Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 19th May 2026 on the following grounds;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 19th May 2026 on the following grounds;
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MISC. CIVIL APPLICATION NO. E400 OF 2025
IN THE MATTER OF A LAPSED TRUST OVER LAND REFERENCE NO.
209/8292/15 – HESHIMA (HAZINA) ESTATE, SOUTH C, NAIROBI
AND
IN THE MATTER OF A CONSENT ORDER DATED 5th FEBRUARY 2009 IN HCCC NO. 1228 OF 2006
BETWEEN
JUDY NJERI MUGO .............................................................................. APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
JAMES MUIRURI KAHUMBURA ......................................................... RESPONDENT
RULING
Introduction
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 19th May 2026 on the following grounds;
1. THAT the Application is fatally defective, incompetent, and an abuse of the court process for having been instituted by way of a Miscellaneous Application in the absence of a substantive suit capable of sustaining the orders sought.
2. THAT this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the Application as framed, the same not being anchored on any existing or properly instituted suit.
3. THAT the Application improperly seeks to review, vary, and/or set aside a Consent Order issued in HCCC No. 1228 of 2006 without moving the Court within the said suit.
4. THAT the Application offends the provisions of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, as no proper basis for review has been established in law.
5. THAT the Application is time-barred and caught up by the equitable doctrine of laches, having been brought after an inordinate delay of over Seventeen (17) years without any sufficient explanation.
6. THAT the Application is incurably defective for non-joinder of necessary parties, particularly the alleged beneficiaries of the trust who are central to the orders sought.
7. THAT the Applicant lacks locus standi to seek the orders herein as framed, and has improperly invoked the jurisdiction of this Honourable Court.
8. THAT the Application improperly seeks substantive and final reliefs, including vacant possession and mesne profits, which cannot be granted within a miscellaneous application.
2. The court directed for the Notice of Preliminary Objectionbe dispensed off by written submissions and both parties complied with the Respondent drafting submissions dated 25th September 2026 while the Applicant drafted submissions dated 5th October 2026
Respondent’s submission
3. Counsel submitted that the present application cannot be a substitute for a substantive where the court is tasked to determine contested rights and seeking substantive reliefs. That the present proceedings cannot stand as a substitute for either an application in HCCC No. 1228 of 2006 or a properly instituted substantive suit and hence the application is consequently fundamentally misconceived and should therefore be dismissed. Counsel relied in the case of Albert Vs Njoroge (Civil Appeal E001 of 2024) [2025] KEHC 12635 (KLR) (10 September 2025) (Judgment)
4. Counsel further submitted that the Applicant had not demonstrated sufficient reasons to review the consent order of 5th February 2009 in HCCC No. 1228 of 2006. He relied on the provisions of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Civil 2020 indicating that the Applicant had failed to provide any evidence of discovery of a new and important matter or evidence which after exercise of due diligence, was not within the Applicant´s knowledge or could not be produced at the time when the orders were made pointing further to the fact that there was an unreasonable delay by the Applicant from the date the consent was entered.
5. Counsel submitted that the delay was not merely a procedural technicality. It goes to the equitable discretion of the Court. A party seeking an equitable remedy must act with reasonable diligence relying on Tight Solutions Limited v Kidege Investment Limited & 4 Others [2024] KEELC 3279 (KLR).
6. He also submitted that the Applicant had not demonstrated an error to warrant the application of review. Hence such an exercise is beyond the proper scope of review and should be subsequently dismissed.
Applicant’s submissions
7. Applicant submitted that the grounds raised by the Applicant in the Preliminary Objection require factual ascertainment that would involve exercise of judicial discretion and therefore cannot be the basis of the Preliminary Objection.
8. Counsel further submitted that the application was anchored on section 44 and 56 of the trustee Act which authorize the court to act on an application in trust matters.
That further the principle that a miscellaneous application cannot sustain a substantive relief is not absolute as there are exceptions to it relying in the case of the Estate of Zakayo Mwangi Kamau (2020) eKLR
9. The Applicant further submitted that the Preliminary Objection has mischaracterized the nature of the application as the Applicant was not seeking for review of the consent, rather the consent had expired by the virtue of the fact that the beneficiaries under the trust had obtained age of majority and hence the application was seeking to give effect to an order that had ran its course.
Analysis and determination
10. Upon considering the Preliminary Objection and the submissions filed the only issue for determination is whether the substantive reliefs can be competently sought through a miscellaneous application in the absence of a substantive suit?
11. Pursuant to the holding in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd -vs- West End Distributors Ltd (1969) EA 696, the test to be satisfied for a Preliminary Objection to succeed is that it ought to raise a pure point of law, it should be based on the assumption that the facts pleaded by the opposing side are correct, and the same cannot be raised if there is need to ascertain a fact or what is sought is in the exercise of judicial discretion. If a Preliminary Objection is successful, it ought to dispose of the suit.
12. The Respondents in their Preliminary Objection argued that the Applicant’s Application is not anchored on any existing suit or properly instituted suit contrary to the general rule of how a suit should be instituted, and that an application can only be filed within a properly instituted suit. According to this court, this is a pure point of law. I therefore find that the objection meets the requisite threshold and is therefore properly taken. Consequently, I will therefore proceed to determine whether it is meritorious.
13. From the record, it is evident that the Applicant has invoked this Court’s jurisdiction through a miscellaneous application seeking review orders of a consent order dated 5th February 2009 what declared trust over t L.R NO. 209/8292/15-Heshima (Hazina) Estate South C.
14. The Applicant ‘s case was that the trust had served its purpose as the beneficiaries were now adults with legal capacity therefore extinguishing the legal and equitable basis of the trust and that the Respondent should not continue exercising control over the suit property.
15. The law is unequivocal that substantive civil claims must be instituted in the manner prescribed by statute. Section 19 of the Civil Procedure Act, read together with Order 3 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, provides that every suit shall be instituted by a plaint or in such other manner as may be prescribed.
16. A miscellaneous application is not one of the recognized modes for instituting a substantive civil claim where contested rights are to be adjudicated. The jurisprudence on this point is consistent. In Tatecoh Housing & Co-operative Sacco Ltd. Vs Qwetu Sacco Ltd (2021) eKLR, the Court held that substantive reliefs, particularly those affecting proprietary rights, cannot be granted in a miscellaneous cause absent a properly instituted suit. The Court held that: “The Applicant cannot seek the orders sought in its miscellaneous application without going through the process of filing suit. It will be observed that among the orders sought in the motion are orders of eviction. One will ordinarily only obtain an order of eviction after full hearing of a case. What the Applicant needed to do was therefore to file a substantive suit for eviction through a plaint. It is upon hearing of such suit and if successful, that an order of eviction would issue.”
17. Similarly, in the case of “Rockland Kenya Limited Vs Commissioner General of KRA & Another (2020) eKLR”, the court held that substantive orders cannot be issued in miscellaneous applications. The court had in turn cited with approval the decision in the case of: Witmore Investment Limited Vs County Government of Kirinyaga & 3 Others (2016) eKLR where Limo J had stated that:-
“where a party such as an Applicant herein seeks an order that in effect appears to resolve with a finality an issue in controversy or a contested issue, the application ceases to be interlocutory and it is a misconception to describe it as such. If the Applicant wanted to move this court for a final resolution of the issues in controversy, raised in the application, it should have moved this court properly in the manner provided by the law.”
18. In the present matter, the orders sought go to the heart of proprietary rights which matters require pleadings, evidence, and a full hearing. To permit such reliefs to be granted through a miscellaneous application would, in the view of the Court, be to circumvent the procedural safeguards embedded in the Civil Procedure framework.
19. I therefore hold that the present proceedings are fatally defective for want of a proper originating suit.
Final disposition
20. Accordingly, the Respondent’s Preliminary Objection dated 19th July 2026 is hereby upheld. Consequently;
i. The Applicant’s chamber summons application dated 9th December 2025 June 2025 and the entire Miscellaneous Application are hereby struck out;
ii. The Applicant is at liberty to institute a proper suit before a court of competent jurisdiction;
iii. Costs of the Preliminary Objection and the struck-out application are awarded to the Respondent/Applicant.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 29th day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Mutugi for the Applicant
Ms. Waliula for the Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant