Background
The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide a Plaint dated 16th December
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide a Plaint dated 16th December
Paragraph 1 →Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Preliminary Objection, responses, including submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the said Preliminary Objection is merited.
Paragraph 14 →In the foregoing, while relying on the legal provisions cited and associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that this suit including Counterclaim is res judicata ELC 198 of 2011 Burton Wachira Githinji & 2 Others v Henry Ruhiu and Milimani Miscellaneous App. No. E 165 of 2024 Issack Hassan Abdi & Another v Burton Wachira Githinji (Sued as the Chairperson and on Behalf of Umoja II Residents Welfare Association), as the issue…
Paragraph 27 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L CASE NO. E628 OF 2025
TITUS DAVID MUTIO ………………………………..……. 1ST PLAINTIFF
MERCY KWEYU .................................................. 2ND PLAINTIFF
JOHN KARIUKI …………………………………………..… 3RD PLAINTIFF
(Suing on their Behalf and on Behalf of the other Shop Owners)
VERSUS
ISSACK HASSAN ABDI ………………………………... 1ST DEFENDANT
ALI ISSA EGAL ................................................. 2ND DEFENDANT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ................................... 3RD DEFENDANT
NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION ..................... 4TH DEFENDANT
NAIROBI LAND REGISTRAR ............................ 5TH DEFENDANT
ATTORNEY GENERAL …................................... 6TH DEFENDANT
BY WAY OF COUNTERCLAIM
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ............................................ PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
ISSACK HASSAN ABDI & 7 OTHERS .................... DEFENDANTS
RULING
1. The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide a Plaint dated 16th December
2025 seeking orders inter alia: that LR No. Umoja Block 107/1057 is public land held by the 3rd Defendant, which has allotted over three hundred (300) of them shops/stalls, and a declaration that the 1st and 2nd Defendants have no claim over the said property.
2. In opposition, the 1st and 2nd Defendants filed the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 7th July 2026 which is for determination. They contend that the suit is incompetent as it offends the provisions of Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act.
Response
3. The 3rd Defendant filed Grounds of Opposition to the Preliminary Objection. It contends that it does not raise a pure point of law as it requires the Court to examine the Judgment, pleadings and record in Nairobi ELC Case No. 198 of 2011 and Milimani ELC Misc. Application No. E165 of 2024. Further, that the elements of res judicata under section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act have not been met. It insists that this Court has a constitutional duty to inquire into the root of title and that under Articles 40(6), 62 and 67 of the Constitution, a title to land is not protected if unlawfully alienated from the public. Further, that Misc. Application No. E165 of 2024 did not determine title to public land as between the 1st and 2nd Defendants and itself.
4. The 4th to 6th Defendants did not file responses.
5. The Preliminary Objection was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
6. The 1st and 2nd Defendants submit that their Preliminary Objection raises a pure point of law being that the suit offends Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act and is therefore barred under the doctrine of res judicata. They contend that the question of ownership of the suit property was conclusively determined in Nairobi ELC Case No. 198 of 2011 vide Judgment delivered on 7th May 2019. Further, that flowing from the said Judgment, they lawfully purchased the suit property from Henry Ruhiu, obtained the requisite development approvals and subsequently issued eviction notices under Section 152E of the Land Act and obtained eviction orders in Nairobi ELC Miscellaneous Application No. E165 of 2024. They urge the Court to resist the invitation to reopen matters already determined through the introduction of additional parties and a fresh cause of action.
7. To buttress their averments, they relied on the following decisions: Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya v Kenya Airways Limited & 3 Others [2015] eKLR; Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd (1969) EA 696; John Florence Maritime Services Limited & Another v Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 Others [2021] KESC 39 (KLR); Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Muiri Coffee Estate Limited & Another [2016] eKLR; Ngeta & 3 Others v Mutuku & 4 Others [2023] KEELC 17845 (KLR); Henderson v Henderson (1843) 67 ER 313; Bernard Mugo Ndegwa v James Nderitu Githae & 2 Others (2010) eKLR; E.T. v Attorney General & Another (2012) eKLR; and Mercy Munee Kingoo & Another v Safaricom Limited & Another [2016] eKLR.
8. On their part, the Plaintiffs submit that the 1st and 2nd Defendants’ Preliminary Objection does not raise a pure point of law since the Court is called upon to wade through facts which are disputed. They insist that they are lawful allottees of market stalls at Umoja II Market situated on the suit property, which is public land. They argue that the requirements of res judicata under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act have not been satisfied, particularly the identity of parties, issues and reliefs sought in the previous and present proceedings.
9. The Plaintiffs further submit that Nairobi ELC Case No. 198 of 2011 only determined whether Henry Ruhiu had fraudulently acquired his title, which allegation was dismissed for want of proof thus the said Court did not determine whether the suit property constituted public land or conclusively establish its rightful ownership, and that Milimani ELC Miscellaneous Application No. E165 of 2024 merely sought to enforce the said Judgment through eviction orders and did not determine the outstanding questions of ownership.
10. To buttress their averments, they relied on the following decisions: General & Another v Andrew Mwaura Githinji & Another [2016] eKLR; Michuki v Kitsao & 2 Others [2023] KEELC 16503 (KLR); and Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, also reported as [2017] KECA 477 (KLR).
11. The 3rd Defendant submits that the 1st and 2nd Defendants’ Preliminary Objection is incompetent as it does not raise a pure point of law, its determination requiring examination of contested facts, pleadings and evidence from previous proceedings. Further, that the threshold of res judicata under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act has not been satisfied. It points out that it was neither a party to the previous proceedings nor did it claim under any party thereto. It maintains that its case in its Counterclaim concerns public utility land held in trust for the people of Nairobi and raises distinct questions regarding the legality of the 1st and 2nd Defendants’ title, which issue were never conclusively determined in the previous suits.
12. It also argues that its Counterclaim constitutes an independent cross-suit under Order 7 Rules 3 and 13 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which survives notwithstanding any dismissal of the Plaintiffs’ suit. Further, that Article 40 (6) of the Constitution does not protect unlawfully acquired property and that land reserved for public use cannot lawfully be alienated to private individuals.
13. To buttress its averments, it relied on the following cases: Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya v Kenya Airways Ltd & 3 Others [2015] eKLR; Oraro v Mbaja [2005] 1 KLR 141; Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] KECA 477 (KLR); Omondi v National Bank of Kenya Ltd [2001] EA 477 and Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR).
Analysis and Determination
14. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Preliminary Objection, responses, including submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the said Preliminary Objection is merited.
15. The 1st and 2nd Defendants have raised a preliminary objection insisting that this suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata by dint of Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. They contend that in a Judgement delivered on 7th May 2019 in ELC No. 198 of 2011, Burton Wachira Githinji & Others v Henry Ruhiu, Henry Ruhiu was declared owner of the suit property which they lawfully purchased from him, thus they subsequently sought eviction orders against the Plaintiffs vide Milimani ELC Miscellaneous Application No. E165 of 2024, which orders were granted.
16. The Plaintiffs opposed the allegation that the suit is res judicata and contend that in the former suit, the Court did not determine whether the suit property had been fraudulently acquired, but not whether the suit property constituted public land. They acknowledge that the subsequent Ruling of 20th November 2025 in ELC Misc. Application E165 of 2024 granted eviction Orders in enforcement of the said Judgment in the former suit. They argue that neither the parties nor the issues are identical and insist that the question of whether the suit property is public land has never been conclusively determined.
17. In the same vein, the 3rd Defendant contends that the elements that constitute res judicata have not been met. Further, that its Counterclaim raises issues of protection of public land which were not determined in the former suit and that it is an independent cross-suit under Order 7 Rules 3 and 13 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which survives notwithstanding any dismissal of the Plaintiffs’ suit.
18. It is an established principle of law that a Preliminary Objection must raise a pure point of law and cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained. This was captured in the case of Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd (1969) EA 696 as follows:
“So far as I am aware, a Preliminary Objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to the jurisdiction of the court or a plea of limitation, or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the dispute to arbitration.”
19. Res judicata is anchored in Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act which provides that:
“No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such Court.”
20. The Supreme court stated as follows in Communications
Commission of Kenya & 5 others v Royal Media Services Limited & 5 others [2014] KESC 53 (KLR):
“(317) The concept of res judicata operates to prevent causes of action, or issues from being relitigated once they have been determined on the merits. It encompasses limits upon both issues and claims, and the issues that may be raised in subsequent proceedings….There are conditions to the application of the doctrine of res judicata: i. the issue in the first suit must have been decided by a competent Court; (ii) the matter in dispute in the former suit between the parties must be directly or substantially in dispute between the parties in the suit where the doctrine is pleaded as a bar; and (iii) the parties in the former suit should be the same parties, or parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title...” Emphasis Mine
21. In their defence, the Plaintiffs and the 3rd Defendant argue that res judicata as raised herein requires the Court to examine facts and pleadings in the former suit, thus it does not amount to a pure point of law. The Court of Appeal has taken the position that res judicata can be properly addressed in liminine. It stated as follows in Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Kiai & 5 others [2017] KECA 477 (KLR):
“Res judicata is a matter properly to be addressed in limine as it does possess jurisdictional consequence because it constitutes a statutory peremptory preclusion of a certain category of suits. That much is clear from Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, 2010.” Emphasis Mine
22. Upon perusal of the judgement in ELC 198 of 2011, I note the suit property is NAIROBI/ UMOJA 107/1/1057 while the suit property herein is NAIROBI/UMOJA 107/1057. The Plaintiffs therein who were members of the UMOJA II Residents Welfare Association sought for cancellation the Defendant’s (Henry Ruhiu)’s Title and Certificate of Lease for Nairobi/ Umoja Block 107/1 / 1057. The Court (Justice JM Onyango) in her judgement dated the 7th May, 2019 dismissed the Plaintiffs’ claim and upheld the Title and Certificate of Lease for Nairobi / Umoja Block 107/1/1057 in the name of Henry Ruhiu. I note in the said Judgement, there was mention of other previous suits being HCCC No. 1655 of 2000 and HCCC No. 6888 of 2007 whose fulcrum also revolved around NAIROBI/ UMOJA/ BLOCK 107/1/1057. The 1st and 2nd Defendants herein confirm that they purchased the said land from Henry Ruhiu and have a Title to that effect.
23. The 1st and 2nd Defendants vide Milimani ELC Misc. Application No. E 165 of 2024 obtained eviction Orders against the Plaintiffs from land parcel number NAIROBI/ UMOJA BLOCK 107/1/1057 on 20th November, 2025. The Plaintiffs commenced this suit in December 2025, wherein they seek a declaration that NAIROBI/ UMOJA BLOCK 107/1057 is public land and the Plaintiffs are lawful allottees of their respective plots from the Nairobi County Government. They have also sought for a declaration that the 1st and 2nd Defendants have no legitimate rights or claim over LR NO. NAIROBI / UMOJA BLOCK 107/1057 as well as a permanent injunction to restrain them from the said land.
24. The Plaintiffs and 3rd Defendant have argued that the Preliminary Objection is not merited and it does not raise pure points of law as facts have to be ascertained. Further, that the 3rd Defendant insists that even if the ownership of the suit property had been determined, but since it has a Counterclaim claiming that the said suit property is public land, the preliminary objection is unmerited.
25. In the case of Koross (Legal personal representative of Elijah CA Koross) v Komen & 4 others (Civil Appeal 223 of 2013) [2015] KECA 906 (KLR) (6 March 2015) (Judgment), the Court of Appeal held that:
“Before delving into res judicata proper, we need to statethat there cannot properly be two judgments, and contradictory ones at that, in the same suit. The presence of a counterclaim in a suit, while essentially amounting to a cross-suit, does not give rise to a separate, stand-alone second judgment. A counterclaim never stands on its own and cannot be a pleading independent of a defence. ……. This rule is in pari materia with Order 8 Rule 6A (2) of the Indian Civil Procedure Rules and Sir Dinshah Fordunji Mulla in The Code of Civil Procedure, 18 th Edition, 2011 at p. 1928 has addressed the essence of the suit and the counterclaim as constituting unfiled proceedings as follows; “A counterclaim has the effect of a cross-suit but only one final judgment is to be pronounced in the suit on the original claim of the plaintiff and the counterclaim of the defendant”. Emphasis Mine
26. In the foregoing, while relying on this Court of Appeal decision, I opine that since a Court of competent jurisdiction has determined the issue of ownership of the suit property and there was no review or Appeal, as a Court I cannot deal with that issue once more since it will be like sitting on Appeal of a fellow Judge’s decision. Further, even if the Counterclaim is dealing with the issue of public land, and it amounts to a cross suit, it does not give rise to a separate, stand-alone second judgment as it cannot stand on its own nor be independent of a defence. I opine that the 3rd Defendant can seek for joinder and review of ELC 198 of 2011 so as to canvass the issues whether the suit property is public land or not.
27. In the foregoing, while relying on the legal provisions cited and associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that this suit including Counterclaim is res judicata ELC 198 of 2011 Burton Wachira Githinji & 2 Others v Henry Ruhiu and Milimani Miscellaneous App. No. E 165 of 2024 Issack Hassan Abdi & Another v Burton Wachira Githinji (Sued as the Chairperson and on Behalf of Umoja II Residents Welfare Association), as the issue revolving around the suit property was decided by Courts of competent Court. Further, that the matter in dispute in the former suit which was the suit property between the parties therein, is also directly and substantially in dispute between the parties herein. Insofar as there are addition of other parties, in my view parties in the former suit who are Umoja Welfare Association, are the same as in the current suit, as they are shop owners on the suit property, hence are all litigating under the same title.
28. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 7th July 2026 merited, will proceed to dismiss this suit including the Counterclaim with costs to the 1st, 2nd and 4th Defendants.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 3RD DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Ms Kyule for Laichena for Plaintiffs
Ms Mwanyika for 4th Defendant
Ms Cheserek for 3rd Defendant
Beatrice Mathenge for 5th and 6th Defendants
Court Assistant: Joan