having been 30 years old, some of the documents were archived and location of the same required in depth searching as they were not readily available on the current active files.
3. The Applicant further raised the ground that there was an error apparent on the face of record.
Respondent’s case
4. The Respondents in response filed grounds of opposition dated 29th September 2006 indicating that the Applicant had not carried out due diligence as they would have been able to produce the document they wish to rely on. That this failure to carry out due diligence does not amount to discovery of new and important under order 45 Rule 1(1) of the civil procedure rules
5. Direction were given for the application to be canvassed by way of written submissions. The Applicant filed submissions dated 5th October 2026.
Applicant’s submissions
6. The Applicant submitted that the grounds of opposition do not raise issue of law rather facts and hence ought to be disregarded and the application treated as unopposed.
7. Counsel further argued that there was mistake and error on the face of record being that the ruling of 13th April 2026 failed to consider the exhibits produced in the supporting affidavit which pointed out to the fact that the Applicant had cleared the loan amount over the charge relying in the case of National Bank of Kenya Limited Vs Ndungu Njau (Civil Appeal No. 211 of 1996) [1997] eKLR
8. On the ground raised on the issue of statutory limitation, counsel reiterated the averments in their supporting affidavit indicating there could be no statutory limitation on an obligation created through a contract as well as imposed on by statue. That the case here was not for recovery of money or land rather to seek to compel the Respondents to give back the premises to the Applicant having paid back the full loan amount.
9. On the issue of discovery of new and important evidence counsel relied on Karanja Vs Murigi (Civil Appeal No. 68 of 2019) [2025] KECA 517 (KLR) to back the arguments in the supporting affidavit.
Respondent’s submissions
10. Counsel submitted that the documents that the Applicant relies on were within the Applicant’s custody and the issue of new and discovery evidence, which after due diligence was not within the Applicant’s knowledge cannot be relied on relying in the Court of appeal case of Rose Kaiza Vs Angelo Mpanju Kaiza (2009) KRECA 422 (KLR).
11. He also submitted there was no error apparent on face of record to grant review as the advancement advanced would require detailed scrutiny of facts to establish whether there was misappropriation of the law of limitation.
12. that the inordinate delay in making the application would be prejudicial to the Respondent as if there were any records establishing that indeed the Applicant charged the suit, the same would have been destroyed.
13. The plaintiff filed rebuttal submissions dated 23rd October 2026 pointing out to the fact that the Respondent had admitted to error apparent on the face of record on a different issue of costs and not the misappropriation of limitation was enough ground to point error on record and hence making the application merited.
14. Counsel also submitted that there was no denial by the Respondent on whether the loan was paid and whether the charge should be discharged rather on how the same should be effected absent of evidence establishing relationship.
Analysis and determination
15. I have read through and carefully considered the Notice of Motion Application dated 25th April 2026, the ground of opposition and the submissions filed and find the following issues for determination.
i. Whether the grounds of opposition are competently before the court.
ii. Whether the Applicant has established any justifiable grounds for the review and setting aside of the orders of the Court dated 13th April 2026.
16. The Applicants have taken the view that the grounds of Opposition raised herein by the Respondent entail factual details, and the same ought to have been presented by way of a replying affidavit. I have given that argument due consideration and would point to the provisions of Order 51 Rule 14 of the Civil Procedure Rules which permits the filing of Grounds of Opposition as one of the three ways of responding to an application; and therefore, the Respondent cannot be faulted in that regard.
17. It matters not therefore that the grounds of Opposition filed by the Respondent do not adequately respond to the factual averments raised by the Applicant. Ultimately, the Court has the duty to render a decision on the basis of the material placed before it.
18. Moving on to the application, it is trite law that this court has a power of Review. The law on Review is based on Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. It is salient to note that this court’s power must be exercised within the framework of the aforementioned statutes.
19. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act provides as follows:-
Any person who considers himself aggrieved-
a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this Act, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or
b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed by this Act, may apply for a review of judgement to the court, which passed the decree or made the order, and the court may make such order thereon as it thinks fit.
20. Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 provides as follows: -
1. Any person considering himself aggrieved-
a) By a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or
b) By a decree or order from which no appeal is hereby allowed, and who from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed or the order made, or on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree or order, may apply for review of judgement to the court which passed the decree or made the order without unreasonable delay.
21. From the above provisions, it is clear that section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act gives the power of Review while Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010, sets out the rules. The rules limit the grounds applicable for Review as follows:
a) The discovery of new and important matter or evidence which after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the knowledge of the Applicant or could not be produced by him at the time when the Decree was passed or the Order made.
b) On account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record.
c) Any other sufficient reason and that the Application has to be made without unreasonable delay.
22. Regarding the discovery of new and important matter or evidence, the Court of Appeal in Rose Kaiza Vs Angelo Mpanju Kaiza [2009] KECA 422 (KLR), held:-“ Applications on this ground must be treated with great caution and as required by order 45 (2). The Court must be satisfied that the materials placed before it in accordance with the formalities of the law do prove the existence of the facts alleged. Before a review is allowed on the ground of a discovery of new evidence, it must be established that the Applicant had acted with due diligence and that the existence of the evidence was not within his knowledge; where review was sought for on the ground of discovery of new evidence but it was found that the petitioner had not acted with due diligence, it is not open to the court to admit evidence on the ground of sufficient cause. It is not only the discovery of new and important evidence that entitles a party to apply for a review, but the discovery of any new and important matter which was not within the knowledge of the party when the decree was made.”
23. The Applicant filed a Notice of Motion Application dated 3rd April 2025 where it sought for declaratory orders among others that the loan that had been secured over the suit property had been settled and that the Respondents should execute and deliver the discharge of the charge to the Applicant.
24. In the ruling dated 13th April 2026 which the Applicant seeks for review, the court dismissed the same. The court indicated that the Applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to point out to the fact that the loan over the charge had been cleared and hence could not be issued with the orders.
25. As discussed earlier, the conditions for the grant of a Review order are very stringent. I have gone through the documents that seek to be produced attached to the supporting affidavit. On the said document at page 23, the schedule indicates that the repayments were all done to leave no balance capturing it at zero.
26. I hold that this is critical evidence that would therefore aid the Applicant in advancing his argument that the loan was cleared. The Applicant has indicated that this was information that could not have being available to them as at the time the originating summons application was being filed being that records to such transactions of over 30 years had been archived and it had to take more effort than necessary to unarchive such.
27. The Respondent argues due diligence was not conducted but based on the argument as above, I hold that the documents could not have been availed earlier which documents I have already said are critical to the Applicant’s case and production of the same will not prejudice the Respondent in any way.
28. In the case of Mohamed Abdi Mahmamud Vs Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamed & 3 Others [2018] eKLR, the Supreme Court of Kenya set out the principles which govern the admission of new and additional evidence as follows:-“We therefore lay down the governing principles on allowing additional evidence in appellate courts in Kenya as follows:-
a) The additional evidence must be directly relevant to the matter before the court and be in the interest of justice; -
b) It must be such that, if given, it would influence or impact upon the result of the verdict, although it need not be decisive;
c) It is shown that it could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial, was not within the knowledge of, or could not have been produced at the time of the suit or petition by the party seeking to adduce the additional evidence;
d) Where the additional evidence sought to be adduced removes any vagueness or doubt over the case and has a direct bearing on the main issue in the suit;
e) The evidence must be credible in the sense that it is capable of belief;
f) .…………….;
g) Whether a party would reasonably have been aware of and procured the further evidence in the course of trial is an essential consideration to ensure fairness and due process;
h) ………………
i) .………………
j) .…………………
k) The court will consider the proportionality and prejudice of allowing the additional evidence. This requires the court to assess the balance between the significance of the additional evidence, on the one hand, and the need for the swift conduct of litigation together with any prejudice that might arise from the additional evidence on others” [Own emphasis]
29. I find that even with exercise of due diligence the documents availed could have been made available during the trial and basing on the requirements as in the above supreme court case the Applicant has demonstrated the need to consider the evidence hence need for review.
30. Having held as above, there is no need for the court to consider the other grounds raised in the application seeking for review as the Applicant have already made a case for themselves.
Final disposition
31. In the premises, I find merit in the application dated 28th April 2026 and would grant the orders prayed for therein, namely;
a) That the ruling dated 13th April 2026 which dismissed the Originating Summons application dated 3rd April 2025 be and is hereby reviewed and set aside.
b) That orders prayed for in the Originating Summons Application dated 3rd April 2025 are hereby granted as prayed.
c) Each party to bear its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 26th day of
October, 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Ms. Miiriti for the Applicant
Mr. Murithi for the Respondents
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant