Land law

Manair Limited v Vitalis Limited & 3 others [2026] KEELC 7510 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Appeal E175 of 2025
Judgment date
3 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court for determination are two applications by the 1st Respondent/Applicant, Vitalis Limited. The first is the Notice of Motion dated 10th April 2026, while the second is the Notice of Motion dated 5th May 2026.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

In Waiyaki Vs Kajiado County Government & 3 others [2025] KEELC 5567 (KLR), the Court held: “The Court has the authority to order a site visit in land disputes where physical verification is necessary to resolve issues of boundaries, extent of the land, occupation, or physical developments. This discretion is exercised judiciously to complement, not replace, documentary and oral evidence, ensuring that the court is fully informed…

Paragraph 30 →

Reasoning passage

Based on the above, I find the report was prepared based on observations without using any scientific or technical processes to arrive at the said decision and thus the findings of the physical condition of the premises and the painting thereon without verifiable scientific or technical process invalidates the entire report. Accordingly, the prayer seeking to set aside and expunge the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 is…

Paragraph 37 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC APPEAL NO. E175 OF 2025

MANAIR LIMITED............................................................APPELLANT/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

VITALIS LIMITED.........................................................1ST RESPONDENT/APPLICANT

PETER MWANGI NYAGA.............................................................2ND RESPONDENT

NAHR JUBA GENERAL
TRADING COMPANY LLC..........................................
...................3RD RESPONDENT

AND

GILBERT MR. MASENGELI, DEPUTY INSPECTOR
GENERAL, ADMINISTRATION POLICE……
…………INTENDED 4TH RESPONDENT

RULING

The Applications

1. Before this Court for determination are two applications by the 1st Respondent/Applicant, Vitalis Limited. The first is the Notice of Motion dated 10th April 2026, while the second is the Notice of Motion dated 5th May 2026.

2. In the Notice of Motion dated 10th April 2026, prayers 1 and 2 are spent. The 1st Respondent/Applicant seeks an order that the Court set aside and expunge from its record the site visit report; an order for the joinder of Gilbert Mr. Masengeli, Deputy Inspector General (Administration Police), as the 4th Respondent; and, upon such joinder, an order finding him in contempt of Court for deploying officers to the suit property known as Land Reference No. 20274 (I.R 63991) and interfering with the Applicant’s occupation of the suit premises in defiance of subsisting orders. The Applicant also seeks costs of the application.

3. The application is supported by the affidavit of Mohamed Yassin Mohamed, a director of the 1st Respondent/Applicant. He deponed that prior to the site visit scheduled for 18th November 2025, the Appellant/Respondent procured the deployment of Administration Police officers to the suit premises, who oversaw the repainting of the premises by removing the name of the 1st Respondent/Applicant and replacing it with that of Truckmart Africa Limited. He further deponed that the said officers barred the Applicant’s representatives from accessing the suit premises and that, as a result, the Applicant was not present when the site visit was conducted on 18th November 2025.

4. He further deponed that the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 did not accurately reflect the state of occupation of the suit premises. In particular, he averred that the Deputy Registrar stated in the report that the paint applied to the premises was not fresh, notwithstanding that he was neither qualified nor recognised as an expert in that field within the contemplation of sections 48 and 49 of the Evidence Act.

5. He also deponed that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli, being the Deputy Inspector General in charge of the Administration Police, was responsible for the deployment of Administration Police officers and that his joinder was necessary on account of the alleged deployment of the officers who oversaw the repainting of the premises and barred the Applicant from accessing the property despite subsisting injunctive orders.

6. The deponent further averred that the Appellant/Respondent’s claim over the suit property was solely predicated upon the judgment in ELC Case No. 34 of 2018, Manair Limited Vs Fleet Logistics Limited, Sigma Limited, National Land Commission and the Chief Land Registrar, whose execution had been stayed and which was the subject of a pending appeal before the Court of Appeal. He further averred that the Appellant/Respondent had not demonstrated how it took possession of the suit premises prior to the site visit, there being no evidence of eviction proceedings instituted against the 1st Respondent/Applicant.

7. The second application is the Notice of Motion dated 5th May 2026, brought under sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 and all other enabling provisions of the law. The Applicant seeks an order certifying the matter urgent and dispensing with service; an order arresting the delivery of the ruling scheduled for 7th May 2026 pending the hearing and determination of the application; an order reviewing the directions and/or orders issued on 13th April 2026 and arresting the delivery of the ruling scheduled for 7th May 2026 pending the hearing and determination of the application dated 10th April 2026; and costs of the application.

8. In support of the application, Mohamed Yassin Mohamed swore an affidavit on 5th May 2026 in which he deponed that on 10th April 2026, the Applicant had moved the Court through an application of the same date seeking to arrest the ruling on the Appellant/Respondent’s application dated 19th September 2025, which was scheduled for delivery on 7th May 2026. He stated that the application was placed before Hon. Justice Mohamed N. Kullow, who directed that it be served and fixed it for hearing on 12th May 2026.

9. He further deponed that the application dated 10th April 2026 challenged the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 on the ground that it did not accurately reflect the state of occupation of L.R. No. 20274 (I.R 63991). He stated that the Appellant/Respondent had painted the gate to the premises and erased the Applicant’s name shortly before the site visit, while maintaining that despite the repainting of the entrance, the Applicant remained in actual possession of the suit property.

10. He further deponed that the Appellant/Respondent’s claim over the suit property was predicated upon the judgment in ELC Case No. 34 of 2018, whose execution had been stayed. According to the deponent, the issues raised in the application dated 10th April 2026 had a significant and direct bearing on the ruling scheduled for delivery on 7th May 2026. He averred that delivery of the ruling before determination of that application would render the application nugatory and subject the Applicant to irreparable harm. He therefore deponed that it was in the interest of the proper administration of justice that the scheduled ruling be arrested and the issues raised in the application dated 10th April 2026 be determined first.

The Response

10. The applications are opposed through a Replying Affidavit sworn by Kaushnik L. Manek, a director of the Appellant/Respondent, on 13th May 2026. He deponed that the applications dated 10th April 2026 and 5th May 2026 were an abuse of the court process, misleading and frivolous. He maintained that the Appellant/Respondent is the registered owner of the suit property and averred that the Applicant had not approached the Court with clean hands and was seeking to delay the delivery of the ruling scheduled for 7th May 2026.

11. The deponent averred that on 13th November 2025, all parties appeared before the Court for a ruling in respect of the Appellant’s application dated 19th September 2025. He stated that the Court vacated the ruling and directed that a site visit be conducted on 18th November 2025 to establish which party was in possession or occupation of the suit property. He further deponed that the parties appeared before the Deputy Registrar on 13th November 2025 and confirmed that the site visit would be conducted on 18th November 2025 in the presence of all the parties together with their advocates.

12. He further deponed that the 1st Respondent/Applicant subsequently filed an application dated 17th November 2025 seeking, inter alia, an injunction restraining the deployment of Administration Police officers to the suit premises and to have the Court confirm which party was in occupation. He stated that the Court did not certify that application as urgent and that the site visit therefore proceeded as scheduled on 18th November 2025 in the presence of the Advocate for the Appellant/Respondent, the Advocate for the 1st Respondent/Applicant, two representatives of the Appellant/Respondent and the Deputy Registrar. He averred that the 1st Respondent/Applicant was not present at the site visit despite the Court having directed that all parties be present.

13. The deponent further averred that during the site visit, the Deputy Registrar inspected the perimeter boundary and confirmed that there was no new or fresh paint on the walls and gate arising from the alleged removal of the 1st Respondent/Applicant’s name. He stated that pursuant to the site visit, the Deputy Registrar filed a report dated 19th November 2025, which stated that Truckmart Africa Limited, being tenants of the Appellant, were in occupation of the suit property. He further averred that the Applicant had, in its application dated 17th November 2025 and Replying Affidavit of the same date, made allegations that the Appellant had repainted the wall and main gate of the suit property and deprived it of possession.

14. He deponed that the site visit report was an independent report arising from the Court-ordered site visit and maintained that the Applicant had not provided sufficient reasons for it to be set aside. He further averred that the report was prepared pursuant to Court orders and was not tainted by fraud. He stated that the orders directing the site visit were suo motu orders of the Court and had neither been reviewed nor set aside.

15. On the proposed joinder and contempt proceedings, the deponent averred that there was no basis for joining Gilbert Mr. Masengeli, Deputy Inspector General (Administration Police), as the 4th Respondent. He stated that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli was not a party in the trial court and that no orders had been issued against him. He further deponed that the 1st Respondent/Applicant had not provided sufficient reasons or proof that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli deployed officers to the suit property who interfered with its occupation. He maintained that the applications dated 10th April 2026 and 5th May 2026 lacked merit and ought to be dismissed with costs.

The 1st Respondent/Applicant’s Further Affidavit

16. In a Further Affidavit sworn on 20th May 2026, Mohamed Yassin Mohamed reiterated that the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 did not accurately reflect the state of occupation of the suit premises. He averred that prior to the site visit, the Appellant had procured the deployment of Administration Police officers who allegedly oversaw the repainting of the premises, removal of the Applicant’s name and prevented its representatives from accessing the premises despite subsisting injunctive orders. He further averred that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli, by virtue of his office as Deputy Inspector General of the Administration Police Service and the functions of that office under Section 26 of the National Police Service Act, was responsible for the deployment and was therefore a necessary party to the proceedings. He attributed the Applicant’s absence from the site visit to its representatives having allegedly been barred from accessing the premises by the deployed officers.

17. He further averred that, at the time of the site visit on 18th November 2025, the Applicant’s application dated 17th November 2025, which sought to forestall the actions complained of, had not received substantive directions. He maintained that the site visit report ought to be expunged on account of the Deputy Registrar’s observation concerning the state of the paint at the premises. He also reiterated that the Appellant’s claim over the suit property was founded on the judgment in ELC Case No. 34 of 2018, whose execution had been stayed and which was the subject of a pending appeal, and contended that the Appellant had not demonstrated how it took possession of the premises prior to the site visit in the absence of eviction proceedings against the Applicant.

Submissions

18. On 30th September 2026 the court directed that the applications be canvassed by way of written submissions. The 1st Respondent/Applicant identified three issues for determination, namely, whether the site visit report should be expunged from the Court record; whether Gilbert Mr. Masengeli should be joined as the 4th Respondent; and whether he should be held in contempt of Court. On the first issue, it submitted that the Deputy Registrar exceeded the scope of the site visit by rendering an opinion that the paint on the premises was not fresh and that the report did not reflect the true state of occupation of the property.

19. In support of its position on the purpose and limits of a site visit, the Applicant relied on Mukasa v Uganda EA 698 at 700; Beatrice Ngonyo Ndungu & another Vs Samuel K. Kanyoro & 2 Others [2017] eKLR; Opio Simon Ongiera Vs Onyai Furasika, Civil Appeal No. 0039 of 2014 [2016] UGHC; and E. Kangye Vs E. Bwana, Kampala HCCS No. 38 of 1989, as cited in Masila v Ndolo [2023] KEELC.

20. It further relied on West Build General Contractors Limited & Another Vs NCBA Bank & Another [2025] KEHC; Kairu (Suing on her behalf and as Administrator of the Estate of Kairu Kahengeri-Deceased) Vs Gatheru & 5 Others [2026] KEELC; Mansukhlal S. Patel v Brian Hune Naylor & 3 Others, Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2000; and James Ndungu Wanjiku Vs Reuben Mwangi Nguri [2011] eKLR in support of its submissions concerning the alleged misrepresentation of the state of occupation and the preservation of property by an interlocutory injunction.

21. On joinder, the 1st Respondent/Applicant relied on Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules and Departed Asians Property Custodian Board Vs Jaffer Brothers Ltd [1999] EA, as cited with approval in Frann Investment Limited Vs Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & 6 Others, Civil Appeal E038 of 2021, and submitted that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli was a necessary party because an order of contempt was specifically sought against him.

22. On contempt, it relied on Econet Wireless Kenya Ltd. Vs Minister for Information & Communication of Kenya & Another [2005] KLR on the obligation to obey court orders and Kristen Carla Burchell Vs Barry Grant Burchell, Eastern Cape Division Case No. 364 of 2005, as cited in Katsuri Limited Vs Kapurchand Depar Shah [2016] eKLR, on the elements required to establish civil contempt. It maintained that the subsisting injunctive orders had been disobeyed through the deployment of Administration Police officers to the suit property and urged the Court to allow the applications with costs.

23. The Appellant/Respondent, on its part, identified three issues for determination: whether the Court-ordered site visit report dated 19th November 2025 could be reviewed, set aside or expunged from the Court record; whether the 1st Respondent/Applicant had met the threshold for the joinder of Gilbert Mr. Masengeli as the 4th Respondent; and whether the applications constituted an abuse of the court process.

24. On the first issue, it submitted that the site visit was conducted pursuant to the Court’s own orders and that the Deputy Registrar merely inspected the property and recorded what was physically observable rather than rendering an expert opinion. It relied on Order 18 Rule 11 and Order 40 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and on Abdalla Vs Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 Others (Petition 34 of 2018) [2019] KESC 52 (KLR), together with Evans Odhiambo Kidero & 4 Others Vs Ferdinand Ndungu Waititu & 4 Others [2014] eKLR, in support of the place of a court-ordered report in judicial determination. It further relied on Outa Vs Okello & 3 Others [2017] KESC 25 (KLR) in submitting that the Court had become functus officio in respect of the specific mandate pursuant to which the site visit had been ordered and undertaken.

25. On joinder, the Appellant/Respondent submitted that Gilbert Mr. Masengeli had not been a party to the proceedings before the trial court and that his joinder at the appellate stage would introduce matters and evidence outside the record from the trial court. It relied on Mohamed Abdi Mahamud Vs Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamed & 3 Others [2018] KECA 677 (KLR) on the admission of additional evidence on appeal.

26. It further relied on Kamau Vs Owiti & 2 Others; Osugo & another [2023] KEELC 20645 (KLR), which cited Meme Vs Republic [2004] 1 EA 124, on the principles governing joinder, and submitted that no legal or proprietary interest had been demonstrated to make the intended 4th Respondent a necessary party to the appeal. The Appellant/Respondent consequently maintained that the two applications constituted an abuse of the court process and urged the Court to dismiss them with costs.

Issues for Determination

27. Having considered the two applications, the affidavits in support and opposition thereto, the further affidavit, the parties’ respective submissions and the authorities relied upon, the issues that arise for determination are:

a) Whether the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 ought to be set aside and expunged from the Court record.

b) Whether Gilbert Mr. Masengeli ought to be joined as the 4th Respondent and, if so, whether he should be held in contempt of Court.

Analysis and Determination

Whether the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 ought to be set aside and expunged from the Court record

28. The Applicant seeks to have the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 set aside and expunged from the Court record. It contends that the report did not reflect the true state of occupation of the suit property and faults the Deputy Registrar for recording that there was no fresh painting at the premises erasing the Applicant’s name. The Appellant opposes the prayer and maintains that the report records the state of affairs found during a site visit conducted pursuant to the Court’s directions.

29. Order 18 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides: “The court may at any stage of a suit inspect any property or thing concerning which any question may arise.”

30. In Waiyaki Vs Kajiado County Government & 3 others [2025] KEELC 5567 (KLR), the Court held: “The Court has the authority to order a site visit in land disputes where physical verification is necessary to resolve issues of boundaries, extent of the land, occupation, or physical developments. This discretion is exercised judiciously to complement, not replace, documentary and oral evidence, ensuring that the court is fully informed before rendering judgment.”

31. Further, in Sojanm Springfields Limited Vs Githinji & 4 others (Civil Appeal 73 of 2019) [2024] KECA 953 (KLR), the Court of Appeal adopted the guidelines in Kimonidimitri Mantheakis Vs Ally Azim Dewji & others (Civil Appeal No. 4 of 2018) [2021] TZCA 663, and stated: “In the light of the cited decisions, for the visit of the locus in quo to be meaningful, it is instructive for the trial Judge or Magistrate to: one, ensure that all parties, their witnesses, and advocates (if any) are present. Two, allow the parties and their witnesses to adduce evidence on oath at the locus in quo; three, allow cross-examination by either party, or his counsel, four, record all the proceedings at the locus in quo; and five record any observation, view, opinion or conclusion of the court including drawing a sketch plan, if necessary, which must be made known to the parties and advocates, if any.”

32. In the present case, the site visit was undertaken pursuant to the Court’s directions after delivery of the ruling on the Appellant’s application dated 19th September 2025 had been deferred. The purpose of the visit was to establish which party was in possession or occupation of L.R. No. 20274 (I.R. 63991). The report subsequently prepared by the Deputy Registrar records that, on 18th November 2025, the Applicant was not in occupation of the premises and that Truckmart Africa Limited was found in occupation as a tenant of the Appellant.

33. The Applicant does not dispute that the site visit was ordered by the Court. Its challenge is directed at the state of affairs recorded in the report. It maintains that prior to the visit, Administration Police officers had been deployed to the premises, where they allegedly oversaw the repainting of the property, removal of the Applicant’s name and replacement thereof with that of Truckmart Africa Limited, and prevented the Applicant’s representatives from accessing the premises. Those allegations are disputed by the Appellant.

34. The report records what was found at the premises on 18th November 2025. The Applicant’s assertion that the state of occupation found on that date had been altered shortly before the visit does not controvert the fact that Truckmart Africa Limited was the entity found in occupation during the inspection. Rather, it raises a separate question as to how and when that state of affairs arose. That question cannot be resolved by expunging the report but falls to be considered against the affidavit evidence and the other material placed before the Court.

35. As regards the reference in the report that there was no fresh painting at the premises erasing the Applicant’s name, the decision in Mwanzi & another Vs Mwangi & 4 others [2026] KEELC 3359 (KLR) is instructive. In that case, the Court was similarly invited to expunge a site visit report prepared by a Deputy Registrar on the ground that the officer had exceeded the scope of the inspection. The Court held: “From the report, there is no indication that he made a determination of the boundary during site visit. Further, that the impugned report was based on observations and presentation by the parties and the team present and not scientific or technical findings. It is my considered view that recording of the existence, location and visible developments on the suit land in the impugned report is a matter of ordinary observation, which did not require specialized survey expertise.”

36. Applying the foregoing to the present case, the report does not make a determination as to when the premises were painted, who undertook the painting or when the Applicant’s name was allegedly removed. It records the physical state in which the premises were found during the inspection. Whether that state had been brought about immediately before the visit in the manner alleged by the Applicant remains a disputed factual matter.

37. Based on the above, I find the report was prepared based on observations without using any scientific or technical processes to arrive at the said decision and thus the findings of the physical condition of the premises and the painting thereon without verifiable scientific or technical process invalidates the entire report. Accordingly, the prayer seeking to set aside and expunge the site visit report dated 19th November 2025 is allowed.

Whether Gilbert Mr. Masengeli ought to be joined as the 4th Respondent and, if so, whether he should be held in contempt of Court

38. The Applicant seeks the joinder of Gilbert Mr. Masengeli, Deputy Inspector General of the Administration Police Service, as the 4th Respondent and, upon such joinder, an order finding him in contempt of Court for allegedly deploying Administration Police officers to the suit property in violation of subsisting court orders.

39. The power of the Court to join a party is provided for under Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, which provides in part that: “The court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party… order that the name of any person who ought to have been joined… or whose presence before the court may be necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit, be added.”

40. In Departed Asians Property Custodian Board Vs Jaffer Brothers Ltd [1999] 1 EA 55, cited with approval in Frann Investment Limited Vs Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & 6 others, Civil Appeal E038 of 2021, the Court stated: “A clear distinction is called for between joining a party who ought to have been joined as a defendant and one whose presence before the court is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit.”

41. The Court further observed that the question is whether the orders sought may affect the person proposed to be joined and whether his presence is necessary for the complete settlement of the questions involved in the proceedings.

42. The present proceedings are an appeal arising from the dispute between the existing parties. Mr. Masengeli was not a party to the proceedings from which the appeal arose, and no interest in L.R. No. 20274 (I.R. 63991) is asserted against or on his behalf. The Applicant seeks his joinder because it alleges that Administration Police officers were deployed to the suit property shortly before the site visit and that, by virtue of his office as Deputy Inspector General of the Administration Police Service and section 26 of the National Police Service Act, he was responsible for that deployment.

43. Section 26 of the National Police Service Act establishes the office of the Deputy Inspector-General responsible for the Administration Police Service and sets out the functions of that office. The Applicant has, however, not placed before the Court any deployment order, communication, instruction or other material connecting Mr. Masengeli personally with the officers alleged to have attended the suit property. The proposition that he deployed the officers rests on the responsibility attached to his office rather than evidence of his involvement in the alleged deployment.

44. More fundamentally, the determination of the present appeal and the questions arising between the existing parties does not require Mr. Masengeli to be made a respondent. The allegations concerning the conduct of Administration Police officers arose after the proceedings giving rise to the appeal and in the context of the site visit ordered by this Court. Joining him for the purpose of pursuing those allegations would introduce into the appeal a dispute concerning alleged post-judgment conduct which did not form part of the proceedings before the court below.

45. I am therefore not satisfied that Mr. Masengeli is a person who ought to have been joined or whose presence is necessary to enable the Court effectually and completely determine the questions arising in this appeal within the meaning of Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. The prayer for his joinder as the 4th Respondent consequently fails.

46. The Applicant’s prayer seeking to have Mr. Masengeli held in contempt was expressly sought upon his joinder as the 4th Respondent. Having declined the prayer for joinder, the foundation upon which the consequential prayer for contempt was sought does not arise for determination. I accordingly decline the prayer seeking to have him held in contempt of Court.

Final Disposition

47. For the foregoing reasons, I find that the 1st Respondent/Applicant has made out a case for the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 10th April 2026 and accordingly expunge the site visit report dated 19th November 2025.

48. On the joinder of Deputy Inspector General (Administration Police) Mr. Gilbert Mr. Masengeli as a 4th Respondent is disallowed as the present proceedings are an appeal arising from dispute between existing parties and Mr. Mr. Masengeli was not a party to the said proceedings.

49. As regards the Notice of Motion dated 5th May 2026, prayers (1), (2) and (3) thereof are spent and no substantive prayer remains for determination. The application is accordingly marked as spent.

50. In the circumstances, the costs of both applications shall abide the outcome of the appeal.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 3rd day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Moshe for Kamande for the 1st Respondent/Applicant

Ms. Anyango for the Appellant/Respondent

Boniface Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder