Small Claims

Cuban Leaves Ltd v Owino [2026] SCC 79 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Mombasa
Case number
SCCCOMM/E226/2026 CUBAN LEAVES LTD VS JOHN OWINO
Judgment date
9 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claim succeeded. Judgment was entered for the Claimant for Kshs. 23,000, with an alternative order that the Respondent repair the Claimant’s wardrobe within 14 days or refund Kshs. 23,000. No interest was awarded on the principal sum, and the Claimant was awarded Kshs. 2,000 costs.

Supporting judgment passages

Ultimately, based on the evidence on record, the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities. Judgment is entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;

Passage 14 →

a) Judgment is entered for Kshs. 23,000/- being the consideration paid to the Respondent.

Passage 15 →

Claimant’s wardrobe within 14 days of the date of this judgment else refund the Claimant Kshs. 23,000/-.

Passage 17 →
Issue 1Whether the Respondent breached the contract for making the Claimant’s cabinet/wardrobe by delivering defective work and failing to rectify it after payment.

Held. Decided for the Claimant. The Respondent made the cabinet, but its doors were defective and required rectification. The Respondent acknowledged the defects in WhatsApp messages, did not rectify them, and instead demanded further money for materials despite having received the contractual payment. The Claimant proved the case on a balance of probabilities.

Ratio. A contractor who has been paid under a contract must perform with reasonable skill, care, diligence and competence. Where defects result from noncompliance, poor workmanship or improper materials, the contractor is responsible for rectifying them and cannot take advantage of his own default to impose the cost on the other contracting party.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The court has considered the pleadings, evidence in support as well as the written submissions in respect of both parties and finds that it is not in dispute that the Respondent was contracted to make a cabinet for the Claimant, which he did but its doors were found to be defective and required rectification. This was acknowledged by the Respondent as evidenced in the whatsapp messages filed, which are admitted in evidence as per Section 32 as read with Section 3(3)(d) of the Small Claims Court Act.

Court’s reasoning →

It has also been proven through the said whatsapp messages that the Respondent did not undertake the said rectifications and instead demanded for money to buy materials for the said work. This is despite causing the defeat and already receiving payment. As rightly submitted by the Claimant, the Respondent failed to exercise reasonable skill, care, diligence, and competence in performance of the contracted works. In Continental Homes Limited v Martova Limited (Civil Case E019 of 2021), the court was clear that the contractor is responsible for rectifying defects that are deemed to arise from noncompliance with the contract, poor workmanship, or use of improper materials. I associate myself with the finding of the court.

Passage 10 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

It has also been proven through the said whatsapp messages that the Respondent did not undertake the said rectifications and instead demanded for money to buy materials for the said work. This is despite causing the defeat and already receiving payment. As rightly submitted by the Claimant, the Respondent failed to exercise reasonable skill, care, diligence, and competence in performance of the contracted works. In Continental Homes Limited v Martova Limited (Civil Case E019 of 2021), the court was clear that the contractor is responsible for rectifying defects that are deemed to arise from noncompliance with the contract, poor workmanship, or use of improper materials. I associate myself with the finding of the court.

Passage 10 →

Ultimately, based on the evidence on record, the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities. Judgment is entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;

Passage 14 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It has also been proven through the said whatsapp messages that the Respondent did not undertake the said rectifications and instead demanded for money to buy materials for the said work. This is despite causing the defeat and already receiving payment. As rightly submitted by the Claimant, the Respondent failed to exercise reasonable skill, care, diligence, and competence in performance of the contracted works. In Continental Homes Limited v Martova Limited (Civil Case E019 of 2021), the court was clear that the contractor is responsible for rectifying defects that are deemed to arise from noncompliance with the contract, poor workmanship, or use of improper materials. I associate myself with the finding of the court.

Passage 10 →

In terms of relief therefore, the Respondent is obligated to rectify the cupboard to the required standards and specifications of the Claimant at his own costs or refund the contractual sum of Kshs. 23,000/-.

Passage 13 →
Issue 2What relief should follow from the Respondent’s defective and unrectified performance?

Held. The Respondent was obliged either to rectify the cupboard to the Claimant’s required standards and specifications at his own cost or refund the Kshs. 23,000 contractual sum. The final orders entered judgment for Kshs. 23,000, alternatively requiring repairs within 14 days, failing which the Respondent must refund Kshs. 23,000. No interest was awarded; costs of Kshs. 2,000 were awarded to the Claimant.

Ratio. Because the Respondent’s defective workmanship had not been rectified despite full payment, the appropriate contractual relief was rectification at the Respondent’s own cost or restoration of the consideration paid.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

In terms of relief therefore, the Respondent is obligated to rectify the cupboard to the required standards and specifications of the Claimant at his own costs or refund the contractual sum of Kshs. 23,000/-.

Passage 13 →

Ultimately, based on the evidence on record, the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities. Judgment is entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;

Passage 14 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

a) Judgment is entered for Kshs. 23,000/- being the consideration paid to the Respondent.

Passage 15 →

Claimant’s wardrobe within 14 days of the date of this judgment else refund the Claimant Kshs. 23,000/-.

Passage 17 →

c) There shall be no interest on (a) above.

Passage 18 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

In terms of relief therefore, the Respondent is obligated to rectify the cupboard to the required standards and specifications of the Claimant at his own costs or refund the contractual sum of Kshs. 23,000/-.

Passage 13 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Respondent breached the oral contract to make a cabinet by delivering defective work, failing to rectify it, and demanding further money; and whether the Claimant was entitled to a refund of Kshs. 23,000 or rectification at the Respondent’s cost.

Material facts

In about January 2025, Cuban Leaves Ltd engaged John Owino to prepare and complete a cabinet for Kshs. 23,000, comprising Kshs. 14,000 for materials and Kshs. 9,000 for labour. The Claimant paid the full amount. It alleged that the cabinet did not conform to…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT MOMBASA COUNTY COURT NAME: MOMBASA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E226/2026 CUBAN LEAVES LTD VS JOHN OWINO

JUDGMENT

The Claimant, acting in good faith, engaged the services of the Respondent sometime in or about January 2025 for the preparation and completion of a cabinet at an agreed consideration of Kshs. 23,000/=. The terms of the oral agreement were clear and unequivocal. Out of the agreed sum, Kshs. 14,000/= was to cater for materials while Kshs. 9,000/= was to constitute labour charges. The Claimant fully honoured its obligations under the agreement by remitting the entire agreed consideration to the Respondent which is not denied.

The Claimant states that the Respondent fundamentally breached the agreement in multiple respects. First, the Respondent failed to produce a cabinet conforming to the agreed specifications. Second, despite receiving full payment, the Respondent failed to complete the work. Third, the Respondent improperly demanded additional monies from the Claimant in order to rectify defects arising from his own workmanship. Fourth, the Respondent engaged in persistent delay and evasion. Consequently, the Claimant seeks refund of Kshs. 23,000/- from the Respondent.

On his part, the Respondent attributes the breach of the contract to the frustrations by the Claimant. The Respondent submits that he commenced performance of the contract, a sum of around Kshs. 14,000/= was utilized in the purchase of materials, which the balance was intended to cater for labour and completion of the works.

Further, that it is the Claimant who failed and/or refused to facilitate completion of the work and rejected the work in progress.

The court has considered the pleadings, evidence in support as well as the written submissions in respect of both parties and finds that it is not in dispute that the Respondent was contracted to make a cabinet for the Claimant, which he did but its doors were found to be defective and required rectification. This was acknowledged by the Respondent as evidenced in the whatsapp messages filed, which are admitted in evidence as per Section 32 as read with Section 3(3)(d) of the Small Claims Court Act.

It has also been proven through the said whatsapp messages that the Respondent did not undertake the said rectifications and instead demanded for money to buy materials for the said work. This is despite causing the defeat and already receiving payment. As rightly submitted by the Claimant, the Respondent failed to exercise reasonable skill, care, diligence, and competence in performance of the contracted works. In Continental Homes Limited v Martova Limited (Civil Case E019 of 2021), the court was clear that the contractor is responsible for rectifying defects that are deemed to arise from noncompliance with the contract, poor workmanship, or use of improper materials. I associate myself with the finding of the court.

In interpreting the conduct of the parties in execution of a contract, the Court in Hassan Zubeidi – Versus - Patrick Mwangangi Kibaiya & another [2014] eKLR held that:

“the legal position is that a party should never be allowed to take advantage of his wrongs/omissions at the expense of the other party. The 1st respondent is seeking to walk away from the JVA with the sole intention of defeating the Applicant's interest notwithstanding the fact that the Applicant's money has been used to significantly reduce the 2nd Respondent's indebtedness to the bank.”

In terms of relief therefore, the Respondent is obligated to rectify the cupboard to the required standards and specifications of the Claimant at his own costs or refund the contractual sum of Kshs. 23,000/-.

Ultimately, based on the evidence on record, the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities. Judgment is entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;

a) Judgment is entered for Kshs. 23,000/- being the consideration paid to the Respondent.

b) In the alternative to (a) above the Respondent to undertake repairs of the

Claimant’s wardrobe within 14 days of the date of this judgment else refund the Claimant Kshs. 23,000/-.

c) There shall be no interest on (a) above.

d) Cost are awarded to the Claimant of Kshs. 2,000/-.

DATED SIGNED AND READ VIRTUALLY AT MOMBASA THE……9th….DAY

OF……JUNE………2026

In the presence of;


HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

……N/A….for Claimant;

…N/A… for Respondent C/A Esther

SIGNED BY/FOR:

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-09 10:25:39

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-09 10:25:39

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder