Small Claims

Gitau v Kikuvi [2026] SCC 125 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Lamu
Judgment date
5 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claim was allowed for Kshs. 320,000 (including the Kshs. 186,480 already admitted and Kshs. 133,520 balance). The counterclaim was dismissed without costs. The claimant was awarded costs and interest at court rates from filing of the claim.

Supporting judgment passages

a) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 7th April 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.320,000/=.

Passage 36 →

b) The counterclaim is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Passage 37 →

c) Costs and interests of the claim are awarded to the claimant

Passage 38 →
Issue 1Whether the acknowledgment of debt agreement dated 16 June 2025 was enforceable, or invalid because it was signed under duress, undue influence, coercion, or while the respondent was unwell.

Held. The agreement was valid and binding. The medical records related to a period before its execution; no police officers were present when it was signed at an advocate's office; and the respondent neither pleaded nor proved undue influence or coercion. The court would enforce, rather than rewrite, the agreement.

Ratio. Parties are bound by a contract they willingly entered into, and a court will not rewrite it merely because of a bad bargain or later regret unless coercion, fraud, or undue influence is pleaded or proved.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

8) In my view the claim turns on the agreement dated 16/6/2025. On one hand the claimant asserts that the agreement ought to be enforced and the respondent to comply with what he signed for whereas on the other hand the respondent asserts that the same was signed under duress and that he was not given an opportunity to read the averments thereto.

Paragraph 8 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

12) It is also clear and as submitted by the claimant that no particulars of such undue influence and/or coercion was ever pleaded by the respondent in defence or the counterclaim. It is therefore in addition to this I do find that there was no undue influence and/or coercion during the signing of the agreement whether from the DCI officers or anyone else. I further hold and find that the agreement in question is valid and parties thereto and bound by it.

Paragraph 12 →

14) As decreed by the court of appeal, this court will not attempt to rewrite the contract dated 16/6/2025. The parties willingly entered into it and they are therefore bound by it. My singular duty is to enforce the same. That is what I am about to do.

Paragraph 14 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

13) Having so found, the court's role is one. To interpret and enforce the contract, not to rewrite it to shield a party from a bad bargain or subsequent regret. This position was well articulated by the Court of Appeal in the case of National Bank of Kenya Limited vs. Pipe Plastic Samkolit (K) Ltd [2002] eKLR, a case cited by the claimant in her submissions where the Court held:

Paragraph 13 →

14) As decreed by the court of appeal, this court will not attempt to rewrite the contract dated 16/6/2025. The parties willingly entered into it and they are therefore bound by it. My singular duty is to enforce the same. That is what I am about to do.

Paragraph 14 →
Issue 2Whether the claimant was entitled to recover the outstanding Kshs. 133,520 under the acknowledgment of debt agreement.

Held. Yes. The respondent had bound himself by the agreement as indebted for Kshs. 320,000 and admitted Kshs. 186,480. The claimant was therefore entitled to the Kshs. 133,520 balance; the final claim award was Kshs. 320,000.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. This was an application of the court's factual finding that the agreement was valid and the stated debt was owed.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

15) The respondent bound himself that he was indebted to the claimant in the sum of Kshs. 320,000/= and having admitted the sum of Kshs.186,480/= I do find also that the claimant is entitled to the difference being Kshs.133,520/=.

Paragraph 15 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

15) The respondent bound himself that he was indebted to the claimant in the sum of Kshs. 320,000/= and having admitted the sum of Kshs.186,480/= I do find also that the claimant is entitled to the difference being Kshs.133,520/=.

Paragraph 15 →

a) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 7th April 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.320,000/=.

Passage 36 →
Issue 3Whether the respondent proved the Kshs. 72,000 counterclaim.

Held. No. The respondent led no evidence showing how the claimed Kshs. 72,000 arose. The counterclaim was therefore unmerited for want of proof and was dismissed without an order for costs.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. The dismissal rested on the factual absence of evidence supporting the pleaded amount.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

16) On whether the counterclaim has been proved, no evidence was led to prove how the Kshs.72,000/= came about. It therefore falls on that ground alone and this could possibly explain why the submissions by the respondent gave the issue a wide berth.

Paragraph 16 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

17) Consequently, the inevitable conclusion I must arrive at is that the claim has been proved on a balance of probability and that the counterclaim is not merited for want of proof.

Paragraph 17 →

b) The counterclaim is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Passage 37 →
Issue 4Who should bear the costs of the claim?

Held. The claimant was awarded costs of the claim, having succeeded. Interest was also awarded at court rates from the date the claim was filed.

Ratio. Costs follow the event to compensate the successful party for the trouble of prosecuting or defending the case, rather than to penalize the losing party.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

c) Who bears costs of the claim?

Passage 32 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

18) It is well recognized that the principle costs follow the event is not to be used to penalize the losing party rather it is for compensating the successful party for the trouble taken in prosecuting or defending the case. The claimant being the successful party she is awarded costs.

Paragraph 18 →

c) Costs and interests of the claim are awarded to the claimant

Passage 38 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

18) It is well recognized that the principle costs follow the event is not to be used to penalize the losing party rather it is for compensating the successful party for the trouble taken in prosecuting or defending the case. The claimant being the successful party she is awarded costs.

Paragraph 18 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

At the hearing of the claim it became more apparent that the respondent only admits Kshs.186,480/= out of the claimed amount of Kshs.320,000/=. Consequently, the court entered judgment on admission for the said sum and now being called upon to determine whether the claimant is entitled to the balance of Kshs.133,520/=.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The claimant in his submissions has raised 3 issues for determination as follows;

Paragraph 6 →

Reasoning passage

When cross examined and upon perusal of the treatment records it became apparent that they related to a period way before the signing of the agreement and as such it has no bearing to the signing of the agreement in my view. I find and hold in similar terms.

Paragraph 10 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether the acknowledgment of debt agreement dated 16 June 2025 was valid and enforceable despite the respondent’s allegations of duress, ill health, undue influence and lack of opportunity to read it; whether the respondent proved the…

Material facts

Hannah Wangari Gitau relied on a written acknowledgment of debt in which Joseph Ngotho Kikuvi acknowledged owing Kshs.320,000. The respondent admitted owing Kshs.186,480 but disputed the remaining Kshs.133,520. He alleged that he signed while unwell, after…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT LAMU

SC COMM NO. E015 OF 2026.

HANNAH WANGARI GITAU.......................................................................….CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

JOSEPH NGOTHO KIKUVI...…………..…………………..……………………RESPONDENT

JUDGEMENT.

INTRODUCTION.

1) At the hearing of the claim it became more apparent that the respondent only admits Kshs.186,480/= out of the claimed amount of Kshs.320,000/=. Consequently, the court entered judgment on admission for the said sum and now being called upon to determine whether the claimant is entitled to the balance of Kshs.133,520/=.

2) It is the claimant’s case that on or about 16th June 2025 together with the respondent entered into a written acknowledgement of debt agreement where the respondent acknowledged being indebted to the claimant for the sum of Kshs.320,000/=. The said agreement was produced in evidence.

3) The claimant states that the respondent is in breach of the said agreement hence this claim.

4) The respondent despite largely denying the claim, at paragraph 4(e)admits to owing the claimant only Kshs.186,480/= and not the entire sum of Kshs.320,000/= and in the same vein raised a counterclaim seeking among other orders that the agreement in question be declared null and void, an order for the claimant to return the warehouse key and payment of Kshs.72,000/= and costs of the counter claim.

5) In addition to the viva voce hearing parties have filed their respective submissions to which I have read and considered in this judgement.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION.

6) The claimant in his submissions has raised 3 issues for determination as follows;

a) Whether the Acknowledgment of Debt Agreement dated 16th June 2025 is a valid and binding contract, or whether it is voidable on account of duress, undue influence, unconscionable terms, or ill health.

b) Whether the Respondent has proved his Counterclaim of Kshs. 72,000/= to the required legal standard.

c) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought in the claim.

7) The respondent on the other hand has rather surprisingly only raised one issue for determination that is whether the debt agreement dated 16th June 2025 is enforceable and nothing has been said about the counterclaim.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

8) In my view the claim turns on the agreement dated 16/6/2025. On one hand the claimant asserts that the agreement ought to be enforced and the respondent to comply with what he signed for whereas on the other hand the respondent asserts that the same was signed under duress and that he was not given an opportunity to read the averments thereto.

9) In a bid to rely on duress as a ground to invalidate the agreement, he asserts that at the time of the signing he was unwell and relied on treatment notes and that he signed the agreement after he had just come from the DCI officers.

10) When cross examined and upon perusal of the treatment records it became apparent that they related to a period way before the signing of the agreement and as such it has no bearing to the signing of the agreement in my view. I find and hold in similar terms.

11) As to whether there was undue influence from the DCI officers, the claimant admitted that she reported the matter to the police and who advised them to go to an advocate as it was more civil than criminal. He admitted in cross examination that the agreement was done at the advocates office and that there were no police officers when he signed the agreement. It is therefore not clear how the police interfered in any way with the signing of the agreement.

12) It is also clear and as submitted by the claimant that no particulars of such undue influence and/or coercion was ever pleaded by the respondent in defence or the counterclaim. It is therefore in addition to this I do find that there was no undue influence and/or coercion during the signing of the agreement whether from the DCI officers or anyone else. I further hold and find that the agreement in question is valid and parties thereto and bound by it.

13) Having so found, the court's role is one. To interpret and enforce the contract, not to rewrite it to shield a party from a bad bargain or subsequent regret. This position was well articulated by the Court of Appeal in the case of National Bank of Kenya Limited vs. Pipe Plastic Samkolit (K) Ltd [2002] eKLR, a case cited by the claimant in her submissions where the Court held:

“A court of law cannot rewrite a contract between parties. The parties are bound by the terms of their contract, unless coercion, fraud or undue influence are pleaded or proved.”

14) As decreed by the court of appeal, this court will not attempt to rewrite the contract dated 16/6/2025. The parties willingly entered into it and they are therefore bound by it. My singular duty is to enforce the same. That is what I am about to do.

15) The respondent bound himself that he was indebted to the claimant in the sum of Kshs. 320,000/= and having admitted the sum of Kshs.186,480/= I do find also that the claimant is entitled to the difference being Kshs.133,520/=.

16) On whether the counterclaim has been proved, no evidence was led to prove how the Kshs.72,000/= came about. It therefore falls on that ground alone and this could possibly explain why the submissions by the respondent gave the issue a wide berth.

17) Consequently, the inevitable conclusion I must arrive at is that the claim has been proved on a balance of probability and that the counterclaim is not merited for want of proof.

c) Who bears costs of the claim?

18) It is well recognized that the principle costs follow the event is not to be used to penalize the losing party rather it is for compensating the successful party for the trouble taken in prosecuting or defending the case. The claimant being the successful party she is awarded costs.

CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION.

19) The upshot of the foregoing I make the following final orders;

a) The claim contained in the statement of claim dated 7th April 2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.320,000/=.

b) The counterclaim is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

c) Costs and interests of the claim are awarded to the claimant

d) The interest shall accrue from the date of filing of the claim and shall be at court rates.

e) Let the file be closed forthwith.

20) Orders accordingly.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT LAMU SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS….5th …..DAY OF …June…2026.

F.M. MULAMA

ADJUDICATOR/RM

In the presence of:

Court Assistant:- Abuswaleh.

Mr. Maina for the Claimant.

Mr. Mutethia for respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder