Land law

Ngugi & another (Suing as administrator of the Estate of Raphael Ngugi Githuku) v Thuo [2026] KEELC 7446 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
4 November 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By an application dated 9/5/2026, the court is asked to reinstate this suit, which abated on 7/5/2022, substitute the deceased defendant with Virginia Waithera Nduta, the executor of the will of the deceased, and issue eviction orders against the intended defendants, agents, servants, employees, or beneficiaries from the land, prohibiting interference, disposal, occupation, construction, or in any way dealing with Title Numbers Ruiru…

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC 33 OF 2008

SAMUEL KIMANI NGUGI

ESTHER WANJIRU NGUGI (Suing as administrator of the estate of RAPHAEL NGUGI GITHUKU…………PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

DAVID THUO ……………………….…………. DEFENDANT

RULING

1. By an application dated 9/5/2026, the court is asked to reinstate this suit, which abated on 7/5/2022, substitute the deceased defendant with Virginia Waithera Nduta, the executor of the will of the deceased, and issue eviction orders against the intended defendants, agents, servants, employees, or beneficiaries from the land, prohibiting interference, disposal, occupation, construction, or in any way dealing with Title Numbers Ruiru West Block 1/2997 and Ruiru West Block 1/2998.

2. The application is supported by the grounds set out on its face and in a supporting affidavit sworn by Martin Kuria, Advocate, on 9/5/2026. The deponent states that judgment herein was rendered on 1/10/2020 and a decree was sent to the defendant's advocate as per a letter dated 17/3/2021, a copy of the decree and the letter marked as MK1.

3. The deponent states that pursuant to the service, the decree holder attempted to execute the decree but was unsuccessful, which the defendant, now deceased, ignored, neglected, or failed to honor, yet the intended defendant was fully aware of the same.

4. The deponent states that a subsequent application was also filed seeking the OCS Ruiru Police Station to supervise the execution as well as the eviction process.

5. The deponent states that when the application came up on 2/3/2023, the court was told that the defendant had passed on as per annexed letter marked MK2.

6. The deponent states that he was unable for some time to establish who had been appointed the beneficiary of the deceased's estate, only to establish through the CTS system that there was Kiambu High Court Succession Cause Number E093 of 2021, in which the proposed defendant was appointed as executor of the will of the late David Luo as per a copy of the will and grant dated 5/5/2022 annexed as MK3.

7. The deponent asks the court to revive the suit, which, according to him, abated, to enable execution to proceed. The deponent states that the legal representative, agent, servant or beneficiary of the estate of the defendant continued to occupy and receive rent from the suit land in total impunity and to the exclusion of the plaintiffs; hence, it is in the interest of justice and fair play to grant the reliefs sought.

8. Though the defendant's lawyers were served with the application and an affidavit of service sworn on 5/6/2026, the defendant did not file a response to the application.

9. Section 39 of the Civil Procedure Act relates to the execution of a decree passed against a legal representative of a deceased person. Order 24 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules relates to abatement of a suit if, after one year of the death of the defendant, there is no substitution. Courts have held that there is no requirement in law to substitute a deceased judgment debtor for purposes of execution.

10. In Osman Omari Rubea v. Manson Hart Ltd & 2 Others (Civil Appeal No. 129 of 2004) [2013] eKLR, the court said that under Order 24 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Rules 3, 4 and 7 do not apply to proceedings in the execution of a decree or order.

11. The same position was emphasized in Agnes Wanjiku Wangondu v. Uchumi Supermarket Limited [2008] eKLR, Julius Mugo Mwirigi v. Wanjiku Njage [2009] eKLR, and in Kenneth Kimani Kaburu & Others v. James Maina & Another [2014] eKLR, that the decree holder should directly pursue the legal representative of the deceased judgment debtor or the person intermeddling with the estate without proceeding to implead the person.

12. Execution against a legal representative is governed by Sections 37 and 39 of the Civil Procedure Act. In Bakari Ibrahim v. Issa Ibrahim, Civil Appeal No. 55 of 2014, the court said that it was imperative under Section 37(1) of the Civil Procedure Act that the appellant should have applied to execute against the judgment debtor's legal representative.

13. The court said that the obligation is on the decree holder to determine whether or not to apply to the court to execute against the deceased's legal representative. The court said that where the judgment creditor elects to do so, he must make an application to execute against the legal representative of such deceased person, otherwise, in the absence of such application, the execution would be unlawful, null and void and of no consequence.

14. In this application, the decree holder has attached the grant issued to the proposed legal representative of the deceased defendant. The law is that a suit where there is a decree passed before the judgment debtor dies does not abate.

15. Therefore, there is nothing to revive as the decree of the court is yet to become stale. All which the applicant needs is to make an application for leave to execute the decree against the legal representative.

16. The court hereby grants leave to execute the decree against Virginia Waithera Nduta, the legal representative of the estate of the deceased defendant. The rest of the prayers in the notice of motion are declined. The decree holder is at liberty to take out execution proceedings under Order 22 and 49 of the Civil Procedure Rules before the Deputy Registrar.

17. Costs to the applicant in any event. File marked closed, save for any post-judgment application.

Signed, dated and delivered on this 4th day of November, 2026 at Milimani.

….……………..

Honorable Justice C.K. Nzili,

Judge.

In the presence of:

Mr. Kuria for the plaintiff

Court Assistant:

Julius Legal Researcher: Bevalyn

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder