Land law

Njemuwa Investment Limited & another v Karanja [2026] KEELC 7372 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Miscellaneous Application E262 of 2026
Judgment date
2 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026. The application seeks, inter alia, an order staying execution of the Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 issued in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025, an order calling for and examining the record of proceedings relating to the assessment and ascertainment of party-and-party costs, and an order setting aside the said assessment together with the…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, the Supporting Affidavit, the Applicants’ written submissions and the authorities relied upon. The Respondent did not file a response to the application. In my view, the principal issue for determination is: whether the Applicants have established sufficient basis for the assessment of costs undertaken in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025 and the consequential Certificate of Costs…

Paragraph 13 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. E262 OF 2026

NJEMUWA INVESTMENT LIMITED.......................................................1ST APPLICANT

JACINTA NJERI MUYA........................................................................2ND APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

JAMES NDUNGU KARANJA................................................................RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before the Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026. The application seeks, inter alia, an order staying execution of the Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 issued in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025, an order calling for and examining the record of proceedings relating to the assessment and ascertainment of party-and-party costs, and an order setting aside the said assessment together with the consequential Certificate of Costs in the sum of Kshs.57,100. The Applicants also seek the costs of the application.

2. The application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and is supported by the affidavit of S. W. Kiragu, Advocate, sworn on 20th August 2026. The Applicants contend that although the Respondent was awarded costs in the lower court matter, the amount payable was not quantified and therefore required assessment in accordance with Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D of the Civil Procedure Rules.

3. The Applicants aver that prior to the assessment of costs, the Respondent did not file and serve upon them a written request for costs, a statement of costs itemising the amounts claimed, or supporting documents as required under Order 21 Rule 9A of the Civil Procedure Rules. They further contend that, as a result, they were not afforded the opportunity under Order 21 Rule 9B to admit the costs claimed, partially reject them or wholly reject them before the matter was placed before the subordinate court for assessment.

4. The Applicants state that despite the absence of those documents and without any response from them on the costs claimed, the learned magistrate proceeded to assess and ascertain the Respondent’s costs and thereafter issued a Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 for Kshs.57,100. It is their contention that the assessment was therefore undertaken without compliance with the procedure prescribed under Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D and is consequently irregular, unlawful and liable to be set aside.

The Response

5. The record shows that on 25th August 2026, the Court directed that the application be served upon the Respondent within seven days and that the Respondent file and serve a replying affidavit within seven days of service. The Court further directed that the application be canvassed by way of written submissions.

6. The Applicants subsequently served the Respondent’s advocates with the application dated 20th August 2026, the Court’s directions and the mention notice by email on 31st August 2026.

7. Despite service, the Respondent did not file a replying affidavit or any other response opposing the application. The application therefore proceeded on the basis of the Applicants’ material on record and their written submissions.

The Applicants’ Submissions

8. The Applicants filed written submissions in support of the application. They identified three issues for determination, namely: whether the correct procedure had been adopted in challenging the assessment of costs by the subordinate court; whether the impugned assessment of costs and the resultant Certificate of Costs ought to be set aside; and who should bear the costs of the application.

9. On the first issue, the Applicants submitted that the assessment of costs undertaken by the subordinate court was an assessment under Order 21 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules and not a taxation undertaken by a taxing officer under the Advocates Remuneration Order. They therefore argued that a reference under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order was not the appropriate procedure for challenging the impugned assessment.

10. In support of that position, they relied on Momposhi (Suing as the Legal Representative of the Estate of Simintei Momposhi, Deceased) Vs Ronko & 2 Others (Environment and Land Appeal E007 of 2025) [2025] KEELC 8639 (KLR), where the Court drew a distinction between taxation of costs by a taxing officer and assessment of costs by a subordinate court and held that the latter may be challenged through a miscellaneous application invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of the superior court.

11. On the second issue, the Applicants submitted that the assessment and Certificate of Costs could not stand because the procedure prescribed under Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D of the Civil Procedure Rules had not been followed. They contended that the Respondent neither filed nor served a written request for costs, a statement of costs or supporting documents and that they were consequently denied an opportunity to respond to the costs claimed before the subordinate court proceeded with the assessment. In support of that submission, they relied on Kariuki Vs Mwabia (Miscellaneous Civil Application E156 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 9381 (KLR), where the Court set aside an assessment of costs for failure to comply with the procedure prescribed under Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D.

12. On costs, the Applicants submitted that the Respondent had failed to comply with the prescribed procedure for assessment of costs and had also failed to oppose the present application despite service. They consequently urged the Court to allow the application, set aside the impugned assessment and Certificate of Costs and award them the costs of the application.

Analysis and Determination

13. I have considered the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, the Supporting Affidavit, the Applicants’ written submissions and the authorities relied upon. The Respondent did not file a response to the application. In my view, the principal issue for determination is: whether the Applicants have established sufficient basis for the assessment of costs undertaken in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025 and the consequential Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 to be set aside.

14. The record shows that the lower court proceedings were concluded by a consent adopted as an order of the Court on 3rd June 2026. Under that consent, the Respondent was awarded costs of the suit. The consent did not, however, quantify the amount payable as costs. What remained thereafter was therefore the assessment and ascertainment of those costs in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law.

15. The applicable procedure is found in Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D of the Civil Procedure Rules. Order 21 Rule 9A provides that: “A party claiming costs at a Magistrates Court shall file a written request, statement of costs and supporting documents with the Court and serve it on the other parties with a breakdown of the costs sought. ”The Rule is couched in mandatory terms and identifies both what must be placed before the Court and what must be served upon the party against whom the costs are sought.

16. Rule 9A does not stand in isolation. Under Rule 9B, once the written request, statement of costs and supporting documents have been served, the party against whom the costs are claimed is afforded an opportunity to respond. Rule 9C thereafter requires the Court, in assessing the costs, to consider the material placed before it and make the appropriate orders. Rule 9D requires the Court to be guided by the Advocates Remuneration Order in the assessment and award of costs.

17. Read together, those provisions establish a deliberate sequence. The party entitled to costs must first disclose the costs claimed and the material supporting them; the opposite party must then be afforded an opportunity to respond; and the Court thereafter undertakes the assessment upon the material placed before it and with reference to the applicable scale under the Advocates Remuneration Order. The procedure therefore serves not merely to arrive at a figure, but to ensure that the figure is arrived at through a process in which both parties have been afforded an opportunity to participate.

18. The effect of those provisions was considered in Kariuki Vs Mwabia (Miscellaneous Civil Application E156 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 9381 (KLR). In considering Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D, the Court observed that: “These rules were introduced with a purpose. That step is not just a procedural issue that can be disregarded or overlooked. ”The Court further held that the party against whom costs are claimed must be notified of the request and afforded an opportunity to respond. Upon finding that no request for costs had been filed and that a certificate had nevertheless been issued, the Court set aside the assessment and directed that the prescribed procedure be undertaken afresh.

19. The Applicants’ complaint in the present matter is substantially the same. They aver that before the impugned assessment was undertaken, the Respondent did not file or serve upon them a written request for assessment of costs, a statement itemising the costs claimed, a breakdown thereof or the supporting documents contemplated under Rule 9A. They contend that they were consequently never afforded the opportunity under Rule 9B to admit, partially reject or wholly reject the costs claimed.

20. The Applicants further aver that notwithstanding those omissions, the learned magistrate proceeded to assess and ascertain the Respondent’s costs and issued the Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 for Kshs.57,100. Their complaint is therefore directed not merely at the quantum eventually certified but at the process through which that amount was reached.

21. Those averments remain uncontroverted. Despite service, the Respondent did not place before this Court any request for assessment, statement of costs, supporting documents or evidence of service upon the Applicants from which the Court could conclude that the requirements of Rules 9A and 9B were complied with before the assessment took place.

22. The absence of a response does not, of itself, mean that the application must succeed. The Applicants must still establish that the omission complained of was material to the validity of the assessment. On that question, I am persuaded that it was. The Rules do not merely require service for its own sake. Service of the statement and breakdown of costs is what enables the opposite party to know the particular items claimed and to exercise the statutory right to respond before liability is quantified.

23. It is also necessary to distinguish between the award of costs and the assessment of those costs. The Respondent’s entitlement to costs had already been settled by the consent order. That entitlement is not challenged in this application. What is challenged is the subsequent ascertainment of the amount payable. The fact that the Respondent had been awarded costs did not dispense with the procedure prescribed under Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D for determining their quantum.

24. In the present case, the omission is more fundamental. The material before this Court indicates that the preliminary steps contemplated under Rules 9A and 9B were not undertaken before the costs were assessed. It follows that when the learned magistrate proceeded to ascertain the costs, the Applicants had not been afforded the opportunity expressly provided by the Rules to interrogate the claim and the Court did not have before it the response contemplated under Rule 9C.

25. The Applicants have additionally challenged the sum of Kshs.50,000 awarded as party-and-party costs on the higher scale, contending that the lower court matter was neither opposed nor defended and that the applicable amount under Schedule 7(2) of the Advocates Remuneration Order was Kshs.20,000. However, having found that the process by which the costs were assessed did not comply with the mandatory procedure under Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D, it would be inappropriate for this Court to undertake a fresh assessment of individual items in the first instance. That exercise properly belongs to the lower court upon compliance with the prescribed procedure and upon consideration of the applicable provisions of the Advocates Remuneration Order.

26. I therefore find that the non-compliance with Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D was not a technical defect capable of being overlooked. It went to the process through which the amount payable as costs was ascertained and deprived the Applicants of the opportunity expressly afforded to them by the Rules to respond to the costs claimed before assessment.

27. It follows that the assessment and ascertainment of costs undertaken in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025 and the consequential Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 in the sum of Kshs.57,100 are irregular and cannot stand. The appropriate course is to set them aside and remit the question of costs to the lower court for fresh assessment upon compliance with Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D of the Civil Procedure Rules and the applicable provisions of the Advocates Remuneration Order.

Final Disposition

28. In the result, the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026 is merited and is allowed on the following terms:

a) The assessment and ascertainment of costs undertaken in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025 is hereby set aside.

b) The consequential Certificate of Costs dated 8th July 2026 in the sum of Kshs.57,100 is hereby set aside.

c) The issue of costs in Milimani MCELC/E868/2025 is hereby remitted to the subordinate court for fresh assessment in accordance with Order 21 Rules 9A to 9D of the Civil Procedure Rules and the applicable provisions of the Advocates Remuneration Order.

d) In view of the circumstances of the matter, each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 2nd day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Kiragu for the Applicant

N/A for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder