Employment law

Nguli v Fine Engineering Work Ltd [2026] KEELRC 2833 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 5th November, 2025. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In the final analysis, I grant the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 36 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

MISC. APPLICATION NO. E433 OF 2025

VICTOR KIMELI NGULI……………….…………………..………. APPLICANT

VERSUS

FINE ENGINEERING WORK LIMITED…..….……………….…RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 5th November, 2025. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

i. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to adopt the assessment award of Kshs.304,190.94 issued by the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services as Judgment of the Court.

ii. THAT a decree for the above sum of Kshs.304,190.94/- plus interest from the date of the award, 2nd July, 2025, or the date of the adoption, to issue in accordance with the assessment of the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services against the Respondent.

iii. THAT a declaration to issue that the Respondent has committed an offense contrary to Section 26(6) of the work injury Benefit Act for failing to pay the Applicant.

iv. THAT the Court commit the directors of the Respondent to one year in jail or fine them Kshs. 500,000/- or both for the offence committed.

v. THAT the costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is supported by grounds on its face, the supporting affidavit of the Applicant sworn on 5th November, 2025, and a further affidavit sworn on 22nd January, 2026.

3. The Applicant states that he is a former employee of the Respondent who was injured in a workplace accident on 2nd October 2021, resulting in serious bodily injuries. He avers that the accident was reported to the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services through the requisite occupational accident notification.

4. He avers that on 2nd July 2025, the Director assessed his compensation at Kshs. 304,190.94. The Applicant states that he served the Respondent with the assessment, but the Respondent has failed, refused and/or neglected to pay the assessed compensation.

5. The Applicant avers that he relies on Section 26(6) of the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA), contending that failure by an employer or insurer to pay compensation is an offence.

6. The Applicant further invokes the principles that a wrong should have a remedy and Article 159(2) of the Constitution, particularly the requirement that justice be administered fairly and without undue delay, and urges the Court to hear and determine the matter expeditiously.

7. The Respondent opposed the Motion vide grounds of opposition dated 9th December, 2025, arguing that it is incompetent, misconceived, frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process.

8. The Respondent contends that the DOSH assessment was never served upon it and, consequently, it was denied the opportunity to challenge the assessment within the statutory 60 day period. The Respondent further states that failure to notify and hear it before the assessment fundamentally violated its right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution.

9. It contends further that the amount of Kshs. 304,190.94 awarded to the Applicant was unjust and manifestly excessive. It states that it could not obtain a second medical opinion to verify the alleged permanent incapacity.

10. The Respondent argues that the Court lacks jurisdiction to enforce a DOSH award, relying on Lameck Nyakundi Anyona v WJJ Kenya Construction Co. Ltd [2022] eKLR. The Respondent points to the DOSH system, which allegedly indicates that the assessment was made on 2nd December, 2021, contrary to the Applicant's stated date of 2nd July, 2025.

11. The Respondent prays that the application be dismissed with costs and that the matter be referred back to DOSH for reconsideration and reassessment, so that the Respondent may be heard on the merits.

12. In his further affidavit, the Applicant, in response to the grounds of opposition, states that the Respondent’s contention that it was not served with the DOSH assessment is not truthful. He maintains that the Respondent was duly served with the DOSH assessment and that the statutory 60 day period for challenging the assessment expired before the Applicant filed the application seeking adoption of the award.

13. The Applicant further states that the Respondent’s insurer, G.A.A. Insurance Company, was served with the assessment award on 30th July, 2025.

14. The Applicant states that after personally visiting the Respondent’s offices, he was informed that the claim had been forwarded to the insurer and was being processed for payment, and based on that representation, he instructed his advocates to write to the insurer demanding payment.

15. The Applicant states that he subsequently learnt from the insurer that it had settled the matter and paid the assessment award to the Respondent.

16. The Applicant therefore maintains that the Respondent’s continued opposition to the application is unjustified, particularly since the assessment had allegedly been served and the award had already been paid to the Respondent by its insurer.

17. Parties’ submissions on the motion have been duly considered.

Analysis and Determination

18. I have considered the application, the supporting affidavit, the further affidavit, the Respondent’s grounds of opposition and the rival submissions. The issues arising for determination are:

i. Whether the Respondent has established a basis for the Court to decline adoption of the award;

ii. Whether the Applicant has established that the assessed sum remains unpaid; and

iii. Whether the Applicant is entitled to the prayers sought, including the criminal sanctions sought under Section 26(6) of WIBA.

Whether the Respondent has established a basis for the Court to decline adoption of the award.

19. Section 51(1) of WIBA provides that a person aggrieved by a decision of the Director may, within 60 days of the decision, lodge an objection with the Director, and if dissatisfied with the Director's response to the objection, the aggrieved party may appeal to this Court within 30 days under Section 52(2). The Court of Appeal in Thepot Patrick Charles v Joash Shisia Cheto [2025] KECA 784 (KLR), affirmed this statutory procedure.

20. The significance of that procedure is that the merits of the Director's assessment are not ordinarily open for reconsideration during adoption proceedings. The Court of Appeal expressly held that, unless exercising its appellate jurisdiction under Section 52 of WIBA, this Court should not undertake a fact finding exercise into the merits of the Director's award.

21. The Respondent herein challenges the assessment on several grounds, including that it was not served, that it was denied an opportunity to be heard, that the amount was excessive, and that it was unable to obtain a second medical opinion. These are, in substance, challenges to the process and merits of the Director's assessment.

22. The Respondent has not placed any evidence before this Court to show that it lodged an objection with the Director under Section 51(1), or that it subsequently appealed to this Court under Section 52(2). It has therefore not invoked the statutory mechanism through which those complaints ought to have been ventilated.

23. On the other hand, the Applicant has produced evidence which supports service of the assessment upon the Respondent's insurer on 30th July 2025. The Respondent, on its part, has not produced evidence controverting the receipt of service by its insurer.

24. Further, the Applicant states that when he visited the Respondent's offices, he was informed that the claim had been forwarded to the insurer and was being processed for payment. This conduct is not entirely consistent with the Respondent's present assertion that it was wholly unaware of the assessment.

25. The Court of Appeal in Charles v Cheto (supra) held that, where the statutory objection period had lapsed, the appropriate avenue for a party seeking to challenge the Director's decision on such procedural grounds was to seek judicial review to quash the award, after seeking a stay of the adoption proceedings, and it proceeded to uphold the adoption because no such step had been taken.

26. The Court of Appeal was categorical that an employer who fails to challenge the award through the mechanisms provided by WIBA cannot subsequently seek to litigate the merits of the award at the adoption stage.

27. I therefore find that the Respondent's complaints regarding the quantum of Kshs.304,190.94, permanent incapacity and the opportunity to obtain a second medical opinion cannot properly be determined in these adoption proceedings.

28. Further, the Respondent's plea that the matter be remitted to DOSH for reassessment consequently cannot be granted in the present proceedings, as the Court is not sitting as an appellate body over the Director's assessment.

Whether the Applicant has established that the assessed sum remains unpaid

29. The Applicant asserts that the award has not been paid to him, and further states that the Respondent's insurer acknowledged receipt of the assessment and that he was subsequently informed that the insurer had paid the assessment to the Respondent.

30. The Respondent has not demonstrated by evidence that the Applicant has received Kshs.304,190.94 or that the award has otherwise been discharged. On the material before the Court, therefore, the Court is not satisfied that the Applicant's claim has been settled.

31. Other than the prayer for adoption of the award, the Applicant prays for a declaration that the Respondent committed an offence under Section 26(6) of WIBA and for the Court to fine its directors Kshs.500,000 or commit them to imprisonment for one year, or both.

32. Section 26(6) provides that an employer or insurer who fails to pay compensation claimed under Section 26 commits an offence and, on conviction, is liable to a fine not exceeding Kshs.500,000 or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both.

33. The criminal sanction in the provision follows conviction for an offence, and cannot in my view properly be imposed merely upon a finding in an enforcement application that an award remains unpaid.

34. The present application is principally an application for adoption and enforcement of an administrative award. It is not a criminal charge against the Respondent or its directors.

35. Consequently, prayers (iii) and (iv) cannot issue in these proceedings.

36. In the final analysis, I grant the following reliefs: -

a) That the assessment/award of the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services in the sum of Kshs.304,190.94 is hereby adopted as a judgment and decree of this Court.

b) Interest shall accrue at court rates from the date of filing the application until payment in full.

c) Prayers (iii) and (iv), seeking criminal sanctions under Section 26(6) of WIBA, are declined.

d) The Respondent shall bear the costs of the application.

48. It is so ordered.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE.

Appearance:

Mr. Muia Present for the Applicant

Ms. Kariuki present for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S- C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder