Background
What is before Court for determination are two pending applications.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before Court for determination are two pending applications.
Paragraph 1 →In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiffs have not established a prima facie case to warrant the orders of interlocutory injunction as sought as the sale of the suit property already took place. In relying on the decision of Nguruman Limited V Jan Bonde Nielsen (2014) eKLR, I will not deal with the two other limbs on injunction.
Paragraph 27 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L CASE NO. E281 OF 2025
NANCY WANJA GATABAKI .................................. 1ST PLAINTIFF
ESTHER SUSAN WANGARI GATABAKI .............. 2ND PLAINTIFF
JOSEPHINE BEATRICE GATHONI ...................... 3RD PLAINTIFF
Suing in their Capacity as the Personal Representatives of the Estate
of the Late DR. SAMUEL MUNDATI GATABAKI, (DECEASED)
VERSUS
CLASSIX AT FOURWAYS LTD ........................... 1ST DEFENDANT
LYNX AT FOURWAYS LTD ............................... 2ND DEFENDANT
WATTS AUCTIONS ........................................... 3RD DEFENDANT
ACCESS BANK KENYA LIMITED ...................... 4TH DEFENDANT
THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR ........................ 5TH DEFENDANT
THE DIRECTOR OF SURVEYS .......................... 6TH DEFENDANT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL .............................. 7TH DEFENDANT
RULING
1. What is before Court for determination are two pending applications.
Notice of Motion dated 9th June 2025
2. It is filed by the Plaintiffs who seek the following Orders:
a) Spent.
b) That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, an order of an injunction to issue restraining the Defendants jointly and/or severally from alienating, further advertising for sale, offering for sale, selling, taking possession of, leasing, transferring, charging or otherwise in any manner whatsoever interfering with all that parcel of land known as No LR. 28223/33/T5.A.
c) Spent.
d) Spent.
e) That this Honourable Court issues further directions as to the Applicant’s subsequent conduct in these proceedings.
f) That the costs of this application be in cause.
3. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the 1st Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. She avers that she is the lawful registered proprietor of L.R 5980 and L.R No. 4508/1 vide purchase from Alexander Lowis and Patricia Lowis vide the Deed of Indenture dated 22nd April 1971. Further, that without her authority, L.R. No. 5980 was, vide the survey plan F/R 185/71, subdivided to create L.R Nos. 5980/1, 5980/2, 5980/3, and 5980/4, with L.R No 5980/1 being earmarked to be surrendered to the government free of costs as a public utility and L.R No. 5980/2, for construction of the Northern Bypass Road, while L.R 5980/3 and L.R 5980/4 were for registration of titles.
4. She claims that the 1st Defendant, in cahoots with the 5th and 6th Defendants, illegally amalgamated the public utility plot L.R No. 5980/1 with L.R 5No 5980/3 and LR 4508/1 to create a new title, LR No. 28223 and multiple other subsequent subdivisions which include the suit property, LR. 28223/33/T5A. Further, that about 26th May 2025, the 3rd Defendant, under the instructions of the 4th Defendant, caused to be published in a local daily, an advert bespeaking the sale of LR No. 28223/33/T5A (L.R No. 182814) by way of public auction, in an attempt to “sanitize” the illegally acquired property and the preceding and subsequent titles emanating from the illegal amalgamation of the public utility Land Reference 5980/1 with private properties Land Reference Numbers 5980/3 and 4508/1.
Response
5. The 4th Defendant filed a Notice of Preliminary Objection in opposition. It contends that the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs lack locus standi to institute/maintain the instant proceedings as they have not obtained a Grant of Letters of Administration in respect of the estate of the late Dr. Samuel Mundati Gatabaki, contrary to Section 82 (a) of the Law of Succession Act. Further, that in the absence of a duly confirmed Grant, the suit is void and ought to be struck out with costs.
6. The 4th Defendant also filed Grounds of Opposition in response. It avers that the Plaintiffs are strangers to the charge instruments and the suit property which is duly registered in the name of the 1st Defendant is lawfully charged to it. Further, that the issues raised herein have been previously litigated upon and determined in Nairobi HCCOMM No. E052 OF 2020 (Lucy Wangari Kamau & others v Muga Developers & others) where the Court declined to grant injunctive relief over the same property. It also contends that the application is calculated solely to delay the 4th Defendant’s lawful exercise of its statutory power of sale.
7. The 4th Defendant also filed a replying affidavit sworn by Elisha
Nyikuli head of Legal & Company Secretariat at the 4th Defendant. He avers that about January 2025, the 4th Defendant acceded to the 2nd Defendant’s request and agreed to advance to it a loan facility in the nature of Financial Guarantee of Kshs.100 million, which was secured by a second further charge for Kshs.32,500,000/= over LR No. 8272/69, Spring Valley, and a first legal charge for Kshs.67,500,000/= over Unit of Land T-5A LR No. 28223/33 and that it conducted a search prior, which indicated that the 1st Defendant is the registered proprietor of the suit property, thus the Plaintiffs are strangers in the suit.
8. He points out that, in a separate suit before this Court Kagambi & 21 Others V Gatabaki (Environment and Land Case Civil Suit E012 OF 2022) [2025] KEELC 6922 (KLR) (14 OCTOBER 2025) (Judgment), this Honourable Court directed the 1st Plaintiff herein to execute the transfer of a number of properties borne out of LR. 28223 hence the Plaintiffs cannot purport not be aware of the existence of the suit property.
9. He contends that in breach of the loan agreement, the 2nd Defendant neglected to repay the said facility and fell in arrears. The 4th Defendant issued necessary notices and upon lapse, it tried to dispose of the charged property for sale by way of public auction on two occasions, on 12th June, 2025 and 14th August, 2025 but both auctions were unsuccessful. He avers that once a property is given as security, it becomes a commodity for sale in case of default and in any case, the Plaintiffs have not satisfied the test for the grant of injunction.
10. He points out that having tried to dispose of the suit property without success, the 4th Defendant proceeded and filed an application pursuant to Section 104 of the Land Act, being NAIROBI HCCOMM NO. E052 OF 2020 Lucy Wangari Kamau & Others v Muga Developers & Others wherein in a Ruling delivered on 13th August, 2020, the Court dismissed an application seeking injunctive orders affirming the 4th Defendant’s right to exercise its statutory power of sale to recover the outstanding loan, and on 1st December 2025, Hon. Justice J.W.W Mongare delivered a Ruling allowing the 4th Defendant to dispose of the suit property at the best reasonable obtainable price below the forced sale value of Kshs.105 million.
11. The 1st Plaintiff filed a replying affidavit in reply to the 4th Defendant’s Preliminary Objection and Grounds of Opposition. She avers that the Plaintiffs have capacity to file the suit, established by a valid Grant, having been duly appointed legal representatives by a Grant of Letters of Administration Intestate issued on 13th January 2021 in Kiambu Succession Cause No. 24 of 2020, In the Matter of the Estate of Samuel Mundati Gatabaki (Deceased). Further, that the causes and reliefs herein and in Commercial and Tax Division Civil Suit No. E052 of 2020 materially differ thus res judicata is inapplicable.
Notice of Motion dated 16th June 2025
12. It is filed by the Plaintiffs who seek the following Orders:
a) Spent.
b) That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, leave be granted to the Applicants/Plaintiffs for the amendment of the plaint dated 9th June 2025 in terms of the draft plaint filed herewith and for the amended plaint to be deemed to be duly filed with leave subject to payment of the requisite filing fees.
c) That upon granting prayer one (1) above, pending the determination of this suit, this court be pleased to make an order consolidating this suit with Milimani ELC Suit No. E075 OF 2023 Nancy Wanja Gatabaki vs Sanyi Jituan Investment Limited and another for joint disposal.
d) Costs of this application be provided for.
13. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the 1st Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. She avers that the Plaintiffs filed the suit vide the plaint dated 9th June 2025 and a Notice of Motion of even date seeking conservatory reliefs over LR 28223/33/T5A, which had been advertised in a local daily newspaper on 26th May 2025 to be disposed of by way of public auction on 12th June 2025. Further, that since the projected sale proceeded, it is imperative that leave be granted to amend pleadings to crystallize the issues of proprietorship and procedural illegalities surrounding the suit property, which she maintains arises from an excision of LR 28223/33 and is a product of wanton fraud.
14. She also contends that the issues herein have been raised in Milimani ELC Suit No. E075 OF 2023 Nancy Wanja Gatabaki v Sanyu Jituan Investment Limited and another and the prayers sought in both suits are similar, and include the cancellation of LR No. 28223/33 and all subsequent subdivisions thereof, including LR 28223/33/T5A thus it is fair and equitable that this suit be consolidated for joint disposal.
15. The two applications were canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
16. The Plaintiffs submit they have a valid Grant and locus standi to institute the suit. Further, that they have met the threshold for grant of injunctions having raised issues whether L.R. No. 5980/1 was surrendered as public utility land and whether it could be amalgamated into private land and whether L.R. No. 28223/33 and L.R. No. 28223/33/T5A are valid derivative titles. Further, that land is unique, and the injury arising from its sale cannot be compensated and the balance of convenience favours preservation, adding that even if the Court were to take the position that the auction date referenced has passed, that would not extinguish the need for preservation.
17. On amendments sought, they submit that their amendments are aimed at enabling the Court to determine the real question in controversy. On consolidation, they insist that ELC No. E075 of 2023 and this suit substantially overlap in factual matrix, title history, and legal questions thus consolidation would serve the overriding objective.
18. The 4th Defendant concedes that the Plaintiffs’ Grant appears valid and predates the suit, but avers that their failure to properly exhibit it necessitated the Preliminary Objection thus they should pay costs. Further, that the Plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate any legally recognizable proprietary or contractual interest affected by its exercise of its statutory power of sale as the suit property was registered in the name of the 1st Defendant at the time of creation of the charge thus there are strangers and have not established a prima facie case. Further, that having participated in and benefited from transactions founded upon subdivisions arising from L.R. No. 29223, the Plaintiffs cannot now seek to disown the very process from which they previously derived benefits.
19. It also submits that it has already exercised its statutory power of sale and the suit property has already been sold through a public auction process and under Section 99 of the Land Act, the rights of a purchaser acquiring property through a statutory sale are protected.
20. On consolidation, it submits that the present suit raises issues of banking law, securities realization, statutory notices, auction procedures and the rights of chargees and purchasers while ELC No. E075 of 2023 principally concerns allegations of historical fraud, unlawful subdivision, irregular registration of titles and the legality of the processes through which various parcels of land were created and transferred, which are fundamentally different from those arising in the present proceedings.
21. To buttress its averments, the 4th Defendant relied on the following decisions: John Njue Nyaga v Nicholas Njiru Nyaga & Another [2013] eKLR; Andrew Ouko v Kenya Commercial Bank & 3 Others [2005] eKLR; English Case of Films Rover International Vs. Cannon Films Sales Ltd (1986) 3 All ER 77; Royal Gardens Hospital v Ebrahim Omenyi Ambwere & Another [2018] eKLR; Law Society of Kenya v Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 others [2014] KESC 29 (KLR), and Nyati Security Guards & Services Limited v Municipal Council of Mombasa [2004] KEHC 1896 (KLR).
Analysis and Determination
22. I have considered the two instant Notice of Motion applications, Notice of Preliminary Objection, respective affidavits including rival submissions and the following are the issues for determination:
a) Whether the Plaintiffs have met the threshold for grant of interlocutory injunction sought.
b) Whether the amendments sought by the Plaintiff are justified.
c) Whether this suit should be consolidated with Milimani ELC Suit No. E075 OF 2023.
23. The Plaintiffs contend that the suit property, L.R. No. 28223/33/T5A. is derived from amalgamation of a public utility land, its private property and that its sale by the 4th Defendant would sanitize the unlawful transaction. They therefore seek an interlocutory injunction to preserve the suit property, leave to amend their plaint, and consolidation of this suit with ELC No. E075 of 2023, which they allege raises substantially similar questions concerning the validity of L.R. No. 28223/33 and its derivative titles.
24. The 4th Defendant’s case is that the suit property was duly registered in
the 1st Defendant’s name and lawfully charged to it as security for a financial facility advanced to the 2nd Defendant and that following default in repayment, it issued the requisite statutory notices and lawfully exercised its statutory power of sale.
25. On whether the Plaintiffs have met the threshold for grant of injunctions sought. In line with the principles on injunctions as stated in Giella vs Cassman Brown & Company Ltd (1973) EA 358, I will decipher if the Plaintiffs have established a prima facie case to warrant an order of interlocutory injunction. It is not in dispute that the suit property is charged to the 4th Defendant to secure loan advanced to the 2nd Defendant. The Plaintiffs allege fraud and insist that the suit property was wrongly amalgamated with public land and charged. However, the 4th Defendant insists it holds a legal charge, had issued statutory notices and the said property was scheduled for sale. It is trite that once a property is given as security to secure a financial facility, it becomes a commodity for sale in case of default. I note the 4th Defendant confirms the suit property has since been sold.
26. Further, the Plaintiffs did not deny that the High Court dismissed an application seeking injunctive orders affirming the 4th Defendant’s right to exercise its statutory power of sale to recover the outstanding loan, and on 1st December 2025, the Court allowed the 4th Defendant to dispose of the suit property at the best reasonable obtainable price below the forced sale value of Kshs.105 million.
27. In the foregoing, I find that the Plaintiffs have not established a prima facie case to warrant the orders of interlocutory injunction as sought as the sale of the suit property already took place. In relying on the decision of Nguruman Limited V Jan Bonde Nielsen (2014) eKLR, I will not deal with the two other limbs on injunction.
28. As to whether the amendments sought by the Plaintiff are justified. I wish to make reference to Order 8 Rule 5 (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides as follows:
“(1) For purposes of determining the real question in controversy between the parties, or of correcting any defector error in any proceedings, the court may either of its own motion or on the application of any party order any document to be amended in such manner as it directs and on such terms as to costs or otherwise as are just.”
29. In Tarmohamed v Mariakani Holdings Limited & another
[2022] KECA 122 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated that:
“….rules that apply to amendment of pleadings will apply, namely that amendments should be liberally allowed, if they can be made without injustice to the other side, or where such injustice can be compensated by costs.”
30. It is trite that the purpose of amendment is to “determine the real question or issue raised by or depending on the proceeding” and it can be done “at any time” which means from the time the suit is filed upto finalization. I note this suit has not been set down for hearing and the Defendants have not indicated what prejudice they stand to suffer if the amendments are allowed. In the foregoing, I find that the amendment sought is merited and will allow it.
31. On whether this suit should be consolidated with Milimani ELC Suit No. E075 OF 2023. On consolidation, the Supreme Court stated as follows in Omoke v Kenyatta & 83 others (Petition 11 (E015) of 2021) [2021] KESC 27 (KLR):
“Consolidation of suits or appeals will be ordered where there are common questions of either law or fact in two or more suits or appeals and where it is desirable that all the related matters be disposed of at the same time.”
32. I note the fulcrum of the present suit revolves around issues of banking
law, securities realization, statutory notices, auction procedures and the rights of chargees and purchasers. Further, I note in ELC No. E075 of 2023 the fulcrum of the dispute revolves around allegations of historical fraud, unlawful subdivision, irregular registration of titles and the legality of the processes through which various parcels of land were created and transferred. It is my considered view that the two suits sought to be consolidated are fundamentally different from those arising in the present proceedings. In the foregoing, I will decline to allow the application for consolidation but direct that the matters proceed simultaneously.
33. In the circumstances, I find the Plaintiffs’ Notice of Motion application dated 9th June 2025 unmerited and will disallow it. I find the 4th Defendant’s Notice of Preliminary Objection unmerited and will disallow it. I further find the Plaintiffs’ Notice of Motion application dated 16th June 2025 partially successful in terms of prayer (b) only but the rest of the prayers are declined.
34. I proceed to make the following final Orders:
i. That leave be and is hereby granted to the Plaintiffs to file and serve an amended Plaint within fourteen (14)
days from the date hereof.
ii. Upon service, Defendants to file and serve their respective amended Defences in fourteen (14) days.
iii. Each party to bear their own costs.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Ndambiri for Plaintiff/Applicant
Gitau for 4th Defendant
Court Assistant: Joan