Background
This Ruling concerns the Defendants’ Preliminary Objection dated 24/6/2026.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This Ruling concerns the Defendants’ Preliminary Objection dated 24/6/2026.
Paragraph 1 →Having considered the preliminary objection and the rival submissions thereto, I am of the view thatthe issues for determination are;a. Whether the preliminary objection raises pure points of law;b. Whether the Preliminary Objection is res judicata.c. Which orders should the Court issue?https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 3
Paragraph 13 →Kabiti & 3 others v Vekaria & another (Environment and Land Case
E319 of 2024) [2026] KEELC 7371 (KLR) (30 October 2026) (Ruling)
Neutral citation: [2026] KEELC 7371 (KLR)
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ENVIRONMENT AND LAND CASE E319 OF 2024
JG KEMEI, J
OCTOBER 30, 2026
BETWEEN
NELSON MUTUMA KABITI ............................................................. 1ST PLAINTIFF
JACOB KAMBO GAKUYA ................................................................. 2ND PLAINTIFF
MARY KAIMURI MURUNGI ........................................................... 3RD PLAINTIFF
RODAH KEMUNYO ........................................................................... 4TH PLAINTIFF
AND
RAMJI DEVJI VEKARIA ................................................................ 1ST DEFENDANT
VICTORIA COMMERCIAL BANK .............................................. 2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
(In respect of the Defendants’ Preliminary Objection dated 24/6/2026)
1. This Ruling concerns the Defendants’ Preliminary Objection dated 24/6/2026.
2. As noted in the Ruling delivered on 25/11/2024, the Plaintifis' claim rests on ownership of various
parcels of land in the Mukuru Imara section of Nairobi County, which they acquired between 2001
and 2003 under the Flood Victims Rehabilitation Project following heavy rains.
3. They contend that the government agencies devised a project to relocate afiected families to adjacent,
unallocated government land and organised the afiected residents into a Community Structure to
facilitate the survey, subdivision, numbering, and allocation of approximately 96 parcels. They further
state that, after receiving ownership certifficates and taking open, continuous, and uninterrupted
possession of their respective plots, they developed low-cost housing units valued at more than Kshs.
23,000,000. They assert that these developments were undertaken with the knowledge of government
authorities and that no adverse claims had been made or Court proceedings initiated previously.
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 1
4. The Plaintifis aver that the 1st Defendant is threatening to evict them on the basis that it holds title to
the land in question. The Plaintifis state that they recently discovered that the 1st Defendant holds titles
for LR. Nos. 209/10307 and 209/10308, and that a charge was created in favour of the 2nd Defendant
Bank in 2012. The Plaintifis argue that, if the 1st Defendant is indeed the title holder, it has lost its rights
to the land by adverse possession, as the Plaintifis have occupied the land openly and notoriously for 21
to 23 years without interruption or legal action by the Defendants. Furthermore, the Plaintifis allege
that the 2nd Defendant Bank failed to conduct due diligence or a ground valuation before charging the
property, and that the charge is null and void ab initio, having been executed in fraudulent conspiracy
to defeat the Plaintifis' acquired rights.
5. It is on that basis that the Plaintifis pray for Judgment against the Defendants as follows;
a. A declaration that the Plaintifis have by virtue of Adverse Possession acquired the right and
title in respect of their respective plot of land acquired and occupied and being part of LR.
Nos. 209/10307 and 209/10308 and are therefore entitled to exclusive permanent occupation,
ownership and title to the said parcels as occupied.
b. A declaration that the charge of LR Nos. 209/10307 and 209/10308 in favour of the 2nd
Defendant was clandestine, illegal and was without due diligence and borne out of a fraudulent
conspiracy to defeat the Plaintifis right and title to the property by dint of Adverse Possession
therefore null and avoid and the charge should by order of this Court be deregistered from LR.
Nos. 209/10307 and 209/10308 as to allow the transfer of the land to the Plaintifis.
c. An order directing the 1st Defendant to sign and transfer LR. Nos. 209/10307 and 209/10308
and/or the subdivided portion of the land as occupied by the Plaintifis in favour of the
Plaintifis as the title holders of the stated parcel of land by dint of Adverse Possession.
d. That in default of signing the transfer of title or transfer and title documents in respect of the
subdivided portions as owned by the Plaintifis by the 1st Defendant, the Deputy Registrar of
the Court be authorized to execute such transfers/forms for and on behalf of the 1st Defendant
and the 2nd Defendants as to cause the Plaintifis to obtain their titles to the land.
e. The Defendants do meet the costs of this case.
6. In their Statement of Defence and Counterclaim dated 20/9/2024, the 1st Defendant asserts that
he is the sole registered and absolute owner of the suit properties, L.R. NO. 209/10307 and L.R.
NO. 209/10308, having acquired them for valuable consideration. He avers that the Plaintifis' claim
for adverse possession is entirely misplaced and speculative, as the Plaintifis are trespassers who
entered the land by force and without any legitimate claim of right. The Defendant states that the
Plaintifis' alleged developments were carried out illegally and with full knowledge of his proprietary
interest. Furthermore, he contends that the Plaintifis' allegations of prior entry constitute fraudulent
misrepresentations, noting that the Plaintifis previously responded to their eviction notices and were
parties to a prior suit (Nairobi ELC NO. 459 of 2018), which was adjudicated in the 1st Defendant's
favour on 24/4/2024.
7. Consequently, the 1st Defendant maintains that the Plaintifis' suit is misguided, brought in bad faith,
and fails to disclose a reasonable cause of action. He claims that the Plaintifis' illegal occupation has
deprived him of the use of his property, prompting a counterclaim for mesne proffits from 2008 to date.
The 1st Defendant denies any wrongdoing, invites the Plaintifis to prove their allegations on the strictest
possible footing, and prays that the suit be dismissed with costs and that the Plaintifis be evicted from
the suit properties.
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 2
8. On that basis, the Defendants raise the instant objection under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act
and pray that the suit be struck out on the grounds that;
a. The suit before Court is Res judicata and should be struck out with costs on the Defendant.
b. The matter in issue in this case is directly and substantially the same as in case – Nairobi ELC
NO. 459 OF 2018 (O.S) – Raphael Nzamu Mwendo & 4 Others –versus- Ramji Devji Vekaria
& Victoria Commercial Bank Limited in which case has been heard and ffinally decided by this
honourable Court. (a copy already ffiled in Court together with bundles of documents).
9. The Court directed that the Preliminary Objection be canvassed by way of written submissions. Both
parties complied. The Defendant/Objectors' submissions are dated 24/6/2026, whereas the Plaintifis’
submissions are dated 15/9/2026.
The 1st Defendant’s submissions
10. The 1st Defendant/ Objector submits that the present suit mirrors a previously determined
representative suit, Nairobi ELC No. 459 of 2018 (O.S), which was ffiled on behalf of over 90 families,
including the current Plaintifis. He argues that a competent Court heard and concluded the former
matter, with no appeal lodged, and that the parties herein are identical to those in the prior litigation.
The 1st Defendant highlights the orders sought in the previous suit, which include adverse possession
and a permanent injunction, and submits that the Plaintifis in the instant suit seek corresponding
reliefs, speciffically a declaration that they have acquired the right and title to their respective plots by
adverse possession. He further submits that the Plaintifis pray for an order to deregister a charge held by
the 2nd Defendant, which they allege was created clandestinely and illegally to defeat their proprietary
rights.
11. The 1st Defendant therefore argues that the instant suit is barred by res judicata, as the parties
and subject matter are identical to those in a prior suit already adjudicated by a competent Court;
accordingly, the Defendant prays that the suit be dismissed with costs.
The Plaintifis’ submissions
12. The Plaintifis vehemently oppose the Defendants' Preliminary Objection on the ground of res
judicata, submitting that the objection is misconceived and fails to satisfy the mandatory, conjunctive
legal prerequisites under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. The Plaintifis assert that they are
independent litigants and strangers to the previously concluded case, so the parties are neither identical
nor litigating under the same title, and the current issue regarding the acquisition of title by adverse
possession has never been litigated. Therefore, the Plaintifis pray that the Preliminary Objection be
dismissed with costs.
Analysis and Determination
13. Having considered the preliminary objection and the rival submissions thereto, I am of the view that
the issues for determination are;
a. Whether the preliminary objection raises pure points of law;
b. Whether the Preliminary Objection is res judicata.
c. Which orders should the Court issue?
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 3
Whether the preliminary objection raises pure points of law;
14. The starting point is to deffine what a preliminary objection is. On what constitutes a Preliminary
Objection, in the case of Hassan Ali Joho & Another -Vs- Suleiman Said Shabal & 2 others SCK
Petition No. 12013[2014] eKLR, the Supreme Court restated the deffinition in the case Mukisa Biscuit
Manufacturers Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd (1969) E.A where the Court of Appeal said that:
“…a Preliminary Objection is in the nature of what used to be a demurrer. It raises a pure
point of law which is argued on the assumption that all the facts pleaded by the other side
are correct. It cannot be raised if any fact needs to be ascertained or if what is sought is the
exercise of judicial discretion.”
15. Prior to determining a question raised as a Preliminary point, the Court is required to ffirst satisfy itself
that the issue raises a pure point of law.
16. The required threshold for distinguishing between questions of law and fact for purposes of sustaining
a preliminary objection as is also a point that is well crystalized. In the case of George Oraro –vs- Eston
Mbaja [2005] eKLR where the Court held that: -
“A preliminary objection is … declared to be a point of law which must not be blurred with
factual details liable to be contested and in any event, to be proved through the processes of
evidence. Any assertion which claims to be a preliminary objection, and yet it bears factual
aspects calling for proof, or seeks to adduce evidence for its authentication, is not, as a matter
of legal principle, a true preliminary objection which the Court should allow to proceed…”
17. The Objector contends that the suit that the present suit mirrors a previously determined
representative suit, Nairobi ELC No. 459 of 2018 (O.S) over the suit property herein was the subject
matter against the same parties. That hence the instant suit is res judicata.
18. The principle of res judicata is provided in Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act as follows:
“No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has
been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between
parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court
competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently
raised, and has been heard and ffinally decided by such Court.”
19. In Henry Wanyama Khaemba –vs- Standard Chartered Bank Ltd & Another (2014) eKLR, where the
Court pronounced itself as follows:-
“The issues of res judicata, duplicity of suits and suit having been spent will require probing
of evidence as it is already evident from the submissions by the 1st Defendant. They are
incapable of being handled as Preliminary Objections because of the limited scope of
jurisdiction on Preliminary Objections.”
20. I am further persuaded by the Court’s holding in George Kamau Kimani & 4 Others Vs County
Government of Trans Nzoia & Another (2014) eKLR, where the Court considering an objection on
the issue of res judicata stated: -
“All those points can be argued in the normal manner. They do not qualify to be raised
as Preliminary Points. One cannot raise a ground of res judicata by way of Preliminary
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 4
Objection. The best way to raise a ground of res judicata is by way of Notice of Motion
where pleadings are amended to enable the Court to determine whether the current suit is
res judicata.”
21. In the instant suit, I am of the view that the issues in the Defendants’ preliminary objection do not
qualify to be raised as preliminary points. They are not pure points of law but consist of issues of
contested facts that invite the Court to analyse facts and exercise its discretion.
22. Final orders for disposal
a. In view of the foregoing, the 1st Defendant’s Preliminary Objection dated 24/6/2026 is
incompetent.
b. It is dismissed with costs to the Plaintifis.
23. It is so ordered
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA
MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J. G. KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
Mr Wanyangu HB for Mr Namada for the Plaintifis
Ms Ilabonga HB for Mr Kimani for the Defendants.
CA- Mr Oglen
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7371/eng@2026-10-30 5