Employment law

Njoroge v Economy Farm Products (K) Limited [2026] KEELRC 4651 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 18th September, 2025, brought pursuant to Articles 50 and 162(2)(a) of the Constitution of Kenya, Sections 26 and 51 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007, Section 12 (1) of the ELRC Act and Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the DOSH award of 26 April 2023 was valid and enforceable; whether the respondent proved payment of Kshs.262,080 under an earlier assessment; whether the court should adopt the Kshs.336,960 award as its judgment; and costs.

Material facts

The applicant stated that, while employed by the respondent as a mason from April 2019, he fell from a godown roof on 21 November 2019 while constructing an animal-feed plant and was injured. He reported the accident, received first aid and treatment, and…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

MISC. APPLICATION NO. E383 OF 2025

LAWRENCE NJUNG’E NJOROGE…………………..………. APPLICANT

VERSUS

ECONOMY FARM PRODUCTS (K) LIMITED…..….………RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 18th September, 2025, brought pursuant to Articles 50 and 162(2)(a) of the Constitution of Kenya, Sections 26 and 51 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007, Section 12 (1) of the ELRC Act and Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

i. This Honourable Court be pleased to adopt as judgment of this court the award of the Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Officer (DOSH) dated 26th April,2023.

ii. Judgment be entered for the Applicant against the Respondent for Kshs. 336,960/= being the amount assessed under the Work Injury Benefits Act.

iii. This Honourable Court be pleased to award interest on the amount from the date of assessment until payment in full.

iv. A Decree do issue accordingly for execution.

v. This Honourable Court be pleased to award any other relief this court may deem fit and just to grant.

vi. Costs of this application be awarded to the Applicant.

2. The application is supported by grounds on its face and the supporting affidavit of Lawrence Njung’e Njoroge sworn on 18th September, 2025.

3. The Applicant states that he was employed by the Respondent, Economy Farm Products (K) Limited, as a mason from April 2019. He avers further that on 21st November 2019, while constructing an animal feed plant at the Respondent’s premises, he fell from the roof of a godown and sustained serious injuries.

4. He states that he reported the accident to his supervisor, who administered first aid, after which he was taken to P.C.E.A. Kikuyu Orthopedic Rehabilitation Center for treatment. The Applicant states that he subsequently reported the accident to the Occupational Safety and Health authorities and served the Respondent with the relevant DOSH/WIBA forms.

5. It is his case that following assessment, he was awarded Kshs. 336,960 as compensation under WIBA, which the Respondent undertook to pay, but has since failed to settle. The Applicant further contends that he has not fully recovered from the injuries and continues to suffer physical consequences arising from the workplace accident.

6. The Applicant finally contends that granting the orders sought will not prejudice any party, as the law prescribes the procedure to be followed after institution of such a suit, and that the balance of convenience favours him; hence the orders sought should therefore be granted.

7. The Respondent did not specifically oppose the application as no replying affidavit or grounds of opposition were filed, only to say that it filed submissions on the motion.

The Applicant’s Submissions.

8. The Applicant submits that Section 26(4) of the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA) requires an employer or insurer against whom a compensation claim is lodged by the Director to settle the same within 90 days. The Applicant contends that the Respondent’s alleged payment of Kshs. 262,080 is unsupported by any documentary evidence.

9. It is the Applicant’s submission that the award of Kshs. 262,080 was not recognized by the County Occupational Safety and Health Officer as alleged by the Respondent in the letter dated 6th December 2022, which called upon the Respondent to report the accident or make submissions. The Respondent did neither and therefore cannot claim that it was unaware of the Applicant’s objection.

10. The Applicant maintains that if the Respondent made the alleged payment, the evidential burden was on it to prove it. The Applicant relies on Sections 107–109 of the Evidence Act, and the case of Abdul v Mokua (Civil Appeal E077 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 4105 (KLR), where the Court reiterated the principle that the person alleging a fact bears the burden of proving it.

11. The Applicant submits that the party alleging that the Kshs. 262,080/= was paid bears the evidential burden of producing evidence of that payment, and that a mere assertion of payment, without supporting evidence, would not discharge that burden on a balance of probabilities.

12. The Applicant further relies on Section 19(1) of the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA), which protects compensation by providing that it cannot be assigned, pledged, attached, executed against, or set off against a debt owed by the person entitled to the compensation. It is submitted that Section 19(2) further renders void any agreement by which an employee purports to assign or relinquish their statutory right to WIBA benefits.

13. On this basis, the Applicant submits that the Respondent’s alleged award of Kshs. 262,080/= dated 6th July 2021 is not supported by the record and that there is no evidence that the Respondent made any payment to the Applicant.

14. The Applicant therefore maintains that the Respondent has failed to establish its allegation of payment and urges the Court to grant the orders sought in the application.

The Respondent’s Submissions.

15. The Respondent submits that the injury was reported and assessed by the Director, who awarded the Applicant 5% permanent incapacity and Kshs.262,080 under DOSH/WIBA/4 dated 6th July 2021. It maintains that it complied with its statutory obligation under Section 26(4) of WIBA and fully settled the assessed amount.

16. The Respondent further argues that the Applicant executed a discharge voucher acknowledging receipt and settlement of the compensation and is therefore estopped, under Section 120 of the Evidence Act, from denying or reopening the claim. It contends that requiring it to pay the compensation again would occasion it grave injustice.

17. The Respondent also submits that the Applicant was paid his full salary throughout the period of sick leave, and relies on the Applicant’s letter dated 28th April 2021 acknowledging such payment. The Respondent submits that it therefore invokes Section 28(4) of WIBA, which provides that an employee is not entitled to periodical compensation for temporary total or partial disablement during a period when the employee is receiving full pay under the Employment Act, another law, or the contract of service.

18. The Respondent challenges the validity and enforceability of the subsequent award dated 26th April 2023, contending that the award is invalid and incapable of enforcement.

19. The Respondent submits that the Director initially assessed the Applicant’s permanent incapacity at 5% and issued an award dated 6th July 2021 in DOSH/WIBA/4.

20. The Respondent challenges the validity of the Applicant’s objection, asserting that he did not annex a formal objection in the prescribed form as required by Section 51 of WIBA, and that the letter of 16th February 2023 merely refers to an objection to the 5% assessment.

21. It argues further that since the initial award was made on 6th July 2021, an objection lodged around 16th February 2023 was well outside the 60 day period prescribed under Section 51(1) of WIBA and the Director had no discretion to extend that statutory period.

22. The Respondent maintains that it was neither notified of nor served with the alleged objection or the letter dated 16th February 2023. It argues further that Section 52(1) of WIBA requires the Director to issue and serve a written response to an objection within 14 days.

23. The Respondent challenges the award dated 26th April 2023, which the Applicant seeks to enforce, on the premise that it was issued in DOSH/WIBA/4, which it contends is the form used for an initial award. According to the Respondent, where an award has been varied, reviewed or set aside, the appropriate form is DOSH/WIBA/6. On these grounds, the Respondent submits that the 26th April 2023 award is invalid and cannot be enforced or adopted by the Court.

24. The Respondent therefore urges the Court to dismiss the application with costs, maintaining that the original award was fully settled and that the subsequent award was procedurally irregular, invalid and unenforceable.

Analysis and Determination

25. I have considered the application together with the rival submissions. The issues that arise for determination are:

i. Whether the award dated 26th April 2023 is valid and enforceable;

ii. Whether the Respondent has proved payment of Kshs.262,080

iii. Whether the Applicant is entitled to adoption of the award of Kshs.336,960 as a judgment of the Court; and

iv. Who should bear the costs of the application.

Whether the award dated 26th April 2023 is valid and enforceable

26. It is not disputed that the Applicant sustained a workplace related injury on 21st November 2019, and that the matter was subsequently assessed by the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services under WIBA.

27. The Respondent's position is that the Director initially assessed the Applicant at 5% permanent incapacity and issued an award of Kshs.262,080 on 6th July 2021, which it maintains was fully settled.

28. The Respondent further asserts that the Applicant's alleged objection to the 5% assessment was not lodged within the sixty days prescribed by Section 51(1) of WIBA, and further argues that the subsequent award of Kshs.336,960 dated 26th April 2023 could not have validly arisen from that objection.

29. Section 51(1) of WIBA provides that a person aggrieved by a decision of the Director may, within sixty days of the decision, lodge an objection against it. Section 51(2) requires the objection to be in writing and in the prescribed form.

30. Section 52 further requires the Director to consider the objection and either vary or uphold the decision, after which an aggrieved party may appeal to this Court.

31. The importance of these provisions cannot be overstated. The Court has recently reiterated that WIBA provides a specific statutory mechanism for challenging a DOSH award and that the prescribed sixty-day period is mandatory. In Kikuyu Pipes and Fittings Center Limited v Kiambu County Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services & another [2026] KEELRC 177 (KLR), the Court held that WIBA contains no provision for enlargement of the sixty-day period and that a party who fails to object within the prescribed period cannot subsequently seek to reopen the award outside the statutory framework.

32. Similarly, in Munandi v Hewson Company Limited [2024] KEELRC 460 (KLR), the Court recognized that an unchallenged DOSH award may be adopted by the Court where no objection or appeal has been filed under Sections 51 and 52 of WIBA.

33. In the present case, the Applicant has placed before the Court the letter dated 16th February 2023 from the County Occupational Safety and Health Officer which expressly states that the employee had objected to the 5% assessment in the first medical report and requested constitution of a medical panel for reassessment.

34. This letter, in my view, constitutes documentary evidence that the DOSH process was revisited after the initial assessment. The critical question is whether that process constituted a lawful objection and review under Sections 51 and 52 of WIBA.

35. The Respondent’s submission is that no formal objection in the prescribed form was produced. That submission has merit to the extent that Section 51(2) expressly requires the objection to be in writing and in the prescribed form. However, the Respondent's argument that the subsequent award is consequently a nullity requires more than pointing to the absence of the particular form.

36. The record, as presented, shows that the DOSH itself subsequently acted upon the Applicant's complaint and issued a fresh award dated 26th April 2023. There is no evidence before the Court of a decision by the Director rejecting the Applicant's objection as incompetent or time-barred, nor is there an appeal challenging the 26th April 2023 award.

37. In Rok Industries Limited v Kang’ethe [2026] KEELRC 61 (KLR), the Court considered competing DOSH Form 4 awards and emphasized that disputes concerning the validity or merits of a DOSH award must be addressed within the statutory objection and appeal framework rather than by the enforcement court effectively sitting as an appellate tribunal.

38. Further, in the Kikuyu Pipes case (supra), the Court reiterated that at the enforcement stage the Court is not entitled to inquire into the merits of the Director's award.

39. In light of the foregoing, I find that the Respondent has raised a legitimate question regarding the procedural history of the 2023 award, but has not demonstrated that the award was set aside, varied or successfully challenged through the statutory mechanism provided under WIBA.

Whether the Respondent has proved payment of Kshs.262,080

40. The Respondent asserts that the first award of Kshs.262,080 was fully settled and that the Applicant executed a discharge voucher acknowledging payment. The Applicant disputes payment and maintains that no evidence shows the sum was ever paid. Having asserted that the earlier award was paid, the Respondent bore the evidential burden of demonstrating payment.

41. Although the Respondent contends that it filed a replying affidavit in opposition to the application, there is none in the court file or in the CTS. The court notes that the Applicant filed a supplementary affidavit in response to the said reply, but it does not appear to have been officially filed. The Respondent thus relies principally on its submissions in the absence of the replying affidavit.

42. It is settled that submissions are not evidence, and hence a party cannot establish payment merely by making the assertion in submissions. In my view, there ought to have been evidence such as a discharge voucher, payment acknowledgment, bank transfer, cheque, insurer's settlement documents, or other material demonstrating that the Applicant actually received the Kshs.262,080.

43. The Court in the circumstances finds that payment of Kshs.262,080 has not been proven on the material before it.

Whether the Court should adopt the award of Kshs.336,960

44. The Court retains the jurisdiction to adopt and enforce a DOSH award where the statutory mechanisms for challenging it have not been invoked successfully. In Stephen Wangusi Nyongesa v Dot.Com Bakery Limited [2022] KEELRC 224 (KLR), the Court held that an assessment made by the Director became payable where the Respondent had not objected under Section 51.

45. The same position was adopted in Wandera v Endmor Steel Millers Limited [2025] KEELRC 265 (KLR), where the Court enforced a DOSH award after finding that the employer had neither objected to nor appealed against the assessment.

46. In the present case, the Respondent has not demonstrated that the 26th April 2023 award was successfully challenged or set aside, nor has it proved the alleged payment of the earlier award.

47. The Court therefore finds no legal basis, within these enforcement proceedings, for disregarding the award issued on 26th April 2023.

48. In whole, I find the application merited and make the following orders:

a) That the DOSH award dated 26th April, 2023 in the sum of Kshs.336,960 is hereby adopted as a Judgment of this Court.

b) That the decretal sum shall attract interest at Court rates from the date of filing the application until payment in full.

c) The Respondent shall bear the costs of the application.

49. It is so ordered.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE.

Appearance:

Mr. Ngige Present for the Applicant

Ms. Bett present for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S- C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder