Land law

Kimani & another (Suing as the administrators ad litem of the Estate of Patrick Ngugi Kimani aka Ngugi Kimani) v Embakasi Ranching Company Ltd & 6 others [2026] KEELC 7533 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
T. Murigi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Plaint dated 20th September 2023, the Plaintiffs seek the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In the end, I find that the Plaintiffs have failed to prove their case on a balance of probabilities. Consequently, I find that the Plaintiffs' suit is without merit and is hereby dismissed with no orders as to cost.

Paragraph 52 →

Reasoning passage

The Plaintiffs brought this suit as the legal administrators of the estate of the deceased, Patrick Ngugi Kimani aka Ngugi Kimani. They produced letters of administration ad litem issued to them on 3rd July 2023 in respect of the deceased’s estate, together with the deceased’s death certificate. The Court finds that the Plaintiffs have the requisite capacity to institute and prosecute this suit on behalf of the estate.

Paragraph 28 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC NO. E085 OF 2023

AGNES WAMBUI KIMANI & JUDY NYAMBURA KIMANI

(Suing as the Administrators Ad Litem of the Estate of

Patrick Ngugi Kimani aka Ngugi Kimani)…………………………. PLAINTIFFS

=VERSUS=

EMBAKASI RANCHING COMPANY LIMITED……………….1ST DEFENDANT

LUCY NYOKABI MATHENGE………………………..……… 2ND DEFENDANT

WALTER KIGERA WAIRERI……………………………..…….3RD DEFENDANT

RAPHAEL KIRUMWA THIMBA…………………………….. 4TH DEFENDANT

ANTHONY JAMES MUHORO ………………….…………. 5TH DEFENDANT

PETER GICHANGI MUNENE ……………………………….. 6TH DEFENDANT

GODFREY MUHURI MUCHIRI ……………………..…...…..7TH DEFENDANT

JUDGEMENT

1. By a Plaint dated 20th September 2023, the Plaintiffs seek the following orders:

a. That there be a Declaration that the Deceased, Patrick Ngugi Kimani aka Ngugi Kimani is the lawful exclusive owner of Plots Numbers Allocated M298 & M299 situated at Ruai within Embakasi Ranching Company Limited Settlement Scheme by the virtue of his being the holder of 1st Defendant's Share Certificate Number 4456 as per the Letter of Allocation dated 28/11/1982 and that the 1st, through the 2nd - 7th Defendants should facilitate the processing of the Leases for the Plots as had been envisaged at the time of allocation.

b. That an injunction does issue against the Defendants, severally, their agents, servants and/or employees from evicting the Plaintiff, selling, dealing with, trespassing, alienating, damaging and/or constructing or destroying the developments upon Original Plot Numbers Allocated M298 & M299 situated at Ruai within Embakasi Ranching Company Limited Settlement Scheme.

c. That eviction Orders do issued as against the Defendants severally, their agents, servants and/or employees and the O.C.S., Ruai Police Station does assist in service and effecting of the Orders.

d. The Plaintiff prays for Damage/Mesne Profits.

e. Costs and interest.

2. Though duly served, the Defendants did not enter appearance or file any defence.

3. The hearing proceeded as an undefended suit.

THE PLAINTIFFS CASE

4. The Plaintiffs called two witnesses in support of their case.

5. PW1, Agnes Wambui Kimani adopted her witness statement dated 20/09/2023 as her evidence in chief. She also produced the documents in the list in support of their case.

6. PW1 testified that the deceased, Patrick Ngugi Kimani, alias Ngugi Kimani, is the registered or equitable owner of Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299, situated at Ruai within the Embakasi Ranching Company Limited Settlement Scheme.

7. She further testified that the 1st Defendant allocated the plots to him by virtue of his holding of the 1st Defendant's Provisional Letter of Allocation, dated 28 November 1982, in respect of two shares in the 1st Defendant's company. The plots were said to form part of the 1st Defendant's L.R. No. 10904/2, which at the time measured approximately 2,024 hectares.

8. She informed the Court that the deceased had paid all requisite charges levied by the 1st Defendant in respect of the allocation from 1982 to date, and that the 1st Defendant’s surveyors had identified, confirmed, and reconfirmed him as the allottee of Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299.

9. She further stated that, by virtue of his two shares, the Deceased was entitled to bonus plots in respect of the original plots and was accordingly allocated Bonus Plots M298B and M299B. She stated that the Defendants had not interfered with the bonus plots, which had since been subdivided into L.R. Nos. 136/542 and 136/550, respectively.

10. She contended that the 2nd to 7th Defendants, in their capacities as directors of the 1st Defendant, unlawfully and irregularly used their collective and individual positions to trespass on Original Plots Nos. M298 and M299, with the sole intention of dispossessing the deceased of those plots, particularly after learning of the deceased’s death on 20th January 1989.

11. She asserted that the 1st Defendant, as the owner of the settlement scheme, sought to withdraw from the express allocation made through the 2nd to 7th Defendants by interfering with ownership and possession of the plots and the processing of leases for those plots.

12. She further testified that the Defendants had trespassed onto the plots and destroyed the developments thereon. She asserted that they had suffered irreparable loss as a result of the Defendants' acts of trespass, destruction, and alienation, the waste caused to the plots, and the failure to process the leases. These consequences arose from the unlawful actions of the Defendants, their servants, employees, and agents.

13. She maintained that, although the Defendants knew the plots belonged to the Deceased, they had refused to allow the Plaintiffs quiet enjoyment of the plots. She further testified that, despite several reports to the Police and the Provincial Administration, the Plaintiffs had not obtained any assistance. They apprehended that the Defendants, their agents, employees and servants would continue to trespass upon, damage and destroy the plots and evict them therefrom unless restrained by an order of this Court.

14. PW2 Judy Nyambura Kimani adopted her witness statement dated 20th September 2023. She echoed the evidence of PW1.

15. After the hearing concluded, the Plaintiffs filed written submissions in support of their case.

THE PLAINTIFF’S SUBMISSIONS

16. The Plaintiffs filed their submissions dated 22nd April 2026.

17. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs sued as administrators ad litem of the deceased's estate and produced a valid grant ad litem in evidence. Counsel argued that the grant conferred capacity on the Plaintiffs to institute and maintain proceedings for the preservation, protection and recovery of estate property, and that they had therefore properly brought this Court.

18. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs adduced documentary evidence showing that the Deceased held Share Certificate No. 4456 and a Letter of Allocation dated 28th November 1982 in respect of two shares in the 1st Defendant, by virtue of which he became entitled to Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299. Counsel contended that the Deceased paid all requisite charges from 1982 onwards, that his ownership was repeatedly confirmed by the 1st Defendant's officers and surveyors, and that the Plaintiffs produced ownership documents, the plot map, and related records issued by the 1st Defendant. Counsel argued that no contrary evidence was tendered and that the Plaintiffs had established a complete chain of ownership from allocation and payment through possession and continuous recognition.

19. Counsel submitted that the Deceased had complied with all the terms and conditions of the allotment, following which the land was no longer available for allocation to a third party. Counsel relied on Rukaya Ali Mohamed v David Gikonyo Nabacha, HCCA No. 9 of 2004, to submit that, once an allotment letter has been issued and the allottee has fulfilled its conditions, the land is no longer available for allotment to another person. Counsel therefore argued that the Defendants could not lawfully allocate, transfer, subdivide, or otherwise deal with the suit properties in a manner inconsistent with the Deceased's prior rights.

20. Regarding the bonus plots, Counsel submitted that the Deceased's two shares entitled him to Bonus Plots M298B and M299B, which were subsequently referred to as L.R. Nos. 136/542 and 136/550, respectively, and that the estate's entitlement extended to all lawful benefits arising from the original allotment.

21. Regarding possession, counsel submitted that the Deceased's family took possession of the suit properties in or about 1983 and remained in continuous possession until 2016, when the Plaintiffs' mother, the last family member to occupy the properties, died. Counsel argued that possession for more than three decades was consistent only with lawful ownership and inconsistent with trespass or temporary occupation. Throughout that period, the Defendants neither revoked the allotment, refunded the monies paid, nor challenged the Deceased's rights.

22. Counsel submitted that, following the deaths of the family members in occupation, the Defendants sought to renege on the allotment, frustrated the Plaintiffs' efforts to regularise the records and obtain title, and appropriated the land for their own use. Counsel contended that the Defendants trespassed onto the land and carried out unlawful construction and destruction thereon, as evidenced by the photographs produced. Counsel argued that this conduct constituted trespass and attempted dispossession, in violation of the right to property under Article 40 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

23. Regarding the revocation of titles, Counsel submitted that any title, lease, transfer, subdivision, or third-party interest created over the suit properties contrary to the Deceased's prior allotment was null and void and ought to be cancelled. Counsel contended that equity could not permit an allotting authority to allocate land, receive payment, allow possession for decades, and thereafter repossess the land for its own benefit. Counsel argued that such conduct amounted to fraud, bad faith, unjust enrichment, and an abuse of corporate power.

24. Counsel submitted that the Defendants had been duly served but had neither entered an appearance nor filed a defence or adduced evidence. Accordingly, the Plaintiffs' evidence remained unchallenged. Counsel relied on Karuru Munyororo v Joseph Ndumia Murage & another, Nyeri HCCC No. 95 of 1988, and Shaneebal Limited v County Government of Machakos [2018] KEHC 5921 (KLR), to submit that uncontroverted and credible evidence ought to be accepted unless it is inherently incredible.

25. Regarding the burden and standard of proof, counsel relied on Sections 107, 108, and 109 of the Evidence Act to submit that the Plaintiffs had established, on a balance of probabilities, lawful allotment, payment, possession, recognition of ownership, trespass, and unlawful interference.

26. In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to grant the orders sought in the Plaint.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

27. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence on record and the Plaintiffs' submissions, the following issues arise for determination:

a. Whether the Plaintiffs have proved that the deceased was the lawful allottee of Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299; and

b. Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to the reliefs sought.

28. The Plaintiffs brought this suit as the legal administrators of the estate of the deceased, Patrick Ngugi Kimani aka Ngugi Kimani. They produced letters of administration ad litem issued to them on 3rd July 2023 in respect of the deceased’s estate, together with the deceased’s death certificate. The Court finds that the Plaintiffs have the requisite capacity to institute and prosecute this suit on behalf of the estate.

29. The record shows that the Defendants were served but failed to enter an appearance or file a defence. The suit therefore proceeded by way of formal proof.

30. It is well established that a Defendant’s failure to defend a suit does not relieve the plaintiff of the burden of proof. Section 107 of the Evidence Act provides as follows:

(1) Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.

(2) When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.

31. In Karugi & Another v Kabiya & 3 Others [1983] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that:

“The burden on the plaintiff to prove his case remains the same, though it is true that, where the matter is not defended, or, as here, validly defended, that burden may become easier to discharge.”

32. The court further observed that:

“The plaintiff has therefore to prove his case. To do so he calls evidence, such evidence before the court, the court may consider it unchallenged and proceed upon it, unless it is clear that it is intrinsically unreliable. No court will believe that the noon is actually the sun, however unchallenged that statement may be.”

33. The Plaintiffs relied on Karuru Munyororo v Joseph Ndumia Murage & another (Nyeri HCCC No. 95 of 1988) as quoted in Shaneebal Limited v County Government of Machakos [2018] KEHC 5921 (KLR), to submit that uncontroverted evidence should be accepted. In that matter, the court stated:

“The plaintiff proved on a balance of probability that she was entitled to the orders sought in the plaint and in the absence of the defendants and/or their counsel to cross-examine her on the evidence, the plaintiff’s evidence remained unchallenged and uncontroverted. It was thus credible, and it is the kind of evidence that a court of law should be able to act upon”

WHETHER THE DECEASED WAS THE LAWFUL ALLOTTEE OF ORIGINAL PLOTS NUMBERS M298 AND M299

34. The Plaintiffs contend that the deceased acquired the suit plots through his shareholding in the 1st Defendant, a land-buying company. Accordingly, the Plaintiffs were required to demonstrate that the deceased acquired the plots in accordance with the 1st Defendant's allocation process.

35. In Lucia Wambui Kariuki & Another vs Grace Wanjiru & Another [2022] eKLR, this Court considered the documentation required to prove acquisition of land through a land-buying company and stated as follows:

“It is not in dispute that the suit land originated from Githunguri Constituency Ranching Company Limited, a cooperative Company owned through membership. It incorporated Kenyans of all walks of life in the quest to acquire land, and so it was basically a land-buying company which acquired large chunks of land at the advent of Independence from the white settlers who were folding up their agricultural activities to return to their native countries. The members pay a membership fee to join and acquire shares in the company. The shareholding was critical as it was the basis of allocation of land. One would then be issued with a share certificate and various receipts for all manner of payments that was demanded for by the company. At the right time, the land would be surveyed by the land buying company and subdivided into smaller portions according to the number of its members and to cater for common utilities as and when desired by the membership. Membership was therefore denoted by the share certificate. The company would maintain a register of members indicating their details, the share certificate number, plot number and such other details as may be peculiar to the membership.

Allocation of land would be through balloting. Members would then be issued with a ballot denoting the plot number balloted for. The instruments required to process the title therefore would be the share certificate, the ballot, the payment receipts and the clearance certificate by the company informing the Land Registrar that the holder of these documents is the rightful proprietor of the land. The ballot number must agree or correspond with the land reference number as shown on the Registry Index map, which denotes the land on the ground.”

36. A person claiming land through a land-buying company is generally expected to provide a share certificate confirming membership, receipts evidencing payments made to the company, a ballot or other instrument identifying the allocated plot, and a clearance issued by the company to the Land Registrar confirming that the person is the rightful proprietor of the land.

37. In this matter, the Plaintiffs produced a Provisional Letter of Allocation dated 28th November 1982, issued by the 1st Defendant in respect of Plot Nos. M298 and M299. The allocation was expressly conditional upon payment of a Civil Engineering Fee of Kshs. 3,500/= per share. The letter also referred to a receipt for survey fees and Share Certificate No. 4456.

38. The Plaintiffs also produced receipts for survey fees and a site visit, a receipt dated 17th June 1993 for Kshs. 20/= issued in respect of a share certificate, and a record indicating that the letters of allotment for Plot Numbers M298 and M299 had been collected.

39. Further, the Plaintiffs produced a police abstract reporting the loss of share certificates in 1993, a receipt for a site visit dated 3rd April 2008, evidence of payment of Kshs. 12,000/= in respect of Bonus Plots M298B and M299B, and an annotation dated 22nd August 2018 confirming that Bonus Plots M298B and M299B correspond to L.R. No. 136/542 and L.R. No. 136/550, respectively. These documents, together with the receipt for Kshs. 20/=, relate to transactions undertaken after the deceased's death on 20th January 1989. No evidence was presented as to who undertook those transactions on behalf of the estate.

40. It is notable that Share Certificate No. 4456 was not produced. The police abstract merely records a report of loss. Although a receipt dated 17th June 1993 for Kshs. 20/= was issued in respect of a share certificate, the certificate itself was not produced. While the deceased’s membership could have been supported by evidence from the 1st Defendant’s member register, no certified copy or extract from the 1st Defendant's register of members was produced. The deceased's shareholding was therefore not established.

41. It is also important to note that the Provisional Letter of Allocation was conditional upon payment of Kshs. 3,500/= per share. No receipt or other evidence of payment was produced. The general assertion that the deceased paid all requisite charges from 1982 to date is not supported by the documents on record.

42. The Plaintiffs also failed to adduce evidence of a ballot. Unlike the bonus plots, which were confirmed to correspond to L.R. Nos. 136/542 and 136/550, there is no evidence linking Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299 to any land reference number on the Registry Index Map or identifying their locations on the ground. In any event, no clearance certificate from the 1st Defendant was produced.

43. Counsel for the Plaintiffs relied on Rukaya Ali Mohamed v David Gikonyo Nabacha (Kisumu HCCA No. 9 of 2004) to support the proposition that once an allottee has fulfilled the conditions of an allotment, the land is no longer available for allocation to another person. In this matter, the allocation was provisional and conditional, and compliance with those conditions has not been demonstrated.

44. The evidence relating to the bonus plots suggests that the 1st Defendant, at some point, recognised the deceased as a shareholder for the purposes of the bonus allocation. However, the bonus plots are not the subject of the reliefs sought, and the Plaintiffs averred that they have not been interfered with. Recognition of the deceased's entitlement to the bonus plots does not, without more, establish that the conditions attached to the provisional allocation of the original plots were met, or that Original Plots Numbers M298 and M299 correspond to the land in respect of which the Plaintiffs complain of trespass.

45. Counsel for the Plaintiffs further submitted that the deceased’s family was in possession of the suit plots from about 1983 until 2016. However, no evidence was led to establish the nature, extent or duration of that possession. In any event, possession does not, of itself, confer ownership of land allocated by a land buying company, and the Plaintiffs did not plead a claim for adverse possession.

46. Based on this material, this Court finds that the Plaintiffs have not proved, on the balance of probabilities, that the deceased was the lawful allottee of Original Plot Numbers M298 and M299, located at Ruai within the Embakasi Ranching Company Limited Settlement Scheme.

WHETHER THE PLAINTIFFS ARE ENTITLED TO THE RELIEFS SOUGHT

47. The declaration sought in prayer (a), together with the order compelling the Defendants to facilitate the processing of leases, is based on proof of the deceased's ownership of the suit plots. Having found that such ownership has not been established, prayer (a) fails.

48. As to prayer (b), which seeks a permanent injunction against the Defendants, the allegations of trespass and destruction were not supported by evidence identifying the persons responsible or linking the alleged acts to the Defendants or to the suit plots. Accordingly, prayer (b) is dismissed.

49. The Plaintiffs sought orders for the eviction of the Defendants. However, no evidence was adduced to establish that the Defendants, or any person claiming through them, occupied the suit plots. Accordingly, Prayer (c) fails.

50. Under Section 2 of the Civil Procedure Act, mesne profits are the profits that a person in wrongful possession of property actually received or might, with ordinary diligence, have received from that property, together with interest. The Plaintiffs neither proved that the Defendants were in wrongful possession nor presented evidence establishing the amount of profits or damages claimed. Accordingly, Prayer (d) is dismissed.

51. In their submissions, the Plaintiffs further sought the cancellation of any irregular titles, leases, transfers, or subdivisions affecting the suit plots. However, no such relief was sought in the Plaint. It is a well-established principle that parties are bound by their pleadings, which define the issues on which a Court may rule. Accordingly, this Court declines to consider that relief.

52. In the end, I find that the Plaintiffs have failed to prove their case on a balance of probabilities. Consequently, I find that the Plaintiffs' suit is without merit and is hereby dismissed with no orders as to cost.

RULING SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

…………………………………….

HON. T. MURIGI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Musa for the Plaintiffs

Ahmed-Court assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder