Land law

Hirji & another v Chege [2026] KEELC 7294 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case 430 of 2008
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Mbogo C.G.

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 11th November 2025, filed by the defendant/applicant and it is expressed to be brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 94 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rule 6 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

From the above, I find the notice of motion dated 11th November, 2025 without merit and it is hereby dismissed. On account of the defendant/applicant age and medical condition, I will order each party to bear its own costs.

Paragraph 17 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. 430 OF 2008

FIROZ NURALI HIRJI...................................1ST PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

SHAROK KHER MOHAMED ALI…............…2ND PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

VERSUS

MARCELLUS LAZIMA CHEGE............................DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 11th November 2025, filed by the defendant/applicant and it is expressed to be brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 94 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rule 6 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, seeking the following orders:-

1. Spent.

2. That there be a stay of execution and enforcement of the ruling and orders of this honourable court delivered on 10th November 2025, committing the judgment debtor to civil jail, pending hearing and determination of this application inter partes.

3. Pending the hearing and determination of this application, this honourable court be pleased to extend the 7 days stay of execution granted by the honourable presiding Judge on 10th November, 2025 for a further period as the court may deem fit.

4. Pending hearing and determination of the intended review, there be a stay of execution and committal orders issued on 10th November 2025, to preserve the applicant’s liberty and right to fair hearing.

5. The honourable court be pleased to suspend the committal warrants and recall any warrants of arrest issued pursuant to the said ruling.

6. The honourable court be pleased to review, vary, or set aside the Ruling delivered on 10th November 2025, on such terms as are just.

7. Costs be in the cause.

2. The application is premised on the grounds appearing on its face and it is further supported by the affidavit of the defendant/applicant sworn on even date. The defendant/applicant deposed that this court delivered judgment against him in September 2017, pursuant to which a monetary decree was issued in favour of the plaintiffs/respondents. He deposed that following the issuance of the decree, he made substantial payments towards its satisfaction through his then advocate, Messrs A. N. Ndambiri & Company Advocates.

3. The defendant/applicant deposed that on 2nd October 2018, he remitted Kshs.5,319,345/- to his former advocate, with instructions to add Kshs.1,400,000/- allegedly held on his behalf and remit the resulting amount to the decree holders in satisfaction of the outstanding judgment debt. Further, that the said advocate failed to remit the monies as instructed, thereby exposing him to execution proceedings notwithstanding his efforts to satisfy the decree. He deposed that upon discovering the alleged non-remittance, he lodged complaints with the directorate of criminal investigations and the advocates complaints commission, seeking investigations into the alleged misappropriation of funds by his former advocate.

4. The defendant/applicant further deposed that the default in satisfying the decree was neither deliberate nor attributable to an unwillingness to pay, but rather to the alleged failure of his former advocate to account for and remit the funds entrusted to him. He deposed that he is aged 74 years and suffers from chronic medical conditions, including hypertension, diabetes mellitus and arthritis, for which he requires regular medical attention and medication. He deposed that the order issued on 10th November, 2025, directing his re-arrest and committal to civil jail for one month, would expose him to serious medical complications and constitute a disproportionate interference with his constitutional rights to dignity, liberty and health.

5. Further, that on 10th November 2025, the court granted a temporary stay of execution for seven days, thereby affording him an opportunity to make the present application. In support of the application, the defendant/applicant annexed among other documents, copies of the judgment and decree, remittance records, correspondence relating to the alleged payments, complaints lodged with investigative and professional regulatory bodies, and medical records concerning his health.

6. The plaintiffs/respondents opposed the application through grounds of opposition dated 23rd November 2025, challenging the same on the following grounds:-

1. That the firm of Khaminwa & Khaminwa is a stranger to these proceedings and has no standing to address the court.

2. That the applicant/judgment debtor is a contemnor who has failed and or refused to obey the orders of the court and particularly the orders of Tuesday, the 28th of October, 2025 that required him, inter-alia, to lodge into court a full account of all the payments allegedly made by the judgment debtor to the plaintiff/judgment creditor within 7 days from that date, that is to say, by the 4th October, 2025 and as such, he ought not have any audience before this honorable court until such time as he has purged himself of such contempt, obeyed all the court’s orders and submitted himself to the authority of this honorable court.

3. That in the circumstances, the application is misconceived and is bad in law.

4. There is no legal basis upon which the court may make any of the orders prayed for in the said application.

5. The said application is made mala fides.

6. The said application is made to circumvent and defeat the cause of justice and to make the court act in vain.

7. That the plaintiff/applicant’s application has no merit and should be dismissed with costs.

7. The plaintiffs/respondents also filed the replying affidavit, dated 9th July 2026, purportedly sworn by Aisha Taib, Advocate. Section 5 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act, Cap 15, provides for the particulars to be stated by a commissioner for oaths in the jurat or attestation of an affidavit, including the place and date upon which the oath is taken. The requirements concerning the administration and authentication of oaths are substantive. The signature of the deponent, standing alone, does not convert an ordinary statement into an affidavit. This affidavit does not disclose that the deponent appeared before a person authorized to administer oaths or that an oath was administered in accordance with the law.

8. The absence of any authentication by a commissioner for oaths is not merely a typographical error or an inconsequential procedural irregularity. It concerns the fundamental requirement that the statement be sworn or affirmed before an authorized officer. Accordingly, the purported replying affidavit dated 9th July, 2026 is hereby struck out and expunged from the record.

9. The application was canvassed through written submissions. By the time of writing this ruling, neither of the parties had filed their written submissions. Be that as it may, I have considered the application and the grounds of opposition. The issues for determination are as follows:-

i. Whether the defendant/applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds for review, variation or setting aside of the orders issued on 10th November, 2025.

ii. Whether the defendant/applicant has established a basis for stay of execution and suspension of the committal warrants.

iii. Who should bear the costs of the application.

10. On the first issue, the defendant/applicant seeks the intervention of this court on the ground that he had made substantial payments towards satisfaction of the decree through his former advocate, who allegedly failed to remit the monies to the decree holders. He further relied on his advanced age, medical condition and the potential consequences of committal to civil jail as circumstances warranting the exercise of the court’s discretion. The jurisdiction to review a judgment or order is governed by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

11. Under Order 45 Rule 1, review may be granted on account of discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant’s knowledge or could not be produced at the time the order was made, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason. In this case, none of the grounds espoused under Order 45 Rule 1 have been pleaded in particular to support the prayers for review and/or setting aside the orders. While the remittance records are proof that part of the decretal amounts were remitted, there is a separate issue as to whether the plaintiffs/respondents received these payments in satisfaction of the decree. I am also mindful that the defendant/applicant has not demonstrated that the alleged payments were newly discovered after the ruling of 10th November, 2025. On the contrary, the payments are said to have been made in 2018, several years before the impugned ruling. Also, the material before this court indicates that the issue concerning payment to the former advocate had previously been raised in the execution proceedings.

12. On the second issue, the power to enforce monetary decree through arrest and detention in prison is provided for under Section 38 of the Civil Procedure Act, subject to the conditions prescribed therein and the applicable provisions of Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The proviso to Section 38 requires the court, before ordering detention in prison in execution of a decree for payment of money, to afford the judgment debtor an opportunity to show cause and to record its reasons for being satisfied that one or more of the prescribed statutory grounds have been established. These grounds include circumstances demonstrating that the judgment debtor is likely to abscond or leave the jurisdiction with the object of obstructing execution, has dishonestly dealt with property, or has or has had the means to pay the decretal amount or a substantial part thereof and has refused or neglected to do so.

13. This provision makes it clear that civil jail is not intended to punish a judgment debtor merely because a decree remains unsatisfied. The court must establish the existence of a lawful basis for detention. The defendant/ applicant has exhibited medical records and maintains that he is 74 years old and suffers from hypertension, diabetes mellitus and arthritis. These circumstances are in my view relevant to the exercise of judicial discretion, particularly where the contemplated mode of execution would involve deprivation of liberty. However, the defendant/ applicant’s age and medical condition do not automatically extinguish his liability under the decree or confer immunity from execution. Article 28 of the Constitution guarantees the right to inherent dignity, while Article 29 protects the right to freedom and security of the person. These rights require the court to ensure that any deprivation of liberty is lawful and proportionate.

14. The court must also consider the right of the decree holders to enjoy the fruits of their judgment. A successful litigant should not be indefinitely prevented from enforcing a valid decree merely because the judgment debtor has raised a dispute with a third party concerning funds allegedly entrusted to that third party. Having examined the application, I note that the defendant/applicant’s principal complaint is that the court failed to give sufficient consideration to the payments allegedly made through his former advocate and the implications of his medical condition.

15. However, the material placed before this court does not establish that the impugned ruling failed to consider the defendant/applicant’s representations or that the court omitted to undertake the statutory inquiry required under Section 38 of the Civil Procedure Act. Neither has the defendant/applicant demonstrated that he was denied an opportunity to show cause before the committal order was issued. In any case, he was indulged by the court on several occasions and together with his surety, they did not attend court.

16. On the material presently before me, I am not satisfied that a sufficient basis has been established for setting aside the impugned ruling. I am equally not persuaded that the defendant/applicant has demonstrated a proper basis for an indefinite stay of execution pending an intended review which has not been separately presented for determination. The defendant/ applicant has invoked Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules which governs stay of execution pending appeal and requires an applicant to demonstrate substantial loss, absence of unreasonable delay and provision of security as ordered by the court.

17. From the above, I find the notice of motion dated 11th November, 2025 without merit and it is hereby dismissed. On account of the defendant/applicant age and medical condition, I will order each party to bear its own costs.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT

THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

29/10/2026.

In the presence of:-

Mr. Benson Agunga – Court assistant

Ms. Aisha Taib for the Plaintiff/Respondent

No appearance for the Defendant/Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder