Background
Before me is the notice of motion dated 27th April, 2026 filed by the 1st defendant/applicant seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Before me is the notice of motion dated 27th April, 2026 filed by the 1st defendant/applicant seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Accordingly, the notice of motion dated 27th April, 2026 stood allowed upon the expiry of the fourteen-day period. The plaintiff/respondent’s suit is hereby struck out for being res judicata, in accordance with the consequential orders sought in the said application. The costs of the application and the suit shall be borne by the plaintiff/respondent.
Paragraph 9 →Consequently, I find that the conditional order took effect upon the expiry of the period stipulated by the court. The subsequent filing of the replying affidavit did not, without enlargement of time or variation of that order, reverse the consequences that had already accrued. In view of this finding, the application dated 27th April, 2026 stood allowed by operation of the orders issued on 9th June, 2026. It is therefore unnecessary…
Paragraph 8 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCLC CASE NO. E139 OF 2026
THE KENYA POWER AND
LIGHTING COMPANY PLC …...….…..............………PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
VERSUS
ROSEWA AGENCIES LIMITED ……........….1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
KIGWE LIMITED ……............................….2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
AND
HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL …….......................….1ST INTERESTED PARTY
DIRECTOR OF SURVEY ……..............................….2ND INTERESTED PARTY
CHIEF LANDS REGISTRAR ……........................….3RD INTERESTED PARTY
NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION …….................….4TH INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
1. Before me is the notice of motion dated 27th April, 2026 filed by the 1st defendant/applicant seeking the following orders:
a. This honourable court be pleased to strike out and dismiss the Plaintiff's suit herein for being res judicata.
b. Costs.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face, and further supported by the affidavit of Charles Kigwe Wathua sworn on even date. The 1st defendant/applicant deposed that the issues raised in the present suit were conclusively determined in Milimani ELC civil suit no. 1048 of 2014, Rosewa Agencies Limited v Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited, wherein judgment was delivered on 22nd February, 2023. Further, that the plaintiff/respondent filed an application for review which was dismissed and that the present proceedings constitute an abuse of the court process.
3. The application was opposed through the replying affidavit of Joseph Muchai an employee of the plaintiff/respondent sworn on 23rd June, 2026. The plaintiff/respondent deposed that the present suit raises distinct issues concerning the existence and enforceability of a wayleaves agreement dated 11th February, 1975 over LR. no. 11407 and its subsequent subdivisions, including LR. no. 18697/4. It was further deposed that these issues were not conclusively determined in the previous proceedings, and that this court is clothed with the requisite jurisdiction to hear and determine this suit.
4. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The plaintiff/ respondent filed its written submissions dated 9th July, 2026. The 1st defendant/applicant did not file its written submissions. Before considering the merits of the application, it is necessary to address the issue arising from the proceedings of 9th June, 2026. On the said date, this court having heard counsel for the respective parties, granted the plaintiff/ respondent fourteen (14) days within which to file and serve its replying affidavit and/or response, failing which the application would stand allowed. The court further gave directions on the filing of submissions and scheduled the ruling for 29th October, 2026.
5. The fourteen-day period expired on 23rd June, 2026. However, the plaintiff/respondent’ s replying affidavit was filed on 24th June 2026, one day outside the period prescribed by the court. While I note that there is an application filed under a certificate of urgency dated 24th July, 2026 seeking variation of the orders issued on 9th June, 2026 and enlargement of time, it is clear that there is no order extending the time within which the plaintiff/ respondent was required to comply.
6. When the matter came before this court on 19th October 2026, counsel for the 1st defendant/applicant maintained that the orders of 9th June, 2026 were self-executing and that the application had consequently stood allowed. Counsel for the plaintiff/respondent disagreed and urged the court to proceed with the ruling. The issue therefore, is whether the plaintiff/respondent’s failure to comply with the orders of 9th June, 2026 attracted the consequences expressly stipulated therein. Court orders are binding upon the parties unless varied, reviewed or set aside. While this court retains discretion under Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules to enlarge time, such discretion must be properly invoked and exercised upon sufficient grounds being demonstrated. The mere filing of a response outside the prescribed period does not constitute an extension of time.
7. The orders issued by the court on 9th June, 2026 were unequivocal. The plaintiff/respondent was required to file and serve its response within fourteen days, failing which the application would stand allowed. In fact, from these proceedings, the plaintiff/ respondent was granted sufficient time to file its response as early as 7th May, 2026 when this matter was first placed before the court. The plaintiff/respondent failed to comply within the prescribed period and has not obtained an order relieving it from the consequences of that default.
8. Consequently, I find that the conditional order took effect upon the expiry of the period stipulated by the court. The subsequent filing of the replying affidavit did not, without enlargement of time or variation of that order, reverse the consequences that had already accrued. In view of this finding, the application dated 27th April, 2026 stood allowed by operation of the orders issued on 9th June, 2026. It is therefore unnecessary to undertake extensive consideration of the merits of the application.
9. Accordingly, the notice of motion dated 27th April, 2026 stood allowed upon the expiry of the fourteen-day period. The plaintiff/respondent’s suit is hereby struck out for being res judicata, in accordance with the consequential orders sought in the said application. The costs of the application and the suit shall be borne by the plaintiff/respondent.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
29/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – Court assistant
Mr. Ododa for the Plaintiff
Mr. Agwara for the 1st Defendant