Small Claims

Mogo Auto Llimited v Nyumbah [2026] SCC 35 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Thika
Case number
SCCCOMM/E1939/2025
Judgment date
2 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment was entered for the claimant, but only for Ksh 100,631, representing the outstanding principal after credited repayments. Interest on that sum accrues at the court rate from the respondent’s last loan payment until full payment. The claimant was awarded Ksh 20,000 costs, and execution was stayed for 30 days.

Supporting judgment passages

a) Judgement is hereby entered in favour of the claimant as against the respondent for Ksh 100,631

Passage 43 →

b) That interests on ksh 100,631/= shall accrue at court’s rate from the date of the last payment of the loan by the respondent until payment in full.

Passage 44 →

c) That the claimant is granted costs of ksh 20,000/=

Passage 45 →
Issue 1Whether the claimant proved its claim.

Held. Only in part. The loan advance and the respondent’s repayments were undisputed, but the claimant did not prove its claims for penalties, the asserted unpaid-principal figure of Ksh 492,132, or monitoring and insurance fees. No contractual clause authorising penalties was identified, and the claimant did not explain or prove the calculations underlying the other claimed sums.

Ratio. A claimant bears the burden of proving contractual charges and the calculations underlying amounts claimed. The court will not speculate or perform unsupported calculations that may prejudice the opposing party.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

a) Whether the claimant proved its claim.

Passage 23 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

18. Consequently, regarding the claim for penalties, this Court finds that the claimant failed to discharge its burden of proof.

Paragraph 18 →

20. Even after converting the said sums using prevailing exchange rates at the time since the loan seems to have been tabulated in dollars, the figures do not appear to correspond with the amount claimed. During the hearing, this Court was not taken through the calculations leading to the said figure and therefore declines to speculate.

Paragraph 20 →

21. On the issue of the monitoring fees, and the insurance fees, although pleaded, the court was not taken through the sums as contained in the statement of claim to know how the sums pleaded were arrived at, it is not for the court to speculate or tabulate for itself as that would be prejudicial to the respondent. On that note those claims fail.

Paragraph 21 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

18. Consequently, regarding the claim for penalties, this Court finds that the claimant failed to discharge its burden of proof.

Paragraph 18 →

20. Even after converting the said sums using prevailing exchange rates at the time since the loan seems to have been tabulated in dollars, the figures do not appear to correspond with the amount claimed. During the hearing, this Court was not taken through the calculations leading to the said figure and therefore declines to speculate.

Paragraph 20 →

21. On the issue of the monitoring fees, and the insurance fees, although pleaded, the court was not taken through the sums as contained in the statement of claim to know how the sums pleaded were arrived at, it is not for the court to speculate or tabulate for itself as that would be prejudicial to the respondent. On that note those claims fail.

Paragraph 21 →
Issue 2Whether the in duplum rule applies to the claimant.

Held. Yes. The in duplum rule applies to the claimant, so total recoverable interest cannot exceed the principal amount advanced.

Ratio. The court treated the in duplum rule as a matter of public interest applicable to entities lending money, not only banks.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

b) Whether the in duplum rule applies to the claimant.

Passage 24 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

23. Consequently, this Court finds that the in duplum rule applies to the claimant and therefore the total interest recoverable shall not exceed the principal amount advanced.

Paragraph 23 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

"In this regard, I hold that being of public interest, the in duplum rule will be applicable for those lending monies as it does to banks."

Passage 38 →

23. Consequently, this Court finds that the in duplum rule applies to the claimant and therefore the total interest recoverable shall not exceed the principal amount advanced.

Paragraph 23 →
Issue 3Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Held. Only partially. The contractual interest rate—effectively 86.4% exclusive of other charges—was exorbitant and exploitative, but the respondent remained indebted. The court awarded the claimant Ksh 100,631, with interest at the court rate from the date of the last payment until settlement, plus Ksh 20,000 costs; execution was stayed for 30 days.

Ratio. Although courts ordinarily enforce freely made contracts, they may decline to enforce interest terms that are exploitative, unconscionable, or oppressive. A creditor should not, however, be denied recovery of the genuine unpaid debt merely because excessive contractual charges are disallowed.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

c) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Passage 25 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

24. On the final issue of whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought, this Court finds that the interest charged was exorbitant. An effective interest rate of 86.4%, exclusive of additional charges, is nothing short of exploitative.

Paragraph 24 →

25. Nevertheless, this Court equally acknowledges that the respondent remains indebted to the claimant and therefore the claimant cannot be denied recovery altogether.

Paragraph 25 →

a) Judgement is hereby entered in favour of the claimant as against the respondent for Ksh 100,631

Passage 43 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

16. In my view, the interest charged on the loan is disproportionate and closely borders on being oppressive. This Court is alive to the principle that it is ordinarily not the role of courts to rewrite contracts freely entered into by parties. Nevertheless, courts should not shy away from interfering where contractual terms become exploitative, unconscionable or oppressive as was held by the Court of Appeal in NATIONAL BANK OF KENYA LTD VS PIPEPLASTIC SAMKOLIT (K) LTD, CIVIL APPEAL NO. 95 OF 1999 where the Court stated:

Paragraph 16 →

24. On the final issue of whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought, this Court finds that the interest charged was exorbitant. An effective interest rate of 86.4%, exclusive of additional charges, is nothing short of exploitative.

Paragraph 24 →

25. Nevertheless, this Court equally acknowledges that the respondent remains indebted to the claimant and therefore the claimant cannot be denied recovery altogether.

Paragraph 25 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Debt, when left unattended, can quietly grow in the shadows into amounts that are mind- boggling. However, while courts exist to enforce obligations willingly entered into by parties, they equally bear the duty of ensuring that debt recovery does not become an instrument of oppression through the unchecked accumulation of interest and charges.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

On the issue of penalties and fines, during the hearing, the claimant’s witness was unable to point this Court to the specific clause providing for penalties in the documents filed before Court. This Court equally scrutinized the loan agreement and was unable to identify any clause expressly providing for such penalties.

Paragraph 17 →

Reasoning passage

Having carefully analyzed the pleadings, evidence and submissions by parties during the hearing, this Court finds that the following issues arise for determination:

Paragraph 12 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether Mogo Auto Limited had proved its claim for Kshs. 677,381; whether the in duplum rule applied to the claimant’s lending arrangement; and whether the claimant was entitled to the remedies sought. The central dispute concerned the…

Material facts

Mogo Auto Limited advanced Aziz Daniel Odoyo Nyumbah Kshs. 400,000 under an asset-financing agreement dated 7 June 2022. The logbook for motor vehicle KBU 973X was jointly registered in their names as security. The respondent admitted borrowing Kshs. 400,000…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT KIAMBU COUNTY COURT NAME: THIKA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E1939/2025

MOGO AUTO LIMITED 1st Claimant

- Versus -

AZIZ DANIEL ODOYO NYUMBAH 1st Respondent

JUDGMENT

A. INTRODUCTION.

1. Debt, when left unattended, can quietly grow in the shadows into amounts that are mind- boggling. However, while courts exist to enforce obligations willingly entered into by parties, they equally bear the duty of ensuring that debt recovery does not become an instrument of oppression through the unchecked accumulation of interest and charges.

2. The matter before this Court is fairly straightforward. Through a Statement of Claim dated 27th October, 2025, the claimant seeks judgment against the respondent in the sum of Kshs. 677,381/= together with interest and costs of the suit.

3. The claimant alleges that on 7th June, 2022, it entered into an asset financing agreement with the respondent whereby it advanced him a loan facility of Kshs. 400,000/= and, as security, the logbook of Motor Vehicle Registration Number KBU 973X was jointly

registered in the names of the claimant and the respondent.

4. The claimant further states that the respondent made payments amounting to Kshs. 299,369/= before defaulting and that the security allegedly went missing, thereby frustrating its ability to exercise its right of sale and recover the outstanding sums.

5. Consequently, the claimant contends that the respondent presently owes it Kshs. 677,381/=

6. The respondent filed a Response to the Claim dated 3rd February, 2026 wherein he admits obtaining a loan facility of Kshs. 400,000/=from the claimant and making repayments amounting to Kshs. 299,369/=, leaving, according to him, a balance of Kshs. 100,631/=. He denies owing the claimant Kshs. 677,381./=

7. The respondent argues that the claimant is now demanding a total of Kshs. 976,750/= in order to fully redeem a loan of Kshs. 400,000/= and contends that the claimant is not permitted to levy interest beyond permissible rates.

8. He further argues that he never agreed to any fines or penalties under the agreement and therefore prays that the claim for Kshs. 677,381/= be dismissed.

9. The matter proceeded for hearing by way of viva voce evidence. The claimant called one witness, its Customer Operations Manager, who adopted his witness statement, produced the claimant’s documents and, upon cross-examination, testified that the claimant charged interest at the rate of 2.4% per month. He further testified that the respondent owed the claimant Kshs. 677,381/=and confirmed that the claimant still retained the original logbook.

10. The respondent equally testified and substantially repeated the contents of his response to the claim and therefore this Court shall not unnecessarily reproduce the same.

11. During cross-examination, he admitted defaulting in repayment and stated that he was willing to pay Kshs. 200,000/= within thirty-five (35) days from the end of May. 2026.

B. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION.

12. Having carefully analyzed the pleadings, evidence and submissions by parties during the hearing, this Court finds that the following issues arise for determination:

a) Whether the claimant proved its claim.

b) Whether the in duplum rule applies to the claimant.

c) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

13. On the first issue, it is not disputed that the claimant advanced a loan facility of Kshs. 400,000/= to the respondent. The dispute revolves around the interest charged, penalties imposed and additional sums claimed.

14. The evidence on record demonstrates that by the time the respondent defaulted, he had already paid Kshs. 299,369/=. The claimant testified through its Operations manager that interest was charged at the rate of 2.4% per month on a flat rate basis over a period of thirty-six (36) months.

15. A simple mathematical calculation demonstrates that by the expiry of the thirty-six months, the respondent would have paid interest amounting to approximately 86.4%, exclusive of additional charges contained in the agreement.

16. In my view, the interest charged on the loan is disproportionate and closely borders on being oppressive. This Court is alive to the principle that it is ordinarily not the role of courts to rewrite contracts freely entered into by parties. Nevertheless, courts should not shy away from interfering where contractual terms become exploitative, unconscionable or oppressive as was held by the Court of Appeal in NATIONAL BANK OF KENYA LTD VS PIPEPLASTIC SAMKOLIT (K) LTD, CIVIL APPEAL NO. 95 OF 1999 where the Court stated:

"A court of law cannot rewrite a contract with regard to interest as parties are bound by the terms of their contract. Nevertheless, courts have never been shy to interfere with or refuse to enforce contracts which are unconscionable, unfair or oppressive due to procedural abuse..."

17. On the issue of penalties and fines, during the hearing, the claimant’s witness was unable to point this Court to the specific clause providing for penalties in the documents filed before Court. This Court equally scrutinized the loan agreement and was unable to identify any clause expressly providing for such penalties.

18. Consequently, regarding the claim for penalties, this Court finds that the claimant failed to discharge its burden of proof.

19. Regarding the claim for unpaid principal, the claimant seeks Kshs. 492,132/=. This Court is unable to understand how the claimant arrived at this figure. The principal amount

advanced was Kshs. 400,000/= together with application fees of USD 342.2 and loan processing fees of USD 170 which as per the loan agreement were to be added to the principal.

20. Even after converting the said sums using prevailing exchange rates at the time since the loan seems to have been tabulated in dollars, the figures do not appear to correspond with the amount claimed. During the hearing, this Court was not taken through the calculations leading to the said figure and therefore declines to speculate.

21. On the issue of the monitoring fees, and the insurance fees, although pleaded, the court was not taken through the sums as contained in the statement of claim to know how the sums pleaded were arrived at, it is not for the court to speculate or tabulate for itself as that would be prejudicial to the respondent. On that note those claims fail.

22. On whether the in duplum rule applies to the claimant, this Court relies on the decision of Mabeya J in MUGURE & 2 OTHERS V HIGHER EDUCATION LOANS BOARD (PETITION E002 OF 2021), where he stated:

"In this regard, I hold that being of public interest, the in duplum rule will be applicable for those lending monies as it does to banks."

23. Consequently, this Court finds that the in duplum rule applies to the claimant and therefore the total interest recoverable shall not exceed the principal amount advanced.

24. On the final issue of whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought, this Court finds that the interest charged was exorbitant. An effective interest rate of 86.4%, exclusive of additional charges, is nothing short of exploitative.

25. Nevertheless, this Court equally acknowledges that the respondent remains indebted to the claimant and therefore the claimant cannot be denied recovery altogether.

26. Having taken note that Ksh 400,000/= was advanced and Ksh 299,367/= has been paid by the respondent, the court makes the final disposition as follows.

a) Judgement is hereby entered in favour of the claimant as against the respondent for Ksh 100,631

b) That interests on ksh 100,631/= shall accrue at court’s rate from the date of the last payment of the loan by the respondent until payment in full.

c) That the claimant is granted costs of ksh 20,000/=

d) There shall be 30 days stay of execution.

Orders accordingly.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT THIKA THIS 2ND DAY OF JUNE 2026.

SIGNED BY/FOR:

★ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. JAMLICK MURIITHI MWENDA

Thika Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-02 16:42:52

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder