Employment law

Vwamula v Dormans Coffee Ltd [2026] KEELRC 4656 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E056 of 2024
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the Court is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 22nd January, 2024 and amended vide the Amended Statement of Claim dated 19th February 2024, wherein the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

On the totality of the evidence before the Court, I find that the Respondent established a valid and fair reason for the termination of the Claimant’s employment.

Paragraph 53 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Irene Vwamula’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair; whether she was entitled to compensation, declarations, salary and welfare savings; and whether Dormans Coffee Ltd proved its Kshs.211,330 counterclaim. These were the issues…

Material facts

The claimant had worked as a distributor for about 17 years. On 30 May 2023, while assigned a company vehicle for coffee distribution in the Mt. Kenya region, she allowed her husband, Franco, an unauthorised person, to drive after she became unwell. The…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E056 OF 2024

IRENE VWAMULA……………………………………….………..CLAIMANT

VERSUS

DORMANS COFFEE LTD…………………………..…………RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. Before the Court is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 22nd January, 2024 and amended vide the Amended Statement of Claim dated 19th February 2024, wherein the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:

a) A Declaration that the Respondent’s conduct in terminating the Claimant’s employment amounted to a violation of the Claimant’s constitutional right to fair labour practices under Article 41 (1) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

b) A Declaration that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was wrongful and unfair, contrary to Sections 43, 45 (2) and 47 of the Employment Act, 2007

c) A Declaration that the Claimant's right to appeal was violated under Article 47 and Article 50 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.

d) A Declaration that the Claimant is entitled to be compensated for:

i. Violation of her Constitutional rights as envisaged under Article 23 (3) and 41 (1) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

ii. Violation of her employment and contractual rights; and

iii. Injury to the Claimant on account of the Respondent’s breaches. An order that the Claimant be compensated.

e) Interest on the amounts stated in (d) above at court rates.

f) An order that the Claimant be paid the final amount due, outstanding salary, benefits and entitlements accrued during her tenure with Dorman Coffee Limited.

g) Costs of this suit

2. The Respondent entered appearance and subsequently filed a Response to the Statement of Claim dated 5th April 2024 together with supporting documents. The Respondent also lodged a counterclaim against the Claimant.

3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 23rd April, 2025 when the Claimant (CW1) and her other witness named Sammy Simiyu Masega (CW2) testified in support of the Claimant’s case. CW1 adopted her witness statement and produced her list and bundle of documents dated 22nd January 2024 as exhibits 1-4, and her further list and bundle dated 22nd July 2024 as exhibit No. 5, while CW2 adopted his witness statement dated 22nd July 2024.

4. The Respondent’s case was subsequently heard on 24th March 2026, where one Rose Magwilu (RW1), the Respondent’s Human Resource Manager, testified in support of the Respondent’s case. She adopted her witness statement dated 5th April 2024 and produced the Respondent’s list and bundle of documents of even date as exhibit 1-13.

5. Submissions were received from both parties in the matter.

The Claimant’s case

6. The Claimant's case is that she was employed by the Respondent as a Distributor and served for approximately seventeen (17) years. She states that during her employment she discharged her duties diligently and faithfully and had not previously been subjected to any disciplinary proceedings or issued with a warning letter. She states that she earned a gross monthly salary of approximately Kshs. 131,699.00.

7. She states that her summary dismissal arose from a road traffic accident involving the Respondent's motor vehicle registration number KBH 106C on 30th May 2023, while she was undertaking the Respondent's business. She testified that she was traveling from Nanyuki to Nairobi in the said motor vehicle in the course of duty, and that at the time of the accident, the motor vehicle was being driven by a person she described as her husband.

8. She further testified that she had permitted him to drive the vehicle because she had suddenly fallen ill, and maintains that she had not previously permitted an unauthorized person to drive a company vehicle.

9. It is her case that following the accident, she was issued with a notice to show cause and thereafter placed on compulsory leave. She states that she was subsequently sent on unpaid leave from May to July, 2023, with the date of compulsory leave being 16th June 2023, but she has no formal letter placing her on compulsory leave. She states that she was subsequently recalled to the office and issued with a letter of summary dismissal.

10. The Claimant acknowledged during cross-examination that she was aware of the Respondent's policy concerning the use of company vehicles and that the policy prohibited unauthorized persons from driving company vehicles.

11. She further acknowledged that Franco was not authorized to drive the vehicle. She states that, in her response to the notice to show cause, she had initially indicated that she was driving the vehicle, which she described as an error of judgment.

12. She confirmed that she was invited to a disciplinary hearing and was advised to attend with a representative, but she did not attend the hearing. She further confirmed that the dismissal letter informed her of her right of appeal.

13. On further cross-examination, the Claimant stated that she was not issued with a formal letter placing her on compulsory leave and confirmed that she was not at work during June, 2023. She could, however, not recall whether she had received a salary advance, but acknowledged that her June 2023 payslip reflected the same.

14. The Claimant was also unable to explain what happened to all the goods that had been in the motor vehicle after the accident. Regarding the money collected from the Respondent’s customers, she stated that approximately Kshs. 8,800 was used towards hospital and ambulance expenses following the accident. She maintained her account of the events leading to the accident and her position that the termination was unfair.

15. The Claimant reiterated on re-examination that she had never previously undergone a disciplinary process during her approximately seventeen years of service and had never before permitted an unauthorized driver to use a company vehicle.

16. She stated that Franco was her husband and that after the accident she reported to work but was instructed to proceed on leave until further notice. She maintained that the reason for her dismissal was that she had allowed an unauthorized person to drive the Respondent's vehicle.

17. The Claimant states that the termination was unlawful and unfair because the Respondent failed to establish valid reasons for termination and further failed to accord her a fair hearing. She further contends that the Respondent's removal of her security pass hindered her ability to access the manager and to exercise her right of appeal.

18. The Claimant in her Amended Statement of Claim specifically alleges violation of Sections 43, 45 and 47 of the Employment Act and Articles 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution.

19. The Claimant further claims that upon termination the Respondent failed to release her outstanding salary, terminal dues and other entitlements.

20. The Claimant finally prays that the court allows her claim.

The Claimant’s Submissions

21. On substantive fairness, counsel submitted that the reason advanced for the dismissal was that the Claimant permitted an unauthorized driver to drive the Respondent's motor vehicle. Counsel argued that the Claimant's conduct occurred in the context of an emergency after she allegedly became unwell while on duty.

22. It is further submitted that the Respondent had failed to demonstrate through proper investigation the circumstances leading to the accident and had not produced a police abstract or technical traffic inspection report. Counsel relied on Section 43(1) of the Employment Act, and the decision in Kenfreight (EA) Limited v Nguti [2016] KECA 409 (KLR), for the proposition that an employer must establish reasonable grounds for the reason relied upon in terminating employment.

23. Counsel further relied on Section 44(3) and (4) of the Employment Act to submit that summary dismissal requires conduct amounting to a fundamental breach of the employee's obligations.

24. On procedural fairness, counsel submitted that although a disciplinary meeting was held, the process was not fair. The Claimant's position was that the Respondent had removed her security pass and thereby prevented her from accessing the workplace and pursuing an appeal. Counsel also invoked Article 47 of the Constitution on fair administrative action.

The Counterclaim

25. On the Respondent's counterclaim, counsel submitted that the Respondent sought Kshs.211,330 comprising Kshs. 107,444 for lost stock, Kshs. 81,556 for unremitted collections allegedly utilized for medical expenses, and Kshs. 22,330 being a salary advance.

26. The Claimant denied liability and contends that the loss of stock occurred following the accident and subsequent looting by members of the public, while the collections were utilized for emergency medical and ambulance expenses.

27. It is her case that the Respondent retained Kshs. 97,000 of her money as welfare savings and argues that such amount could not lawfully be set off against the Respondent's claims. The Respondent relied on Section 19 of the Employment Act to support this position.

28. On reliefs, counsel submitted that the Claimant was entitled to compensation for unfair termination, payment of her outstanding dues and welfare savings, interest and costs.

The Respondent’s Case

29. The Respondent’s case was presented by Rose Magwilu (RW1), its Human Resource Manager. She testified that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent from 17th July 2006, and worked for about 17 years, rising through the ranks. She avers that at the time of separation the Claimant earned a salary of Kshs. 58,500.

30. The Respondent states that on 30th May 2023, the Claimant was assigned motor vehicle KBH 160C for distribution of coffee in the Mt. Kenya region, and that while the vehicle was in her custody, she allowed an unauthorized person named Mr. Franco to drive it without the Respondent’s approval.

31. The Respondent states that the vehicle was subsequently involved in an accident along the Sagana-Karatina Road at about 6.00 p.m. The Respondent contends further that this was contrary to its company policy and resulted in extensive damage to the vehicle and loss of goods valued at Kshs. 107,444.

32. The Respondent further states that the Claimant had Kshs. 81,556 in company collections which she used without authorization to meet ambulance and medical expenses for herself and the unauthorized driver. It avers that the Claimant had earlier received a salary advance of Kshs. 22,330, which remained outstanding.

33. The Respondent therefore counterclaims for the Kshs. 211,330 being the lost stock, collections and salary advance.

34. It is the Respondent’s case that following the incident, the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter dated 16th June 2023, which she responded to on 20th June 2023. It avers that she was thereafter invited to a disciplinary hearing on 3rd July 2023, which she attended with a colleague, Brenda Huti, and was given an opportunity to explain the circumstances leading to the accident.

35. The Respondent states that, being dissatisfied with her representations, it issued a summary dismissal letter dated 19th July 2023, informing her of her right to appeal, which she did not exercise. It states that the Claimant’s final dues were processed and paid, and she was issued with a Certificate of Service.

36. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that the Claimant told the Respondent that she had fallen ill and allowed her husband to drive the subject motor vehicle. She stated, however, that the Respondent did not consider that the driver was her husband and treated him as an unauthorized driver.

37. RW1 confirmed that the Claimant had not previously breached the relevant protocol, had gone to hospital after falling ill, and had an active company medical cover. She also confirmed that the vehicle was insured.

38. RW1 further maintained that the Respondent’s SOP did not permit a driver who was unwell to drive and neither did it permit a spouse or other unauthorized person to drive a company vehicle.

39. RW1 further told the court that the Respondent deducted amounts owed by the Claimant, but acknowledged that documents showing the amounts owed had not been provided.

40. On re-examination, she stated that the deductions related to a staff advance and Barclays loan. She also explained that differences in the Claimant’s payslips, including the July 2023 payslip, arose because employees received commissions and per diems.

41. She maintained that the Respondent investigated the incident, that the Claimant had not declared who her husband was, and that the Respondent supported her following the accident. She also confirmed that the Claimant’s security pass was not taken away.

42. The Respondent maintained that the Claimant’s conduct constituted a breach of company policy and trust, giving it valid and fair grounds for termination of her employment, and that she was subjected to a fair disciplinary process.

43. The Respondent prays that the Claimant’s claim be dismissed, and judgment be entered on its Kshs.211,330 counterclaim together with interest and costs.

Analysis and Determination.

44. I have considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced and the Claimant’s submissions. The issues that present for determination are:

i. Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair

ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought

iii. Whether the Respondent has proved its counterclaim.

Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair

45. Section 43(1) of the Employment Act places upon the employer the obligation to prove the reason or reasons for termination, while Section 45(2) requires the employer to establish that the reason was valid and fair, and that the termination was carried out in accordance with fair procedure. Further, under Section 47(5), the employee bears the initial burden of showing that the termination was unfair, while the employer bears the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination.

46. The Court of Appeal in CFC Stanbic Bank Limited v Danson Mwashako Mwakuwona [2015] KECA 919 (KLR) affirmed that the Court, when determining whether an employee was fairly terminated/dismissed, must examine both substantive and procedural fairness required under the law. It further recognized that the question is whether the employer had reasonable grounds for the decision and whether the decision fell within the range of reasonable responses open to an employer in the circumstances.

47. Further, in Kenya Revenue Authority v Gitahi & 2 others [2019] KECA 300 (KLR), the same court emphasized that the Court should not substitute its own view for that of the employer where the employer has demonstrated a genuine and substantively justified reason for the disciplinary action and the eventual termination/dismissal.

48. It is not disputed that the Claimant was entrusted with the Respondent's motor vehicle and it is also not disputed that she permitted one Franco, whom she accepts was an unauthorized person, to drive the motor vehicle. The Claimant has also expressly acknowledged that she was aware of the Respondent's policy prohibiting unauthorized persons from driving company vehicles.

49. The Claimant's explanation is that she suddenly became unwell and, in those circumstances, allowed her husband to take over driving. Indeed, the Respondent's own witness confirmed that the Claimant stated that she became unwell, went to hospital after the incident, and had not previously breached the relevant protocol.

50. Nevertheless, the existence of an emergency does not, without more, extinguish the employer's legitimate interest in enforcing a vehicle use and safety policy. The Claimant admitted the essential act constituting the alleged misconduct; hence, the Respondent did not, in my view, need to prove that the Claimant personally caused the accident before taking disciplinary action. The misconduct complained of was the unauthorized transfer of control of the company vehicle, rather than merely the occurrence of the accident.

51. Further, the Claimant's initial response to the notice to show cause, in which she stated that she herself had been driving, also materially weakens her explanation, not to mention that she subsequently accepted that this was an error of judgment on her part.

52. I, in the circumstances, find that the Respondent has proved a factual and employment related reason for taking disciplinary action against the Claimant. I also conclude that the reason was connected with her conduct and her obligations as the employee entrusted with the company vehicle.

53. On the totality of the evidence before the Court, I find that the Respondent established a valid and fair reason for the termination of the Claimant’s employment.

54. On whether the Claimant was accorded a fair hearing, Section 41 of the Employment Act establishes the procedural requirements before termination of employment on grounds of misconduct. As a bare minimum, the employee must be informed of the reason for the contemplated termination and afforded an opportunity to make representations in the presence of another employee or shop-floor union representative of the employee's choice. (See Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR).

55. The Respondent's evidence is that the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter dated 16th June 2023, which she responded to on 20th June 2023, and was subsequently invited to a disciplinary hearing on 3rd July 2023. The Respondent states that the Claimant attended the hearing accompanied by Ms.Brenda Huti and was given an opportunity to explain the circumstances of the accident.

56. By the Respondent's documentary evidence and RW1's testimony, it is established that the Claimant actually attended the hearing with a colleague and was heard contrary to her assertion that she did not. The Claimant cannot simultaneously contend that she was denied a hearing merely because she did not agree with the outcome.

57. The Claimant further alleges that her security pass was removed, thereby preventing her from accessing the workplace and pursuing an appeal. The Respondent's witness, however, expressly denied that the security pass was taken away, and more importantly, the dismissal letter expressly informed the Claimant of her right of appeal, and the Respondent's evidence is that she did not exercise that right.

58. On a balance of probabilities, therefore, the allegation that the Respondent prevented the Claimant from appealing has not been established. On the contrary, the evidence before the Court shows that the Respondent provided an appeal mechanism, but the Claimant did not invoke it.

59. It then follows that the requirements of Section 41 were satisfied, and so I hold.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought

60. The Claimant claims Kshs.263,338 being salary for June and July, 2023 and Kshs.97,000 on account of welfare savings.

61. The Respondent's witness placed the Claimant's salary at Kshs.58,500, while the Claimant claimed approximately Kshs.131,699 as her gross monthly pay.

62. RW1 acknowledged that the Respondent made deductions but conceded that documents showing the amounts owed had not been produced in evidence. Under Sections 10 and 74 of the Employment Act, employers have the obligation to maintain employment records, and where an employer relies upon payroll records, advances or deductions, it should produce the documentary basis for those deductions.

63. The Claimant’s pay slip produced before court by the Respondents for the month of June, 2023 indicates the Claimant’s gross salary as Kshs. 58,000/-. The Respondent has further produced evidence that the salary for July, 2023 was remitted and that the Claimant acknowledged receipt thereof.

64. Other than the pay slip, nothing shows the salary for June, 2023 was remitted, and the Claimant’s claim succeeds on this account limited only to the salary for June, 2023.

65. On the Kshs.97,000 welfare savings, there is evidence that the Respondent retained that amount, but the precise legal basis upon which it was retained and whether it remained payable to the Claimant has not been sufficiently established in the material before the Court.

66. In the circumstances, only the salary for June 2023 has been proven to be due and payable.

Whether the Respondent has proved the counterclaim.

67. The Respondent counterclaims against the Claimant Kshs.107,444 for lost stock, Kshs.81,556 for collections allegedly used for medical and ambulance expenses, and Kshs.22,330 as salary advance, all amounting to Kshs.211,330.

68. For starters, the fact that the Claimant was responsible for the vehicle does not, by itself, make her personally liable for every loss occasioned by the accident. The Respondent was required to prove the individual heads of its counterclaim and the Claimant's legal liability for them.

69. The Claimant's case is that the goods were lost after the accident through looting by members of the public. The record does not indicate that the Respondent produced sufficient independent evidence establishing that the Claimant herself appropriated or negligently caused the loss of the stock.

70. On the Kshs.81,556, the Claimant accepts that the money was used for emergency medical and ambulance expenses, although she disputes the amount and the Respondent's authorization. The Respondent did not establish the amount the Claimant actually held, the contractual or legal obligation governing its use, or that the expenditure was unauthorized.

71. Finally, the Kshs.22,330 salary advance is a more readily ascertainable employment debt, but the Respondent still bore the evidential burden of proving that the advance was made and remained outstanding. The Court of Appeal has consistently held that a monetary claim in the nature of special damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved. (See Abson Motors Limited v Dominic B. Onyango Konditi [2018] KECA 161 (KLR).

72. In Patrick Musyoka Kakuli v Kariuki Ngari [2018] KEELRC 1252 (KLR), the Court declined an employer's counterclaim where the employer had failed to produce the employment records necessary to prove advances and other alleged liabilities.

73. This principle is particularly applicable here for the reason that RW1 expressly acknowledged that documents supporting the deductions had not been provided.

74. In the upshot, I find and hold that the counterclaim for Kshs.211,330 has not been proven to the required standard, and the same is hereby dismissed.

75. In the circumstances, I proceed to make the following orders:

a) That the Claimant’s dismissal is both procedurally and substantively fair and lawful.

b) That the claim for compensation for unfair termination and the declarations founded on Articles 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution therefore fail.

c) That the Respondent shall pay the Claimant salary for June 2023, amounting to Kshs. 58,000/-

d) That the Respondent's counterclaim for Kshs.211,330 is dismissed.

e) That each party shall bear its own costs, the claim having only marginally succeeded.

76. Judgment accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Ms. Ravid h/b for Ms. Githunguri for the Claimant

Mr. Ouma h/b for Ms. Obiayo for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S -C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder