Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 22nd September 2026 on the following grounds;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 22nd September 2026 on the following grounds;
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLA E184 OF 2026
MOSES JAIKA LUVAI………………………………………...APPLICANT/APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
JOASH CALVIN OMONDI…………………………….…………………RESPONDENT
RULING
Introduction
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 22nd September 2026 on the following grounds;
a) THAT the supporting affidavit bears the stamp of a firm of advocates as opposed to a Commissioner of Oaths and as such it falls foul of the provisions of the oaths and Statutory Declarations Act and the rules thereto
b) THAT since the supporting affidavit is a nullity in law then the application is unsupported and as such cannot stand.
2. The court directed for the notice of Preliminary Objection be dispensed off by written submissions and only the Respondent complied filing submissions dated 29th September 2026.
Respondent’s Submission
3. Counsel submitted that the supporting affidavit to the notice of motion dated 17th August 2026 had not been properly commissioned to conform to the provisions of Sections 2(1) and 4(1) the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act. That the affidavit had been commissioned by a law firm instead of a natural person who should be a qualified person as envisaged by the above provisions.
4. That the said defect in the Commissioning is fatally defective and as such the Affidavit and by extension the Application ought to be struck out relying on the case of David Wamatsi Omusotsi Vs The Returning Officer Mumias East and 2 Others Election Petition Number 9 of 2017.
Analysis and determination
5. Upon considering the Preliminary Objection and the submissions filed the only issue for determination is whether the notice of Preliminary Objection dated 2nd September 2026 is merited?
6. The Respondent raised the fact that the supporting affidavit filed in support of the application dated 17th August 2026 was not commissioned and is therefore fatally defective.
7. Sections 4 and 5 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act provides how affidavits are to be commissioned. They also provide the particulars to be stated in jurat or the attestation clause. They require every commissioner for oaths before whom any oath or affidavit is taken to state in the jurat or attestation at what place and on what date the oath or affidavit is taken or made.
8. In the case of Geoffrey Githinji Mwangi & 2 others Vs Jubilee Party & 11 others [2018] eKLR, the court held that: -“As we have already seen in the relevant provisions of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act, the Chief Justice will appoint as commissioners individual advocates in practice, not their firms. Such commission is personal to the particular advocate so appointed. The commission is not issued to his firm. An affidavit therefor ought to show that it was taken by an individual advocate and commissioner for oaths, not by a firm of advocates. If affidavits were to be taken by a firm of advocates, what would prevent any member of that firm, be they advocates who have not been appointed commissioners for oaths, or clerks and secretaries, from purporting to take affidavits on behalf of such firm? That would clearly be against the clear provisions of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act.
This is in line with one of the holdings in the case mentioned by the Appellants in ground 2 of their appeal. That case is David Wamatsi Omusotsi v The Returning Officer Mumias East Constituency & 2 others, High Court Kakamega Election Petition No. 9 of 2017 [2017] eKLR. In that case Njagi, J held inter alia –“It is clear from the provisions of the said Act that affidavits cannot be commissioned by a firm of advocates as happened in this case. An affidavit can only be commissioned by a commissioner for oaths and other officials of the court allowed to do so under the Act....”
I entirely and respectfully agree with that holding.
The issue therefore was whether, on the face of the document itself, the affidavit in issue was taken by a commissioner for oaths, duly appointed. It clearly was not. The affidavit showed on the face of it that it was taken by Bwonwonga & Co Advocates & Commissioner for Oaths, not by any Bwonwonga, Advocate who could well have been a duly appointed commissioner for oaths. Bwonwonga & Co Advocates could not have been appointed commissioner for oaths under section 2[1] of the Act. Such appointment could only be of an advocate in practice, not a firm of advocates. Contrary to what was submitted for the Appellants, the issue whether the affidavit was duly taken by a commissioner for oaths was an issue of law, not fact. It was not open to the election court to call any advocate to verify that he or she was the advocate and commissioner for oaths behind the rubber stamp impression and that the signature thereon was his or hers. The affidavit itself ought to have clearly shown on the face of it who the advocate and commissioner for oaths taking the affidavit was. The purported knowledge of the election court of a Mr. Bwonwonga who was said to be a commissioner for oaths was irrelevant.”
9. From the foregoing, it is clear that the statement that was made and not commissioned do not amount to an affidavit. These statements cannot be taken to be evidence that support the Motion before Court.
10. What about Article 159 of the Constitution and the oxygen principles which both command courts to seek to do substantial justice in an efficient, proportionate and cost-effective manner and to disregard technicalities?
In Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat Vs IEBC & 6 others [2013] eKLR Kiage, JA held: -“I am not in the least persuaded that Article 159 of the Constitution and the oxygen principles which both command courts to seek to do substantial justice in an efficient, proportionate and cost-effective manner and to eschew defeatist technicalities were ever meant to aid in the overthrow or destruction of rules of procedure and to create an anarchical free-for-all in the administration of justice. This Court, indeed all courts, must never provide succor and cover to parties who exhibit scant respect for rules and timelines. Those rules and timelines serve to make the process of judicial adjudication and determination fair, just, certain and even-handed. Courts cannot aid in the bending or circumventing of rules and a shifting of goal posts for, while it may seem to aid one side, it unfairly harms the innocent party who strives to abide by the rules. I apprehend that it is in the even-handed and dispassionate application of rules that courts give assurance that there is a clear method in the manner in which things are done so that outcomes can be anticipated with a measure of confidence, certainty and clarity where issues of rules and their application are concerned…”
11. The defects raised on the Applicant’s supporting affidavit is not mere technicality but touch on a point law as it is in breach of Section 4 and 5 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act. The supporting affidavit was not commissioned by an advocate recognised under Section 2 of the Act. I therefore strike out the purported supporting affidavit as it is incurably defective.
12. Having struck out the supporting affidavit, the application dated 17th August 2026 is therefore rendered incompetent as it falls short of the content required under Order 51 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides that: -“Every notice of motion shall state in general terms the grounds of the application, and where any motion is grounded on evidence by affidavit, a copy of any affidavit intended to be used shall be served.”
13. This is a mandatory requirement and without a duly filed compliant affidavit to support the application, the same cannot stand by itself as it requires evidence
Final disposition
i. Consequently, I find that the application dated 17th August 2026 to be incurably defective and hereby strike it out.
ii. Costs be awarded to the Respondent.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 29th day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. MacDonald for the Appellant/Respondent
Mr. Nganga for the Respondent/Applicant
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant