Land law

Njau v Kamumu & 4 others [2026] KEELC 7326 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mbogo C.G.

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This appeal arises from the judgment of Hon. S. A. Opande, Principal Magistrate, delivered on 5th June, 2024 in Milimani MCELC no. E015 of 2022, Peter Ngurura Kamumu v Roysambu Housing Co-operative Society Limited & 4 Others. Being dissatisfied with the whole judgment, the appellant filed the memorandum of appeal dated 3rd July 2024, challenging the said judgment on the following grounds:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

This being a first appeal, the court is mandated to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence tendered before the trial court and arrive at its own independent conclusion, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses testify. This principle was stated in Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others [1968] EA 123. Having considered the grounds of appeal and the record, I find that the issues for determination…

Paragraph 4 →

Reasoning passage

I find that the trial court erred in declaring the appellant’s title void and ordering its cancellation without sufficient evidence. Ground four of the appeal succeeds to the extent that fraud was not proved. This finding does not amount to a determination that the appellant was an innocent purchaser for value without notice, as that assertion must itself be established by evidence. On the award of damages, the trial court awarded the…

Paragraph 13 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLA NO. E089 OF 2024

FRANCIS KARANJA NJAU........................................................APPELLANT

VERSUS

PETER NGURURA KAMUMU............................................1ST RESPONDENT

ROYSAMBU HOUSING CO-OPERATIVE

SOCIETY LIMITED……….................……………………………..2ND RESPONDENT

CHIEF LANDS REGISTRAR,

NAIROBI COUNTY………………….................………………..…3RD RESPONDENT

THE CABINET SECRETARY

MINISTRY OF LANDS……………………….…………………........4TH RESPONDENT

THE HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL.....................................5TH RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. This appeal arises from the judgment of Hon. S. A. Opande, Principal Magistrate, delivered on 5th June, 2024 in Milimani MCELC no. E015 of 2022, Peter Ngurura Kamumu v Roysambu Housing Co-operative Society Limited & 4 Others. Being dissatisfied with the whole judgment, the appellant filed the memorandum of appeal dated 3rd July 2024, challenging the said judgment on the following grounds:-

1. That the learned magistrate erred both in law and in fact in finding that only a letter which emanated from the 1st defendant’s advocates’ office was sufficient proof that the plaintiff was a lawful owner of the suit property.

2. That the learned magistrate erred both in law and fact by taking into account the mistakes of an advocate and failed to grant the appellant a chance to be heard hence finding that the appellant did not call any witness at trial.

3. That the learned magistrate erred in law and in fact in allowing the 1st respondent’s prayers on grounds that the suit was unopposed without regard to the appellant’s intention to defend the suit.

4. That the learned trial magistrate erred both in law and fact by fact in cancelling the appellant’s title without giving regard that the appellant was an innocent purchaser for value without notice of any alleged fraud.

5. That the learned trial magistrate erred in law and in fact by awarding an award of Kshs. 1,200,000 as nominal general damages for fraud and failed to appreciate that the 1st respondent did not plead or prove any fraud or irregularity on the part of the appellant.

6. That in all the circumstances of the case, the learned magistrate failed to render justice to the appellant.

2. The appellant therefore prays for the following orders: -

a. This appeal be allowed.

b. The judgment and the orders issued by the learned magistrate on 5th June, 2024 be varied, quashed and/or set aside.

c. The respondent be condemned to pay the costs of this appeal and cost in the subordinate court.

d. Any other relieds as the court shall deem fit and just.

3. The grounds of appeal were canvassed through written submissions. The appellant filed written submissions dated 30th June, 2026. The 1st respondent filed written submissions dated 17th June, 2026. I have considered the grounds of appeal and the written submissions filed by counsel for the respective parties and the authorities relied upon. I have also perused the replying affidavit sworn by the 1st respondent on 18th March, 2026. Since the appeal falls for determination on the basis of the record of the trial court, the said affidavit cannot be used to canvass the appeal.

4. This being a first appeal, the court is mandated to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence tendered before the trial court and arrive at its own independent conclusion, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses testify. This principle was stated in Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others [1968] EA 123. Having considered the grounds of appeal and the record, I find that the issues for determination are as follows:-

i. Whether the learned trial magistrate erred in finding that the 1st respondent had established ownership of the suit property.

ii. Whether the appellant was denied an opportunity to be heard.

iii. Whether cancellation of the appellant’s title and the finding of fraud were justified.

iv. Whether the award of Kshs.1,200,000/= was warranted.

v. Who is to bear costs.

5. The dispute before the trial court concerned the ownership of land parcel known as Nairobi/ Block 116/43. In a plaint dated 24th January 2022, the 1st respondent, who was the plaintiff before the trial court, claimed to be the lawful proprietor of the suit property, having acquired his interest through allocation by the 2nd respondent herein. He challenged the legitimacy of the titles held by the appellant and the 2nd respondent and sought, among other reliefs, declarations of ownership, cancellation of the impugned titles, issuance of title documents in his favour, a permanent injunction and damages. The appellant together with the 2nd respondent filed their statement of defence dated 4th February 2022, denied the allegations in the plaint, and maintained that the 1st respondent and the person appearing in the records are not the same. The 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents filed their statement of defence dated 15th February, 2022 equally denying the particulars of the plaint. The 1st respondent filed reply to the 1st and 2nd defendants’ defence dated 16th February, 2022.

6. Upon hearing the matter, the learned trial magistrate found in favour of the 1st respondent and declared him the lawful owner of the suit property. The court further ordered cancellation of the impugned title documents, rectification of the register, issuance of title documents in favour of the 1st respondent and awarded Kshs.1,200,000/= as nominal general damages for fraud.

7. On the first issue, Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act place the burden of proof upon the party asserting the existence of a fact. Accordingly, the burden rested upon the 1st respondent to establish, on a balance of probabilities, his entitlement to the suit property and the grounds upon which the competing titles ought to be invalidated. From the impugned judgment, the learned trial magistrate relied substantially on a letter dated 28th February 2020, emanating from the advocates for the 2nd respondent, as evidence that the 1st respondent was the rightful owner of the suit property. The court further observed that neither the appellant nor the 2nd respondent had called witnesses to controvert the 1st respondent’s claim.

8. While the said letter was relevant evidence, the question is whether it was sufficient, together with the other evidence presented, to establish lawful ownership and justify cancellation of the existing titles. In Maina v Maina [2013] KECA 94 (KLR) , the court of appeal held that where the root of title is challenged, the registered proprietor must demonstrate the legality of the process through which the title was acquired. The same principle requires a party seeking cancellation of another person’s registered title to establish the legal and factual grounds for such cancellation. Section 26(1) of the Land Registration Act recognizes a certificate of title as prima facie evidence of ownership, subject to challenge on grounds of fraud or misrepresentation to which the proprietor is proved to be a party, or where the certificate was acquired illegally, unprocedurally or through a corrupt scheme.

9. In the present case, the learned trial magistrate found that the appellant was guilty of fraud because the letter dated 28th February, 2020 contradicted the defence advanced and because the appellant and the 2nd respondent failed to call witnesses. In my view, that reasoning was insufficient to sustain a finding of fraud. The failure of a defendant to tender evidence does not relieve the plaintiff of the obligation to prove his case.

10. More importantly, the trial court did not sufficiently examine the circumstances surrounding the acquisition of the competing titles or identify the specific fraudulent acts established against the appellant. Although the 1st respondent claimed entitlement through the 2nd respondent, evidence of membership and an acknowledgment of allocation could not, without adequate examination of the competing interests, conclusively establish that the appellant’s title was fraudulently acquired.

11. On the second issue, the appellant contends that he was condemned unheard on account of mistakes attributed to his advocate. I have examined the proceedings before the trial court. The record discloses that the appellant was represented by counsel and that opportunities were afforded to the defence to participate in the proceedings. The trial court also considered requests for adjournment before proceeding to conclude the matter. The right to be heard under Article 50(1) of the Constitution guarantees a party a reasonable opportunity to present his case. It does not confer an unrestricted entitlement to adjournments. In the circumstances, I am not persuaded that the trial court denied the appellant an opportunity to be heard. Grounds two and three of the appeal therefore fail. It is important to note that this finding does not, however, cure any deficiency in the evidence upon which the judgment was founded. It was for trial court to evaluate the evidence against the applicable legal standards, notwithstanding the absence of defence testimony.

12. Turning to the cancellation of title, Section 80 of the Land Registration Act empowers the court to order rectification of the register where a registration was obtained, made or omitted by fraud or mistake. However, the court must be satisfied that the circumstances warranting such rectification have been established. In this case, the trial court proceeded to invalidate the competing titles without sufficiently establishing the circumstances under which they were acquired or the particular illegality or fraud attributable to the appellant. The finding that fraud had been proved was not adequately supported by the evidence and the reasoning disclosed in the judgment.

13. I find that the trial court erred in declaring the appellant’s title void and ordering its cancellation without sufficient evidence. Ground four of the appeal succeeds to the extent that fraud was not proved. This finding does not amount to a determination that the appellant was an innocent purchaser for value without notice, as that assertion must itself be established by evidence. On the award of damages, the trial court awarded the 1st respondent Kshs.1,200,000/= as nominal general damages for fraud, notwithstanding its acknowledgment that no evidence of financial loss had been presented.

14. Having found that the conclusion on fraud was not sufficiently supported by the evidence, the award of damages founded upon that conclusion cannot stand. In any event, the award of Kshs.1,200,000/=, described as nominal damages, was not adequately explained or justified in the circumstances of the case. Ground five of the appeal therefore succeeds. Having re-evaluated the record, I am satisfied that although the appellant was afforded an opportunity to participate in the proceedings, the trial court erred in the evaluation of the evidence relating to ownership and fraud, thereby arriving at conclusions that were not sufficiently supported by the evidence.

15. The 1st respondent bore the legal burden of establishing his entitlement to the suit property and the grounds for invalidating the competing titles. The absence of defence evidence did not shift or extinguish that burden. In the circumstances, the finding of ownership, the orders for cancellation and rectification, and the consequential award of damages cannot be sustained. Considering the nature of the dispute and the rights of the parties involved, I am of the view that the interests of justice would be better served by having the dispute determined afresh upon a proper evaluation of the evidence presented by the respective parties. In the circumstances, I find this to be an appropriate case for the exercise of this court’s powers under Section 78(1)(e) of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 42 Rule 26 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

16. From the above, I find merit in the memorandum of appeal and I make the following orders: -

i. The appeal dated 3rd July, 2024 is hereby allowed.

ii. The judgment and decree of Hon. S. A. Opande, Principal Magistrate, delivered on 5th June, 2024 in Milimani MCELC No. E015 of 2022 are hereby set aside.

iii. Milimani MCELC No. E015 of 2022 is hereby remitted to the chief magistrate’s Court at Milimani for hearing and determination de novo before a magistrate other than Hon. S. A. Opande.

iv. The parties shall appear before the chief magistrate’s Court for directions on the fresh hearing.

v. The costs of this appeal shall abide the outcome of the retrial.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT

THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

29/10/2026.

In the presence of:-

Mr. Benson Agunga – Court assistant

Dr. Kinyanjui for the Appellant

Ms. Kamuyu for the 1st Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder