REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. 1099 OF 2016
SANDALWOOD LENANA LIMITED - PLAINTIFF
VS
THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE
NAIROBI CITY COUNCIL - 1ST DEFENDANT
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
NAIROBI CITY WATER AND
SEWERAGE COMPANY LIMITED - 2ND DEFENDANT
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
NATIONAL ENVITONMENT
MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY - 3RD DEFENDANT
BAYSIDE LIMITED - 4TH DEFENDANT
RULING
(In respect of the 1st Defendant’s application dated 6/2/2026 and the Plaintiff’s application dated 16/2/2026)
Background
1. For determination before this court is the 1st Defendant’s application dated 6/2/2026 and the Plaintiff’s application dated 16/2/2026 and filed on 16/3/2026. On the face of the applications, the 1st Defendant’s application seeks entry of judgment after taxation whereas the Plaintiff’s application seeks to set aside a dismissal order and reinstate an application. I will therefore start with the Plaintiff’s application.
Plaintiff’s application
2. The Plaintiff’s application is premised on the provisions of Order 12 rule 7 and Order 22 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Plaintiff prays for the following orders in the main;
a. That this court be pleased to set aside the orders made on 26/1/2026 and reinstate the Plaintiff’s application dated 19/11/2025 for hearing on merit.
b. That the costs of this application be moved for.
3. The application is premised on the grounds on the face of it and further supported by the affidavit of Jane Ngángá. The Plaintiff avers that upon filing its application dated 19/11/2025 under certificate of urgency, the court issued directions on 25/11/2025 directing it to serve the Respondents with the application within 3 days. The Respondents were in turn directed to file their responses within 15 days. Parties were further directed to file and exchange their written submission within 5 days before the hearing of the application. The application was slated for hearing on 26/2/2026.
4. It is deposed that the Plaintiff complied with the court’s direction and issued a hearing notice for 26/2/2026 accordingly. However, on 26/2/2026, its counsel learnt that its application had been dismissed on 26/1/2026 for non-attendance. It is argued that the matter was not scheduled for hearing on 26/1/2026 and contends that it will suffer prejudice unless the orders sought are granted.
1st Defendant’s Replying Affidavit
5. The 1st Defendant in its Replying Affidavit deponed by Christine Ireri on 6/5/2026, asserts that the Applicant’s application dated 19/11/2025 was rightfully dismissed by this Honourable Court on 26/1/2026 due to non-attendance. The 1st Defendant maintains that it diligently followed up on the matter through the court registry and CTS system after learning of the application, and duly served its Replying Affidavit upon the Applicant prior to the hearing.
6. The 1st Defendant avers that the Applicant’s claims regarding the service of hearing notices and court directions are untrue and misleading, as no such service was ever effected, nor has the Applicant provided proof thereof. That the Applicant cannot rely on its own failure to serve court directions to impugn a lawful dismissal order, especially given that it has failed to provide any credible explanation for its non-attendance. Further, that the Plaintiff has demonstrated a pattern of indolence, as this is not the first instance where its application has been dismissed for non-attendance. It is deposed on a without prejudice basis that in case of a reinstatement, the 1st Defendant be granted costs.
1st Defendant’s application
7. The Defendant’s application is anchored on the provisions of Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act, Rule 7 of the Advocates Remuneration Order seeking orders that;
a. This Honourable Court be pleased to enter judgment for the 1st Defendant against the Plaintiff for the sum of Kenya Shillings Three Hundred and Forty Thousand, Five Hundred and Fifty-Seven Thousand (Kshs. 340,557) only as it appears on the Certificate of costs dated 30th October 2025.
b. This Honourable Court be pleased to grant interest on the said sum of Kenya Shillings Three Hundred and Forty Thousand, Five Hundred and Fifty Seven Thousand (Kshs. 340,557) to run from one month of service of the Bill of Costs on the Plaintiff, that is 13th March 2025 until full payment.
c. The 1st Defendant be allowed to execute the judgment herein against the Plaintiff.
d. Costs of this application be provided for.
8. The application is based on the grounds on the face of and further supported by the affidavit of its counsel on record of even date. The gist of the 1st Defendant’s application is that a Certificate of Costs was issued on 30/10/2025 following taxation of its Party and Party Bill of Costs dated 14/11/2024. That the Certificate of Costs having not been set aside, judgment should be entered in its favour as required in law.
9. The applications were canvassed by way written submissions. Both parties complied. The Court has had occasion to read through the submissions by parties and considered them in its determination.
Analysis and Determination
10. Considering the applications, the responses made and the rival submissions as well as the court record, the issues that commend themselves to me for determination, are:
a. Whether the court should reinstate the application dated 19/11/2025 as prayed.
b. Depending on the findings in (i) above, which orders should be granted in respect of the 1st Defendant’s application.
c. Who should bear the cost of the application?
Whether the court should reinstate the suit as prayed
11. The law applicable for setting aside judgment or dismissal is Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provide as follows;
“Where under this Order judgment has been entered or the suit has been dismissed, the court, on application, may set aside or vary the judgment or order upon such terms as may be just.”
12. Reinstatement of a suit is discretionary. Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act gives the court inherent power to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice to be met. What the court is to consider while exercising discretion was emphasized in the case of Esther Wamaitha Njihia & 2 Others -vs- Safaricom Ltd [2014] eKLR where the court citing relevant cases on the issue held inter alia:-
“The discretion is free and the main concern of the courts is to do justice to the parties before it (see Patel vs E.A. Cargo Handling Services Ltd.) the discretion is intended to be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence or excusable mistake or error but is not designed to assist a person who deliberately sought, whether by evasion or otherwise, to obstruct or delay the cause of justice (see Shah vs. Mbogo). The nature of the action should be considered, the defence if any should also be considered; and so should the question as to whether the Plaintiff can reasonably be compensated by costs for any delay bearing in mind that to deny a litigant a hearing should be the last resort of a court…. It also goes without saying that the reason for failure to attend should be considered.”
13. This Court is guided by the holding in the above case in regard to how to apply the discretion it has. It should exercise it judiciously and for purposes of avoiding injustice and hardship which may result from an excusable error.
14. In the instant case, the Plaintiff’s contention is that the application was listed for hearing on 26/1/2026 instead of 26/2/2026 as per the court’s directions issued on 25/11/2025.
15. I have perused the court record; I note that in deed the application dated 19/11/2025 was slated for hearing on 26/2/2026 as per directions issued on 25/11/2025. The application was therefore erroneously listed for hearing on 26/1/2026. Accordingly, the I am inclined to allow the Plaintiff’s application dated 16/2/2026 and filed on 16/3/2026.
16. Consequently, having allowed the Plaintiff’s application, the 1st Defendant’s application shall be held in abeyance pending the hearing and determination of the Plaintiff’s application dated 19/11/2025.
17. Based on the foregoing, the following orders do issue;
a. The orders issued on 26/1/2026 dismissing the Plaintiff’s application dated 19/11/2025 for non-attendance is hereby set aside.
b. The Plaintiff’s application dated 26/1/2026 is hereby reinstated for hearing and determination on its merits.
c. The 1st Defendant’s application dated 6/2/2026 shall be held in abeyance pending the hearing and determination of the Plaintiff’s application dated 19/11/2025.
d. There shall be no orders as to costs.
18. It is so ordered
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
1. Mr. Onsomu H/B for Mr. Nyakundi for the Plaintiff
2. Ms Indosia H/B for Mr. Kithi for the 1st Defendant
3. N/A for the 2nd and 3rd Defendants
4. Ms. Ogado H/B for Mr. Owino for 4th Defendant
CA – Mr. Oglen