REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. E024 OF 2026
EAST CHURCH FLATS LIMITED - APPLICANT
VS
ARUN MAHENDRA ADALJA - 1ST RESPONDENT
DR. RAJNKANT PRABHULAL SHAH - 2ND RESPONDENT
SOPHINAH KALONDU MBITI - 3RD RESPONDENT
RULING
(In respect of the 1st Respondent’s applications dated 25/6/2026 and 29/6/2026 respectively as well as the Preliminary Objection dated 29/6/2026)
1. The Applicant, by the Originating Summons dated 8/6/2026, against Arun Mahendra Adalja, Dr. Rajnikant Prabhulal Shash and Sophinah Kalondu Mbiti, the 1st to 3rd Respondents herein, claims approval of a contract of sale over LR No. NAIROBI/BLOCK 4/89 (Original No. 1870/VI/61) dated 23/10/2025, and has therefore brought this Summons for determination of the following questions:
a. Should this Honourable Court order the Deputy Registrar to execute the surrender of lease of Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja (deceased) to facilitate the registration of the surrender of lease?
b. Should This Honourable court order the Land Registrar to register the surrender of lease of Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja (deceased) entry No. 3 dated 16/7/2003 known as all that one type “C” Flat No. 4 in Block “4”as shown in the plan regal in Vo. “B2” Folio 176/166 in LR No. NAIROBI/BLOCK4/89?
c. Is the Applicant entitled to the sale and transfer of the Land known as LR No. NAIROBI /BLOCK4/89 to the Purchaser, Morning Light Apartment Limited?
d. What other Order is just and mete in the circumstances of this suit?
e. Who is to bear the costs of this suit?
2. The summons is based on the grounds set out on the face of it and is supported by the Affidavit of Marco Carolei, dated the same day. The Applicant seeks the court's approval to execute the surrender of a lease and to transfer the property known as Unit C-4 in Block A, situated on L.R. No. 1870/VI/61 (now Nairobi/Block 4/89), which forms part of an 11-unit development. The registered proprietor and developer, having secured consent from the other ten-unit owners, has agreed to sell the entire land and units to a third party, Morning Light Apartment Limited, for Kshs. 710,000,000. It is alleged that completion of this sale has been hindered because one of the leaseholders, Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja (Deceased), has no appointed administrator or executor. That the deceased's beneficiaries, the 1st and 3rd Respondents, are engaged in a pending succession dispute regarding the deceased's estate. To prevent the collapse of the entire sale and substantial loss to the parties, the Applicant prays that the court authorise the Deputy Registrar to execute the surrender on behalf of the deceased's estate and direct the Land Registrar to register the transfer, with the deceased's share of the proceeds, amounting to Kshs. 64,545,454, to be deposited in court or in a joint interest-earning account pending the determination of the succession cause.
3. In opposition to the application, the 1st Respondent filed Notices of Motion dated 25/6/2026 and 29/6/2026, respectively, together with a Preliminary Objection dated 29/6/2026. These applications and the Preliminary Objection are the subject of this Ruling.
Application dated 25/6/2026
4. The application is grounded on the provisions of Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution of Kenya, Section 45 of the Law of Succession Act, Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2011, Section 3A and Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act, and Orders 2 Rule 15, 5 Rules 21 to 29, and 51 Rules 1 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules. In the main, the 1st Respondent prays for orders that;
a. The Originating Summons dated 8/6/2026, together with all consequential proceedings and applications thereto, be struck out and/or dismissed with costs.
b. In the alternative to prayer number 2 above, these proceedings be stayed pending the hearing and determination of the 3rd Respondent's pending application within Nairobi High Court Succession Cause No. 315 of 2018 seeking authority to deal with and dispose of flat No. 4 (Type C) in Block A constructed on L.R. No. 1870/VI/61 (Nairobi/Block 4/89).
c. The costs of this application and of the Originating Summons be borne by the Applicant.
5. The application is based on the grounds on its face and on the 1st Respondent’s supporting affidavit of even date. The 1st Respondent, the son of the deceased, Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja, opposes the Applicant’s Originating Summons seeking to dispose of the deceased’s leasehold interest in Flat No. 4, Block A (Nairobi/Block 4/89). The Respondent asserts that no personal representative or administrator has been appointed to the estate, which remains the subject of a pending succession cause (Nairobi High Court Succession Cause No. 315 of 2018). Accordingly, the Applicant, the 3rd Respondent, and their purported purchaser, Morning Light Apartment Limited, lack the legal authority to deal with, transfer, or surrender assets of the estate. Such actions would constitute unlawful intermeddling under section 45 of the Law of Succession Act.
6. The Respondent further contends that the present proceedings constitute an abuse of the court process, noting that the 3rd Respondent has already filed a substantially similar application seeking the sale of the flat, which remains pending before the Family Division. The Respondent also alleges that the 3rd Respondent, having previously challenged the validity of the deceased’s will, acted inconsistently by purporting to authorise the sale at a general meeting, allegedly in breach of a restraining order issued against her in 2018. The Respondent argues that the Application amounts to impermissible forum shopping, as it was filed without material disclosure of the pending succession proceedings, which have exclusive jurisdiction to determine matters concerning estate property. The deponent further asserts that this court has already ruled on the issue of jurisdiction over the suit property in its Ruling and Judgment delivered on 20/1/2021 and 26/10/2023, respectively, in ELC 576 of 2026. Accordingly, the deponent contends that this court is not precluded from addressing the issue again.
7. The 1st Respondent contends that the Originating Summons was not duly served upon him. He avers that he ordinarily resides in Perth, Australia, and that the Applicant failed to obtain the mandatory prior leave of the Court required to effect service outside the jurisdiction, thereby rendering the service invalid and the proceedings fatally irregular. Accordingly, the Respondent seeks an order striking out the Originating Summons or, in the alternative, a stay of proceedings pending the determination of the parallel application before the Family Division of the High Court. He emphasises that the Applicant’s financial interests cannot override the legal requirements governing the due administration of the estate.
The Preliminary Objection
8. The 1st Respondent’s grounds of objection are that;
a) The Originating Summons, although framed as a claim for surrender of a lease and transfer of leasehold title, is in substance and effect a claim concerning the devolution, administration and distribution of an asset comprised in the estate of the late Dr. Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja, who died on 14/1 2016, namely his interest in Flat No. 4 (Type C) in Block A, constructed on L.R. No. 1870/VI/61 (Nairobi/Block 4/89). It is therefore a probate matter which ought to be dealt with in the succession proceedings concerning his estate, but has instead been cloaked as a land matter.
b) The jurisdiction of this Honourable Court is constitutionally and statutorily circumscribed by Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 as read with Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2011, to disputes relating to the environment and to the use and occupation of, and title to, land, and does not extend to matters concerning the dealing and or distribution of estate assets.
c) By virtue of Section 47 of the Law of Succession Act (Cap. 160), exclusive jurisdiction over all matters relating to the estates of deceased persons is vested in the High Court of Kenya, exercising its probate jurisdiction. No other court, including this Honourable Court, is competent to determine such matters or to make orders the practical effect of which is to dispose of estate property.
d) In the premises, the Originating Summons is incompetent, this Honourable Court is bereft of jurisdiction to entertain or to determine it, and the same ought to be struck out in limine with costs awarded to the to the 1st Respondent on an indemnity basis.
Application dated 29/6/2026
9. In his application dated 29/6/2026, the 1st Respondent substantively prays for orders that:
a. This Honourable Court be pleased, to order the attendance, for cross- examination before this Honourable Court, of the deponent of the affidavits of service sworn on 17/6/2026 and 29/6/2026, namely Mr. Amos Ogutu Wandago, on the contents of the said affidavits and the email service allegedly effected thereunder.
b. The affidavit of service sworn on 17/6/2026 and 29/6/2026 be declared defective and/or unreliable for want of proper service and accordingly struck out or expunged from the record.
c. The costs of this application be borne by the Applicant.
10. The application is premised on the grounds that the 1st Respondent, who is domiciled and ordinarily resides in Perth, Western Australia, has never been a resident of Kenya. The Applicant was, at all material times, aware of the 1st Respondent's residence in Perth, a fact admitted in the Originating Summons and the Supporting Affidavit of Marco Carolei, and further confirmed by direct communications between the Applicant's counsel, Mr. Amos Ogutu Wandago, and the 1st Respondent's advocate in a separate succession cause, Mr. Abbas Esmail. That notwithstanding this knowledge, the Applicant failed to seek or obtain the mandatory prior leave of the Court to effect service outside the jurisdiction, as strictly required under Order 5 Rules 21 to 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. Consequently, the 1st Respondent contends that the purported service by email is a nullity.
11. In addition, it is stated that the Applicant's Counsel on record swore two Affidavits of Service purporting to effect service upon Ms Linda Randa, Mr David Omondi, Mr Eric Mutua, and the firm of Anjarwalla & Khanna LLP. However, the 1st Respondent contends that he did not instruct any of these individuals or the firm to accept service on his behalf in these proceedings. Anjarwalla & Khanna LLP, which represents him in a separate succession cause, had no instructions to accept service in the present proceedings. Neither Mr Omondi nor Ms Randa is authorised to accept service for this purpose. The 1st Respondent submits that the hearing concerns an irreversible order directing the Deputy Registrar to execute a surrender of lease and transfer estate property to a third-party purchaser, and that the Affidavits should not be relied upon without the deponent being subjected to cross-examination. Accordingly, it is just and equitable for the deponent to be cross-examined to prevent substantial and irreparable prejudice to the 1st Respondent.
12. The application is further supported by the Affidavit of Mr. Sikander Ahmed Walimohamed, Counsel for the 1st Respondent, which was sworn on 29/6/2026.
Applicant’s Further Affidavit
13. The Applicant filed a Further Affidavit dated 8/7/2026, sworn by Marco Carolei, in response to both applications and the Preliminary Objection. The deponent avers that the 1st Respondent, who resides in Australia, has been communicating with him by email and WhatsApp. He further avers that all shareholders are surprised that the 1st Respondent is objecting to the sale of the land and shares, despite never having objected to the sale of the suit property, even after being served with notice of the General Meeting. The Applicant maintains that the 1st Respondent previously testified truthfully before Justice Mbugua regarding the Deceased’s intention to sell the flat during his lifetime, as supported by the attached Letter of Consent. The Applicant argues that the majority of shareholders having resolved to sell the property, it would be manifestly unjust to restrain the sale of the land and the other 10 units pending the determination of a Succession case to which the current owners are not parties.
14. It is deposed that, in order to safeguard the interests of the 1st Respondent, the Applicant is willing to deposit the share of the proceeds due to the Estate either with the Court or into a joint account held by the advocates. The Applicant submits that the 1st Respondent will suffer no prejudice, as he neither resides in nor rents the apartment, which is currently deteriorating. The Applicant further confirms that the sale is not intended to benefit any beneficiary or survivor of the Deceased Shareholder. Accordingly, the Applicant prays that the 1st Respondent's applications be dismissed and that the Originating Summons be allowed.
1st Respondent’s Supplementary Affidavit
15. The 1st Respondent, in his Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 16/7/2026, contends that Marco Carolei lacks the authority to swear an affidavit on behalf of the Applicant. That Marco Carolei holds no formal office, directorship, or shareholding in the Applicant company, as evidenced by CR 12 obtained from the Companies Registry. He therefore deposes that Carolei’s authority to swear the affidavit is questionable. He further deposes that the subject property forms part of the free estate of the Deceased. He argues that, in the absence of a confirmed grant of representation, no party, including the Applicant, has the legal authority to consent to, authorise, or transfer the leasehold interest. Consequently, the deponent asserts that the Applicant's position is contradictory, as it refers to the necessity of his consent while simultaneously asserting that the estate may be transferred without representation.
16. The 1st Respondent further objects to the admission of Exhibit marked "MC-1a," a purported "Letter of Consent by the Deceased." He contends that the document should be disregarded because it is an illegible WhatsApp image, lacks an original or certified copy, is undated, and has no established chain of custody. He further contends that the document is legally ineffective, as it is expressly labelled "SUBJECT TO CONTRACT" and is conditional upon an offer for all flats, constituting a mere agreement to agree rather than enforceable consent. Finally, the deponent denies the allegation that the Flat is deteriorating and submits that the assertion is baseless, given the deponent’s lack of personal knowledge and failure to disclose the source of the information. He maintains that the Court lacks jurisdiction to receive or supervise the proceeds of a deceased person's estate.
Written Submissions
17. On 30 June 2026, directions were issued for the Notice of Motion and the Preliminary Objection to be canvassed simultaneously by way of written submissions. Both parties complied with the directions. The Applicant’s submissions are dated 8/2026, while the 1st Respondent’s submissions are dated 2 July 2026. The Court has had the opportunity to review the submissions and has duly considered them in reaching its determination.
Analysis and Determination
18. Flowing from the above and the totality of the material placed before Court, the issues for determination, in my view are;
a. Whether the Preliminary Objection dated 29/6/2026 is merited?
b. Whether the Application dated 25/6/2026 is merited?
c. Whether the Application dated 29/6/2026 is merited?
d. Who bears costs?
Whether the Preliminary Objection dated 25/8/2025 is merited?
19. The parameters of consideration of a Preliminary Objection are now well settled. A Preliminary Objection must only raise issues of law. The principles that the Court is enjoined to apply in determining the merits or otherwise of the Preliminary Objection were set out in the leading case of Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] E.A 696 the celebrated case on Preliminary Objection, it was held as follows:
“… The first matter related to the increasing practice of raising points, which should be argued in the normal manner, quite improperly by way of Preliminary Objection. A Preliminary Objection is in the nature of what used to be a demurrer. It raises a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct. It cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion. The improper raising of points by way of Preliminary Objection does nothing but unnecessarily increase costs and, on occasion, confuse issues. This improper practice should stop.”
20. The Supreme Court in Hassan Ali Joho & Another v Suleiman Said Shabal & 2 Others SCK Petition No. 10 of 2013 [2014] eKLR the stated that a Preliminary Objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit.
21. From the foregoing, it follows that, for a Preliminary Objection to succeed, the following criteria must be satisfied: first, it must raise a pure point of law; second, it must be argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the opposing party are correct; and third, it cannot be raised where any fact must be ascertained or where the relief sought requires the exercise of judicial discretion. If successful, a valid Preliminary Objection should dispose of the suit. See David Karobia Kiiru v Charles Nderitu Gitoi & Another [2008] eKLR.
22. The 1st Respondent’s preliminary objection challenges this Court’s jurisdiction to entertain the Originating Summons. It is well established that jurisdiction goes to the root of a matter and is therefore a pure question of law.
23. A court can only exercise jurisdiction as conferred on it by the constitution or other written law. See Samuel Kamau Macharia & another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited & 2 others [2012] eKLR. Consequently, every court must ascertain for itself whether or not it has jurisdiction in any particular matter placed before it before embarking on determining the matter. In the now famous case of, ‘The Owners of Motor Vessel Lilian S Vs Caltex Kenya Ltd (1989) KLR where the court held that: -
“It is reasonably plain that a question of jurisdiction ought to be raised at the earliest opportunity and the court seized of the matter is then obliged to decide the issue right away on the material before it. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court has no power to make one more step. Where a court has no jurisdiction, there would be no basis for a continuation of proceedings pending other evidence. A court of law downs tools in respect of the matter before it the moment it holds the opinion that it is without jurisdiction.”
24. The second requirement for a meritorious Preliminary Objection is that it must be argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the opposing party are correct. It is undisputed that the deceased, Mahendra Krishnalal Adalja, held a leasehold interest in the suit property and that no personal representative or administrator of his estate has been appointed. Indeed, this issue remains the subject of a pending succession cause, Nairobi High Court Succession Cause No. 315 of 2018.
25. The jurisdiction of the ELC Court is limited by Article 162(2) and (3) of the Constitution of Kenya and Section 13(2) of the ELC Act No. 19 of 2011. Article 162(2)(b) which states that ELC Court has the mandate to hear and determine disputes relating to use and occupation and title to land.
26. Section 13(2) of the ELC Act on the other grant power to ELC to hear and
determine disputes relating to, inter alia, the environment, land use planning, title, boundary disputes, land administration and management, choses in action or other instruments granting enforceable interests in land, and other related issues.
27. Section 47 of the Law of Succession Act provides: -
”The High Court shall have jurisdiction to entertain any application and determine any dispute under this Act and to pronounce such decrees and make such orders therein as may be expedient: Provided that the High Court may for the purpose of this section be represented by Resident Magistrates appointed by the Chief Justice.”
28. The jurisdiction of the High Court and the Environment and Land Court, as it relates to the intersection between the probate court and this court, was settled by the Court of Appeal in the case of Diasproperty Limited & Others –vs- Githae & 10 Others (2024) KECA 318 KLR, where the court stated thus -
“36. Under Article 165(5)(b) of the Constitution, the High Court shall not have any jurisdiction in respect of matters within the jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court. Under Article 162(2) of the Constitution and section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2012, all matters relating to land, its ownership, use, tenure, boundaries, and so on, are reserved for the Environment and Land Court.
37. It is notable that under Rule 43(1) of the Probate and Administration Rules, made under the Law of Succession Act, where, in succession proceedings, a party claiming that he was beneficially entitled to a parcel of land that the deceased left in his name, or there is a general dispute relating to the ownership of a parcel of land registered in the name of the deceased, such dispute has to be adjourned and be determined in originating summons in a separate court. It is when such a determination is made that the succession court can confirm the grant, bearing in mind the determination. Of course, with the Constitution and the Environment and Land Court Act, such a dispute has to be referred to the Environment and Land Court for resolution.”
29. With respect to matters concerning intestate and testamentary succession, the administration of deceased persons’ estates, and related or incidental matters, the probate Court including the High Court and Magistrates’ Courts has statutory jurisdiction to hear disputes as provided for under the Law of Succession Act.
30. Probate courts have jurisdiction over the free property of a deceased person. This generally refers to property that the deceased was legally competent to dispose of during their lifetime and in which their interest was not extinguished upon death. The Applicant does not challenge the deceased's ownership rights in the suit property. Accordingly, the suit property constitutes free property over which the succession court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the matter.
31. The Preliminary objection is therefore merited. This court is bereft of jurisdiction to hear and determine this claim.
Whether the Application dated 25/6/2026 is merited?
32. Having found the Preliminary Objection merited, the application is, in effect, determined. Needless to add, the Originating Summons would still be struck out pursuant to Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules on sub judice. It is evident that a similar application is pending before the High Court. As the High Court is the court with jurisdiction to determine the dispute, this court is barred from handling a matter that is pending before a court of competent jurisdiction.
33. The record further indicates that a previous suit, ELC Suit No. 576 of 2016, was brought before this Court between the same parties, except that the Applicant in the Originating Summons was not a party to that suit. Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act provides for the doctrine of res judicata. In its Ruling delivered on 20/01/2021 and its Judgment delivered on 26/10/2023, this Court held that it lacked jurisdiction to determine any dispute concerning the suit property herein, as the property belongs to the deceased. The Court emphasised that any such claim should be pursued before the probate court.
34. This court therefore has no powers to overturn the decisions already rendered by this court on the issue.
Whether the Application dated 29/6/2026 is merited?
35. Having determined that this Court lacks jurisdiction to hear the suit, the court has ceased to act. As the suit is incompetent, the court has no basis for ruling on the application. In any event, the court has ceased to act for lack of jurisdiction.
36. In light of the foregoing facts, evidence, and principles, I find that the Applicant has not met the criteria for the Court to exercise its jurisdiction to grant the orders sought.
37. Final orders for disposal
a. Accordingly, the Originating Summons dated 8/6/2026 is hereby struck out.
b. I make no order as to costs.
38. It is so ordered
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
1. Mr. Odero H/B for Ms. May for the Applicant
2. Mr. Wali Mohamed for the 1st Respondent
3. N/A for the 2nd and 3rd Respondents
CA – Mr. Oglen