REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC PETITION E065 OF 2025
ABDIRAHMAN SHEIKH
MUHUMED ALZALEY……………………..………………. PETITIONER
VERSUS
THE NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION.............1ST RESPONDENT IIMBANI DISPENSARY PROJECT……………….2ND RESPONDENT
AND
FRANLIN MUTHOKA
MUMU………………..PROPOSED 3RD RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
RULING
1. Vide the Motion dated 22nd October, 2025 brought pursuant to the provisions of Articles 10, 22, 23, 25, 40, 48, 50(1) and 159 of the Constitution; Rules 3 and 5 (d) (ii) and (e) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, the 3rd proposed Respondent/Applicant seeks the following reliefs:
i. The Petition herein be consolidated with Milimani ELC Petition No.E003 of 2020: Green Two Estate Owners and Residents Association -versus- the Chief Land Registrar, The National Land Commission, Limbani Dispensary Project Group, Franklin Muthoka Mumu, the Director of Criminal Investigation and the Attorney General.
ii. In the alternative to prayer (a) above, this Petition be stayed pending the hearing and determination of Milimani ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 aforestated.
iii. The Honourable Court be pleased to order that Franklin Muthoka Mumu be joined in the proceedings as the 3rd Respondent to enable him defend the Petition and file the appropriate response in the circumstances.
iv. Consequent upon order (a) above the Honourable Court be pleased to order that the Petitioner do amend the Petition and include Franklin Muthoka Mumu as the 3rd Respondent.
v. Costs of this application to be provided for.
2. In support of the Motion is the affidavit sworn by Franklin Muthoka Mumu, the Proposed 3rd Respondent/Applicant herein of an even date. He deponed that he is a retired Major of the Kenya Army, where he served from 1978 to 1992, and the registered proprietor of L.R. No. 209/10772, situated in South C, Mugoya Phase Four, Nairobi County.
3. He stated that he is sued as the 4th Respondent in Milimani ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 and, upon being served with the Petition and Notice of Motion dated 30th July 2020, entered appearance and filed a replying affidavit in opposition and that the Petition was subsequently determined through written submissions, culminating in a judgment delivered by Oguttu Mboya J. on 2nd June 2022.
4. Dissatisfied with that decision, he lodged a notice of cross-appeal in Nairobi Civil Appeal No. E525 of 2022, seeking a fresh hearing through viva voce evidence before a different Judge and that by its judgment delivered on 31st July 2025, the Court of Appeal allowed his challenge, set aside the proceedings and judgment of the Environment and Land Court, and remitted the Petition for a fresh trial on a priority basis before another Judge.
5. It was deposed that pursuant to that decision, the parties appeared before this court on 22nd September 2025, when the matter was allocated to Kullow J and directions were issued for their appearance before the trial court on 13th October 2025; that the Applicant was also granted leave to file a cross-petition and further documents, which he subsequently filed and that when the parties appeared before Kullow J on 13th October 2025, the court sought time to study the record and fixed the matter for further directions on 5th November 2025.
6. He stated that the Petitioner herein is aware of the Milimani ELC Pet E003 of 2020 and has since filed an application seeking to be joined as an Interested Party. Indeed, when ELC Petition no E003 of 2020 came up on 13th October, 2025 as aforestated, the Petitioner was represented by a Ms. Robi Jabela who held brief for Mr Kuria.
7. According to the Applicant, it is quite evident that the two Petitions concern the same subject matter, L.R 209/10772; that the two Petitions seek to challenge the same decision of the National Land Commission, the 1st Respondent herein dated 18th April, 2018 and that conducting separate proceedings hereof over the same subject matter in the pending ELC Pet E003 of 2020 will be contradictory and inimical to justice and will embarrass the fair trial of both this matter and the Petition.
8. Demonstrably, he urged, the two Petitions raise substantially similar questions of law and fact, involve similar and interrelated parties, and concern issues that are closely connected. He therefore submitted that allowing the application for joinder and consolidating the two Petitions will facilitate the efficient and expeditious determination of the issues in dispute between the parties.
9. In opposition to the Motion, the Petitioner swore a replying affidavit dated 23rd February 2026. He deponed that the plea for consolidation is unwarranted because the two Petitions differ in their parties, causes of action, subject matter, reliefs sought and legal questions for determination.
10. The Petitioner explained that ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 concerns the ownership, possession and threatened eviction of the occupants of L.R. No. 209/10772, subsequently subdivided into L.R. Nos. 209/16432 and 209/16433. In contrast, the present Petition challenges the legality, constitutionality and procedural propriety of the National Land Commission’s determination dated 18th April 2018 and published in the Kenya Gazette on 9th November 2018. According to him, the latter Petition raises distinct constitutional and administrative law questions concerning due process, fair administrative action and the Commission’s jurisdiction.
11. He further stated that the Petitioners in ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 were not the subject of the impugned determination, which was directed at him personally and concerned his alleged liability to compensate Jimbani Dispensary Project. He maintained that consolidation will improperly conflate a challenge to the decision of a statutory commission with a property and possession dispute involving different parties, evidence, legal tests and remedies.
12. The Petitioner also pointed out that the two Petitions are at materially different procedural stages. ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 had already undergone substantive adjudication and appellate intervention before being remitted for a fresh hearing, whereas ELC Petition No. E065 of 2025 remains at a separate stage. Consolidation would therefore, in his view, occasion confusion, delay and procedural prejudice rather than promote the expeditious determination of the matters.
13. Although he acknowledged having applied to be joined as an Interested Party in ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020, he clarified that his intended participation was limited to presenting material evidence and explaining the history of the property, having been its original owner before transferring it to the Petitioners and that his intended joinder was therefore not meant to expand or alter the issues arising in that Petition.
Submissions
14. The Applicant filed written submissions dated 19th March 2026. Counsel submitted that Rules 5(c) and (d) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013 confer upon the court discretion, either on its own motion or upon application, to join any person who ought to have been joined in the proceedings. Cited in support was JMK vs MWM & Another [2015] KECA 524 (KLR).
15. Counsel argued that the Applicant demonstrated a direct and substantial interest in the present petition, having asserted that he is the registered proprietor of L.R. No. 209/10772 and produced a copy of the title in his name; that he is also the 4th Respondent in ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020, in which he has filed a cross-petition. Further and that the Petitioner herein has acknowledged that he sold the resultant titles to the Petitioners in ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020.
16. According to counsel, the two Petitions concern the same property and involve parties whose interests are closely connected. Consequently, it was urged, the Applicant has demonstrated personal interest or stake in this Petition.
17. As regards consolidation, counsel, guided by Law Society of Kenya vs Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 Others [2014] eKLR, submitted that the same facilitates the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes and provides a framework for the fair and impartial administration of justice and that in this case, both Petitions concern L.R. No. 209/10772 and challenge the National Land Commission’s determination dated 18th April 2018.
18. In the alternative, counsel submitted that the present Petition should be stayed under the doctrine of sub judice because ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020, which was instituted earlier, remains pending and concerns the same property and substantially similar issues. Reliance was placed on Kenya Bankers Association vs Kenya Revenue Authority [2019] eKLR for the proposition that the doctrine is concerned with the matters in issue rather than merely the reliefs sought.
19. The Petitioner/Respondent filed written submissions dated 23rd March 2026. Counsel referred to Rule 17 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013, which empowers the court, either on its own motion or upon application by a party, to consolidate petitions on such terms as it considers appropriate.
20. According to counsel, as explained in Nyati Security Guards & Services Ltd vs Municipal Council of Mombasa, Civil Suit No. 992 of 1994, consolidation is intended to save costs, time and effort and may be ordered where the suits raise common questions of law or fact, arise from the same transaction or series of transactions, or where consolidation is otherwise desirable.
21. Applying those principles, counsel submitted that ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 concerns the ownership, possession and occupation of L.R. No. 209/10772, subsequently subdivided into L.R. Nos. 209/16432 and 209/16433. In contrast, ELC Petition No. E065 of 2025 challenges the legality, constitutionality and procedural propriety of the National Land Commission’s determination dated 18th April 2018 and gazetted on 9th November 2018.
22. It was further urged that the two Petitions are materially distinct in their causes of action, applicable legal frameworks, evidentiary requirements and reliefs sought. Whereas this Petition raises constitutional and administrative law questions concerning due process, fair administrative action and the jurisdiction of the National Land Commission, ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 concerns the proprietary and possessory rights of the registered owners and occupiers of the subdivided parcels following the issuance of eviction notices.
23. Accordingly, it was submitted, while Petition No. E003 of 2020 seeks declaratory and protective reliefs concerning title and possession, this Petition seeks to quash an administrative determination directed against the Petitioner/Respondent, to which the Petitioners in ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 were not parties
Analysis and Determination
24. Having considered the pleadings and submissions, the following are the issues that arise for determination:
i. Whether the Applicant should be joined into these proceedings?
ii. Whether the present petition should be consolidated with ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020?
25. The Applicant seeks to be joined into these proceedings. It is not in dispute that a person may be joined or added to a constitutional Petition as a Petitioner, Respondent or an Interested Party. The addition of a party to a Petition in any of these capacities is provided for under Rules 5 and 7 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013(Mutunga Rules).
26. Rule 5 reads as follows:
“The following procedure shall apply with respect to addition, joinder, substitution and striking out of parties—
(a)Where the petitioner is in doubt as to the persons from whom redress should be sought, the petitioner may join two or more respondents in order that the question as to which of the respondent is liable, and to what extent, may be determined as between all parties.
(b)A petition shall not be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the Court may in every proceeding deal with the matter in dispute.
(c)Where proceedings have been instituted in the name of the wrong person as petitioner, or where it is doubtful whether it has been instituted in the name of the right petitioner, the Court may at any stage of the proceedings, if satisfied that the proceedings have been instituted through a mistake made in good faith, and that it is necessary for the determination of the matter in dispute, order any other person to be substituted or added as petitioner upon such terms as it thinks fit.
(d)The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear just—(i)order that the name of any party improperly joined, be struck out; and(ii)that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, or whose presence before the court may be necessary in order to enable the court adjudicate upon and settle the matter, be added.
(e)Where a respondent is added or substituted, the petition shall unless the court otherwise directs, be amended in such a manner as may be necessary, and amended copies of the petition shall be served on the new respondent and, if the court thinks, fit on the original respondents.”
27. Speaking to the rationale for joinder, the Court of Appeal in Merry Beach Limited vs Attorney General & 18 others [2018] KECA 18 (KLR) stated thus:
“The right to be heard before an adverse decision is taken against a party is fundamental and permeates our entire justice system. This Court in Mbaki & Others vs. Macharia & Another [2005] 2 EA 206, at page 210, while underscoring the significance of that right expressed: “The right to be heard is a valued right. It would offend all notions of justice if the rights of a party were to be prejudiced or affected without the party being afforded an opportunity to be heard.”
It is for that reason that our legal system has embedded relevant provisions in the Constitution and legislative texts to ensure the realization of that right. Of relevance to the appeal before us is Rule 5 (d) (ii) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013 (popularly known as Mutunga Rules) which provides-“5.(d) The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear just-(i) order that the name of any party improperly joined, be struck out; and (ii) that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, or whose presence before the court may be necessary in order to enable the court adjudicate upon and settle the matter, be added.”
28. In Gad Omondi Opiyo vs Peter Kibinda, Scrutineer & 7 others [2019] KEHC 2472 (KLR), the court noted thus:
“Upon considering the nature of this petition and the proposed Respondent having demonstrated it has an identifiable stake, interest and duty in these proceedings, I find that the participation of the Applicant in this petition is necessary for just determination of the matters in issue in the petition. I find the joinder will enable the Applicant to protect its interest which may have adversely and negating affect if the application is not granted to enjoin the Applicant as a Respondent to the petition. Its enjoinder would further enable court to determine any issue or question in the instant petition not only between the petitioner and the Respondents but also between the petitioner and Applicant who has sought court’s leave to be enjoined as a Respondent.”
29. The Applicant seeks to be joined in these proceedings as the 3rd Respondent on the ground that he has a direct and substantial interest in the dispute. He contends that the present Petition concerns the National Land Commission’s determination relating to L.R. No. 209/10772 and that its outcome may affect his interests and the position he has taken in the related proceedings.
30. A consideration of the Petition shows that the Applicant is not a stranger to the controversy. The Petition expressly identifies “Muthoka alias Major Muthoka” as one of the directors or members of the 2nd Respondent who asserted ownership of L.R. No. 209/10772 and allegedly interfered with the Petitioner’s occupation of the property.
31. It further refers to civil and criminal proceedings instituted against him and other officials of the 2nd Respondent arising from the competing claims and title documents over the property. Beyond those allegations, the Applicant himself asserts that he is the registered proprietor of L.R. No. 209/10772, and holds a title thereto thereby laying a direct proprietary claim to the very property that is the subject of the impugned determination.
32. Further, the Petition challenges the National Land Commission’s determination arising from the complaint of the 2nd Respondent and seeks, among other reliefs, a declaration that the grant relied upon by the 2nd Respondent in respect of L.R. No. 209/10772 is a forgery. That relief bears directly upon the Applicant’s asserted status as the registered proprietor of the property and the title upon which his claim is founded.
33. In those circumstances, the Applicant has demonstrated more than a remote or academic interest in the proceedings. His participation will enable the court to receive a complete response to the Petitioner's allegations, determine the dispute with the benefit of all materially affected parties and avoid prejudice arising from orders made in his absence. No prejudice incapable of being addressed has been demonstrated by the Petitioner.
34. The next issue for determination is whether the present Petition should be consolidated with ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020? Black’s Law Dictionary (8th Edition) defines consolidation as:
“to combine, through court order, two or more actions involving the same parties or issues into a single action ending in a single judgment, or sometimes, separate judgments…”
35. On the aspect of consolidation of the suits, Rule 17 of the Constitution of Kenya [protection of rights and fundamental freedoms] Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013, states as follows:
“…The Court may on its own motion or on application by any party consolidate several petitions on such terms as it may deem just….”
36. The principles to consider were amply set out in the case of Republic versus Paul Kihara Kariuki & 2 Others Ex-parte Law Society of Kenya [2020] eKLR, where the Honourable Court stated and observed as hereunder:
“11. The principles of consolidation of suits are settled. They were best explained in Stumberg and another v Potgeiter as follows:-“Where there are common questions of law or facts in actions having sufficient importance in proportion to the rest of each action to render it desirable that the whole of the matters should be disposed of at the same time, consolidation should be ordered.”12.The Supreme Court Case of India in Prem Lala Nahata & v Chandi Prasad Sikaria had this to say: -“…Consolidation is a process by which two or more causes or matters are by order of the Court combined or united and treated as one cause or matter. The main purpose of consolidation is therefore to save costs, time and effort and to make the conduct of several actions more convenient by treating them as one action. The jurisdiction to consolidate arises where there are two or more matters or causes pending in the Court and it appears to the Court that some common questions of law or fact arises in both or all the suits or that the rights to relief claimed in the suits are in respect of or arise out of the same transaction or series of transactions; or that for some other reason it is desirable to make an order consolidating the suits”13.In Law Society of Kenya v The Centre for Human Rights and Democracy, the Supreme Court of Kenya had this to say about consolidation of suits: -“The essence of consolidation is to facilitate the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes and to provide a framework for a fair and impartial dispensation of justice to the parties. Consolidation was never meant to confer any undue advantage upon the party that seeks it, nor was it intended to occasion any disadvantage towards the party that opposes it.” [Emphasis added]14.From the above jurisprudence, a broad principle emerges relating to consolidation of suits. That is, where there are common questions of law or fact in actions having sufficient importance in proportion to the rest of each action to render it desirable that the whole of the matter should be disposed at the same time, consolidation should be ordered. However, it is succinct position of law that precedential verdicts are to be followed where the facts of the case are almost identical in nature or the question of law involved is identical.”
37. Vide the present Petition, the Petitioner seeks inter-alia, a declaration that the determination of the 1st Respondent regarding the ownership of L.R 209/10772 issued on 18th April, 2018 and gazzetted on 9th November, 2018 in the Kenya Gazzette Vol CXX-No 138 is unconstitutional and the 1st Respondent’s decision in this regard was ultra vires its constitutional and statutory mandate.
38. The Petitioner also contends that the grant held by the 2nd Respondent for L.R No 209/10772 Nairobi is a forgery as adjudged in Nairobi Chief Magistrates Criminal case No 899 of 2005, as well as general, exemplary and aggravated damages.
39. The Petitioner’s case, in essence, is that although he acquired L.R. No. 209/10772 from KANU and subsequently disposed of his entire interest in the property, the 1st Respondent, acting on a complaint by the 2nd Respondent, proceeded ex parte to determine that the 2nd Respondent was the genuine owner and that his title was illegal, without notifying or hearing him.
40. He contends that the determination was made without jurisdiction, concerned private land, disregarded previous judicial findings concerning the competing title, and violated his rights to fair administrative action, a fair hearing and property.
41. On the other hand, ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020 was instituted by Green Two Estate Owners and Residents Association against, among others, the Chief Land Registrar, the National Land Commission and Limbani Dispensary Project Group. The Petitioners bring the Petition on their own behalf and on behalf of the registered proprietors of various parcels within Green Two Estate, which they state were acquired through purchase and transfer and are subdivisions of L.R. Nos. 209/16432 and 209/16433.
42. Their case, in essence, is that their properties are private land and that the National Land Commission had no jurisdiction to investigate or determine claims relating to them as historical land injustices. They challenge the Commission’s determination published in Gazette Notice No. 11714 of 2018, contend that they were neither notified nor heard in the proceedings leading to that determination, and maintain that they acquired their respective properties as innocent purchasers without notice of any fraud or irregularity.
43. They consequently seek, among other reliefs, declarations protecting their titles, nullifying the impugned determination insofar as it affects their properties, and restraining interference with their ownership and occupation.
44. The Applicant asserts that the two Petitions raise substantially similar questions of law and fact, involve similar and interrelated parties, and arise from the same underlying dispute concerning L.R. No. 209/10772 and its subdivisions. He contends that both Petitions challenge, albeit from different perspectives, the National Land Commission’s determination relating to the property and that their consolidation would avoid duplication of proceedings and facilitate the efficient and expeditious determination of the issues between the parties.
45. In contrast, the Petitioner opposes the consolidation on the basis that the two Petitions are distinct. He contends that Petition No. E003 of 2020 principally concerns the ownership, possession and occupation of the properties comprised in L.R. Nos. 209/16432 and 209/16433, whereas the present Petition challenges the legality, constitutionality and procedural propriety of the National Land Commission’s determination of 18th April 2018, subsequently gazetted on 9th November 2018.
46. He urges that the parties, causes of action, evidence, applicable legal principles and reliefs sought are different and that, given the different stages of the proceedings, consolidation would occasion confusion, delay and prejudice.
47. The court has keenly considered the two Petitions. Indeed, the two Petitions are not mirror images of each other and each raises issues peculiar to the respective Petitioners. Petition No. E003 of 2020, for instance, places particular emphasis on the rights of the individual proprietors of the subdivisions, their alleged status as innocent purchasers and the threatened interference with their possession and titles. The present Petition, on the other hand, directly challenges the National Land Commission’s determination and raises questions concerning the competing grant over L.R. No. 209/10772.
48. The inquiry, however, does not end with those differences. At the centre of both petitions is L.R. No. 209/10772 and the competing claims arising from that property and its subsequent subdivisions. More significantly, both proceedings call into question the National Land Commission’s inquiry and the determination of 18th April 2018 published in Gazette Notice No. 11714 of 2018.
49. Indeed, in Petition No. E003 of 2020, the Petitioners expressly challenge the Commission’s jurisdiction to investigate their properties and seek orders directed at the very determination and Gazette Notice that are impugned in the present Petition.
50. It follows that, notwithstanding the differences in the manner in which the respective claims are framed, there is a substantial overlap in the factual and legal questions that the court will be required to determine. In particular, both Petitions require the court to interrogate the National Land Commission’s jurisdiction and procedure in dealing with the competing claims over L.R. No. 209/10772 and its subdivisions, as well as the legal effect of the resulting determination.
51. Determining those questions separately would entail duplication of evidence and judicial effort and, more importantly, create a real possibility of inconsistent findings concerning the same determination and the same underlying property dispute.
52. It should be emphasized that consolidation does not merge the Petitions into a single cause or extinguish the distinct claims of the respective parties; it merely provides a procedural framework within which the overlapping questions may be heard and determined together.
53. As regards the contention that consolidation would cause delay or prejudice on account of the different procedural stages of the Petitions, the court notes that Petition No. E003 of 2020 has been remitted for hearing afresh. There is therefore no concluded determination that would be reopened or disturbed by consolidation. In the circumstances, any inconvenience occasioned by bringing the matters together is outweighed by the benefit of having the common questions determined comprehensively and consistently.
54. Accordingly, the court is satisfied that the two Petitions disclose a sufficient factual and legal nexus to meet the threshold for consolidation. Ultimately, the present Notice of Motion succeeds as follows:
a) Franklin Muthoka Mumu be and is hereby joined in the proceedings as the 3rd Respondent.
b) This Petition is hereby consolidated with Milimani ELC Petition No. E003 of 2020: Green Two Estate Owners and Residents Association -versus- the Chief Land Registrar, The National Land Commission, Limbani Dispensary Project Group, Franklin Muthoka Mumu, the Director of Criminal Investigation and the Attorney General.
c) Each party to bear its own costs.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 29th day of October, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Mr. Mideng’a for 3rd proposed Respondent
Mr. Hans Oichoe for 4th Proposed Respondent
Mr. Muchiri holding brief for Luci for 2nd Respondent
Mr. Obum for Kuria for Petitioner
Mr. Hasee for NLC – 1st Respondent
Court Assistant: Tracy