Employment law

Munguti v Ardhi Sacco Society [2026] KEELRC 2832 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E529 of 2024
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before Court is the Judgment debtor/Applicant’s Motion application dated 28th October, 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 16 and 20 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, Rule 33 of the ELRC (Procedure) Rules, 2016, Sections 1A, 3, 3A, 63(e), 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 Rule 22,0rder 40 Rule l(a) and 2 (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, wherein the Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the Notice of Motion, the supporting affidavit, the Replying Affidavit in opposition, and the rival submissions. The issues for determination are:

Paragraph 23 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, the Court finds no sufficient basis to grant the prayer for payment by three equal monthly instalments.

Paragraph 42 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the judgment debtor established grounds to review the judgment delivered on 29 September 2025; whether execution should be stayed; and whether the judgment debtor should be allowed to pay the decretal sum in three monthly instalments.

Material facts

Catherine Munguti, the decree holder, had obtained a judgment against Ardhi Sacco Society. Ardhi Sacco applied on 28 October 2025 to stay execution, review the award, and pay any rectified sum by instalments. It alleged that the Court used a monthly salary of…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT& LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E529 OF 2024.

CATHERINE MUNGUTI..………………DECREE HOLDER/RESPONDENT

VERSUS

ARDHI SACCO SOCIETY……………JUDGMENT DEBTOR/APPLICANT

RULING

1. Before Court is the Judgment debtor/Applicant’s Motion application dated 28th October, 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 16 and 20 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, Rule 33 of the ELRC (Procedure) Rules, 2016, Sections 1A, 3, 3A, 63(e), 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 Rule 22,0rder 40 Rule l(a) and 2 (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, wherein the Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

i. Spent

ii. Spent

iii. THAT there be a stay of execution of the judgment and/or decree delivered on 29th September 2025 entered by Hon. Lady Justice Christine Noontatua Baari and any Decree or any other consequential orders.

iv. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to review and vary its judgment delivered on 29th September 2025, on the ground that the court applied an erroneous salary amount of Ksh.92,000.00 instead of Ksh.81,620.00 in computing the award for wrongful computation, leading to a mathematical and factual error in the final sum.

v. THAT upon review, the court do apply the correct monthly salary of Kshs.81,620.00 in the computation of the award to read as follows;

a) Damages for unlawful and unfair termination, the equivalent of 12 months' salary @ Kshs.81,620.00 totaling to Ksh.979,440.00 instead of Ksh.92,000.00 per month totaling Kshs.1,104,000.00

b) One month's salary in lieu of notice in the sum of Kshs. 81,620.00 totaling instead of Ksh.92,001.00.

c) Salaries for the months of February, March and May 2019 @ Ksh.81,620.00 totaling Ksh.244,860.00 instead of Ksh.92,000.00 totaling to 368,000.00.

d) The total award to read Ksh.1,305,920.00 in place of Ksh.1,564,000.00, being a difference of Ksh.258,080.00.

vi. THAT without prejudice to the foregoing, this Honorable Court be pleased to allow the Applicant to pay the rectified judgment sum, if any, by three (3) equal monthly instalments from the date of this order.

vii. THAT costs of this application be in the cause.

2. The application is supported by grounds on the face of the Motion and the affidavit of Bernard Mariga together with the supporting annexures.

3. The Applicant contends that the judgment delivered on 29th September, 2025 contains an error apparent on the face of the record in that the Court applied a monthly salary of Kshs. 92,000 instead of the correct salary of Kshs. 81,620, which was admitted in evidence. It avers that, as a result, the award was erroneously computed at Kshs. 1,564,000 instead of the correct amount of Kshs. 1,305,920, resulting in an excess of Kshs. 258,080.

4. The Applicant states that it therefore seeks rectification of the judgment, contending that execution based on the erroneous computation would occasion substantial loss and unjust enrichment of the Claimant.

5. The Applicant states that it is ready and willing to satisfy the judgment once the correct computation is made, but seeks leave to pay the decretal sum in three equal monthly instalments due to the SACCO’s current financial constraints. It states that its cash flow is limited because it relies on members’ deposits and has advanced substantial loans to members.

6. The Applicant further states that the application was filed without unreasonable delay upon discovery of the alleged error, and urges the Court, in the interests of justice and fairness, to correct the error and review the judgment accordingly.

7. The Claimant/Respondent opposed the application vide a Replying affidavit sworn on 14th November, 2025, by the Claimant/Respondent herein.

8. The Claimant/Applicant maintains that the Judgment delivered on 29th September 2025 did not contain an error apparent on the face of the record, arguing that the Court correctly relied on the documentary evidence available at the time of hearing, particularly the December 2018 pay slip showing a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 92,000.00. The Claimant therefore contends that the alleged use of Kshs. 92,000.00 instead of Kshs. 81,620.00 is not an error but was based on the evidence on record.

9. The Claimant further notes that the Judgment awarded of Kshs. 368,000.00 for unpaid salaries for February to May 2019 and Kshs. 1,104,000.00 as 12 months’ compensation for unfair termination.

10. The Claimant argues that the Applicant’s reliance on the purported new evidence amounts to an attempt to reopen and re-litigate matters already determined, thereby delaying justice and abusing the review process.

11. The Claimant urges the Court to uphold the finality of the Judgment, particularly given the hardship she suffered after the unfair termination.

12. The Claimant further relies on the December 2018 pay slip and salary review notice dated 17th December 2018 as evidence supporting the salary figure of Kshs. 92,000.00.

13. The Claimant further challenges the authenticity and evidential value of the purported January 2019 pay slip relied upon by the Respondent/Applicant, and contends that the pay slip lacks a payroll number, incorrectly identifies her designation as “Support Staff” instead of “MPA Manager,” and assigns her job group 6 instead of job group 1.

14. The Claimant also points out that the January 2019 pay slip omits the Kshs. 5,000 medical allowance allegedly enjoyed throughout the employment, which further casts doubt on its authenticity. The Claimant argues that the Respondent, as the custodian of employment records, has not explained why it did not produce the purported pay slip during the trial.

15. It is further contended that the January 2019 pay slip was never produced or admitted in evidence during the court proceedings and that introducing it at the review stage amounts to introducing new evidence through the back door. The Claimant relies on Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2016, arguing that the requirements for review on the basis of new evidence have not been met because the document was within the Respondent’s custody and could have been produced with due diligence.

16. The Claimant also alleges non-disclosure of material facts and argues that the Respondent is not entitled to the equitable relief of review. In particular, the Claimant asserts that the application was filed after expiry of the 30 day stay period.

17. She avers that the Respondent’s claims of financial hardship and request for payment by instalments are unsupported, and that the Respondent has not demonstrated good faith or provided security for performance of the decree.

18. The Claimant further states that access to the FOSA account remains unavailable despite the Court’s direction that it be unfrozen, and reiterates that the disputed January 2019 pay slip was never issued to her, produced, nor admitted during the trial.

19. The Claimant contends that the application is an appeal disguised as a review, intended to re-argue matters already determined rather than address any error apparent on the face of the record. The Claimant maintains that the Court’s review jurisdiction is limited and cannot be used to re-evaluate evidence or substitute findings that were properly reached on the material before the Court.

20. The Claimant argues that the Respondent/Applicant has failed to identify any error, misdirection or oversight warranting interference with the Judgment, which was based on the pleadings, evidence and submissions presented at trial. The Claimant therefore maintains that the Judgment remains valid and that the review application is frivolous, an abuse of the Court process, and intended to delay execution and frustrate enjoyment of the fruits of her judgment.

21. The Claimant therefore urges the Court to preserve the finality of the Judgment and reject the application.

22. The parties filed submissions on the motion, which have been duly considered.

Analysis and Determination

23. I have considered the Notice of Motion, the supporting affidavit, the Replying Affidavit in opposition, and the rival submissions. The issues for determination are:

i. Whether the Applicant has established a basis for review of the Judgment delivered on 29th September 2025;

ii. Whether an order for stay of execution should issue; and

iii. Whether the Applicant should be permitted to liquidate the decretal sum by installments.

24. At the outset, I note that although the application cites Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2016, the application was filed on 28th October, 2025 after the coming into force of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024. The applicable provision on review is therefore Rule 74 of the 2024 Rules.

25. Rule 74(1) permits review of a court judgment on account of discovery of new and important evidence which could not, despite due diligence, have been produced at the time of the decree, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, a need for clarification or for any other sufficient reason. Section 16 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act similarly empowers the Court to review its judgments, awards, orders or decrees in accordance with the Rules.

26. In National Bank of Kenya Limited Vs Ndungu Njau [1997] KECA 389 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that an error apparent on the face of the record must be self evident and should not require an elaborate argument to establish. The Court distinguished such an error from a matter on which another judge might take a different view, observing that the latter is properly a ground for appeal, and not review.

27. The Applicant herein contends that the Court applied a salary of Kshs.92,000 instead of Kshs.81,620. The Claimant, however, relies upon the December 2018 payslip and salary review notice showing a gross salary of Kshs.92,000 and disputes the authenticity and evidential value of the January 2019 payslip relied upon by the Applicant.

28. The competing positions demonstrate that the issue is not an obvious arithmetical or clerical error. It is a dispute as to the correct evidential basis upon which the Claimant's salary ought to have been determined.

29. In my view, resolving that dispute would require the Court to revisit and re-evaluate the employment records and potentially substitute its own factual finding for that made in the Judgment, which is not the function of review. As held in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau (supra), a review cannot be used to invite the Court to reconsider a matter that was contested and determined, merely because a party considers the Court's conclusion erroneous. Such a course would effectively cause the Court to sit on appeal over its own decision.

30. This position is further compounded by the Applicant's reliance upon the purported January 2019 payslip. The Claimant maintains that the document was never produced or admitted at trial and that it remained in the Respondent's custody. If the Applicant seeks to rely on the document as newly discovered evidence, it was incumbent upon it to satisfy Rule 74(1)(a) by demonstrating that the evidence was not within its knowledge and could not, despite due diligence, have been produced at the time of the original proceedings.

31. The Applicant has not provided a satisfactory explanation as to why an employment pay slip said to have been generated in the ordinary course of employment could not be produced during the trial.

32. The pay slip cannot be introduced at the review stage merely because the Applicant now considers it more favourable to its position.

33. The alleged mathematical error therefore cannot be established independent of the underlying factual dispute as to the applicable salary and the precise months for which salary was awarded. It follows that the Applicant has not demonstrated a self-evident error apparent on the face of the record.

34. I accordingly find and hold that the prayer for review is an invitation to the Court to re-evaluate evidence and reconsider findings already made in the Judgment. The prayer for review therefore fails.

35. On the prayer for stay of execution, the law requires that the Applicant demonstrate substantial loss, that there was no unreasonable delay, and provide appropriate security. In Kenya Shell Ltd v Benjamin Kibiru & Another [1986] KLR 410, the Court of Appeal emphasized that substantial loss is the cornerstone of an application for stay.

36. The Applicant herein has made general assertions concerning its financial constraints and cash flow, but has not placed before Court sufficient evidence demonstrating substantial loss in the event the execution is effected. It has equally not offered security for the due performance of the decree.

37. The Court is also alive to the successful Claimant's right to enjoy the fruits of her Judgment, and in the absence of demonstrated substantial loss and appropriate security, there is no sufficient basis upon which execution of the judgment should be stayed.

38. The prayer for stay of execution therefore equally fails.

39. The Applicant’s final prayer is an order allowing it to make payments of the decretal amount by instalments. Order 21 Rule 12(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the Court, upon sufficient cause being shown, to permit a judgment debtor to pay a decretal sum by installments and to impose such terms as to interest or security as it considers appropriate.

40. This discretion is, however, judicial and must balance the interests of the judgment debtor against those of the decree holder. In Keshvaji Jethabhai & Bros Ltd v Saleh Abdulla [1959] EA 260, the Court emphasized that inability to pay the whole decretal sum immediately is not, by itself, sufficient. The debtor must demonstrate bona fides by arranging prompt payment of a fair proportion, while hardship may be considered where indulgence can be granted without prejudicing the creditor.

41. The Applicant has not placed sufficient financial material before the Court to demonstrate why three equal monthly instalments are necessary or why immediate payment would cause hardship warranting such indulgence.

42. In the circumstances, the Court finds no sufficient basis to grant the prayer for payment by three equal monthly instalments.

43. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2025 is hereby dismissed.

44. The Judgment delivered on 29th September 2025 remains undisturbed.

45. The costs of the application shall be borne by the Applicant/Respondent.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Ms. Sila h/b for Mr. Kotonya for the Decree Holder/Respondent

N/A for the Judgment debtor/Applicant

Ms. Esther S -C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder