Land law

Parkuiyare v Kenya Railways Corporation & 14 others [2026] KEELC 7416 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Petition E080 of 2024
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
J G Kemei

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is coming up for determination is the Petitioner’s application dated 1/10/2024 and the 1st Respondent’s Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

On the issue of whether allowing the Notice of Preliminary Objection will prejudice the Petitioner, it is submitted that the answer is in the positive. The Petitioner contends that permitting the objection would violate his constitutional right to a fair hearing under Article 50, which is a non-derogable principle of natural justice. It is argued that the hardship likely to be occasioned to the Petitioner by denying him the opportunity…

Paragraph 15 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC PETITION NO E080 OF 2024

DANIEL SENTERO PARKUIYARE - PETITIONER

VERSUS

KENYA RAILWAYS CORPORATION - 1ST RESPONDENT

DUPOTO JUA KALI SELF-HELP GROUP - 2ND RESPONDENT

DUPOTO SETTLEMENT SCHEME - 3RD RESPONDENT

MSIMAMO MWEMA SETTLEMENT SCHEME - 4TH RESPONDENT

JOHN KIYIAN KARU - 5TH RESPONDENT

LIKAM OLE KIAMBU - 6TH RESPONDENT

DAVID OLE NKARATOI - 7TH RESPONDENT

SANKALA OLE KITUARISHO - 8TH RESPONDENT

DAVID GOLIGOL NTETE - 9TH RESPONDENT

VICTO OCHIENG’ - 10TH RESPONDENT

JAMASAS OLE KARU - 11TH RESPONDENT

MARIPET OLE NTININ - 12TH RESPONDENT

ODINGA LETOOLE - 13TH RESPONDENT

LODIAKA LEKAMARIO - 14TH RESPONDENT

JOSHUA MEMUSI MEISI - 15TH RESPONDENT

RULING

(In respect of the Petitioner’s application dated 1/10/2024 and the 1st Respondent’s Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025)

Background

1. What is coming up for determination is the Petitioner’s application dated 1/10/2024 and the 1st Respondent’s Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025.

Petitioner’s application

2. The Petitioner’s application is expressed to be brought under the provisions of Article 4, 13, 19 & 23 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013. The Petitioner substantively prays for orders that;

a. This Honorable Court be pleased to grant Conservatory Order barring the Respondents, from receiving any payments from the Kenya Railways Corporation, or any other person purporting to act on behalf of the Petitioner as a member of Schemes, and its membership on account of the compulsory acquisition of L.R. No.2935, pending hearing and determination of this Petition.

b. This Honorable Court be please to grant a Conservatory Order barring Kenya Railways Corporation, by themselves, their servants or any other person from commencing, continuing and/or concluding the process of occupation of the suit property, pending hearing and determination of this Petition.

c. The costs be provided for.

3. The application is premised on the grounds on the face of it and further supported by the Petitioner’s Affidavit of even date. The deponent avers that that he is a bona fide member of the Respondent Scheme, a registered Community Based Organization having purchased three parcels of land (Plot Nos. 24, 471, and 512) between 2006 and 2009 from the then officials. The Petitioner avers that following the purchase, he took peaceful possession of the property, constructed houses and built a perimeter wall.

4. The Petitioner avers that sometime back in the year 2023, he learnt that the Scheme was processing a title deed to facilitate the sale of 55 acres of the suit property to the Kenya Railways Corporation. He deposes that although is aware of a payout of Kshs. 2,750,000,000/= for the 55 acres, no explanation was offered regarding the balance or the status of his plots, despite numerous attempts to seek clarification from the Secretary, Mr. John Kiyian Karu. He avers that when he subsequently visited the property, he was surprised to realize that all residents had been evicted and bulldozers were on site under heavy police presence. He claims that based on the payment so far effected, an eighth of an acre was valued at Kshs. 6,250,000 hence the total amount due to him for his three plots is Kshs. 18,750,000/=. It is on that basis that he seeks the above orders.

1st Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

5. The 1st Respondent in the Replying Affidavit of Stanley Gitari sworn on 3/8/2026 avers that it lawfully acquired the suit property, L.R. No. Nairobi/Block 125/2173, through a purchase agreement with the registered owners and completed the payment of the purchase price on 15/12/2023. It is averred that whereas the Court granted orders on 30/1/2024, restraining it from releasing funds regarding the acquisition, the said orders were overtaken by events as the transaction had already been concluded. The 1st Respondent asserts that having effected the payment and obtained a title in its favour, the orders sought are overtaken by events. It maintains that it acted in good faith and in accordance with the law, having conducted due diligence and secured a lawful transfer and title; it thus denies any allegations of collusion or secrecy in the process.

6. On a without prejudice basis, the 1st Respondent states that the settlement was paid to the Dupoto/Darfur Settlement Welfare Scheme through its appointed advocates, who are duly mandated to handle the Scheme's affairs. The Respondent contends that it has fully discharged its obligations and has no role in the internal governance of the Scheme or the subsequent distribution of monies to individual members. It therefore argues that any claims by the Petitioner regarding entitlement to proceeds are strictly between the him and the Scheme officials, which issues do not concern the 1st Respondent.

7. The 1st Respondent argues that the Petitioner/Applicant has not established a prima facie case with a probability of success to warrant issuance of an injunction since payment to the Scheme’s registered Trustees was already effected. On irreparable harm, it is averred that the Applicant has not demonstrated that it would suffer irreparable harm that cannot be compensated by way of damages. It is argued that granting the orders sought would be in vain and would prejudice the 1st Respondent, who is the lawful registered proprietor.

8. Accordingly, the 1st Respondent prays that the Application be dismissed with costs, asserting that the balance of convenience tilts in its favor and that the suit is defeated by events.

1st Respondent’s Preliminary Objection

9. The 1st Respondent also filed a notice of Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025 on grounds that;

a. This Honourable Court lacks the requisite jurisdiction to adjudicate over this dispute by virtue of the provisions of Sections 112 and 133C of the Land Act No. 6 of 2012 as the issues stated in the Petition ought to first be dealt with in the dispute resolution mechanisms mandatorily provided for under the law which vests jurisdiction of this matter in the Land Acquisition Tribunal;

b. Section 133C (6) of the Land Act No. 6 of 2012 specifically states that disputes relating to compulsory acquisition of land ought to first be lodged with the Land Acquisition Tribunal.

c. Proceedings before this honorable Court can only be instituted through an appeal against the decision of the Land Acquisition Tribunal and to the limited to the extent stipulated under Section 133D of the Land Act No.6 of 2012.

d. This Petition is therefore premature, mischievous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process.

e. This Court therefore lacks jurisdiction to entertain, hear or determine the issues raised in the Petition.

Petitioner’s Grounds of Opposition

10. The Petitioner filed grounds of opposition dated 5/1/2026 in response to the Preliminary Objection. The grounds are that;

a. The Preliminary Objection is misconceived, incompetent, frivolous, vexatious, and an abuse of the due process of this Honorable Court.

b. The Preliminary Objection does not raise pure points of law as envisaged in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696.

c. The Petition raises substantial constitutional issues touching on the violation and threatened violation of the Petitioner’s constitutional rights and fundamental freedoms.

d. This Honorable Court has the requisite jurisdiction under Articles 22, 23, 162(2)(b) and 165(3)(b) of the Constitution as read together with Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act to hear and determine the Petition herein.

e. The doctrine of exhaustion is not absolute and does not bar this Honorable Court from entertaining constitutional petitions raising violations of fundamental rights and freedoms.

f. The Land Acquisition Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to determine constitutional questions and grant the constitutional reliefs sought in the Petition.

g. The issues raised in the Petition transcend compensation disputes contemplated under the Land Act and therefore cannot be conclusively determined by the Tribunal.

h. The Preliminary Objection improperly invites this Honorable Court to interrogate contested facts and evidentiary matters.

i. The Preliminary Objection is an abuse of the Court process and is intended to delay the fair hearing and determination of the Petition.

j. It is in the interest of justice that the Preliminary Objection be dismissed with costs to the Petitioner.

Written Submissions

11. On 6/7/2026 directions were taken to canvass the Notice of Motion and Preliminary Objection simultaneously by way of written submissions. However, both parties only submitted on the Preliminary Objection.

12. The 1st Respondent submits that the Preliminary Objection raises a pure point of law on jurisdiction as the Petitioner specifically failed to exhaust the mandatory statutory dispute resolution mechanisms established under Sections 112, 133C (6), and 133D of the Land Act before filing suit. Relying on the locus classicus definition in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturers Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd (1969) E.A and its affirmation in Kigathi v Kenya National Highways Authority & another [2025] KEELC 993 (KLR), the 1st Respondent argues that this threshold issue can be resolved on the face of the pleadings without delving into contested factual evidence or requiring the exercise of judicial discretion. Accordingly, it is submitted that the objection is properly before Court and ought to be determined in limine.

13. The 1st Respondent further submits that the Petition is barred by the doctrine of constitutional avoidance. He asserts that Courts should refrain from determining constitutional questions where a dispute can be properly resolved through available non-constitutional statutory fora. Relying on the case of Edward v Attorney General and Communications Commission of Kenya [2026] KEHC 2767 (KLR), the 1st Respondent argues that Constitutional Petitions are remedies of last resort intended for genuine constitutional crises. It is contended that the Petitioner has failed to demonstrate the inadequacy of the statutory forum established under Section 133C (6) of the Land Act. It is argued that the dispute falls squarely within the statutory mandate of the Land Acquisition Tribunal and the Petitioner has failed to exhaust these prescribed remedies. The 1st Respondent contends that the Petition is vexatious, frivolous, and an abuse of the Court process thus depriving this Honourable Court of jurisdiction to entertain the matter at this stage. Consequently, the 1st Respondent prays that the Preliminary Objection be sustained, the Petition be dismissed in its entirety and the costs of both the objection and the Petition be awarded to the 1st Respondent.

14. The Petitioner in his submissions submits that the Notice of Preliminary Objection lacks merit and should be disallowed. He argues that this Court is duly vested with the requisite jurisdiction to hear and determine the matter. Relying on the principles established in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturers Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd (1969) E.A and the case of Owners of the Motor Vessel "Lillian S" v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KECA 48 (KLR), regarding the centrality of jurisdiction, the Petitioner contends that the subject matter falls squarely within the Court's mandate. It is averred that pursuant to Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, this Court possesses the original and appellate jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes relating to land and the environment, including claims for the redress of rights and fundamental freedoms as affirmed in Nicholus v Attorney General & 7 Others [2023] KESC 113 (KLR). Accordingly, the Petitioner maintains that jurisdiction has been sufficiently demonstrated hence the 1st Respondents' objection is devoid of merit.

15. On the issue of whether allowing the Notice of Preliminary Objection will prejudice the Petitioner, it is submitted that the answer is in the positive. The Petitioner contends that permitting the objection would violate his constitutional right to a fair hearing under Article 50, which is a non-derogable principle of natural justice. It is argued that the hardship likely to be occasioned to the Petitioner by denying him the opportunity to prosecute his case on its merits outweighs the prejudice, if any, to the 1st Respondent. Further, that Article 159 mandates the Court to prioritize substantive justice over undue regard for technicalities. Consequently, it is argued that allowing the objection would delay the determination of the matter, thereby denying the Petitioner justice.

Analysis and Determination

16. Flowing from the above and the totality of the material placed before Court, the issues for determination, in my view are;

a. Whether the Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025 is merited?

b. Whether the Application dated 1/10/2024 is merited?

c. Who bears costs?

Whether the Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025 is merited?

17. The parameters of consideration of a Preliminary Objection are now well settled. A Preliminary Objection must only raise issues of law. The principles that the Court is enjoined to apply in determining the merits or otherwise of the Preliminary Objection were set out in the leading case of Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] E.A 696 the celebrated case on Preliminary Objection, it was held as follows:

“… The first matter related to the increasing practice of raising points, which should be argued in the normal manner, quite improperly by way of Preliminary Objection. A Preliminary Objection is in the nature of what used to be a demurrer. It raises a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct. It cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion. The improper raising of points by way of Preliminary Objection does nothing but unnecessarily increase costs and, on occasion, confuse issues. This improper practice should stop.”

18. The Supreme Court in Hassan Ali Joho & Another v Suleiman Said Shabal & 2 Others SCK Petition No. 10 of 2013 [2014] eKLR stated that a Preliminary Objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit.

19. Flowing from the above it emerges that for a Preliminary Objection to succeed the following tests ought to be satisfied: Firstly, it should raise a pure point of law; secondly, it is argued on the assumption that all the facts pleaded by the other side are correct; and finally, it cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion. A valid Preliminary Objection should, if successful, dispose of the suit. See the case of David Karobia Kiiru v Charles Nderitu Gitoi & Another [2008] eKLR.

20. The 1st Respondent raised a Preliminary Objection impugning this Court’s jurisdiction to entertain the instant Application and Petition as filed. It is trite that jurisdiction goes to the root of a matter and as such it is a pure point of law. In the case of celebrated case of Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] eKLR it was stated thus;

“Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a Court has no power to make one more step. Where a Court has no jurisdiction, there would be no basis for a continuation of proceedings pending other evidence. A Court of Law downs tools in respect of the matter before it the moment it holds the opinion that it is without jurisdiction.”

21. The second test for a meritorious Preliminary Objection is it is argued on the assumption that all the facts pleaded by the other side are correct. The Petitioner herein dispute the subject of the Preliminary Objection to the effect that this Court lacks the requisite jurisdiction to hear and determine both the application and Petition. It contends that this Court enjoys original and appellate jurisdiction as vested upon it by the Constitution of Kenya and the Environment and Land Court Act. In so far as he objects to the 1st Respondent’s position in the Preliminary Objection, the second test is thus not met.

22. The third and last test is that an efficacious Preliminary Objection cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion.

23. For the Court to determine the veracity of the Preliminary Objection it has to look into the pleadings vis-à-vis the provisions of the law touching on the subject matter in respect to the doctrine of exhaustion. The Court has to interrogate the pleadings against the orders to make such a determination. This exercise calls for analysis of facts and evidence and thus ousts the third stricture of a successful Preliminary Objection.

24. The totality of the above rendition in particular the second and third tests for a commendable Preliminary Objection, leads to but one conclusion that the Preliminary Objection fails.

25. Ultimately the first issue is answered in the negative.

26. In its submissions, the 1st Respondent challenges the jurisdiction of the Court on account of the doctrine of constitutional avoidance. The doctrine of constitutional avoidance dictates that where a dispute can be effectively resolved under ordinary law, Courts must refrain from converting it into a constitutional question.

27. It is settled law that submissions do not constitute pleadings or evidence. They are simply arguments that parties use to market their idea or issue to the Court. They do not take the place of evidence. Indeed, it was stated by this Court in Patrick Simiyu Khaemba –vs- Kenya Electricity Transmission & another [2021] eKLR as follows: -

“As such, since submissions are “marketing tools” for parties, they must contain what is being marketed… But counsel, and learned for that matter, often market their clients’ issues to judges and judicial officers generally through submissions.”

28. Also, the Court of Appeal in Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi -vs- Mwangi Stephen Muriithi & Another [2014] eKLR stated that:

“Submissions are generally parties’ “marketing language”, each side endeavouring to convince the Court that its case is the better one. Submissions, we reiterate, do not constitute evidence at all. Indeed, there are many cases decided without hearing submissions but based only on evidence presented.”

29. In Nancy Wambui Gatheru vs. Peter W Wanjere Ngugi Nairobi HCCC No. 36 of 1993 his Lordship stated as follows:

“Indeed, and strictly speaking submissions are not part of the evidence in a case. Submissions, to this Court’s view, are a course by which counsel or able litigants focus the Court’s attention on those points of the case that should be given the closest scrutiny in order to firmly establish a claim/charge or disprove it. Once the case is closed a Court may well proceed to give its judgement. There are many cases especially where parties act in person where submissions are not heard. Even some counsel may opt not to submit. So, submissions are not necessarily the case.”

30. From the above decisions, it is evident that submissions do not constitute pleadings or evidence. Therefore, this Court cannot grant an order sought in the submissions which has not been stated in the pleadings, in this case the preliminary objection. Parties are bound by their pleadings and therefore the Court can only determine issues as contained in the pleadings.

Whether the Application dated 1/10/2024 is merited?

31. A conservatory order was defined in the case of Invesco Assurance Co. Ltd vs. MW (Minor suing thro' next friend and mother (HW) [2016] eKLR as follows: -

“A conservatory order is a judicial remedy granted by the Court by way of an undertaking that no action of any kind is taken to preserve the subject until the motion of the suit is heard. It is an order of status quo for the preservation of the subject matter.”

32. The primary constitutional source of power for the grant of conservatory orders is Article 23(3)(c), which expressly authorizes the grant of such orders in proceedings brought under Article 22. Article 22 is deliberately broad: it covers threatened violations and gives standing to persons acting in the interest of groups, classes, associations and the public interest.

33. Courts have time and again held that there is need to exercise caution in dealing with applications for conservatory orders so as not to venture into the arena of the main Petition. See the case of Muslim for Human Rights (Milimani) & 2 Others vs Attorney General & 2 Others (2011) eKLR where the Court held as follows: -

“The Court must be careful for it not to reach final conclusion and to make final findings. By the time the application is decided; all the parties must still have the ability and flexibility to prosecute their cases or present their defences without prejudice. There must be no conclusivity or finality arising that will or may operate adversely vis-a vis the case of either parties. The principle is similar to that in temporary or interlocutory injunctive in civil matters. This is a cardinal principle and happily makes my functions and work here much easier despite walking a tight legal rope that I could easily lose balance with the slightest slip due to any laxity or being carried away by the passion or zeal of persuasion of any one side.”

34. A Court must therefore maintain a delicate balance whenever dealing with a request for conservatory orders.

35. As for the prevailing jurisprudence, it is now established that in the exercise of judicial discretion when entertaining applications for conservatory orders, an applicant must demonstrate that it has a prima facie case with a reasonable prospect of success, demonstrate that the petition has a public interest connotation, show the merit of the case and that, in the absence of such an order, there exists a tangible risk of prejudice resulting from the violation or threatened violation of the Constitution. These principles are non-exhaustive. In reiterating the guiding principles, the Supreme Court of Kenya in Munya v Kithinji & 2 others [2014] KESC 30 (KLR) stated: -

“Conservatory orders, consequently, should be granted on the inherent merit of a case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values, and the proportionate magnitudes, and priority levels attributable to the relevant causes.”

36. Furthermore, the decision in Board of Management of Uhuru Secondary School v. City County Director of Education & 2 others [2015] KEHC 2174 (KLR), examined multiple judicial rulings pertaining to conservatory orders and succinctly summarized the principles as follows:

a) The applicant should present a prima facie case showing a likelihood of success.

b) Demonstrate that without the conservatory orders, there is a likelihood of suffering prejudice.

c) Show evident likelihood of success.

d) Satisfy the Court that if an interim conservatory order is not granted, the petition or its substratum will be rendered nugatory.

e) Show a public interest connotation in the matter.

37. In the matter presently before the Court, the Petitioner contends that he is a bona fide member of the 3rd Respondent Scheme having purchased three plots from its then officials. He deposes that although he is aware of a payout of Kshs. 2,750,000,000/= for the 55 acres, no explanation was offered regarding the balance or the status of his plots, despite numerous attempts to seek clarification from the Secretary, Mr. John Kiyian Karu. He avers that when he subsequently visited the property, he was surprised to realize that all residents had been evicted and bulldozers were on site under heavy police presence.

38. The 1st Respondent on the other hand avers that it already effected payment of the 55 acres it acquired from the 3rd Respondent’s officials hence the application is overtaken by events. The 1st Respondent has adduced a Bank Statement and a copy of the Title in its favour for the acquired parcel.

39. On the face of it, the 1st Respondent already acquired the property and the payment effected. It then follows that the application is overtaken by events. Court orders are not mere suggestions to be issued in vain. The orders sought cannot therefore issue. As to the whether due process was followed in the acquisition is an issue to be determined at trial.

40. Final Orders for disposal: -

a) The Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025 is unmerited. It is dismissed.

b) The Notice of Motion dated 1/10/2024 is unmerited. It is dismissed.

c) Each party shall bear its own costs.

41. It is so ordered

DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.

J G KEMEI

JUDGE

Delivered online in the presence of:

1. N/A for the Petitioner

2. Mr. Ronald Too for the 1st Respondent

3. N/A for the 2nd – 15th Respondents

CA – Mr. Oglen

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder