Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Applicant’s Chamber Summons Application dated the 15th December 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Applicant’s Chamber Summons Application dated the 15th December 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →In the circumstances, I find that the learned taxing officer did not commit an error in principle to tax the Bill of Costs as she did in her Ruling dated the 28th November, 2025 in Nairobi Misc. Application No. E013 of 2025.
Paragraph 29 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L MISC. APPLICATION NO. E084 OF 2026
SICHANGI PATNERS &
ASSOCIATES NETWORK LLP …………………….....……. APPLICANT
VERSUS
KENYA AIRPORTS AUTHORITY …………………..…. RESPONDENT
RULING
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Applicant’s Chamber Summons Application dated the 15th December 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
a) That this Honourable Court be pleased to vacate and set aside in its entirety the Ruling of the Honourable Judith Omollo taxed on 28th November, 2025 in Nairobi Misc. Application No. E013 of 2025.
b) That this Honourable Court do order that the Bill of Costs herein be taxed afresh before a different Taxing Officer or in the alternative this court be pleased to substitute the amounts awarded in the disputed items as follows:
i. Item 1- relating to instructions fees;
ii. Item 2- relating to instructions fees on the Counterclaim;
iii. Item 3- Fees for getting up for trial; and
iv. Item 4 – Advocate Client Costs;
c) That this Honourable Court be pleased to make all such orders and/or directions as it deems fit and just to grant under the circumstances.
d) That costs of this Application be awarded to the Applicant.
2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the supporting affidavit of George Sichangi, Advocate. He avers that in her Ruling delivered on 28th November 2025, the learned taxing officer taxed the Applicant’s Advocate Client Bill of Costs dated 22nd September 2025 in Nairobi Misc. EP No. E013 OF 2025. Further, that she erred in principle and law by failing to consider the value of the subject matter as captured in the judgement delivered on 6th June, 2024 in Nairobi ELC No. 796 OF 2024 Verakiya Investments Limited v National Land Commission & 6 others, but instead based her decision on a value that was in the pleadings. Further, that she apportioned different values of the subject matter for different parties in the suit; being kshs.7,974,960,000/= in respect of the 5th Defendant and kshs.250,000,000/= in respect of the 3rd Defendant and adopted the value of the suit land, exclusive of developments thereon despite the property being developed.
Response
3. The application is opposed by the Respondent vide its Grounds of Objection. It contends that no Notice of Objection against the taxation ruling was filed by the Applicant in line with Paragraph 11 (1) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, 2014 and that the application was filed outside the statutory fourteen (14) day period contemplated under Paragraph 11 (2) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, 2014. Further, that the application was first filed at the High Court and since the said Court had no jurisdiction, the application is a nullity and incapable of being transferred to this Court thus the alleged transfer to this Court does not breathe life to the application.
4. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
5. The Applicant urges the Court to tax the impugned Bill of Costs itself
for the specific disputed items to avoid further delay. It submits that under Item (1) of the Bill of Costs, which concerns Instruction Fees and Getting Up fees, the Deputy Registrar was required to adopt the value of the subject matter provided in the analysis and determination of the judgment, being Ksh.7,974,960,000/= as it is trite that once judgement is rendered, parties are bound by it, in as far as what the subject matter is. Further, that the taxing officer was not at liberty to suggest that she would only accept the said subject matter as applicable to the 5th Defendant since the said sum was awarded in relation to the said 5th Defendant and that, the subject matter applicable to the 3rd Defendant shifted to what was suggested by parties in evidence.
6. It further submits that the taxing officer incorrectly applied Joreth Limited v Kigano & Associates Nrb CA Civil Appeal No 66 of 1999 (2002) eKLR, which contemplates that a claim gets its true legal value from what is awarded or declared by the Court in that final judgment but a taxing officer is allowed to look at external evidence if the value of the subject matter is unascertainable from the face of the pleadings or judgment.
7. It cites the case of Mereka & Company Advocates v National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees (Civil Miscellaneous Application 29 of 2020) [2024] KEHC 12668 (KLR) (Civ) (17 October 2024) (Ruling) to urge the Court to enhance the amount awarded herewith upwards based on the subject matter of Kshs.7,974,960,000 and award Instruction fees of Ksh.119,824,400/=.
8. With regard to item 2 of the Bill of Costs which concerns Instruction Fees on the Counterclaim, it urges the Court to apply the principles applicable in determining the subject matter from the Plaint. On item 3, Getting Up for trial, it urges the Court to calculate it at a third of the award for Instructions fees and cascade that the Advocate Client Costs, on item 4, would be the total raised by 50% or a half of the total of Instruction Fees and the Getting Up fees.
9. On its part, the Respondent submits that the application is fatally defective for want of compliance with Paragraph 11 (1) and (2) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, 2014 and that its transfer to this Court does not breathe life to it, as it remains incurably defective.
10. It also submits that in computing its Instruction fees, the Applicant has
erroneously based its computations on Kshs.7,974,960,000/= as the value of the subject matter, yet in its judgment in Civil Suit No. 796 of 2014, where the Applicant represented it, as the 3rd Defendant and the Plaintiff in the Counterclaim, asserting property rights over LR No. 9095, the Court found that the Plaintiff in the said suit, having acquired the suit property irregularly, was not entitled to any compensation for the value of the land or the developments thereon by all other Defendants save for the 5th Defendant, whom the Court ordered to compensate it, a sum of 50% of the amount claimed , being Kshs.7,974,960,000/=.
11. Further, that while the 5th Defendant was ordered to compensate the Plaintiff in that manner, it did not defend the suit thus the claim as against it, remains non contested as the Court did not determine the value of the suit property including the developments thereon. It urges the Court that should it be inclined to infer the value of the subject matter from the judgment, the prudent approach would be to adopt the value of the land exclusive of the illegal developments, which the Court ordered to be demolished and urges the Court to adopt the Ministry of Land’s valuation by its Assistant Deputy Director Department of Valuation in the Ministry of Lands and Physical Planning who produced a valuation report valuing the suit property and improvements thereon at Kshs.645,000,000/= and the value of the land itself at Kshs.247,100,000/= while the Plaintiff’s valuer gave the value of the land at Kshs.250,000,000/= as of 22nd July 2014.
12. It also submits that where a suit is uncontested, the applicable scale is as provided under Schedule 6 Part A (1) (a) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, 2014. Further, that it would be against the interests of justice and public policy, oppressive and would amount to an unjust enrichment were the Court to apply the value of the subject matter as the Applicant seeks. It urges the Court to interrogate the Instruction fees judiciously and consider that taxing officers are duty-bound to interrogate whether the fees claimed are exorbitant, unreasonable, or founded on unverified figures.
13. It submits that Instruction fees are an independent and static item which should only be charged once, thus the Applicant, by raising Instruction fees for both defence and the counterclaim, has improperly charged Instruction fees twice under the two items both of which relate to the proceedings before Civil Suit No. 796 of 2014. It urges the Court to find that the scale for determination of the Instruction fees payable is Schedule 6A thus the amount payable as Instruction fees is Kshs.75,000/= and a sum of Kshs.119,749,400/= be taxed off.
14. To buttress its averments, it relied on the following decisions: Abraham Mwangi Wamigwi v Simon Mbiriri Wanjiku & Another [2012] eKLR; Supreme Court Petition E011 of 2023 [2024] KESC 44 (KLR) Kenya Airports Authority v Otieno Ragot and Company Advocates; Stephen Karanja Kibuku v Safaricom Limited [2018] KEHC 1367; Joreth Ltd v Kigano & Associates NRB CA Civil Appeal No. 66 of 1999 [2002] eKLR; and Shamshudin Khosla & Others v Kenya Revenue Authority [2011] eKLR.
Analysis and Determination
15. Upon consideration of the instant Chamber Summons application including the respective affidavits as well as rivalling submissions, the following are the issues for determination:
a) Whether the Application is a nullity owing to its initial filing at the High Court and whether it flouts paragraph 11 (1) and (2) of the Advocates Remuneration Order.
b) Whether the Taxing Officer erred in principle in taxing the Applicant’s Advocate- Client Bill of costs dated 22nd September 2025.
16. The Applicant contends that the taxing officer erred in principle in taxing its Advocate-Client Bill of Costs by failing to adopt the value of the subject matter as determined in the judgment delivered on 6th June 2024, in Civil Suit No. 796 of 2014, being Kshs.7,974,960,000/=, and instead relied on the value pleaded by the parties. It contends that the taxing officer incorrectly applied different values of the subject matter to different Defendants and purported to exclude developments on the suit property notwithstanding the findings in the judgment, thus improperly assessed items Nos. 1 - 4 of its Bill of Costs dated 22nd September, 2025.
17. On its part, the Respondent contends that the application is incompetent for non-compliance with Paragraph 11 (1) and (2) of the Advocates Remuneration Order and that its initial filing before a Court without jurisdiction rendered it a nullity. Further, that the Applicant erroneously adopted Kshs.7, 974, 960,000/= as the value of the subject matter, yet the said amount related exclusively to compensation awarded against the 5th Defendant. It maintains that the appropriate taxation ought to exclude illegal developments ordered to be demolished. Further, that the Applicant improperly claimed separate Instruction fees for defending the Plaint and prosecuting the Counterclaim.
18. On the first issue, the instant application was first filed before the High Court before its transfer to this Court. Section 18 (1)(a) of the Civil Procedure Act allows a Court to transfer a matter to another Court for final disposal. I note vide an Order dated the 12th March, 2026 where both parties were represented before Justice Mulwa at the High Court, she directed that the Reference be transferred to the ELC since it emanated from the proceedings in the ELC. I note none of the parties objected nor sought for review or appeal of the said Orders. Since the Orders emanated from a Court with equal jurisdiction as this Court, at this juncture, I am unable to review or set aside the said Orders of transfer to hold that the instant Reference is incompetent as this is an issue which ought to have been raised before the transfer from the High Court. I hence find that the instant Application is not a nullity owing to its initial filing at the High Court.
19. On whether the application flouts paragraph 11 of the Advocates
Remuneration Order, the same requires a party aggrieved by the decision of the taxing officer to file a notice to the taxing officer within fourteen (14) days, specifying the items objected to. Where a decision of the taxing officer contains detailed reasons for the decision, Courts have held that failure to request for reasons is not fatal. To this end, it was held as follows in Ahmednassir Abdikadir & Company Advocates V National Bank of Kenya Ltd (2) [2006] 1EA 5:
“Although Rule 11(1) of the Advocates Remuneration Order stipulates that any party who wishes to object to the decision of the taxing officer, should do so within 14 days after the said decision and thereafter file his reference within 14 days from the date of the receipt of the reasons, where the reasons for the taxation on the disputed items in the bill are already contained in the considered ruling, there is no need to seek for further reason simply because of the unfortunate wording of Subrule (2) of Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order demands so. The said rule was not intended to be ritualistically observed even when reasons for the disputed taxation are already contained in the formal and considered ruling.” Emphasis Mine
20. In the foregoing, I will decline to strike out the Reference on account
that the Applicant failed to comply with paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, requiring a party aggrieved by the decision of the taxing officer to file a notice to the taxing officer within fourteen (14) days, specifying the items objected to.
21. On the second issue, this Court does not have jurisdiction to interfere with the decision of a taxing officer unless an error in principle is established, as stated in Kipkorir Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board [2005] 1KLR 528.
22. The Applicant contends that the taxing officer instead of adopting the subject matter as provided in the Judgement being Kshs.7,974,960,000/= applied a figure from the pleadings. The Respondent argues that the said sum of Kshs.7,974,960,000/= arose from a compensation order made against the 5th Defendant who was ordered to pay half of it, to the Plaintiff and who did not defend the suit hence the claim was unascertained. It argues that compensation awarded against the 5th Defendant cannot be treated as the value of the interest the Applicant defended on its behalf.
23. The applicable principles for determining the value of the subject
matter were well settled by the Court of Appeal in Joreth Ltd v Kigano & Associates [2002] KECA 153 (KLR) and restated by the Supreme Court in Kenya Airports Authority v Otieno Ragot and Company Advocates [2024] KESC 44 (KLR) as follows:
“55. It is common ground that the subject matter of the suit in issue should be identified first, and then the value thereof determined. How is the value of the subject matter to be determined? Paragraph 1 of Schedule VIA is clear on this issue, and in point of fact stipulates that, “… where the value of the subject matter can be determined from the pleading, judgment or settlement of the parties”. This means that the value of the subject matter can be determined from the pleadings or judgment or settlement of the parties. In that regard, the Court of Appeal in the case of Joreth Ltd v Kigano & Associates [2002] 1 EA 92 expressed that- “We would at this stage point out that the value of the subject matter of a suit for the purposes of taxation of a Bill of costs ought to be determined from the pleadings, judgment or settlement (if such be the case) ...” Emphasis Mine
24. The Respondent relied on the holding in the aforementioned Supreme Court case in which it opined that in a non-contested suit, the claim or amount pleaded therein without more, does not ipso facto render that claim or amount pleaded therein without more the value of the subject matter. The Court stated:
“The position still remains that the amount therein has not been ascertained or determined, and as such, it cannot be applied as the value of a subject matter in a disputed taxation.”
25. In this instance, I note the judgement giving rise to the impugned Bill of Costs and reference did not indicate the value of the subject matter but the Plaintiff therein sought various declaratory orders. However, in the Judgement, the Court held that due to the special arrangements between the Plaintiff therein and the 5th Defendant, the 5th Defendant was to compensate the Plaintiff’s the sum of 50% of the amount claimed of Kshs.7,974,960,000/=. I note that there was a Valuation Report from the Ministry of Lands which valued the suit property inclusive of development at Kshs.645,000,000/=. I further note that the 5th Defendant did not defend the suit and the claim against it was hence uncontested.
26. It is worthnoting that where a claim is uncontested, the applicable
scale to be used is stipulated under Schedule 6 Part A (1) (a) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, 2014. Since the Court in its impugned judgement held that there were illegal developments, I opine that the taxing officer did not err to adopt the value of the land exclusive of the developments thereon. Further, she did not err in principle by basing her taxation on paragraphs 60 of the Judgement. I note that at paragraph 60 of the impugned judgement the Court made reference to the valuation reports of Ministry of Lands at Kshs.240,000,000/= and the one for Rank Global which returned the value of the suit property at Kshs.250,000,000/= and this is what the taxing officer used to calculate the value of the land.
27. The Applicant has sought for Instruction fees for defending the Respondent in the Counterclaim. In Tom Rading Kuyoh v Joshua Nyiera (Sued as Chairman of Fera Association); Nairobi City County Government (Interested Party) [2021] KEELC 2766 (KLR), Eboso J stated as follows:
“….. a cross-petition or a counter-claim is a separate and distinct suit. Consequently, instructions to prosecute or defend a petition or a counter-claim attract separate instruction fees.”
28. I note at item (1) in the Bill of Costs, the Applicant sought for Instruction fees to defend the main suit. While at item (2) of the Bill of Costs, it sought for Instruction fees to defend the Counterclaim. The taxing officer in her ruling calculated the Instruction fees for item one at kshs. 3,950,000/=. She further calculated the Instruction fees at item two at Kshs.3,950,000/=. This in essence means that she awarded Instruction fees for both the main suit and the counterclaim. In my view the getting up fees was properly calculated once at Kshs.1,316,667/ = as the Applicant defended the suit was once. On the Advocate Client costs, she calculated it at Kshs.4,668,668.50 as per scale.
29. In the circumstances, I find that the learned taxing officer did not commit an error in principle to tax the Bill of Costs as she did in her Ruling dated the 28th November, 2025 in Nairobi Misc. Application No. E013 of 2025.
30. In the foregoing, I find the instant Chamber Summons application unmerited and will dismiss it.
31. Each party to bear their own costs.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Kariuki for Respondent
Mulili for Respondent
Court Assistant: Joan