Land law

Kirundi v Karimi & another [2026] KEELC 7385 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elcl Appeal E091 of 2025
Judgment date
2 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court for determination is the 1st Respondent/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 20th April 2026 brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A, 78 and 79B of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rules 4, 11, 13 and 27 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the application, the affidavits filed in support of and in opposition thereto, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. In my view, the sole issue for determination is whether the irregularities in the Record of Appeal warrant the striking out of the appeal or are capable of being cured by appropriate orders of the Court.

Paragraph 20 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELCL APPEAL NO. E091 OF 2025

GEOFFREY CHEGE KIRUNDI.................................................APPELLANT/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS.

ANNE WATHUTI KARIMI.................................................1ST RESPONDENT/APPLICANT

EMBAKASI RANCHING COMPANY LIMITED.....................................2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court for determination is the 1st Respondent/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 20th April 2026 brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A, 78 and 79B of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rules 4, 11, 13 and 27 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

2. The Applicant principally seeks an order striking out the Record of Appeal filed on 23rd March 2026 for being incompetent, irregular, materially incomplete and an abuse of the process of the Court. In the alternative, she seeks the expunging and/or striking out of all documents and material in the Record of Appeal which did not form part of the pleadings, proceedings and evidence before the subordinate court, together with costs of the application.

3. The application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and is supported by the affidavit sworn by Anne Wathuti Karimi. The Applicant contends that the Record of Appeal is materially incomplete and defective for omitting parties, pleadings, documents and evidentiary material that formed part of the lower court record, and for including documents which were not produced, admitted or relied upon before the subordinate court.

4. In her Supporting Affidavit, the Applicant deponed that she had read and considered the Record of Appeal filed by the Appellant and had also perused the pleadings, proceedings and other documents filed in the subordinate court from which the appeal arose. She stated that the Record of Appeal did not include all the parties who had participated in the proceedings before the subordinate court. In particular, she deponed that the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General were parties to those proceedings but had not been included as parties in the appeal. She annexed copies of pleadings and extracts from the lower court record in support of that assertion.

5. The Applicant further deponed that the Record of Appeal did not contain all the pleadings, documents and evidentiary material that formed part of the lower court record. She specifically identified the documents appearing at pages 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 113, 114, 115 and 119 of the Record of Appeal as documents which, according to her, did not form part of the proceedings before the subordinate court and were neither produced, admitted nor relied upon during the trial. She annexed extracts from the subordinate court record which, she stated, did not show those documents as having been tendered in evidence, marked for identification or admitted as exhibits.

6. She further deponed that the impugned documents were at all material times within the Appellant’s possession, knowledge and control and that the Appellant had the opportunity to place them before the subordinate court during the hearing.

7. She stated that no explanation had been offered as to how, when or why they were not produced before the trial court; that the Appellant had not demonstrated that the trial court declined to admit any material evidence tendered by him; that no order had been made requiring the production of additional evidence or the examination of any witness for purposes of determining the appeal; and that no application had been made or leave granted to the Appellant to adduce additional evidence on appeal. The Applicant accordingly deponed that the impugned documents ought to be expunged from the Record of Appeal, or alternatively, that the Record of Appeal be struck out.

The Response

8. The application was opposed by the Appellant/Respondent through a Replying Affidavit sworn by Geoffrey Chege Kirundi on 22nd May 2026. He deponed that the application was premised on the omission of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General from the Record of Appeal, notwithstanding that they had been parties in Milimani CMELC No. E397 of 2022. He stated that although their names were omitted from the Record of Appeal, they had been served with the Memorandum of Appeal and notified of the filing of the appeal.

9. The Appellant further deponed that parties to proceedings from which an appeal arises are automatically parties to the appeal notwithstanding the omission of their names. He stated that the non-inclusion of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General was an error that could be cured through amendment of the Record of Appeal and that the omission did not go to the substance of the appeal.

10. On the documents impugned by the Applicant, the Appellant admitted that some of the documents identified in paragraph 10 of the Supporting Affidavit had not been produced during the hearing of Milimani CMELC No. E397 of 2022. He nevertheless deponed that the error could be cured by expunging those documents from the Record of Appeal. He specifically stated that the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 of the Record of Appeal had been produced as part of his documents during the hearing before the subordinate court and should therefore not be expunged.

11. He further deponed that the matters complained of in the application arose from human error and could be rectified through amendment of the Record of Appeal. He stated that the appeal raised triable issues with a high probability of success and prayed that it be allowed to proceed on its merits by granting him leave to file an amended Memorandum of Appeal and an amended Record of Appeal out of time.

12. In a Further Affidavit sworn on 9th June 2026, the Applicant reiterated that the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General had been parties to the proceedings before the subordinate court and maintained that their omission, together with the omission of pleadings and documents relating to them, rendered the Record of Appeal incomplete. She further deponed that the Appellant had not demonstrated service of the Memorandum of Appeal upon the Attorney General, noting that the annexure referred to in his Replying Affidavit as evidence of service had not been attached.

13. On the impugned documents, she acknowledged the Appellant’s admission that some documents had been introduced into the Record of Appeal without leave and agreed that they ought to be expunged, save for the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 which she had since ascertained formed part of the trial court bundle. She also maintained that the Appellant’s prayer in the Replying Affidavit for leave to file an amended Memorandum and Record of Appeal out of time could not properly be granted through a replying affidavit and ought to have been sought by way of a formal application.

Submissions

14. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions. The Applicant identified three issues for determination, namely: whether the documents introduced by the Respondent at the appellate stage without leave and without compliance with Order 42 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules were properly before the Court; whether the failure to join the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General, who had been parties before the trial court, rendered the appeal fatally defective; and what orders ought to issue on the application and costs.

15. On the first issue, the Applicant submitted that the Respondent had admitted introducing documents which had not formed part of the trial court record and had not obtained leave to adduce them as additional evidence. Reliance was placed on Mohamed Abdi Mohamed Vs Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamed & 3 Others [2018] eKLR on the principles governing admission of additional evidence on appeal and the prohibition against using additional evidence to fill gaps or patch weaknesses in a party’s case.

16. On the omission of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General, the Applicant submitted that the two had participated in the proceedings before the subordinate court and that the reliefs sought in the appeal were capable of affecting their interests. She relied on Njihia & Another Vs Njoroge (Environment and Land Appeal No. 15 of 2021) [2023] KEELC 17424 (KLR) for the proposition that failure to join, or at the very least properly serve, a party who had participated in the trial proceedings and whose interests were directly affected by the appeal could render the appeal fatally defective.

17. The Applicant further submitted that the inclusion of documents not forming part of the trial court record and the omission of parties who had participated before the trial court, considered cumulatively, rendered the appeal fundamentally defective and warranted its striking out, or alternatively the expunging of the impugned documents.

18. The Respondent, on the other hand, framed the issue for determination as whether the Applicant’s application ought to be allowed as prayed. He submitted that although some documents had been included in the Record of Appeal despite not having been produced at the trial, that error did not render the entire appeal fatally defective and could be cured by expunging the offending documents. He maintained that the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 had in fact been produced before the subordinate court. With regard to the omission of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General, the Respondent submitted that although they had not been named in the Memorandum of Appeal, they had been served with the Memorandum of Appeal and notified of the appeal. He distinguished Njihia & Another Vs Njoroge (supra) on the basis that, in the present appeal, no adverse orders were sought against the omitted parties and they had been served.

19. The Respondent further relied on William Kiprono Towett & 1597 Others Vs Farmland Aviation Ltd & 2 Others [2016] eKLR, in which the Court of Appeal applied Order 1 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules and held that a suit should not be defeated by reason of misjoinder or non-joinder of parties. He also relied on Raila Odinga Vs Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 4 Others, Petition No. 5 of 2013, on the need for courts to determine disputes on their merits rather than allow procedural prescriptions to override substantive justice. He consequently urged the Court to dismiss the application and permit the appeal to proceed on its merits.

ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION

20. I have considered the application, the affidavits filed in support of and in opposition thereto, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. In my view, the sole issue for determination is whether the irregularities in the Record of Appeal warrant the striking out of the appeal or are capable of being cured by appropriate orders of the Court.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

21. The Applicant’s challenge to the Record of Appeal rests on two principal grounds. The first is that the Respondent included documents which did not form part of the proceedings or evidence before the subordinate court and did so without leave of this Court. The second is that the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General, who were parties before the subordinate court, were omitted from the appeal. The Court must therefore determine the legal effect of each of these irregularities and whether, either individually or cumulatively, they warrant the striking out of the appeal.

22. As regards the documents included in the Record of Appeal, the starting point is Order 42 Rule 13(4) of the Civil Procedure Rules which identifies the documents that ought to be before the appellate court before an appeal proceeds to hearing. It provides, inter alia, that the record should contain the pleadings, the notes of the trial magistrate, the transcript of the proceedings, all affidavits, maps and other documents put in evidence before the magistrate, and the judgment, order or decree appealed from. The appellate record is therefore intended to place before the appellate court the material that was before the trial court and upon which the impugned decision was made.

23. Where a party desires to introduce evidence which did not form part of the proceedings before the trial court, the applicable provision is Order 42 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It provides as follows:

“The parties to an appeal shall not be entitled to produce additional evidence, whether oral or documentary, in the Court to which the appeal is preferred; but if—

a) the Court from whose decree the appeal is preferred has refused to admit evidence which ought to have been admitted; or

b) the Court to which the appeal is preferred requires any document to be produced or any witness to be examined to enable it to pronounce judgment, or for any other substantial cause,

the Court to which the appeal is preferred may allow such evidence or document to be produced, or witness to be examined.”

24. It follows that a party cannot, by the mere act of inserting documents into a Record of Appeal, convert material which was not before the trial court into evidence properly before the appellate court. Additional evidence may only be introduced in accordance with Order 42 Rule 27 and upon the Court being satisfied that the circumstances prescribed therein have been met.

25. The same question arose before the Court of Appeal in Kenya National Capital Corporation Limited Vs Galot & 5 Others [2023] KECA 958 (KLR). In that case, documents which had not been produced before the trial court were included in the record of appeal without an application for leave to adduce additional evidence. The Court held that a record of appeal cannot be used as a vehicle for introducing documents that were not part of the evidentiary record before the trial court. It consequently struck out the offending documents while declining to strike out the entire appeal.

26. In the present application, the position regarding the impugned documents is substantially common ground. The Respondent expressly admitted in his Replying Affidavit that some of the documents identified by the Applicant had not been produced during the hearing before the subordinate court. He contended, however, that the appropriate course would be to expunge those documents rather than strike out the appeal. He maintained that the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 of the Record of Appeal had formed part of his documents before the subordinate court.

27. The Applicant subsequently acknowledged in her Further Affidavit that, upon verification, the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 had indeed formed part of the trial court bundle and should therefore not be expunged. What consequently remains undisputed is that the other impugned documents identified by the Applicant were not produced or admitted in evidence before the subordinate court. There is equally no evidence that the Respondent sought or obtained leave under Order 42 Rule 27 to introduce them as additional evidence on appeal.

28. In those circumstances, those documents cannot properly remain part of the Record of Appeal. Their inclusion was irregular and the appropriate remedy is to expunge them. I am, however, not persuaded that their inclusion, without more, warrants the striking out of the entire appeal. As demonstrated in Kenya National Capital Corporation Limited Vs Galot & 5 Others (supra), the Court is capable of isolating and removing material improperly introduced into the appellate record without extinguishing an otherwise competent appeal. The defect is therefore curable by expunging the offending documents.

29. The second complaint concerns the omission of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General from the appeal notwithstanding their participation in the proceedings before the subordinate court. The Respondent does not dispute the omission. His position is that it arose through error, that the two parties had been notified of the appeal and that the omission could be remedied by amendment. The Applicant, on the other hand, maintains that the Respondent did not place before the Court evidence demonstrating service upon the omitted parties and that their absence renders the appeal defective.

30. Order 1 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that:

“No suit shall be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the Court may in every suit deal with the matter in controversy so far as regards the rights and interests of the parties actually before it.”

Order 1 Rule 10(2) further empowers the Court, at any stage of the proceedings and either upon or without an application by either party, to order the addition of a person whose presence before the Court may be necessary to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the proceedings.

31. The Respondent relied on William Kiprono Towett & 1597 Others Vs Farmland Aviation Ltd & 2 Others [2016] eKLR for the proposition that proceedings ought not to be defeated merely on account of misjoinder or non-joinder of parties. That principle is applicable in the circumstances before me. While it was incumbent upon the Respondent to properly identify the parties who participated in the proceedings from which the appeal arose, I do not consider the omission, in the circumstances of this case, to be an incurable defect requiring the appeal to be struck out.

32. I have also considered the Applicant’s reliance on Njihia & Another Vs Njoroge (Environment and Land Appeal No. 15 of 2021) [2023] KEELC 17424 (KLR). The significance of joining and serving parties whose interests may be affected by an appeal cannot be understated. Such parties ought to be afforded an opportunity to participate in the appellate proceedings. That consideration, however, does not necessarily mean that every omission to name a party who participated before the trial court must result in the termination of an appeal. The Court must consider whether the omission is capable of cure without occasioning prejudice or compromising the fair determination of the appeal.

33. In the present case, the appeal has not yet been heard. The omission can therefore be rectified before substantive consideration of the appeal by joining the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General and ensuring that they are served with the amended appellate documents. No prejudice incapable of being remedied has been demonstrated. Striking out the entire appeal in those circumstances would be disproportionate when the Court is able to cure the defect and preserve the parties’ right to have the appeal determined on its merits.

34. Having considered the two complaints together, I am not persuaded that the irregularities render the appeal incurably incompetent. The inclusion of documents which were not produced before the subordinate court is capable of being remedied by expunging those documents, while the omission of the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General is capable of being cured by their joinder and service before the appeal proceeds to hearing. The drastic remedy of striking out the entire appeal is therefore not warranted.

FINAL DISPOSITION

35. In the result, the Notice of Motion dated 20th April 2026 succeeds in part and I make the following orders:

a) The prayer seeking to strike out the Record of Appeal and the appeal is declined.

b) The documents appearing at pages 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115 and 119 of the Record of Appeal, having not formed part of the evidence before the subordinate court and having been introduced without leave of the Court, are hereby expunged from the Record of Appeal.

c) For avoidance of doubt, the documents appearing at pages 103 and 113 of the Record of Appeal shall remain on record, the parties having confirmed that they formed part of the trial court record.

d) The Respondent shall, within fourteen (14) days from the date hereof, amend the appellate pleadings to include the Ministry of Lands and the Honourable Attorney General as parties to the appeal and shall serve them with the amended documents.

e) The Respondent shall within the same period file and serve a duly regularized Record of Appeal consistent with the orders made herein.

f) In view of the partial success of the application, each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 2nd day of November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Odongo for the 1st Respondent/Applicant

Mr. Irungu for the 2nd Respondent

N/A for the Appellant

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder