Land law

Olchumari v Kiok & 4 others [2026] KEELC 7359 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Os Case 134 of 2015
Judgment date
2 November 2026
Judge(s)
Christine Ochieng

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion dated 19 March 2026 was allowed. The 5th Defendant/Land Registrar was cited for contempt for failing to implement the 5 July 2018 decree, and was compelled forthwith to cancel or reverse the subdivisions of KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and restore it to the deceased’s estate. Non-compliance attracts civil jail for up to six months or a KSh 500,000 fine. The Plaintiff was awarded costs.

Supporting judgment passages

will allow it in the following terms:

Passage 65 →

a. The 5th Defendant be and is hereby cited for contempt for failing to implement the Order/ Decree of this Court issued on the 5th July, 2018.

Passage 66 →

b. The 5th Defendant/Contemnor be and is hereby compelled to implement the Decree of this Court dated the 5th July, 2018 by forthwith cancelling and/or reversing all the subdivisions undertaken on suit property title NO. KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and the suit property be restored to its original status to form part of the estate of the deceased (MASIKULE OLCHUMARI PIDILAI KIOK) failure of which he will be committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine of Kshs. 500,000/=.

Passage 67 →
Issue 1Whether the 5th Defendant should be cited for contempt for contravening the Orders issued on 5th July, 2018 and committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine as the Court may direct or both.

Held. Decided. The Land Registrar was cited for contempt for failing to implement the 5 July 2018 order/decree. He had knowledge of the authentic decree, whose terms were clear and unambiguous, but deliberately and in bad faith declined implementation on the ground that events had overtaken it. He was ordered forthwith to cancel/reverse the subdivisions of KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and restore the land to the deceased’s estate; failure would result in civil jail for up to six months or a KSh 500,000 fine.

Ratio. Civil contempt requires proof, to a heightened standard, that an order is clear, unambiguous and binding; that the alleged contemnor had knowledge or proper notice; that they breached it; and that the breach was deliberate. A Land Registrar with knowledge of a valid, clear decree cannot decline to implement it merely by asserting that it has been overtaken by events, particularly where the subdivisions relied on already existed when the decree was issued.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

6. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits and submissions, the only issue for determination is whether the 5th Defendant should be cited for contempt for contravening the Orders issued on 5th July, 2018 and committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine as the Court may direct or both.

Paragraph 6 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

a. The 5th Defendant be and is hereby cited for contempt for failing to implement the Order/ Decree of this Court issued on the 5th July, 2018.

Passage 66 →

b. The 5th Defendant/Contemnor be and is hereby compelled to implement the Decree of this Court dated the 5th July, 2018 by forthwith cancelling and/or reversing all the subdivisions undertaken on suit property title NO. KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and the suit property be restored to its original status to form part of the estate of the deceased (MASIKULE OLCHUMARI PIDILAI KIOK) failure of which he will be committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine of Kshs. 500,000/=.

Passage 67 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

'there are essentially four elements that must be proved to make the case for civil contempt. The applicant must prove to the required standard (in civil contempt cases which is higher than civil cases - (a) the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant; (b) the defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order; (c) the defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order; and (d) the defendant's conduct was deliberate.'

Passage 59 →

16. I further note that the Land Registrar who is the 5th Defendant despite knowledge of the Order and Decree willfully and deliberately declined to implement it and contended that it has been overtaken by events, vide his letter dated the 19th February, 2026. From the excerpt of the judgement which I have quoted above, it is clear the judgement/order was clear and unambiguous. Further, the Land Registrar had knowledge of his role in the implementation of the impugned judgement but failed to implement it. In my view he acted in breach of the terms of the Order/ Decree and his conduct was malafides and deliberate.

Paragraph 16 →

17. Based on the facts before Court while associating myself with the decisions cited above, since there was no ambiguity in the terms of the Judgement, I find that the 5th Defendant acted in breach of the Orders of the Court. It is my considered view that since there was a valid Judgement of the Court, the 5th Defendant had no business declining to implement it, claiming it had been overtaken by events as by the time the said Judgement was delivered, the alleged subdivisions had already taken place.

Paragraph 17 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the Applicant/ Decree holder’s Notice of Motion application dated the 19th March, 2026 where he seeks the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Based on the facts before Court while associating myself with the decisions cited above, since there was no ambiguity in the terms of the Judgement, I find that the 5th Defendant acted in breach of the Orders of the Court. It is my considered view that since there was a valid Judgement of the Court, the 5th Defendant had no business declining to implement it, claiming it had been overtaken by events as by the time the said Judgement…

Paragraph 17 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Kajiado West Land Registrar, as 5th Respondent/Contemnor, should be cited and punished for contempt for failing to implement the judgment and decree issued on 5 July 2018, including cancellation or reversal of subdivisions arising from…

Material facts

The 2018 judgment found that the defendants had unlawfully subdivided and apportioned KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78, property belonging to the deceased’s estate, and ordered cancellation of the subdivisions and restoration of the land to the estate. The Applicant…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC OS CASE NO. 134 OF 2015

IN THE MATTER OF THE LAW OF SUCCESSION ACT (CAP 160)

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION RULES (UNDER CAP 160)

AND

IN THE MATTER OF INTESTATE ADMINISTRATION OF THE ESTATE OF MASAKULE OLE OLCHUMARI PIDILAI KIOK (DECEASED)

AND

IN THE MATTER OF PROTECTION OF DECEASED PERSON’S PROPERTY PURSUANT TO SECTION 45 & 46 OF THE LAW OF SUCCESSION ACT (CAP 160)

AND

IN THE MATTER OF LAND TITLE NOS. KAJIADO/ LOODARIAK/ 78 AND THE SUBDIVISIONS THEREFROM KNOWN AS TITLE NOS. KAJIADO/ LOODARIAK/ 4375, 4376, 4377, 4378, 4379, 4380 & 4381

BETWEEN

NTIAMASASI OLE

KIOK OLCHUMARI ……………... APPLICANT / DECREE HOLDER

VERSUS

JOHN KAMUYE

OLE KIOK ………………... 1ST RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR

POOSIO

ENE KIOK ………………. 2ND RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR

SOTIAN ENE

OLCHUMARI ………….. 3RD RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR

MAASAINI OLE

NTIAMASASI ………….. 4TH RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR

AND

THE LAND REGISTRAR,

KAJIADO WEST

LAND REGISTRY ………………… 5TH RESPONDENT/CONTEMNOR

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the Applicant/ Decree holder’s Notice of Motion application dated the 19th March, 2026 where he seeks the following Orders:

a. Spent

b. The Contemnor be summoned to appear before this court and/or show cause why he shouldn’t be punished for deliberate and continued disobedience of court orders/decree issued on 5th July, 2018.

c. This Honourable Court be pleased to cite the Contemnor for contempt of court orders/decree.

d. This Honourable Court be pleased to commit the Contemnor to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine as the Court may direct or both.

e. This Honourable Court be pleased to compel the Contemnor to purge the contempt by cancelling and/or reversing all the subdivisions undertaken on suit property title NO. KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and the suit property be restored to its original status to form part of the estate of the deceased.

f. This Honourable Court be pleased to issue any other order it deems fit to meet the ends of justice.

g. Costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is premised on grounds on the face of it and the supporting affidavit of NTIAMASASI OLE KIOK OL CHUMARI where he deposes that on the 5th July, 2018, this Court delivered a judgement and declared that subdivisions including distribution of the suit property were illegal, unlawful and ordered the resultant subdivisions to be cancelled and the suit property to be restored to form part of the estate of the deceased.

3. He states that the said Orders have never been set aside, varied or stayed and remain in force. He avers that despite service of the abovementioned orders/decree, the Respondents including the Contemnor have wilfully and deliberately disobeyed or disregarded the said decree/orders. He explains that on 18th December, 2025, the Contemnor wrote a letter to ELC Milimani Court seeking verification on the authenticity of the said orders/decree. Further, that in a letter dated the 22nd January, 2026, the ELC Milimani Court confirmed that the Court decree was authentic and originated from it. He states that on the 19th February, 2026, the Contemnor wrote a letter claiming the Court Order had been overtaken by events. He insists that the acts by the Land Registrar implies that he will not comply with the Court Order and undermines the authority as well as dignity of this Court. He reiterates that his rights and other beneficiaries’ rights and interests are affected by the subdivision of the deceased’s estate into title Nos. KAJIADO/ LOODARIAK/4375, 4376, 4377, 4378, 4379, 4380 & 4381.

4. The 1st to 3rd Defendants opposed the instant application by filing a replying affidavit sworn by JOHN KAMUYE OLE KIOK, the 1st Defendant. He denies knowledge of the instant suit until the 2nd and 3rd Defendants were arrested and taken to Kiserian Police Station where the Plaintiff’s advocates were demanding to be paid their costs. He insists that summons to enter appearance was never served upon them. He casts aspersions on the various affidavits of service filed in Court which indicated that they were served. He contends that the trial was a sham and carefully scripted with a fake (4th Defendant) to disenfranchise the rest of the family over their land. He insists that the 1st to 3rd Defendants never granted anyone authority to plead or act for them. Further, that no affidavit of service is annexed to the supporting affidavit to demonstrate to the Court that the Judgement and Decree were duly served upon the Defendants. Further, that no Orders were served upon the Respondents and they had no knowledge whatsoever of the alleged Orders or at all. He argues that the Plaintiff failed to seek Conservatory Orders during the pendency of the suit to preserve the suit property and consequently the said property underwent further lawful dealings, including subdivision and transfer to third parties thereby rendering the Orders sought impracticable, prejudicial to innocent third parties and incapable of enforcement without occasioning grave injustice. He reiterates that the Plaintiff inexplicably waited for a period of close to eight (8) years from the date of the Judgement in 2018 before allegedly effecting service of the Decree upon the 5th Respondent, and concedes that by 19th February, 2026 he was aware that the status of the subject property had since changed, thereby rendering the Orders overtaken by events. He further casts aspersions on legal representation and commissioning of documents. He reaffirms that the instant application amounts to abuse of the Court process.

5. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Analysis and Determination

6. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits and submissions, the only issue for determination is whether the 5th Defendant should be cited for contempt for contravening the Orders issued on 5th July, 2018 and committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine as the Court may direct or both.

7. The Applicant/ Decree holder in his submissions reiterates his averments as per the supporting affidavit. He argued that the 5th Defendant/ Respondent is in contempt of the Decree/ Orders issued by this Court since the said Orders were clear, unambiguous as well as binding on him. Further, that he had knowledge of the Order, and willfully acted in breach of it. To buttress his averments, he relied on various authorities including: Sheila Cassat Issenberg & Another v Anthony Machatha Kinyanjui (2021) KEHC 5692 (KLR; Paragon Electronic Limited v Chief Land Registrar; Commission on Administrative Justice (2025) KEHC 2156; and Republic v Kenya School of Law & 2 Others Ex parte Juliet Wanjiru Njoroge & 5 Others (2015) eKLR.

8. The 1st to 3rd Defendants / Respondents in their submissions reiterated their averments as per the replying affidavit. They insisted that the supporting affidavit was defective as it offended section 4 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act (Cap 15) and that the 5th Defendant was not in contempt of the Decree/ Order of this Court. They argued that the Plaintiff filed this suit in secrecy, there is no affidavit of service demonstrating service, there are more proprietors of the suit property, and that the subject matter has mutated. To support their arguments they relied on various decisions including: Mwandi v Songe (2025) KEELC 5145 (KLR); Kithome & Another v Haile & Another (2024) KEELC 6407 (KLR); Joseph Babu Kaangi & Another v Munket Pulei (Suing as the personal representative of the Estate of Kasaine Pulei Kinyoei alias Kasina Ole Pulei) & Others (2026) Nairobi COACA No. 322 of 2023 and Alfred Mutua v Bonface Mwangi (2022) eKLR and Sheila Cassat Issenberg & Another v Anthony Machatha Kinyanjui (2021) KEHC 5692 (KLR).

9. For the avoidance of doubt, I wish to highlight a portion of the judgement delivered on the 5th July, 2018:

‘Clearly by subdividing the suit property and apportioning the subdivisions to themselves, the Defendants intermeddled with the suit property which belongs to the estate of the Deceased. This was done without following the laid down procedure set out in the Law of Succession Act. The court finds no difficulty in making the finding that the subdivision of the suit property by the Defendants into the subdivisions was both unlawful and invalid.

d) Whether the subdivisions and the distribution of the same to the Defendants should be nullified and a proper administration of the suit property ordered to be done as required by law.

With the finding made in (c) above, this court cancels the subdivisions and hereby orders that the suit property be restored and form part of the estate of the Deceased. This court also orders that the suit property be administered as the court shall order in proper succession proceedings filed in the appropriate court under the Law of Succession Act.’

10. I note the aforementioned judgement is yet to be implemented despite service having been effected upon the 5th Defendant, and this is what has culminated in the instant application. The 1st to 3rd Defendants have opposed the instant application claiming they were not served and casting aspersions on the affidavits of service which are in the Court file. However, at this juncture, I opine that the only issue I am dealing with, is whether the Land Registrar is in contempt of Orders of the Court or not.

11. Black’s Law Dictionary (Ninth Edition) describes contempt of Court as follows:

“Conduct that defies the authority or dignity of a court. Because such conduct interferes with the administration of justice, it is punishable usually by fine or imprisonment.”

12. In Halsbury’s laws of England at para 463 Vol 9(1) (Re-issue) 3, it was stated as follows:

“and a person not a party against whom any judgement or order may be enforced is liable to the same process for enforcing obedience to it as if he were a party”.

13. On punishment for contempt of court, section 29 of the Environment and Land Court Act stipulates that:

‘Any person who refuses, fails or neglects to obey an order or direction of the Court given under this Act, commits an offence, and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding twenty million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or to both’.

14. In the case of North Tetu Farmers Co. Ltd v. Joseph Nderitu Wanjohi (2016) eKLR Justice Mativo (as he then

was) enumerated the elements of civil contempt as follows:

'there are essentially four elements that must be proved to make the case for civil contempt. The applicant must prove to the required standard (in civil contempt cases which is higher than civil cases - (a) the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant; (b) the defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order; (c) the defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order; and (d) the defendant's conduct was deliberate.'

15. In the current scenario, there is a judgement which was delivered on the 5th July, 2018 in favour of the Plaintiff. The 5th Defendant who is the Land Registrar sought for verification of authenticity of the said Orders/Decree vide his letter dated the 18th December, 2025. Further, that in a letter dated the 22nd January, 2026, the ELC Milimani Court confirmed that the Court Decree was authentic and originated from it.

16. I further note that the Land Registrar who is the 5th Defendant despite knowledge of the Order and Decree willfully and deliberately declined to implement it and contended that it has been overtaken by events, vide his letter dated the 19th February, 2026. From the excerpt of the judgement which I have quoted above, it is clear the judgement/order was clear and unambiguous. Further, the Land Registrar had knowledge of his role in the implementation of the impugned judgement but failed to implement it. In my view he acted in breach of the terms of the Order/ Decree and his conduct was malafides and deliberate.

17. Based on the facts before Court while associating myself with the decisions cited above, since there was no ambiguity in the terms of the Judgement, I find that the 5th Defendant acted in breach of the Orders of the Court. It is my considered view that since there was a valid Judgement of the Court, the 5th Defendant had no business declining to implement it, claiming it had been overtaken by events as by the time the said Judgement was delivered, the alleged subdivisions had already taken place.

18. It is against the foregoing that I find the Applicant/ Decree holder’s

Notice of Motion application dated the 19th March, 2026 merited and

will allow it in the following terms:

a. The 5th Defendant be and is hereby cited for contempt for failing to implement the Order/ Decree of this Court issued on the 5th July, 2018.

b. The 5th Defendant/Contemnor be and is hereby compelled to implement the Decree of this Court dated the 5th July, 2018 by forthwith cancelling and/or reversing all the subdivisions undertaken on suit property title NO. KAJIADO/LOODARIAK/78 and the suit property be restored to its original status to form part of the estate of the deceased (MASIKULE OLCHUMARI PIDILAI KIOK) failure of which he will be committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months or pay a fine of Kshs. 500,000/=.

c. The Plaintiff is awarded the costs of this application.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 2ND DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Onyango for Hashi for 1st – 3rd Defendants

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder