Land law

Intra Africa Assurance Company Ltd v Onuonga (Being sued as the administrator on behalf of the Estate of Peter Okinyi Okeri - Deceased) & 3 others [2026] KEELC 7189 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Christine Ochieng

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Plaintiff’s suit was dismissed with costs to the Defendant. The Defendant’s Counterclaim succeeded: the Plaintiff must transfer LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court to the Defendant as administratrix of the estate; an injunction protects her title, possession and quiet enjoyment; and declarations issued that the Interested Parties acted as the Plaintiff’s agents/worked jointly with it and that their receipt of the full purchase price was deemed receipt by the Plaintiff. Costs of the suit and Counterclaim were awarded to the Defendant, jointly against the Plaintiff and Interested Parties. The Interested Parties’ Notice of Claim succeeded only as to declarations that the Plaintiff paid no purchase consideration, was not a purchaser, and held the listed properties as security for Kin Holdings’ financial facilities; their interest and no-debt claims were not granted.

Supporting judgment passages

65. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiff has not proved its case on a balance of probability and will proceed to dismiss it with costs to the Defendant. I find that the Defendant has proved her case in the Counterclaim and will proceed to enter judgement in her favour as against the Plaintiff and Interested Parties. I further find that the Interested Parties have only proved certain claims in their Notice of Claim as against the Plaintiff. I will proceed to make the following final Orders:

Paragraph 65 →

i. An order of specific performance be and is hereby issued compelling the Plaintiff to transfer all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

Passage 156 →

vi. A declaratory order be and is hereby issued that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

Passage 165 →
Issue 1What was the relationship between the Plaintiff and Interested Parties and if the Interested Parties had authority to sell the suit house LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, to the Defendant?

Held. The Interested Parties had a relationship with the Plaintiff under which the Plaintiff held the properties as lien/security for financial facilities advanced to the Interested Parties, with sale proceeds to repay the loan. The Plaintiff knew of the sale to the deceased. The Interested Parties had the Plaintiff’s authority to sell the suit house, the deceased paid the full purchase price, and the Plaintiff was required to transfer the house to the Defendant. Any unpaid loan balance was to be pursued against the Interested Parties rather than by withholding transfer from the paid purchaser.

Ratio. Agency may be express or implied from the parties’ conduct and circumstances. The correspondence and conveyancing evidence established the relationship, security arrangement, the contemplated sale process, and the Plaintiff’s knowledge of this sale. Those facts established authority to sell and meant that the Plaintiff’s remedy for any unpaid facility was loan recovery, not refusal to transfer to the purchaser who had paid in full.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

• What was the relationship between the Plaintiff and Interested Parties and if the Interested Parties

Passage 90 →

had authority to sell the suit house LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, to the Defendant?

Passage 91 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

59. From the above excerpts alone, it is evident that there was indeed a relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties. Further, the 1st Interested Party had been a decree holder in the aforementioned High Court Suit but it seems it was granted the properties which were later transferred to the Plaintiff that paid certain amounts which IP1 explained was put there for purposes of paying stamp duty. From the correspondence produced as exhibits, it is evident the Plaintiff was holding the properties in lien for a loan extended to the Interested parties and proceeds of sale was to be used to settle the loan amount. Further, the Plaintiff was well aware of the sale of the suit house to the deceased but declined to transfer the said house to him. It is also worthnoting that PW1 admitted in evidence that he was actually interested in purchasing the said suit house.

Paragraph 59 →

60. Based on my analysis above while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the Interested Parties indeed had authority from the Plaintiff to sell the suit house to the Defendant. Further, since IP1 confirmed that the deceased paid the full purchase price, I find that the Plaintiff should indeed be ordered to effect the transfer of the suit house to the Defendant. It is my considered view that even if the Plaintiff felt that the Interested Parties had not finished repaying the monies owed to it, then the remedy was to pursue the repayment of the loan but not refuse to transfer the suit house to the Defendant who had paid the full purchase price.

Paragraph 60 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

“It is trite that an agency relationship can be created in several ways and can also be construed from the conduct of the parties. According to Halsbury’s Law of England 4th Edition Volume 1 (2) para 19 and 20 a principal agency relationship is created by the express or implied agreement of principal and agent or by ratification by the principal of the agent’s acts done on his behalf. Express agency is created where the principal or some person authorized by him, expressly appoints the agent whether by deed, by writing under hand or orally. An implied agency arises from the conduct or situation of parties.”

Passage 103 →

59. From the above excerpts alone, it is evident that there was indeed a relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties. Further, the 1st Interested Party had been a decree holder in the aforementioned High Court Suit but it seems it was granted the properties which were later transferred to the Plaintiff that paid certain amounts which IP1 explained was put there for purposes of paying stamp duty. From the correspondence produced as exhibits, it is evident the Plaintiff was holding the properties in lien for a loan extended to the Interested parties and proceeds of sale was to be used to settle the loan amount. Further, the Plaintiff was well aware of the sale of the suit house to the deceased but declined to transfer the said house to him. It is also worthnoting that PW1 admitted in evidence that he was actually interested in purchasing the said suit house.

Paragraph 59 →
Issue 2Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint.

Held. No. The Plaintiff failed to prove its case on a balance of probabilities. Its claim for an injunction, damages and related relief based on unlawful occupation was dismissed, with costs to the Defendant.

Ratio. Because the Interested Parties were authorized to sell the house and the deceased had paid the full purchase price, the Plaintiff could not treat the Defendant’s occupation as unlawful or refuse the resulting transfer. The Plaintiff’s remaining recourse, if any, lay in recovery of its loan from the Interested Parties.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

• Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint.

Passage 92 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

61. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiff is not entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint. The Defendant in her Counterclaim sought to be deemed as a bona fide purchaser for value and for specific performance. In the case of Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa& 5 others (Petition 8 (E010) of 2021) [2023] KESC 30 (KLR), the Supreme Court held that:

Paragraph 61 →

65. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiff has not proved its case on a balance of probability and will proceed to dismiss it with costs to the Defendant. I find that the Defendant has proved her case in the Counterclaim and will proceed to enter judgement in her favour as against the Plaintiff and Interested Parties. I further find that the Interested Parties have only proved certain claims in their Notice of Claim as against the Plaintiff. I will proceed to make the following final Orders:

Paragraph 65 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

60. Based on my analysis above while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the Interested Parties indeed had authority from the Plaintiff to sell the suit house to the Defendant. Further, since IP1 confirmed that the deceased paid the full purchase price, I find that the Plaintiff should indeed be ordered to effect the transfer of the suit house to the Defendant. It is my considered view that even if the Plaintiff felt that the Interested Parties had not finished repaying the monies owed to it, then the remedy was to pursue the repayment of the loan but not refuse to transfer the suit house to the Defendant who had paid the full purchase price.

Paragraph 60 →
Issue 3Whether the Defendant is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Counterclaim.

Held. Yes. The Defendant was found to be a bona fide purchaser for value and entitled to registration as owner and specific performance. The court ordered the Plaintiff to transfer the suit house to her as administratrix, permanently restrained the Plaintiff from interfering with her title, ownership, possession and quiet enjoyment, and declared that the Interested Parties were the Plaintiff’s agents or worked jointly with it in the development and sale, and that their receipt of the full consideration was deemed receipt by the Plaintiff. The Defendant received costs of the suit and Counterclaim jointly against the Plaintiff and Interested Parties.

Ratio. A bona fide purchaser for value must establish valid acquisition, necessary due diligence as to the lawful owner, and valuable consideration. On the court’s findings that the Interested Parties were authorized to sell and the deceased paid in full, the Defendant met that standard and was entitled to specific performance.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

• Whether the Defendant is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Counterclaim.

Passage 93 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

62. From my analysis above, I find that the Defendant is indeed a bona fide purchaser for value and is hence entitled to be registered as owner of the suit house. I hence find that the Defendant is indeed entitled to the Orders of specific performance as sought in the Counterclaim. On whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim. The Interested Parties as Defendants in the Counterclaim filed a Notice of Claim seeking various Orders against the Plaintiff that was also a Defendant therein. As between the 1st Interested Party (2nd Defendant in the Counterclaim) and the Plaintiff, from the evidence I have analyzed above, I find that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

Paragraph 62 →

i. An order of specific performance be and is hereby issued compelling the Plaintiff to transfer all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

Passage 156 →

v. The costs of suit and Counterclaim awarded to the Defendant to be borne by the Plaintiff and Interested Parties jointly.

Passage 161 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

“…in order to be considered a bona fide purchaser for value, they must prove; that they acquired a valid and legal title, secondly, they carried out the necessary due diligence to determine the lawful owner from whom they acquired a legitimate title and thirdly that they paid valuable consideration for the purchase of the suit property ...”

Passage 151 →

62. From my analysis above, I find that the Defendant is indeed a bona fide purchaser for value and is hence entitled to be registered as owner of the suit house. I hence find that the Defendant is indeed entitled to the Orders of specific performance as sought in the Counterclaim. On whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim. The Interested Parties as Defendants in the Counterclaim filed a Notice of Claim seeking various Orders against the Plaintiff that was also a Defendant therein. As between the 1st Interested Party (2nd Defendant in the Counterclaim) and the Plaintiff, from the evidence I have analyzed above, I find that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

Paragraph 62 →
Issue 4Whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim.

Held. Partly. The court declared that the Plaintiff paid no consideration to the 1st Interested Party for the listed properties, was not their purchaser, and that their transfer to the Plaintiff was solely to secure financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party. However, the court declined to declare that the interest charged was non-contractual, unconscionable, illegal, null or void, because the contractual interest terms were not proved; it also declined to declare that the 2nd Interested Party owed no outstanding debt, as the available statement showed Kshs.9,903,755.35 outstanding and no proof of full payment was produced.

Ratio. The evidence showed that the transfers operated as security for lending rather than purchases by the Plaintiff. But a court cannot rewrite the parties’ contract, and the Interested Parties did not provide evidence establishing agreed interest terms or full repayment of the outstanding facility.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

• Whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim.

Passage 94 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

63. From the excerpts I have reproduced above, I find that the Transfer of parcels of land known as 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 to the Plaintiff was solely and purely for purposes of securing the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party by the Plaintiff and that is the reason that there were loan statements and the Plaintiff’s Chairman kept on reminding the Interested Parties to repay the loan or else some properties would be sold. On prayer by the 2nd Interested Party (3rd Defendant in the Counterclaim) that the interest charged by the Plaintiff in respect of the financial facilities afforded to it was non-contractual, unconscionable, illegal, null and void. From the correspondence, I note the interest on the loan between Plaintiff and Interested Parties was varied from 15.5% to 18.5%. I note from the correspondence there seems to have been a disagreement on payment of the said interest.

Paragraph 63 →

However, except for the correspondence, the Interested Parties did not present in Court a document to demonstrate how the Interest was to be charged. I am hence unable to make a finding on this since there seems to have been a contract between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties, and in relying on the decision of National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & another (Civil Appeal No. 95 of 1999), as a Court I cannot interfere or rewrite the contract between them.

Paragraph 63 →

vi. A declaratory order be and is hereby issued that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

Passage 165 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

However, except for the correspondence, the Interested Parties did not present in Court a document to demonstrate how the Interest was to be charged. I am hence unable to make a finding on this since there seems to have been a contract between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties, and in relying on the decision of National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & another (Civil Appeal No. 95 of 1999), as a Court I cannot interfere or rewrite the contract between them.

Paragraph 63 →

64. Further, on the 2nd Interested Party’s claim that it does not owe the Plaintiff any outstanding financial facilities and or loan or debt, I note as per the statement for 2nd Interested Party dated 31st August, 1996, it still owed Kshs.9,903,755.35 and the Interested Parties have not presented any other documents to demonstrate that this amount was fully paid. Further, from the correspondence and loan statements, the Interested parties seemed to have been in default. In the circumstances, I am unable to make a finding that the 2nd Interested Party does not owe the Plaintiff any outstanding financial facilities and or loan or debt.

Paragraph 64 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Plaintiff commenced this suit vide a Plaint dated 10th December 2003. It contended that it is the registered owner of LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit house’. Its case is that the Defendant has unlawfully entered the suit house and continues to unlawfully remain in occupation. It prays that judgement be entered against the Defendant for:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the pleadings, testimonies of the witnesses, exhibits including written submissions and the following are the issues for determination:

Paragraph 40 →

Reasoning passage

Based on my analysis above while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the Interested Parties indeed had authority from the Plaintiff to sell the suit house to the Defendant. Further, since IP1 confirmed that the deceased paid the full purchase price, I find that the Plaintiff should indeed be ordered to effect the transfer of the suit house to the Defendant. It is my considered view that even if the Plaintiff felt…

Paragraph 60 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Interested Parties had authority, as the Plaintiff’s agents or joint actors, to sell LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court to the deceased; whether the Plaintiff was entitled to eviction-related relief; whether the Defendant was…

Material facts

The Plaintiff was the registered proprietor of the suit house and alleged that the Defendant unlawfully occupied it. The Defendant, administratrix of Peter Okinyi Okeri’s estate, said her late husband bought the house from the Interested Parties, paid the…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE N0. 181 OF 2017

INTRA AFRICA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED … PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

SUSAN MORAA ONUONG’A

Being sued as the Administrator on behalf of the estate of

PETER OKINYI OKERI (DECEASED) …………………. DEFENDANT

AND

ECCONS CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING

(K) LTD ……………...… 1ST INTERESTED PARTY/2ND DEFENDANT

KIN HOLDINGS

LIMITED …………..…. 2ND INTERESTED PARTY/3RD DEFENDANT

JOSEPH SIRO

MOSIOMA ……………. 3RD INTERESTED PARTY/4TH DEFENDANT

JUDGEMENT

1. The Plaintiff commenced this suit vide a Plaint dated 10th December 2003. It contended that it is the registered owner of LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit house’. Its case is that the Defendant has unlawfully entered the suit house and continues to unlawfully remain in occupation. It prays that judgement be entered against the Defendant for:

a) A permanent injunction restraining the Defendant whether by himself, his servants or agents from remaining and or continuing in occupation of all that parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court in Nairobi owned by the Plaintiff herein.

b) General damages.

c) Costs together with interest thereon.

d) Any further or other relief as this court may deem fit and just.

Response

2. The suit was opposed by the Defendant who filed a further amended Defence and Counterclaim dated 15th January 2019. She admitted to being in possession of the suit house since 2001 and contended that her occupation is pursuant to a purchase from the Plaintiff by her late husband, Peter Okinyi Okeri through its alleged agents, the 1st to 3rd Interested Parties.

3. In her Counterclaim, she insisted that the Plaintiff contracted its agent, the 1st Interested Party, to develop and sell all twenty-one (21) houses built on LR No. 330/843 Gitanga Hill Court, while the 2nd Interested Party was engaged in resource mobilization and the 3rd Interested party was the alleged face of the two (2) companies. Further, that the 1st to 4th Defendants in the Counterclaim jointly and severally presented LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), for sale at a consideration of kshs.5,535,000/=. She confirmed that the 1st to 3rd Interested Parties/Defendants received full consideration from her late husband, on behalf of the Plaintiff. Further, that the suit house’s value is now kshs.20 million. She also contended that the Plaintiff has purported to christen her as a tenant and to levy distress for rent and has unlawfully failed to transfer the suit house to her.

4. In the Counterclaim she sought for the Plaintiff’s suit be dismissed with costs and judgement be entered in the Counterclaim for:

a) An order of specific performance compelling the Plaintiff to transfer all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

b) A permanent injunction restraining the Plaintiff by itself, its officers, agents or servants from defeating, frustrating or otherwise interfering with the Defendant’s title, ownership, possession and quiet enjoyment of all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

c) A declaration that the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Interested Parties were/are agents of the Plaintiff or worked jointly and in concurrence with the Plaintiff in the development and sale of the subject property LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court to the Defendant.

d) A declaration that once the Interested Parties jointly and severally received the full consideration the Plaintiff was deemed to have received the same in full and final settlement of the sale/purchase price.

e) The purchase by the Defendant be and is hereby insulated to the effect that the Plaintiff’s claim be and is hereby limited to taking of accounts between the Plaintiff and the Interested parties exclusive of the Defendant without negating the contract of sale of the property LR 330/843, House Number 21, Gitanga Hill Court to the Defendant.

f) Further and or in the alternative, the Plaintiff, the Interested parties who are all Defendants in the amended counterclaim be jointly and severally ordered to compensate the Defendant commensurately to the market/current value of the subject property.

g) General damages for breach of contract on the part of the Plaintiff and Interested Party Defendants jointly and or severally.

h) Costs of the suit.

i) Any other relief deemed fit for grant by court in the interest of justice.

5. The Plaintiff filed a reply to the amended Defence and a Defence to the Counterclaim. It denied allegations levelled against it in the Plaint, reiterated ownership of the suit house and contended that it has never entered into any agency agreement either expressly and/or impliedly ratified any acts of any person claiming to be acting on its behalf in any purported sale of the suit house. On a without prejudice basis, it denied being in receipt of any consideration and being aware of such payments and averred that on 17th January 2004, Peter Okinyi Okeri-deceased did seek its consent to remain on the suit house for about four (4) or (5) months and proposed to pay a monthly rent of kshs.25,000/= during that period.

6. The 2nd to 4th Interested Parties/ Defendants filed a reply to Defence and a Defence to the Counterclaim. They contended that there is no procedure set out in the Civil Procedure Rules for a Defendant to join a party as an Interested party and to plead against such a party. Further that the further amended Defence and Counterclaim does not include a title by way of Counterclaim as required under Order 7 Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

7. They also claimed that the 1st Interested Party sued Gitanga Properties Limited in HCCC No. 1459 OF 1996 for Kshs.24,596,000/= being contract funds owned and a consent judgement was entered on 21st June, 1996 for the 1st Interested Party herein, but Gitanga properties Limited did not honour the decree and consequently, LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/843, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 were attached and vested in the 1st Interested Party. Further, that residential houses were erected thereon but they were incomplete and in order to complete them, the 1st Interested Party requested the 2nd Interested Party to obtain financial facilities from the Plaintiff, which advanced financial facilities to the 1st Interested Party and the suit properties were transferred to the Plaintiff as security on the understanding that upon completion of the houses, the 1st Interested Party would offer them for sale and thereafter, proceeds would be shared between the Plaintiff and the 1st Interested Party and that the share due to the Plaintiff would be used to repay the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party and the surplus sale proceeds would be held for the 1st Interested Party.

8. They contended that pursuant to the said understanding, the 1st Interested Party and the 3rd Interested Party exclusively sourced for purchasers who remitted their full purchase price in full, including Peter Okinyi Okeri- deceased, who paid for the suit house to the 1st Interested Party thus the Plaintiff is obligated to execute an instrument of transfer in his favour. They sought for a dismissal of the Counterclaim against them and concede that the Defendant’s Counterclaim be allowed.

9. The 1st to 3rd Interested Parties filed a Notice of Claim, relief and remedy against the Plaintiff, pursuant to Order 1 Rule 24 of the Civil Procedure Rules, seeking the following Orders against it:

a) As between the 1st Interested Party (2nd Defendant in the Counterclaim) and the Plaintiff:

i. A declaratory order that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/8261, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

ii. A declaratory order and or finding that the Plaintiff was not a purchaser and did not purchase the parcel of land known as LR no. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside 330/8261, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

iii. A declaratory order that the Transfer of parcels of land known as 330/8261, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 to the Plaintiff was solely and purely for purposes of securing the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party by the Plaintiff.

b) As between the 2nd Interested Party (3rd Defendant in the counterclaim) and the Plaintiff:

i. A declaratory order that the interest charged by the Plaintiff in respect of the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party is non-contractual, unconscionable, illegal, null and void.

ii. A declaratory order that the 2nd Interested Party does not owe the Plaintiff any outstanding financial facilities and or loan or debt.

10. The suit was heard through viva voce evidence.

Evidence of the Plaintiff

11. PW1 was Moses Murungi Kirima, the Plaintiff’s Underwriting Manager. He testified that the suit property where the said house is situated, was acquired by the Plaintiff from Gitanga Properties Limited pursuant to a Court Order in which the Registrar signed on behalf of the 1st Interested Party, who had failed to do so. Further, that in mid-2003, Peter Okinyi Okeri(deceased) unlawfully occupied the suit house, action the Plaintiff protested. It was his testimony that he had initially made a visit to Mr. Nyaoga of Mohammed & Muigai Advocates to express interest to purchase the suit house and that he was informed that he could only purchase it from the lawful owner.

12. It was his testimony that on 17th January 2004, Peter Okinyi Okeri (deceased) wrote to the Plaintiff admitting to be unlawfully in occupation of the suit house and further requested it to favour him with four or five months within which to seek alternative accommodation and it was agreed that he would pay ksh.25,000/= as rent during those months but he failed do so and this forced the Plaintiff to levy distress by attaching his motor vehicle KAM 962F, which was later released following a consent recorded on 20th July 2004. He was categorical that the 2nd Interested Party who was the developer of the suit property did not have authority to sell the suit house on the Plaintiff’s behalf. He produced documents at pages 16-24 of the Plaintiff’s list and bundle of documents dated 10th April 2018 as P. Exhibit 1-4.

13. In cross-examination, by Counsel for the Defendant, PW1 insisted that the Defendant has been illegally occupying the suit house. Further, even when presented with a loan statement indicating that the Plaintiff loaned the 2nd Interested Party, and a letter from the Plaintiff seeking confirmation of the loan balance from the 2nd Interested Party, he stated that he was not aware of the loan and insisted that the 1st and 2nd Interested Parties are strangers to the Plaintiff and that they had no contractual relationship.

14. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the Interested Parties, and when referred to correspondences between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties, he insisted that they had no relationship. Further, on reference to a letter at page 20 of the Defendant’s bundle dated 2nd June 2021, which letter is dated 8th January 2004 addressed to the 2nd Interested Party by the Plaintiff and is signed by one J. Muriuki, Chief Accountant, he admitted that the said J Muriuki was the Plaintiff’s member of staff but averred that the letter was a forgery.

15. In re-examination, PW1 confirmed that the 3rd Interested Party was a great friend of the Plaintiff’s chairman so when he needed money, the Plaintiff would loan him. He also confirmed that the Plaintiff loaned the 2nd Interested Party as per the loan statement attached by the Interested Party but averred that the said loan is not linked to the suit property. He was emphatic that there was nothing to indicate that Plaintiff was paid consideration by the Defendant.

Evidence of the Defendant

16. The 1st Defendant testified as DW1. She confirmed being the wife to the

late Peter Okinyi Okeri. It was her testimony that her late husband purchased House No. 21 on LR No. 330/843 through the 3rd Interested Party. She confirmed that they then moved into the suit house which was incomplete as it had a leaking roof, had no gate, washrooms were not in usable condition, and the wardrobes were incomplete. She claimed that her husband fixed the gate and washrooms and that the 3rd Interested Party would visit her late husband to discuss the purchase of the suit house and what payments needed to be made.

17. She stated that a few months after occupying the suit house, her late husband informed her that he received a letter stating that they had occupied the suit house illegally and requiring them to vacate within seven (7) days. It was her further testimony that later on, auctioneers took the husband’s car, Peugeot 405, KAM 962F. She claimed that after her husband’s death, she came across copies of cheques and acknowledgements of cash payments made in purchase of the suit house to the 3rd Interested Party and letters which related to the purchase, also written by the 3rd Interested Party on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Interested Parties, supporting the sale of the house to her husband and also complaining of harassment including interference from the Plaintiff. She produced documents from her list and bundle dated 1st March 2023 as D. Ex 1-24.

18. In cross-examination by Counsel for the Interested Parties, DW1 was referred to D. Exhibit 10, (letter dated 17th July 2003), from the Plaintiff to the 3rd Interested Party, discussing the sale of the suit house, D. Exhibit 11, (letter dated 25th February 2002), from the Plaintiff, introducing the 3rd Interested Party to Kenya Police Anti-corruption Unit as its marketing consultant, D. Exhibit 3, and D. Exhibit 5, confirming to the Plaintiff that her late husband had purchased the suit house. She stated that there was a relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties contrary to PW1’s evidence and insisted that her late husband paid the full purchase price to the 1st Interested party.

19. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiff, she insisted that together with her late husband, they engaged directly with the 3rd Interested Party. She confirmed that they did not conduct a search before purchasing the suit house since they knew the 3rd Interested Party was the owner as he gave them the Conveyance Agreement dated 16th August 1996 between Gitanga Properties Limited and the Plaintiff and the 1st Interested Party, which was the basis of their purchase though it does not indicate who the owner of the suit property is. She confirmed that her late husband made some payments to the 1st Interested Party and others to 3rd Interested Party.

20. She further confirmed that her late husband wrote the letter dated 17th January 2004 in which he stated that he did not own the suit house and sought for four (4) to five (5) months from the Plaintiff to seek alternative accommodation. She was also aware that her late husband made a complaint to the police in respect of the transaction with the 3rd Interested Party. It was her testimony that she still lives in the suit house and that it is not completed and has a leaking roof.

21. In re-examination, she stated that her husband wrote the letter dated 17th January 2004 (page 19 of her bundle), following harassment from the Plaintiff and after being coerced and misled that he was on the wrong. Further, that as per correspondence dated 17th July 2003 (page 33 of her bundle), the Plaintiff was aware of the sale of the suit property to her late husband as there was an arrangement between the Plaintiff and the 1st to 3rd Interested Parties with regards to the sale of the suit house.

Evidence of the Interested Party

22. The 3rd Interested Party, a director of the 1st Interested Party and

former shareholder and director of the 2nd Interested Party, which has since wound up its operations, testified as IP1. It was his testimony that the 1st Interested party sued Gitanga Properties Limited in HCCC No. 1459 OF 1996 for Kshs.24,596,000/= being contract funds owed and a consent judgement was entered on 21st June 1996 for the 1st Interested Party herein, thereby settling the matter. He explained that Gitanga properties Limited did not honour the Decree thus LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/884, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 were attached and vested in the 1st Interested party. Further, that the suit property was developed with residential houses but they were incomplete and in order to complete them, the 1st Interested Party requested the 2nd Interested Party to obtain financial facilities from the Plaintiff, which advanced financial facilities to the 1st Interested Party and the suit properties were transferred to the Plaintiff as security on the understanding that after completion of the houses, the 1st Interested Party would offer them for sale, the Plaintiff would execute instruments of transfer with the firm of messrs Mohamed & Muigai Advocates acting for the parties in the transaction. It was his testimony that thereafter, proceeds would be shared between the Plaintiff and the 1st Interested Party and that the share due to the Plaintiff would be used to repay the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party and the surplus sale proceeds would be held for the 1st Interested Party.

23. He testified that pursuant to the said understanding, the 1st and 3 Interested Parties exclusively sourced for purchasers who remitted their full purchase price, including Peter Okinyi Okeri-deceased who paid for the suit house thus the Plaintiff is obligated to execute an instrument of transfer in his favour. Further, that the said arrangement was entered into in good faith and in trust as the 3rd Interested Party was a longtime friend of Mr. T Gacheha, who was then the Chairman of the Plaintiff. He insisted that by conduct, the 1st Interested Party took responsibility of repaying the loan due from the 2nd Interested Party to the Plaintiff.

24. He explained that in breach of the said contract, the Plaintiff, intending to unjustly enrich itself, declined to sign a sale agreement in favour of the Defendant and purported to impose a non-contractual claim upon the 2nd Interested Party, yet it is estopped from reneging on its promise and agreement. He informed the Court that the Interested Parties sent a draft sale agreement to the Plaintiff for perusal and signature but it did not return the signed copy back. He pointed the Court to a letter dated 6th August 1996 from the Plaintiff addressed to Mohammed & Muigai Advocates and stated that it indicates that the nature of the transactions contemplated as between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties were clear from the word go. He produced documents in the Interested Parties’ list and bundle of documents dated 15th April 2021 and 6th May 2021 as IP EX (a) No. 1-6 and IP EX (b)7-16.

25. In cross-examination, IP1 stated that the letter of 17th March 2003, addressed to him by Mr. Muriuki, the Plaintiff’s Chief Accountant refers to the suit house thus the Plaintiff was aware of the sale and identification of purchasers and even if there is a dispute over accounts between the 1st and 2nd Interested Parties and itself, it would not negate sale to the Defendant who paid the full the purchase price for the suit house. He insisted that he had capacity to offer the suit house for sale to the Defendant as the Interested parties were the vendors.

26. He contended that the statement of accounts in the Interested parties

list and bundle of documents indicating the loan summary is testament of the relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested parties. Further, that interest payable on the loans advanced by the Plaintiff was the genesis of the dispute between the Plaintiff and the Interested parties, since they agreed on a 15.5% interest but the Plaintiff decided to charge 18.5%. He also pointed out that they sold other houses and the suit house was the last house to be sold.

27. Upon cross-examination by Counsel for the Plaintiff, IP1 confirmed that the suit property where suit house is situated, is registered to the Plaintiff pursuant to a transfer and consideration of Kshs.2.5 million which he contends was indicated on the transfer for purposes of stamp duty, adding that he disclosed the position to the Defendant. He had no document from the Plaintiff authorizing him to sell the suit house for Kshs.5.6 million and despite the Plaintiff writing to him stating that they did not authorize him to sell the suit house, he insisted that he transacted as owner not agent of the Plaintiff. He did not have the offer letter addressed to Peter Okinyi Okeri-deceased nor the sale agreement he allegedly sent to the Plaintiff for perusal and execution.

28. Upon re-examination, IP1 reiterated his evidence in chief and in cross-

examination and insisted that the letter dated 6th August 1996, confirmed his relationship with the Plaintiff.

29. Parties thereafter filed their respective written submissions.

Submissions

30. The Plaintiff submits that being the registered proprietor of the suit

house, it enjoys protection under Section 26 of the Land Registration Act. Further, that impeachment of its title was not pleaded by the Defendant and the Interested Parties. It insisted that the allegation that the suit house was transferred to the Plaintiff as security for a loan and is held in trust is neither borne by evidence nor does it detract from its registered ownership and even if there was an equitable obligation to re-transfer the suit property upon repayment of the loan, it does not invalidate its title.

31. It also submits that the Defendant’s evidence shows that her deceased husband dealt exclusively with the Interested parties thus it cannot be bound by a contract to which it was not privy. Further, that its letter of 17th July 2003 cannot be taken to confirm that the Defendant purchased the suit house from the Plaintiff and that even if the Interested Parties’ purported to act as agents of the Plaintiff, the nemo dat quod non habet principle applies and they had no capacity to pass title to the deceased.

32. It submits that vide his letter dated 17th January 2004, the deceased admitted to be in illegal occupation and was later acknowledged as a tenant but he breached the said tenancy forcing it to distress for rent and to attach his motor vehicle. It also submits that the Defendant did not undertake any due diligence when purporting to purchase the suit house thus he does not qualify as an innocent purchaser for value and her Counterclaim has no foundation as no contract existed between the Plaintiff and the deceased.

33. To buttress its averments, the Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Kariobangi Sewage Farmers Self Help Group v Nairobi City Council & 2 others [2024]KEELC 4961(KLR); Mutitu Water Project Self Help Group v Mutitu Water and Sanitation Company Limited & others HCCC No. E004 of 2023 [2025] KEHC 17023 (KLR); Sehmi & another v Tabarana Company Limited & 5 others (Petition E033 OF 2023)[2025] KESC 21 (KLR)(11 April 2025) (Judgement) and National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (k) Ltd & another [2001] eKLR.

34. The Defendant submits that the Plaintiff is not the lawful proprietor of

the suit house as it was unable to prove the root of its title. She cites the letter dated 4th April 1997, at page 9 of the Interested Parties' Bundle B dated 6th May 2021, which indicates that the Plaintiff had advanced a loan facility to the 2nd Interested Party and insists that the relationship between the Plaintiff and the 2nd Interested Party was that of lender and borrower, which is inconsistent with the Plaintiff’s contention that it had already purchased the suit property pursuant to the Conveyance dated 16th August 1996.

35. She also submits that the 3rd Interested Party was an agent of the

Plaintiff and contends that an agency relationship may arise through express appointment or by representation. Further, that the Plaintiff's letters and engagement with the 1st Interested Party is sufficient evidence of such authority particularly its letter dated 17th July 2003, in relation to the sale of the suit property thus the Plaintiff is estopped from denying the said authority.

36. She also submits that her late husband purchased the suit house which the Plaintiff acknowledged vide its letter dated 17th July 2003. She argues that the preparation of a formal Agreement for Sale by the Plaintiff's advocates is also consistent with the sale and points out that the Interested Party admitted that her late husband had paid a sum of Kshs.5.7 million in consideration thus the Plaintiff's subsequent attempt to challenge that transaction is inconsistent with its own conduct and admissions.

37. To buttress her averments, she relied on the following decisions: Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] eKLR; Freeman and Lockyer (A firm) v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) & Another [1964] 1 ALL E.R. 630, and Branwhite versus Worcester Works Finance Ltd. [1969] 1 A.C. 552 at 587.

38. On their part, the Interested Parties submit that there is no evidence that the Plaintiff paid any purchase price to the 1st Interested Party with regard to the suit property thus it was not owner of the suit property, as it was holding it as lien to secure repayment of loan facilities granted to the 2nd Interested Party. Further, that correspondences dated 6th August 1996, 8th April 1997 and 17th July 2003 respectively confirm the arrangements between the Plaintiff and themselves, in so far as the suit house is concerned, which was that the 1st Interested Party would sell the suit house but the Plaintiff would execute contracts for sale and part of the sale proceeds would be used to repay the loan due from the 2nd Interested Party to the Plaintiff thus the said contract cannot be re-written. I note the Interested Parties have made reference to LR No. 330/826 as 330/8261 but in all the documents it is indicated as 330/826 which this court will use by dint of Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act.

39. To buttress their averments, the Interested Parties relied on the decisions: John Onyancha Zurwe v Oreti Atinda [2009] KECA 315 (KLR) and Prudential Assurance Company of Kenya Limited v Jutley & another [2007] KECA 505(KLR).

Analysis and Determination

40. I have considered the pleadings, testimonies of the witnesses, exhibits including written submissions and the following are the issues for determination:

• What was the relationship between the Plaintiff and Interested Parties and if the Interested Parties

had authority to sell the suit house LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, to the Defendant?

• Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint.

• Whether the Defendant is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Counterclaim.

• Whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim.

What was the relationship between the Plaintiff and Interested Parties and if the Interested Parties had authority to sell the suit house LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, to the Defendant?

41. While it is not disputed that the Plaintiff is registered as proprietor of LR No. 330/843, House No. 21, Gitanga Hill Court, its ownership of the property is disputed by the Interested Parties who contend that they acquired several properties, including where the suit house, is situated following a Decree in HCCC No. 1459 of 1996,and that the Plaintiff financed the development of the properties, which were transferred to it, to hold in lien as security, with the understanding that after completion, the houses would be sold, with the Plaintiff's share of the proceeds being applied towards repayment of the financial facilities. The Plaintiff disputes the Interested Parties version and contends that it acquired the suit property pursuant to a Court Order in which the Deputy Registrar signed on behalf of the 1st Interested Party, who had failed to do so. The Interested Parties dispute the Plaintiff’s ownership and insist that the 1st Interested Party owns the suit property and that it transferred it to the Plaintiff, to hold it as a lien for a financial facility.

42. The Defendant is in occupation of the suit house and while the Plaintiff claims that her occupation is unlawful, she contends that her late husband purchased the property through the Interested Parties whom she alleges were acting as agents of the Plaintiff.

43. On whether the Defendant’s occupation is lawful, the Court will determine whether the Interested Parties had capacity to sell to the Defendant’s late husband, in light of the Interested Parties’ contention that they were in a lien arrangement with the Plaintiff, which was aware of and participated in the sale to Peter Okinyi Okeri-deceased, whom they confirmed paid the full purchase price. The Court will also determine whether the Plaintiff held the suit property as lien. It was stated as follows in Wais Capital Limited v Dhadho Gaddae Godhana [2019] KEELC 1618 (KLR):

“11. In this case, it is common ground that the transfer was registered until the loan amount is made in full together with interest or until the property is sold, whichever comes first. In this case, there is no evidence to show that the property was sold. In my understanding, what the agreement envisaged is that in the event of default by the defendant, the property would be sold to recover the loan. In essence, the transfer registered was primarily for security purposes and not to pass title to the plaintiff.”

44. The Plaintiff has denied having authorized the Interested Parties moreso the 3rd Interested Party, to sell the suit house, to the Defendant and contends that they were strangers and had no contractual relationship with them. The Plaintiff denies receiving the purchase price. It is worth noting that the Plaintiff never denied that the Interested Parties indeed constructed twenty-one (21) houses on LR No. 330/843 Gitanga Hill Court and sold all of them except for the suit house, which is in dispute.

45. It is trite that an agency relationship can either be implied or express.

Express agency arises where the principal expressly appoints another person to act on their behalf, whether orally or in writing, while implied agency is inferred from the conduct of the parties and the circumstances of the relationship. This is as per the definition in Mutua & another v Wainaina t/a Nellies Shuttle /Coaches [2024] KEHC 1490 (KLR), where it was stated that:

“It is trite that an agency relationship can be created in several ways and can also be construed from the conduct of the parties. According to Halsbury’s Law of England 4th Edition Volume 1 (2) para 19 and 20 a principal agency relationship is created by the express or implied agreement of principal and agent or by ratification by the principal of the agent’s acts done on his behalf. Express agency is created where the principal or some person authorized by him, expressly appoints the agent whether by deed, by writing under hand or orally. An implied agency arises from the conduct or situation of parties.”

46. In Lucy Nungari Ngigi & 4 others v National Bank of Kenya Limited & another [2015] eKLR the Court cited Bowstead and Reynolds on Agency, Seventeenth Edition, Sweet & Maxwell, Page 1-001, which defines an agency relationship to be:

“... a relationship which exists between two persons, one whom expressly or impliedly consents that the other should act on his behalf so as to affect his relations with third parties, and the other of whom similarly consents so to act or so acts.”

47. The Court of Appeal in Mayfair Holdings Ltd v Ahmed [1990] KECA 66 (KLR) Hancox CJ, with S Gachuhi and Gicheru JJ A concurring further considered the nature and creation of express and implied agency and stated as follows:

“23.I turn now to the law of agency. The general proposition is that “whatever a person who is sui juris can do personally he can also do through his agent” – per Stirling LJ in Bevan v Webb [1901] 2 Ch D 59 at p 77. The reason is set out in Story on Agency 9th Edition where the author says at the beginning: “In the expanded intercourse of modern society it is easy to perceive that the exigencies of trade and commerce, the urgent pressure of professional, official and other pursuits, the temporary existence of personal illness or infirmity, the necessity of transacting business at the same time in various remote places, and the importance of securing accuracy, skill, ability, and speed in the accomplishment of the great concerns of human life, must require the aid and the assistance and labours of many persons, in addition to the immediate superintendence of him whose rights and interests are to be directly affected by the results.24. The relationship of principal and agent can be created in many ways, for example by a verbal telephone conversation, by fax, telex or even by circumstances from which agency can be implied. The execution of power of attorney is but one of the ways in which the relationship can be so created, and if the authority of an agent is required to be conferred by deed or an instrument under seal, as where the agent is given power to execute a deed, then the necessary authority has to be conferred by a power of attorney. However, although under section 3(3) of the Contract Act, cap 23, a contract for the disposition of an interest in land must be evidenced by writing (as under its similar counterpart in the United Kingdom, section 40(1) of the Law of Property Act (1925), writing is not necessary for the appointment of an agent to sell or purchase land, so that the agency in this case (if it existed) could have been created independently of a power of attorney….26. Two further aspects of the general law relating to agency may also be stated. First that the general rule is that an agent is ordinarily neither entitled to sue nor liable to be sued on a contract made by him in a representative capacity, - per Wright J in Montgomerie v UK Mutual Steamships Association: [1891] 1 QB 370 at p 371, ….”

48. Further, in the case of Mbugua v Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd [2002] 2 EA 34 the Court of Appeal held that:

“The mere fact that a person contracts with another to carry out certain work does not, in itself, create a relationship of principal and agent. Liability cannot be imposed on one person for the acts of another unless an agency relationship is clearly established either expressly or by necessary implication."

49. The Plaintiff contends that since the deceased purchaser dealt exclusively with the Interested Parties, it was not privy to their contract and thus cannot be bound by the Interested Parties actions. It also contends that the doctrine of Nemo dat quod non habet applies. The Court of Appeal stated as follows in the case of Agricultural Finance Corporation v Lengetia Limited & Jack Mwangi [1985] KECA 58 (KLR):

“…As it stated in Halsbury’s Laws of England, 3rd Edition, Volume 8 at paragraph 110: “As a general rule a contract affects only the parties to it, and cannot be enforced by or against a person who is not a party, even if the contract is made for his benefit and purports to give him the right to sue or to make him liable upon it. The fact that a person who is a stranger to the consideration of a contract stands in such near relationship to the party from whom the consideration proceeds that he may be considered a party to the consideration does not entitle him to sue upon the contract.”

50. In this instance, I note DW1 in her evidence confirmed that her late husband paid the full purchase price for the suit house. She produced proof of payment as her exhibits. She further produced various documents that culminated in their purchasing of the suit house. IP1 also confirmed that the deceased had paid the full purchase price. The Plaintiff however insists that the Interested Parties had no instructions to sell the suit house hence the Defendant is a trespasser thereon. I note there were various correspondence between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties, which this Court will proceed to highlight certain excerpts therefrom.

51. In a letter dated the 17th July, 2003 from Mr. J Muriuki who was the Plaintiff’s Chief Accountant, addressed to the 3rd Interested Party and copied to messrs Mohammed & Muigai Advocates, he states thus:

“SALE OF LR. NO. 330/843

GITANGA ROAD, LAVINGTON

We have seen a ‘Draft’ Agreement for Sale of the subject property and we wish to raise the following points; which need your urgent clarification:

1. INITIAL OFFER

a) Your initial offer of 14th August, 2001 had the same price tag of KShgs.4,000,000.00. Why is the price the same 2 years down the line?

b) What binds us to that price when we have not received any consideration from Mr. Okeri?

2. ADDITIONAL WORKS

a) Was the KShgs.600,0000.00 for additional works paid to you?

b) If so, were the additional works as listed completed to the satisfaction of the purchaser?

c) Does it then mean that you also received the balance of KShgs.1,000,000.00 to enable you complete the additional works?

d) We will need confirmation from the purchaser on 2(a-c) above.

3. DRAFT SALE AGREEMENT

a) Page 2-3 (a) – We have not received an amount of KShgs.400,000.00 from the buyer

- so this is not a statement of fact!

b) Page 3-7 The Purchaser’s Advocates are not stated.

c) Page 3-8 – See No. 2(a-c) above

d) Page 3-9 (ii) This one is mandatory so that we are able to determine whether any outstanding rates are likely to dilute our out-lay.

e) Page 3-Special conditions – (4) – This ties up with (d) above and would definitely include Land Rent.

f) Page 4-(5) – Actual amounts must be provided; again to protect our realisable out-lay.

Kindly clear the above points with the utmost urgency to enable us complete this transaction without undue delay.

We believe you are the one who had briefed the Lawyers at the time of drafting the Sale Agreement and we are therefore, by a copy of this letter informing them of the position.”

52. As per the letter dated the 6th August, 1996 authored by the Plaintiff’s representative and addressed to its lawyers messrs Mohammed Muigai & Co. Advocates, whose subject revolved around sale of the houses on LR 330/843 where the suit house is, the author stated that:

“.. We are writing in reply to your letter Ref No. JMN/CIV/372/96 dated 5th August, 1996 and our subsequent discussion on the offer and hereby confirm our acceptance of the offer. In this connection and as explained in the course of our discussion under reference, arrangements must be made whereby the Vendor ECON Construction & Engineering Limited will take into account the debt owed to us by the associated Company KIN Holdings Limited which debt will be paid through part of the proceeds of sale. You are kindly requested therefore to go ahead and arrange for the transfers to be effected after which we shall effect payment of the amount outstanding on the account of Kin Holdings Ltd, as at 31st December..”

53. In letter dated 6th September, 1996 from the Chairman of the Plaintiff addressed to Managing Director Kin Holding Limited (2nd Interested Party), he stated that:

‘………….it is noted that the agreed purchase price for the two properties is Kshs. 5 m each which will be paid to Mohammed & Muigai Advocates. We shall then execute the transfer on receipt of the confirmation from the Advocates that they have received the sale proceeds…’

54. In another letter dated the 4th April, 1997 from the Chairman of the Plaintiff addressed to J S Mosioma Esq, he wrote that:

‘With that disbursement in place you were going to complete the works on the houses and your were going to receive the funds in a matter of days. Up to the time of writing these funds have not been received. It is, therefore, a matter of considerable regret to have to write to you and insist that the promised amount of Kshgs. 9,600,000.00 must be received immediately whether from the advocates or from whatever source. In this context we would underline the fact that unless this money is received with 14 days from the date of this letter, we might be left with no alternative but to apply recovery proceedings through direct sale of L.R. Nos 330/835; 330/843; 330/844 and 330/847. As you are no doubt aware we hold the title documents for these properties and if we are going to apply them towards settlement of the debt under reference, there is an inevitable risk that the sales might not realise the sort of prices that are currently expected from L.R. Nos 330/846 and 330/863…..’

55. Yet in a letter dated the 8th May, 1997 from the Chairman of the

Plaintiff to the firm of messrs Mohammed & Muigai Advocates, he stated that:

‘As you will no doubt recall we hold documents of title for 4 properties within the project namely, L.R Nos 330/835, 330/845, 330/844 and 330/847. What would constitute our own recovery process would mean that we shall sell these properties without any reference to Mr. Mosioma with a review to recovering the balance outstanding on the account of Kin Holding Ltd. If we are forced take that line we shall not be able to guarantee that the price of Shgs. 4.5 million currently being dealt with on L.R. No. 330/836 will necessarily be realized.’

56. I note in the pleadings and the Decree in Nairobi HCCC No. 1459 of 1996, issued on the 9th July, 1996, ECCON CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING LTD was the Plaintiff while GITANGA PROPERTIES LIMITED was the Defendant. In the said suit, the Plaintiff sought to be transferred to LR Nos. 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/843, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823. In the Decree which emanated from a Consent, it was agreed that the Defendant was to pay to the Plaintiff Kshs.24,596,000/= together with interest at the rate of 18% p.a from 17th June, 1996.

57. Later on, there were various conveyance documents in respect to the properties mentioned herein above, I wish to reproduce an excerpt from one of the Conveyance Document dated 16th August, 1996 between Gitanga Properties Limited (Vendor) and Intra Africa Assurance Company Limited (Purchaser) at page 2, it states that:

‘The vendor was ordered by a decree dated 9th May 1996 to transfer to the Plaintiff thereof (ECCON CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING LIMITED) the within written plot and others and whereas the Plaintiff is desirous to have the plot herein described transferred directly to the purchaser hereto and whereas the vendor herein has failed to transfer the said plot to the purchaser. The deputy registrar of the High Court of Kenya is herein joined for the purposes of execution.’

58. PW1 in his testimony vehemently denied that there was a relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties. He insisted that the Plaintiff owned the suit house. PW1 further claimed that the Plaintiff acquired the suit property where suit house is situated through the Court and the Deputy Registrar had to sign the Conveyance because the Interested Parties had failed to do so, but this is not the position as per the conveyances which were produced as exhibits.

59. From the above excerpts alone, it is evident that there was indeed a relationship between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties. Further, the 1st Interested Party had been a decree holder in the aforementioned High Court Suit but it seems it was granted the properties which were later transferred to the Plaintiff that paid certain amounts which IP1 explained was put there for purposes of paying stamp duty. From the correspondence produced as exhibits, it is evident the Plaintiff was holding the properties in lien for a loan extended to the Interested parties and proceeds of sale was to be used to settle the loan amount. Further, the Plaintiff was well aware of the sale of the suit house to the deceased but declined to transfer the said house to him. It is also worthnoting that PW1 admitted in evidence that he was actually interested in purchasing the said suit house.

60. Based on my analysis above while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the Interested Parties indeed had authority from the Plaintiff to sell the suit house to the Defendant. Further, since IP1 confirmed that the deceased paid the full purchase price, I find that the Plaintiff should indeed be ordered to effect the transfer of the suit house to the Defendant. It is my considered view that even if the Plaintiff felt that the Interested Parties had not finished repaying the monies owed to it, then the remedy was to pursue the repayment of the loan but not refuse to transfer the suit house to the Defendant who had paid the full purchase price.

61. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiff is not entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint. The Defendant in her Counterclaim sought to be deemed as a bona fide purchaser for value and for specific performance. In the case of Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa& 5 others (Petition 8 (E010) of 2021) [2023] KESC 30 (KLR), the Supreme Court held that:

“…in order to be considered a bona fide purchaser for value, they must prove; that they acquired a valid and legal title, secondly, they carried out the necessary due diligence to determine the lawful owner from whom they acquired a legitimate title and thirdly that they paid valuable consideration for the purchase of the suit property ...”

62. From my analysis above, I find that the Defendant is indeed a bona fide purchaser for value and is hence entitled to be registered as owner of the suit house. I hence find that the Defendant is indeed entitled to the Orders of specific performance as sought in the Counterclaim. On whether the Interested Parties are entitled to reliefs sought in their Notice of Claim. The Interested Parties as Defendants in the Counterclaim filed a Notice of Claim seeking various Orders against the Plaintiff that was also a Defendant therein. As between the 1st Interested Party (2nd Defendant in the Counterclaim) and the Plaintiff, from the evidence I have analyzed above, I find that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823. Further the Plaintiff did not tender any evidence of payment of the purchase price for these properties. Further, it did not deny that the figure in the Conveyance was put therein for purposes of payment of stamp duty.

63. From the excerpts I have reproduced above, I find that the Transfer of parcels of land known as 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 to the Plaintiff was solely and purely for purposes of securing the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party by the Plaintiff and that is the reason that there were loan statements and the Plaintiff’s Chairman kept on reminding the Interested Parties to repay the loan or else some properties would be sold. On prayer by the 2nd Interested Party (3rd Defendant in the Counterclaim) that the interest charged by the Plaintiff in respect of the financial facilities afforded to it was non-contractual, unconscionable, illegal, null and void. From the correspondence, I note the interest on the loan between Plaintiff and Interested Parties was varied from 15.5% to 18.5%. I note from the correspondence there seems to have been a disagreement on payment of the said interest. However, except for the correspondence, the Interested Parties did not present in Court a document to demonstrate how the Interest was to be charged. I am hence unable to make a finding on this since there seems to have been a contract between the Plaintiff and the Interested Parties, and in relying on the decision of National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & another (Civil Appeal No. 95 of 1999), as a Court I cannot interfere or rewrite the contract between them.

64. Further, on the 2nd Interested Party’s claim that it does not owe the Plaintiff any outstanding financial facilities and or loan or debt, I note as per the statement for 2nd Interested Party dated 31st August, 1996, it still owed Kshs.9,903,755.35 and the Interested Parties have not presented any other documents to demonstrate that this amount was fully paid. Further, from the correspondence and loan statements, the Interested parties seemed to have been in default. In the circumstances, I am unable to make a finding that the 2nd Interested Party does not owe the Plaintiff any outstanding financial facilities and or loan or debt.

65. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiff has not proved its case on a balance of probability and will proceed to dismiss it with costs to the Defendant. I find that the Defendant has proved her case in the Counterclaim and will proceed to enter judgement in her favour as against the Plaintiff and Interested Parties. I further find that the Interested Parties have only proved certain claims in their Notice of Claim as against the Plaintiff. I will proceed to make the following final Orders:

i. An order of specific performance be and is hereby issued compelling the Plaintiff to transfer all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

ii. A permanent injunction be and is hereby issued

restraining the Plaintiff by itself, its officers, agents or servants from defeating, frustrating or otherwise interfering with the Defendant’s title, ownership, possession and quiet enjoyment of all that property known as LR Number 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court, Nairobi, to the Defendant as the Administratrix on behalf of the estate of the late Peter Okinyi Okeri absolutely.

iii. A declaration be and is hereby issued that the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Interested Parties were/are agents of the Plaintiff or worked jointly and in concurrence with the Plaintiff in the development and sale of the subject property LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21), Gitanga Hill Court to the Defendant.

iv. A declaration be and is hereby issued that once the Interested Parties jointly and severally received the full consideration the Plaintiff was deemed to have received the same in full and final settlement of the sale/purchase price.

v. The costs of suit and Counterclaim awarded to the Defendant to be borne by the Plaintiff and Interested Parties jointly.

Notice of Claim

As between the 1st Interested Party (2nd Defendant in

the Counterclaim) and the Plaintiff:

vi. A declaratory order be and is hereby issued that the Plaintiff did not pay any consideration by way of purchase price or otherwise or at all to the 1st Interested Party in lieu of the transfer of the parcel of land known as LR No. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside parcels of land known as LR No’s 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

vii. A declaratory order be and is hereby issued that the Plaintiff was not a purchaser and did not purchase the parcel of land known as LR no. 330/843 (House No. 21) Gatanga Hill Court, Nairobi alongside 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823.

viii. A declaratory be and is hereby issued that the Transfer of parcels of land known as 330/826, 330/835, 330/836, 330/853, 330/844, 330/847, 330/850, 330/852 and 330/823 to the Plaintiff was solely and purely for purposes of securing the financial facilities afforded to the 2nd Interested Party by the Plaintiff.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Thiga for Plaintiff

Kwamboka and Mose for Defendant

Bundotich for Interested Parties

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder