Background
The petitioner filed the amended petition dated 10th November, 2025 seeking the following prayers:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The petitioner filed the amended petition dated 10th November, 2025 seeking the following prayers:-
Paragraph 1 →I have considered the amended petition, the replies thereof, the written submissions and authorities relied upon by counsel. The issues for determination are as follows:-
Paragraph 23 →I find that the evidence establishes the existence of excessive nocturnal noise within the affected neighbourhood during the periods assessed. What has not been established with sufficient precision is the individual contribution of each of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents to the recorded exceedances. Whereas Article 70(3) dispenses with the requirement to establish personal loss or injury when seeking enforcement of environmental…
Paragraph 28 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCLPET. NO. E012 OF 2024
IN THE MATTER OF: THE ALLEGED VIOLATION OF THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS UNDER ARTICLE 42(1) & ARTICLE 70 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: RULES 3&17 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA(PROTECTION OF RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS AND ENFORCEMENT OF THE CONSTITUTION) PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE RULES 2012 AND ALL OTHER ENABLING POWERS AND PROVISIONS OF THE LAW
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: THE ENVIRONMENT AND MANAGEMENT COORDINATION (NOISE AND VIBRATION POLLUTION) (CONTROL) REGULATION 2009
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: THE NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ALCOHOLIC DRINKS CONTROL AND LICENSING ACT, 2014
BETWEEN
EXETER PEARL APARTMENTS
MANAGEMENT LIMITED……………..............……………………………..PETITIONER
VERSUS
BAR NEXT DOOR VENTURES LIMITED
T/A THE BAR NEXT DOOR BAR AND GRILL………...…….……..1ST RESPONDENT
THE KETTLE HOUSE BAR
AND GRILL LIMITED ...........................................................2ND RESPONDENT
SAMAKI SAMAKI SEAFOOD AND JAZZ ...............................3RD RESPONDENT
DIRECTOR OF ENVIRONMENT,
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT..............................4TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT
MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY(NEMA)...................................5TH RESPONDENT
THE CHAIRPERSON,
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ALCOHOLIC
DRINKS CONTROL AND LICENSING BOARD.......................6TH RESPONDENT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT...............................7TH RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner filed the amended petition dated 10th November, 2025 seeking the following prayers:-
1. A declaration that the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents continued operation of business within the petitioner’s area of residence in contravention of the Environmental Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations 2009 L.N No. 61 of 2009 is a violation of the petitioner’s rights to life and right to a clean and healthy environment as contemplated by Article 26 (1) and Article 42(1) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 respectively.
2. A declaration that the issuance of business permits and liquor licenses to the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents’ by the 6th and 7th thereby allowing them to operate their businesses in the manner complained of by the petitioners is unlawful/illegal.
3. A declaration that issuance of licenses and permits to businesses or establishments as the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents within residential areas by the 6th and 7th respondents is a violation to the petitioner’s rights to a clean and healthy environment.
4. A mandatory injunction against the 1st, 2nd, 3rd respondents’, their agents and/or servants compelling them to comply within 30 days and thereafter with the first Schedule of the Environmental Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations 2009 on maintaining noise level 35 decibels at night and 45 decibels day time or whichever.
5. A mandatory injunction against the 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th respondents compelling them to revoke all liquor licenses issued to the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents if non-compliant with the Environmental Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations 2009 L.N No. 61 of 2009 within 30 days and thereafter.
6. A permanent injunction restraining the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents, their agents and/or servants from carrying out their businesses in the subject residential areas without complying with the Environmental Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations 2009 L.N No 61 of 2009.
7. That the OCS Kileleshwa Police station do ensure compliance with the above orders.
8. The Petitioner be awarded costs of the petition.
9. Any other or further relief this Court may deem fit to grant.
2. The facts of the amended petition is that the petitioner is responsible for the management and operation of residential apartments situated along Othaya Road in Kileleshwa, which are situated in close proximity to entertainment establishments operated by the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents. The 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents operate nightclubs, lounges and entertainment establishments whose principal activities include the sale of alcoholic drinks and playing loud music. It is alleged that the establishments operate during peak business hours, particularly on Fridays and weekends, from approximately 6.00 p.m. until between 6.00 a.m. and 7.00 a.m. the following morning.
3. The petitioner contends that the respondents continuously play excessively loud music, particularly during nighttime hours, thereby disturbing the residents’ sleep, comfort, repose and peaceful enjoyment of their homes. It is further alleged that the noise emanates not only from amplified music but also from patrons engaging in loud conversations, shouting and screaming, as well as motor vehicles hooting, revving engines and moving at high speeds.
4. The petitioner stated that the persistent noise and vibrations have adversely affected the residents’ health, safety and general well-being. Further, that children and elderly residents are particularly affected and that the disturbances have interfered with the residents’ ability to obtain adequate rest and sleep. The petitioner further alleges that some residents have been compelled to spend nights away from their homes, while others have relocated altogether, thereby affecting property values and the ability to attract new tenants. In addition, the establishments attract unfamiliar patrons whose presence poses security concerns to the residents. Further, that inadequate parking and traffic-control measures have resulted in congestion and disorder within the residential neighbourhood, further interfering with the residents’ peaceful enjoyment of their premises.
5. It is the petitioner’s case that despite the establishments being situated within a residential neighbourhood, the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents have failed or refused to implement adequate measures to mitigate noise pollution, including effective soundproofing and compliance with the permissible noise levels prescribed under the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations, 2009.
6. The petitioner stated that it has on numerous occasions raised complaints with the management of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents concerning the noise disturbances and requested that appropriate soundproofing and mitigation measures be undertaken. According to the petitioner, these efforts have not yielded any meaningful results, and that the establishments have continued operating in a manner that interferes with the residents' rights. While reports were made to the 4th to 7th respondents, the said authorities failed or neglected to take appropriate enforcement measures, including investigations, assessment of noise levels and enforcement of compliance with the applicable environmental standards.
7. The petitioner particularly faults the 6th and 7th respondents for issuing business permits and liquor licenses to the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents, thereby permitting entertainment establishments to operate within a residential neighbourhood despite the alleged noise disturbances. It maintained that the continued licensing and operation of the establishments without effective enforcement of noise-control measures has contributed to the infringement of the residents' environmental rights.
8. The petitioner further contends that the continued operation of the establishments, coupled with the alleged failure by the regulatory authorities to intervene, amounts to a violation of the residents’ constitutional rights, particularly the right to life under Article 26(1) and the right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42 of the Constitution. It consequently seeks the intervention of the court to restrain the continued emission of excessive noise and compel compliance with the applicable environmental laws.
9. The amended petition is supported by the affidavit of Stephen Abimbola, the director of the petitioner sworn on even date, together with the further affidavit sworn on 13th February, 2026. While reiterating the facts of the amended petition, the petitioner relied on noise measurements, photographs and environmental assessment reports, including a noise levels assessment report prepared by Aeroscan Labs Limited following measurements undertaken between 15th and 17th November, 2024. In the further affidavit sworn on 13th February 2026, the petitioner challenged the 2nd respondent’s supplementary affidavit and its expert report dated 17th January, 2026. The petitioner deposed that the measurements commissioned by the 2nd respondent do not adequately represent the noise experienced by residents within their bedrooms, living spaces and balconies.
10. The petitioner further deposed that the 2nd respondent’s own expert report records an average nocturnal noise level of 35.54 dB(A), which, according to the petitioner, exceeds the prescribed limit of 35 dB(A). The suggestion that the noise is exclusively attributable to traffic and other neighbouring establishments was disputed. The petitioner deposed that according to the further noise assessment by Aeroscan Labs Limited on 6th and 7th February 2026, the measurements recorded noise levels ranging from approximately 48 dB(A) to 81.5 dB(A). The petitioner maintained that the findings demonstrate the persistence of excessive noise notwithstanding the soundproofing measures undertaken by the 2nd respondent.
11. The 1st respondent opposed the amended petition through the replying affidavit of Raphael Murangira, sworn on 23rd May, 2024. The 1st respondent deposed that before commencing operations, they confirmed that the premises were approved for commercial use and that the landlord had obtained the requisite change-of-user approval. Thus, the business was established in accordance with the applicable planning and licensing requirements. Further, that they obtained the requisite single business permit and liquor licence and submitted an environmental assessment report to NEMA. Therefore, the establishment has complied with the environmental requirements imposed by the relevant authorities and that the available regulatory records do not establish the noise violations alleged by the petitioner.
12. The 1st respondent denied playing music in contravention of the prescribed standards and contended that the allegations are unsupported by reliable measurements attributing the complaint to its premises. Further, that the establishment operates in a locality where there are other commercial activities and sources of environmental noise. The 1st respondent challenged allegations concerning the conduct of the establishment’s patrons and security personnel, including claims that its staff acted aggressively towards persons raising complaints.
13. The 2nd respondent opposed the amended petition through the replying affidavit of its director, Benjamin Kariuki Kimani sworn on 2nd July, 2025. The 2nd respondent deposed that its establishment holds the requisite business permits, liquor licence, change-of-user approval and the environmental impact assessment licence issued by NEMA. Further, that it has complied with the relevant environmental requirements and undertaken mitigation measures, including soundproofing its premises. It was deposed that the petitioner’s apartments are situated along Othaya Road, approximately one kilometre away by road, and that several other commercial establishments and sources of noise exist between the properties.
14. The 2nd respondent also referred to Chiromo Mental Hospital and Little Souls Learning Centre as establishments situated closer to its premises, and that these institutions have not raised complaints concerning excessive noise from the 2nd respondent and that the available evidence does not establish that noise emanating from its establishment reaches the petitioner’s apartments at unlawful levels. The petitioner’s initial noise readings were challenged on the grounds that they do not adequately identify the measuring equipment, its calibration, the precise location of measurement or the particular source of the recorded noise. It was deposed that screenshots and isolated measurements cannot conclusively establish liability under the applicable regulations.
15. The 2nd respondent relied on an environmental noise assessment prepared by Theobald Luchidio, which established that its operations comply with the permissible noise levels. They maintained that the report supports the effectiveness of the soundproofing measures and disputes the attribution of ambient environmental noise to the 2nd respondent. The 2nd respondent subsequently filed a supplementary affidavit sworn by Faith Jerono Seroney on 23rd January, 2026. She described herself as a registered environmental lead expert, NEMA Registration No. 7768, engaged to undertake an independent ambient environmental noise assessment at the 2nd respondent’s premises.
16. She deposed that the assessment was conducted on 17th January, 2026 using a calibrated type 1 precision integrating sound level meter, applying the relevant international standards and the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations, 2009. Measurements were undertaken at selected locations to determine the effectiveness of the soundproofing measures and compliance with the prescribed noise limits. According to the deponent, recorded nocturnal noise levels ranged between 20.28 dB(A) and 35.54 dB(A), with an average of approximately 35.54 dB(A) at the nearest boundary. She maintained that the measurements demonstrate compliance and that elevated noise peaks were attributable to external environmental sources, including traffic, hooting, human activity and neighbouring commercial establishments.
17. She further deposed that the 2nd respondent undertook substantial soundproofing works, including installation of double-glazed roofing, heavy sound-insulating glass, sound-absorbing materials, acoustic panels and sealed openings. The report includes photographic evidence of the premises before and after the works and describes the positioning of speakers to minimize the transmission of sound outside the establishment. The deponent concluded that the available measurements do not establish that the 2nd respondent’s operations are responsible for the excessive noise alleged by the petitioner.
18. The 4th, 6th and 7th respondents opposed the amended petition through the replying affidavit of WS Ogola, the acting country solicitor in the office of the 7th respondent sworn on 25th August, 2025. The 7th respondent deposed that while it has established administrative mechanisms through which residents may report noise disturbances, including complaints to public health and environmental officers, the petitioner has not demonstrated that any formal complaint was lodged with the county government before the commencement of these proceedings. The 7th respondent denied that it has neglected its statutory obligations and contends that a regulatory authority cannot reasonably be faulted for failing to investigate a complaint of which it had no knowledge.
19. The 7th respondent deposed that the environmental reports relied upon by the petitioner do not establish any particular omission or wrongdoing attributable to the 4th, 6th or 7th respondents, and stated that the reports do not identify specific enforcement measures which the county government was required to undertake but failed to implement.
20. The 5th respondent opposed the amended petition through the replying affidavit of David Ong’are, its director of environmental compliance, sworn on 23rd September, 2026. It was deposed that in response to concerns regarding entertainment facilities operating within residential areas, the 5th respondent issued public notice no. 1 on 9th September, 2025 requiring operators of affected establishments to submit environmental compliance documentation and mitigation measures within seven days. Further, that a physical inspection of the premises operated by the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents was conducted on 22nd July, 2026 to assess their overall environmental compliance. According to the 5th respondent, the inspection established that the 1st respondent had an approved EIA licence but had been advised to upgrade it to a comprehensive project report pursuant to the applicable environmental assessment framework.
21. With regard to the 2nd respondent, the authority established that it possessed a valid EIA licence and had installed soundproofing structures, while undertaking to rectify identified operational gaps. In respect of the 3rd respondent, the inspection established that the premises contained sound-amplifying equipment capable of generating noise audible outside the building. The establishment was however served with an environmental notice requiring compliance with the applicable environmental requirements, including undertaking the requisite environmental assessment and obtaining the necessary licences. The 5th respondent acknowledged that no formal decibel measurements were undertaken during the inspection. Nevertheless, it undertook supervisory measures within its statutory mandate and the petitioner has not established any deliberate inaction, neglect or failure on the part of the 5th respondent.
22. The amended petition was canvassed through written submissions. The petitioner filed its written submissions dated 24th February, 2026. The 1st respondent filed its written submissions dated 7th April 2026, the 2nd respondent filed written submissions dated 9th April 2026, the 4th to 7th respondents filed written submissions dated 2nd June 2026 while the 5th respondent filed written submissions dated 23rd September, 2026.
23. I have considered the amended petition, the replies thereof, the written submissions and authorities relied upon by counsel. The issues for determination are as follows:-
i. Whether the petitioner has demonstrated a violation or threatened violation of the right to a clean and healthy environment.
ii. Whether the public authorities have failed to discharge their statutory obligations.
iii. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.
24. The petitioner has relied on several environmental assessments indicating elevated nocturnal noise levels within its apartment and the surrounding neighbourhood. The 1st and 2nd respondents dispute the reliability and attribution of those measurements, while the 2nd respondent has produced its own expert reports indicating that mitigation measures have been undertaken. Particularly, the environmental noise measurement report prepared by Theobald Luchidio following measurements undertaken on 18th September and 9th October 2024, which was submitted to the court through the 5th respondent. The report records nocturnal noise levels ranging from approximately 39.1 dB(A) to 62.9 dB(A), with an average of 44.59 dB(A) at the measurement location near the petitioner’s apartments.
25. The report expressly acknowledges that the recorded levels exceeded the stipulated nocturnal limit of 35 dB(A). However, it also explains that the measurements were undertaken at Gate 16 along Othaya road because access to the apartments was unavailable. The expert concluded that the noise could not be attributed to the operations of the 2nd respondent alone, given the contribution of traffic, hooting, vehicle engines and other commercial activities within the neighbourhood. The court must therefore consider both aspects of that report. Whereas it supports the existence of excessive ambient noise within the locality, it does not conclusively establish that the entire exceedance was attributable to the 2nd respondent.
26. The 2nd respondent’s subsequent report prepared by Faith Jerono Seroney on 17th January, 2026 records substantially lower measurements following soundproofing works. However, the report includes a measurement of 35.54 dB(A), which exceeds the stated nocturnal limit of 35 dB(A), assuming that limit applies to the measurement location. The conclusion of compliance must therefore be evaluated against the actual measurements and applicable legal standards.
27. The petitioner’s further report prepared by Aeroscan Labs Limited following measurements undertaken on 6th and 7th February, 2026 records elevated noise levels within the petitioner’s apartments. The report supports the petitioner’s contention that noise disturbances persisted notwithstanding the mitigation measures undertaken by the 2nd respondent. Nevertheless, the competing reports were undertaken on different dates, at different measurement points and under different environmental circumstances. Further, some of the measurements represent aggregate ambient noise rather than emissions isolated to a particular establishment. The reports therefore require careful consideration before liability can be attributed to any individual respondent.
28. I find that the evidence establishes the existence of excessive nocturnal noise within the affected neighbourhood during the periods assessed. What has not been established with sufficient precision is the individual contribution of each of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents to the recorded exceedances. Whereas Article 70(3) dispenses with the requirement to establish personal loss or injury when seeking enforcement of environmental rights, it does not dispense with the need to demonstrate a sufficient factual basis connecting the conduct complained of to the particular relief sought.
29. I have also considered the environmental approvals and business permits supplied by the 1st and 2nd respondents. The same demonstrate that the establishments have obtained certain approvals to conduct their respective businesses. However, the validity of such approvals does not authorize activities conducted in violation of environmental law. As regards the 3rd respondent, the 5th respondent’s inspection undertaken on 22nd July, 2026 is particularly relevant. The inspection established that this particular business possessed sound-amplifying equipment capable of generating noise audible outside the building and that certain environmental compliance requirements remained outstanding.
30. The 5th respondent consequently issued an environmental notice requiring the 3rd respondent to comply with the applicable requirements, including undertaking the requisite environmental assessment and obtaining the necessary approvals. Although no formal decibel measurements were undertaken during that inspection, the findings disclose regulatory concerns requiring follow-up and enforcement. I am therefore satisfied that the environmental concerns raised by the petitioner are not merely speculative. The noise assessments demonstrate that the same exceeded within the neighbourhood, while the 5th respondent’s subsequent inspection identified compliance concerns relating to certain establishments.
31. On the second issue, under the Fourth Schedule to the Constitution, county governments are responsible for controlling noise pollution and other public nuisances. The 5th respondent retains supervisory and coordination responsibilities under the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act. The 4th to 7th respondents contend that the petitioner failed to lodge formal complaints before instituting the proceedings. However, while the absence of a prior formal complaint may be relevant when determining whether an authority neglected to act, it does not extinguish the continuing statutory obligation to enforce environmental standards. In this case, the evidence does not sufficiently establish the dates, contents and recipients of every alleged complaint made before commencement of the proceedings. I am therefore unable to make a finding that each public authority deliberately neglected its duties prior to the institution of the amended petition.
32. Nevertheless, I note that the 5th respondent has since undertaken regulatory action, including issuing the public notice dated 9th September, 2025 and conducting an inspection on 22nd July, 2026. These measures demonstrate that the authority has not remained entirely inactive. The inspection disclosed outstanding compliance issues, particularly concerning the 3rd respondent. The regulatory authorities therefore remain obligated to ensure that the identified deficiencies are addressed and that all establishments operate within the permissible environmental standards.
33. On the third issue, I find that the petitioner has demonstrated a sufficient basis for preventive and compliance-oriented relief under Article 70 of the Constitution. The right to a clean and healthy environment would be inadequately protected if the court were to disregard the established exceedances merely because the precise contribution of each establishment has not been conclusively quantified. However, I am not persuaded that the evidence supports the declaration that the issuance of business permits and liquor licences to the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents was unlawful. The petitioner has not sufficiently demonstrated that the relevant licences were issued contrary to the applicable statutory requirements or that the licensing authorities acted outside their powers.
34. Equally, an order directing automatic revocation of licences would be inappropriate without a proper determination of non-compliance by the competent authorities and observance of the applicable statutory procedures. With regard to the prayer for a permanent injunction, I find that the evidence does not warrant a blanket prohibition against the operation of the establishments. The appropriate remedy is to require compliance with the applicable environmental standards and direct the responsible authorities to undertake the necessary verification and enforcement measures.
35. In the premises, I am satisfied that the amended petition has merit to the extent that it seeks protection against excessive noise pollution and enforcement of the applicable environmental standards. However, the evidence does not support all the declarations and coercive remedies sought against the respective respondents.
36. From the above, the amended petition dated 10th November, 2025 succeeds in part, and I make the following orders:-
i. A declaration is hereby issued that the residents of the petitioner are entitled to the protection of their right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42 of the Constitution, including protection against noise pollution exceeding the applicable statutory limits.
ii. The 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents are hereby directed to conduct their respective business operations in compliance with the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution) (Control) Regulations, 2009, including the permissible noise levels prescribed under the First Schedule.
iii. The 4th, 5th and 7th respondents shall, within thirty (30) days from the date of this judgment, undertake a comprehensive environmental noise assessment of the establishments operated by the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents and the surrounding residential neighbourhood, including the petitioner’s apartments.
iv. Upon completion of the assessment, the 4th to 7th respondents shall take appropriate enforcement measures against any establishment found to be operating contrary to the applicable environmental requirements, including the issuance of compliance notices and such further measures as authorized by law.
v. The 5th respondent is hereby directed to ensure appropriate follow-up on the environmental compliance deficiencies identified during its inspection of 22nd July 2026, particularly those relating to the 3rd respondent.
vi. Each party to bear its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
29/10/2026.
In the presence of:-
Mr. Benson Agunga – Court assistant
Mr. Tanui for the Petitioner
Mr. Kabaiku for the 2nd Respondent
Ms. Omollo holding brief for Mr. Bogongo for the 4th, 6th and 7th Respondents
Ms. Kahura for the 5th Respondent
Mr. Kimani holding brief for Mr. Mutea for the 1st Respondent