Background
By an Originating Summons dated 18th July 2025, brought under Order 52 Rule 4(1) (e) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiff seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By an Originating Summons dated 18th July 2025, brought under Order 52 Rule 4(1) (e) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiff seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →In the end, I find that the Originating Summons dated 18th July 2025 partially succeeds on the following terms:
Paragraph 49 →These are matters for the taxing officer, not for this Court in these proceedings. Accordingly, this Court finds that the Defendant holds a lien over the documents, but the extent of the costs secured by that lien remains to be determined through taxation.
Paragraph 42 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC SUIT NO. E044 OF 2025(O.S)
IRERI KARINGI………………………………………………………. PLAINTIFF
-VERSUS-
NGUGI MWANGI T/A
NGUGI MWANGI & CO. ADVOCATES ………………..……. DEFENDANT
JUDGEMENT
1. By an Originating Summons dated 18th July 2025, brought under Order 52 Rule 4(1) (e) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiff seeks the following orders:
a. The Defendant delivers to the Plaintiff the following documents in respect of the sale of one-acre portion of Land Reference Number 21/1/30 (original No. 21/125) now Title No. Nairobi/Block 229/599.
i. Original conveyance.
ii. Copy of the supplemental Agreement duly signed by the Plaintiff and not signed by the Purchaser.
iii. The original transfer in triplicate duly signed by the Plaintiff and not signed by the Purchaser.
iv. A receipt for Kshs. 990,000.00 paid by the Plaintiff to the Defendant as legal fees and disbursements.
b. The Defendant files and taxes his bill in respect of professional services rendered to the Plaintiff in connection with the Agreement for sale of One Acre portion of Land Reference Number 21/1/30 (original No. 21/125) now Title No. Nairobi/Block 229/599 by the Plaintiff to Aurumo Limited.
c. The costs of this summons be paid by the Defendant in any event.
2. The application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of Plaintiff sworn on even date.
THE PLAINTIFF’S CASE
3. The Plaintiff averred that he had instructed the Defendant to act on his behalf in the sale of a one-acre portion of Land Reference Number 21/1/30 (Original No. 21/125) situated in Nairobi. He stated that he handed the Defendant the original conveyance for the property together with other documents.
4. He averred that on 26th March, 2024, the Defendant issued him with a fee note for Kshs. 4,900,000/= for professional services rendered. He stated that he paid the Defendant Kshs. 990,000/= towards legal fees and disbursements, but the Defendant did not issue a receipt.
5. He averred that by a letter dated 7th May, 2025, the Defendant demanded payment of Kshs. 16,240,000/=. He further averred that during the transaction, the Defendant prepared a supplemental agreement and the original transfer in triplicate, both of which he signed, but the purchaser declined to sign them.
6. He averred that, on 5th June 2025, he instructed A.K. Muchiri & Co. Advocates to act on his behalf in the transaction in place of the Defendant. He further averred that, on 10th June 2025, the Defendant forwarded to him the letter and fee note dated 7th May 2025, demanding Kshs. 16,240,000/=.
7. He averred that on 18th June, 2025, his advocates wrote to the Defendant demanding, among other things, that all correspondence be directed to them and that the documents held by the Defendant be released to them. He stated that the Defendant did not respond to that letter but instead wrote directly to him on 10th July, 2025, demanding payment of the sum.
8. He contended that the amount claimed was excessive and inconsistent with the Advocates Remuneration Order. He further contended that the Defendant’s conduct was unbecoming of an advocate, as the Defendant had declined to communicate with his advocates and continued to correspond directly with him despite the withdrawal of instructions.
THE DEFENDANT’S CASE
9. The Defendant filed a Replying Affidavit dated 13th March 2026 in opposition to the Originating Summons. The deponent contends that the suit is misconceived, incompetent, bad in law, and an abuse of the Court process, as the Plaintiff failed to demonstrate any reasonable grounds for the orders sought.
10. He acknowledged that on 16th September, 2022, the Plaintiff instructed him to act on his behalf in various conveyancing and land transactions relating to Land Reference Number 21/1/30 situated at Rosslyn Estate, Nairobi. He stated that, pursuant to those instructions, he rendered extensive professional services, including advising on and securing the subdivision and conversion of the property, ensuring compliance with the Land Registration Act, preparing sale agreements, conducting due diligence, and negotiating and supervising the transactions.
11. He averred that, in accordance with the Plaintiff’s express instructions, he attended more than 20 meetings and negotiations with prospective purchasers and agents regarding the sale, subdivision, development, and joint venture arrangements concerning the suit property and related parcels.
12. He stated that he negotiated, structured and processed eight proposed transactions, including inter alia, the proposed sale of one acre from L.R. No. 21/1/30 for Kshs. 114,000,000/=; the proposed sale of half an acre from L.R No. 21/1/30 to Murunga and Joy Murunga for Kshs. 52,000,000/=; the proposed sale of one acre from L.R No. 21/1/30 to Aurumo Limited for Kshs. 120,000,000/=; the proposed sale of L.R No. Kaagari/Weru/11264 to Kinoti Agostino Kiogora and Karwitha Purity M’Mburugu for Kshs. 1,900,000/=; and other proposed transactions and joint venture arrangements that subsequently fell through.
13. He averred that, in one of the transactions, the parties executed a Supplementary Agreement stipulating that the balance of the purchase price would be paid into his firm’s client account for onward transmission. He maintained that the Plaintiff’s termination of his instructions and purported appointment of another advocate were deliberate attempts to circumvent that arrangement and to avoid payment of the fees owed to his firm.
14. He averred that he had diligently rendered the services and made all relevant documents and instruments available to the Plaintiff for inspection, approval, and execution. He further averred that, despite the substantial work completed, the Plaintiff had made no payment towards his fees, leaving an outstanding balance of Kshs. 16,240,000/=. He further averred that he had issued fee notes and made several written demands, but had received no response.
15. He averred that he held documents relating to the transactions, including original conveyances, titles, agreements and correspondence, which the Plaintiff had voluntarily deposited with his firm during the engagement. He contended that, following the withdrawal of instructions, his firm lawfully exercised an advocate’s lien over the documents pending settlement of the fees. He argued that the Plaintiff’s demand for unconditional release of the documents without payment was unjust, inequitable and contrary to established principles of law and professional practice.
16. He further contended that the suit had been brought in bad faith to frustrate his right to exercise an advocate’s lien. He asserted that the orders sought would condemn him unheard. He argued that, having failed to settle his fees, the Plaintiff had approached the Court with unclean hands and could not invoke its equitable jurisdiction. He also averred that he had never received any communication from the Plaintiff regarding the purported appointment of A.K. Muchiri & Co. Advocates.
17. He contended that the Plaintiff’s suit sought the release of the documents without payment of the fees owed to Counsel, an approach he argued was legally untenable and contrary to established legal principles.
18. The Originating Summons was canvassed by way of written submissions.
THE PLAINTIFF’S SUBMISSIONS
19. The Plaintiff filed his submissions dated 28th May 2026.
20. On behalf of the Plaintiff, Counsel identified the following issues for the Court’s determination:
a) Whether the Defendant was lawfully entitled to withhold the Plaintiff’s original conveyance and related documents;
b) Whether the Defendant’s claim for fees was lawful, ascertainable and enforceable in the absence of taxation or a valid fee agreement; and
c) Whether the Court should order the release of the documents and refer the fees to taxation.
21. Regarding the first issue, Counsel submitted that the Defendant’s claim to retain the Plaintiff’s title documents in respect of unpaid fees amounting to Kshs. 16,240,000/= was misconceived, unsupported by cogent evidence, and contrary to the Advocates Act and the Advocates Remuneration Order. Counsel submitted that the fees had neither been agreed upon nor taxed and therefore remained unascertained and disputed, such that no lien could lawfully attach to the documents. Counsel further submitted that several transactions relied upon by the Defendant had never materialised or were unrelated to legal service. Counsel contended that the Defendant had improperly relied on survey-related activities and preliminary processes undertaken by third parties, without evidence that the Plaintiff had instructed him to undertake them as part of a legal retainer.
22. Counsel further submitted that the Defendant had produced no written retainer, fee agreement, or correspondence establishing the nature and scope of his instructions. Counsel contended that an advocate seeking to recover fees must establish the precise work undertaken and the basis for the claim. Counsel further argued that aborted, speculative, or incomplete negotiations could not give rise to recoverable advocate-client costs, and that the Defendant had produced no executed agreements, completion documents, or registrable instruments.
23. Counsel submitted that, under Section 51 of the Advocates Act and the Advocates Remuneration Order, disputed advocate-client costs must be taxed before they become enforceable. Counsel further submitted that the Defendant had neither filed a bill of costs nor exhibited a fee agreement capable of ousting taxation. Counsel relied on National Bank of Kenya v Kang’ethe George Joseph & Another [2015] eKLR to submit that an advocate’s lien may not be exercised oppressively or in a manner that unjustly prejudices a client’s proprietary rights. Counsel also relied on Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Rachier & Amollo Advocates [2024] KEHC 12108 (KLR) to submit that disputed advocate-client costs are not payable until taxed. Counsel argued that the Plaintiff acted in good faith by paying Kshs. 990,000/=, inviting taxation, and expressing a willingness to pay any amount found to be due, whereas the Defendant bypassed the statutory mechanism while withholding the title documents.
24. Regarding the second issue, Counsel submitted that it was not disputed that the Defendant received the original conveyance in the course of a conveyancing transaction. Counsel reiterated that the Plaintiff had paid Kshs. 990,000/= in fees and disbursements, while the further demand for Kshs. 16,240,000/= was disputed, untaxed, unliquidated and unsupported by a fee agreement. Relying on Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Rachier & Amollo Advocates [2024] KEHC 12108 (KLR), Counsel submitted that an advocate’s fees are not due until a bill of costs has been served and, if unpaid, taxed, and that retaining client property as a lien for undetermined fees is irregular. Counsel contended that the claim was speculative and exaggerated and amounted to an oppressive exercise of the lien.
25. On the third issue, Counsel submitted that Order 52 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the Court to order the delivery of client documents, direct the rendering of accounts, order the taxation of advocate-client costs, and secure payment of any sums found due. Counsel relied on Order 52 Rule 4(3), which permits the Court to order the taxation and payment or securing of costs, and to protect the advocate’s lien, as it deems fit. Counsel cited Ondeng v Okoth t/a GS Okoth Advocates [2025] KEHC (KLR), to submit that advocate-client fee disputes should be resolved through taxation while safeguarding the client’s substantive rights.
THE DEFENDANT’S SUBMISSIONS
26. The Defendant filed its submissions dated 5th July 2026.
27. On behalf of the Defendant, Counsel submitted that the advocate-client relationship and the Defendant's outstanding fees were not in dispute.
28. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff had failed to provide evidence that the fees associated with the transaction had been paid. Accordingly, Counsel submitted that the Defendant was entitled to exercise a lien over the Plaintiff’s title pending payment. Counsel further submitted that the lien secured the outstanding fees, particularly because the Defendant no longer acted on behalf of the Plaintiff and had no other means of recovery.
29. Relying on Booth Extrusions (Formerly Booth Manufacturing Africa Limited) v Dumbeyia Nelson Muturi Harun t/a Nelson Harun & Company Advocates [2014] eKLR, Counsel submitted that an advocate’s general lien entitles the advocate to retain any papers, money, or chattels belonging to a client that come into the advocate’s possession in that capacity until all outstanding costs and charges have been paid. Counsel further submitted that the lien is based on the principle that a client should not benefit from an advocate’s work without paying for it.
30. Counsel submitted that an advocate holding a retaining lien is entitled to retain the documents until the costs have been paid in full. Relying on Re Taylor [1891] 1 Ch 590, Counsel submitted that the lien does not depend on a bill having been rendered, provided the costs have been incurred. Relying on Barratt v Gough-Thomas [1950] 2 All ER 1048, Counsel acknowledged that the lien is passive and confers only a right of retention, and that, once the advocate’s taxable costs have been paid, the client is entitled to delivery of the documents.
31. Counsel submitted that the record contained neither a certificate of taxation nor evidence that the taxed costs had been paid. Accordingly, Counsel argued that the Plaintiff would be required to pay the taxed costs before an order for delivery of the title could be issued. Counsel relied on Clement Munyao Kakenyi v Florence Mwangangi & Company Advocates [2021] KEELC 1570 (KLR), in which the Court dismissed an application for delivery of titles on that basis.
32. Counsel submitted that the present suit violates Articles 47(1) and 159(2)(a) and (b) of the Constitution and Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act, and constitutes an inefficient use of judicial resources. Counsel reiterated the Defendant’s assertions that the outstanding fees amounted to Kshs. 16,240,000/=; that fee notes and demands had been disregarded; and that the documents had been voluntarily deposited with the Defendant’s firm during the engagement and were lawfully held. Counsel further submitted that the suit was brought in bad faith to defeat the Defendant’s lien. Counsel contended that granting the orders sought would condemn the Defendant unheard.
33. Relying on Invesco Assurance Company Ltd v The Nation Media Group, Counsel submitted that the defence of an advocate’s lien could be determined only on its merits at a full hearing, which would involve the examination and cross-examination of witnesses. Counsel submitted that the suit lacks merit and should be dismissed, with costs.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
34. Having considered the Originating Summons, the respective affidavits and the rival submissions, the following issues arise for determination:
a. Whether the Defendant is entitled to retain the Plaintiff’s documents by way of an advocate’s lien.
b. Whether the Court should order the delivery of the documents
c. Whether the Defendant should be directed to file and tax his bill of costs.
WHETHER THE DEFENDANT IS ENTITLED TO RETAIN THE PLAINTIFF’S DOCUMENTS BY WAY OF AN ADVOCATE’S LIEN
35. Order 52, Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the Court, where an advocate-client relationship exists or has existed, to order the delivery of papers and documents to which the client is entitled. It provides as follows:
(1) Where the relationship of advocate and client exists or has existed, the court may, on the application of the client or his legal personal representative, make an order for—
a. the delivery by the advocate of a cash account;
b. the payment or delivery up by the advocate of money or securities;
c. the delivery to the applicant of a list of the money or securities which the advocate has in his possession or control on behalf of the applicant;
d. the payment into or lodging in court of any such money or securities;
e. the delivery up of papers and documents to which the client is entitled.
(2) Applications under this rule shall be by originating summons, supported by affidavit, and shall be served on the advocate.
(3) If the advocate alleges that he has a claim for costs the court may make such order for the taxation and payment, or securing the payment, thereof and the protection of the advocate’s lien, if any, as the court deems fit.
36. It is well established that an advocate has a general retaining lien over a client’s papers, money, and chattels that come into the advocate’s possession in a professional capacity. The advocate may retain these items until the client’s costs have been paid. In Booth Extrusions (Formerly Booth Manufacturing Africa Limited) v Dumbeyia Nelson Muturi Harun t/a Nelson Harun & Company Advocates [2014] eKLR, the Court held that:
“A review of case law in the context of an Advocate – Client relationship, will reveal that there is the general lien which confers upon the advocates the right to retain all papers, money or other chattel the property of their client which came into possession of the advocates as their clients’ advocate until all the costs and charges due to the advocates are paid. The lien is general and not restricted to costs owing in respect to the property which the client is claiming possession. It is simply a retaining lien premised upon the advocate having actual physical possession of the property the subject of the lien.19.The policy underlying liens briefly put is that it would be unfair for a party to enjoy the result of an advocate’s work without paying the advocate and then let the advocate seek payment elsewhere when payment could be easily gathered through the lien. Consequently, an advocate having a retaining lien over documents in her or his possession is entitled to retain the documents against the client until the full amount of his costs is paid: see Barrat –v- Gough Thomas [1950]2 All ER 1048, 1053. Provided that the costs in question have been incurred, the existence of the lien arguably does not rest upon a bill having been rendered to the client: see Re Taylor [1891] 1Ch 590, 596. In so much however as the lien protects the advocate, the general lien confers only a right to retain property. It exists for no other purpose. It is merely passive and “the solicitor [advocate] has no right of actively enforcing his demand”: see Barrat –v- Gough Thomas [1950] 2All ER 1048, 10563. Once the Advocates’ taxable costs, charges and expenses are paid the client is no doubt entitled to an order for the delivery up of the retained documents.20. The foregoing is a brief restatement of the nature of an advocate lien as founded on various common law cases and may be continued if one asks when the lien ceases.”
37. In the matter at hand, the advocate-client relationship is admitted. It is not in dispute that the original conveyance came into the Defendant’s possession in the course of the conveyancing transaction for which he was retained. The Defendant prepared the supplemental agreement and the transfer pursuant to the same retainer. Accordingly, the Defendant holds the documents in his professional capacity, and a lien may attach to them.
38. The Plaintiff contends that no lien can attach to the documents because the fees have neither been agreed nor taxed. This Court is not persuaded that the absence of taxation extinguishes the lien. The lien attaches to costs incurred, whether or not a bill has been rendered. However, the absence of taxation means that the amount claimed under the lien remains unascertained and disputed.
39. In John Karungari Nyamu & another (2008) eKLR, Lesiit J. opined that:
“… I agree with the learned Judge’s holding that the Advocates fee only becomes due after the Bill of Costs has been taxed by the Court. Before the Bill is taxed, there is no telling how much is due to the Advocate. The position is therefore that an advocate cannot exercise lien over client’s money on basis of a Bill of Costs that is yet to be taxed.”
40. In the present matter, the lien is exercised over the Plaintiff’s documents rather than his funds. The principle that taxation determines the costs payable to an Advocate is equally applicable.
41. The Defendant claims Kshs. 16,240,000/=, whereas his earlier fee note, dated 26th March 2024, was for Kshs. 4,900,000/=. The Plaintiff produced an RTGS confirmation evidencing payment of Kshs. 990,000/=, which the Defendant disputes. A substantial portion of the Defendant’s claim relates to transactions that were not completed, and it remains disputed whether those transactions fall within the scope of the retainer.
42. These are matters for the taxing officer, not for this Court in these proceedings. Accordingly, this Court finds that the Defendant holds a lien over the documents, but the extent of the costs secured by that lien remains to be determined through taxation.
WHETHER THE DOCUMENTS SHOULD BE DELIVERED
43. Order 52 Rule 4(3) recognises the need to balance the protection of an advocate’s lien against the client’s right to access their documents. The Court may order the delivery of those documents while ensuring that the advocate’s costs are secured.
44. The Defendant ceased acting for the Plaintiff in June 2025. The Defendant neither submitted a bill of costs for taxation nor produced a fee agreement that would preclude taxation. In the meantime, the Plaintiff is unable to deal with his property without the original conveyance. The Plaintiff has also expressed his willingness to have the fees taxed and to pay any amount found to be due.
45. In these circumstances, it would be oppressive to permit the Defendant to retain the documents indefinitely. Conversely, it would be unjust to order their unconditional release while the Defendant’s claim for costs remains undetermined. Accordingly, the appropriate course is to order delivery of the documents upon the Plaintiff’s furnishing security for the Defendant’s costs, pending taxation.
46. The Defendant contended that the defence of a lien may be determined only at a full hearing and that the orders sought would condemn him unheard. Order 52 Rule 4 provides that these questions may be determined summarily by an originating summons. The Defendant has had the opportunity to be heard through his replying affidavit and submissions. Accordingly, that contention is without merit.
47. With respect to the receipt for Kshs. 990,000/=, whether the amount was paid and the purpose of the payment remain disputed. Taxation is the appropriate forum for determining this issue, and any sums proven to have been paid will be taken into account.
WHETHER THE DEFENDANT SHOULD FILE AND TAX HIS BILL OF COSTS
48. The Plaintiff seeks an order that the Defendant file and tax his bill of costs. The Defendant asserts that his fees remain unpaid and undetermined. Taxation is the legal mechanism for ascertaining an advocate’s costs where fees are disputed, and no agreement on fees exists. Both parties will benefit from ascertaining the amount. This prayer is therefore merited.
49. In the end, I find that the Originating Summons dated 18th July 2025 partially succeeds on the following terms:
a. The Defendant shall file and serve an advocate-client bill of costs for the professional services rendered to the Plaintiff in connection with Land Reference Number 21/1/30 (Original No. 21/125), now Title No. Nairobi/Block 229/599, within thirty (30) days of this ruling. The bill shall be taxed by the Deputy Registrar of this court.
b. The Plaintiff shall, within 30 days of this ruling, deposit the sum of Kshs. Kshs. 4 million in court as security for the Defendant’s costs, pending taxation.
c. Within 7 days of the deposit, the Defendant shall deliver the following documents to the Plaintiff’s advocates on record:
i. the original conveyance;
ii. the supplemental agreement executed by the Plaintiff; and
iii. the original transfer in triplicate executed by the Plaintiff.
d. If the Defendant fails to file his bill of costs within the time allowed, he shall deliver the documents to the Plaintiff’s advocates unconditionally, and the security shall be released to the Plaintiff.
e. Each party shall bear its own costs.
JUDGMENT SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
…………………………………….
HON. T. MURIGI
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Duncan Otieno for the Plaintiff
Chebii for the Defendant
Vena –Court assistant