Land law

Ngugi and Wamuyu Advocates & another v Ndungu & another [2026] KEELC 7448 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
4 November 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application dated 13 March 2026 seeking authority for separate amenities and a permanent partition was dismissed for want of merit. There were no orders as to costs, and the file was marked closed.

Supporting judgment passages

36. There is no evidence that the severance as proposed in the decree was not capable of implementation. The upshot is that the court finds no merit in the application dated 13/3/2026. It is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Paragraph 36 →

37. File marked closed.

Paragraph 37 →
Issue 1Whether the applicants were entitled to orders permitting separate staircases, ablution facilities, electrical installations and other amenities, and a permanent partition between Parts B and C of the co-owned building.

Held. No. The court dismissed the application. The parties had not shown that they had pursued implementation of the existing consent decree through the Land Registrar, that the decree was impossible to implement, or that the plaintiffs had impeded its implementation. The proposed works were also inchoate and lacked sanction from an architect, the county, or other relevant planning authorities.

Ratio. For tenants in common holding undivided shares, implementation of a partition decree must first be pursued before the Land Registrar under the Land Registration Act. A party may move to court under section 94(9) only after being aggrieved by the Land Registrar's decision.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

36. There is no evidence that the severance as proposed in the decree was not capable of implementation. The upshot is that the court finds no merit in the application dated 13/3/2026. It is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Paragraph 36 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

33. In this matter, after the consent decree dated 28/11/2023, there is no evidence that the parties moved the court or the land registrar to effect the decree as per the cited rules. There is no evidence that the consent decree has been impossible to implement or has been impeded by the plaintiffs.

Paragraph 33 →

34. The proposal for the requested order, according to the respondents, seems to be inchoate and unsanctioned by an architect, the county, or the relevant authorities under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act and the rules made thereunder.

Paragraph 34 →

36. There is no evidence that the severance as proposed in the decree was not capable of implementation. The upshot is that the court finds no merit in the application dated 13/3/2026. It is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Paragraph 36 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

35. In a tenancy in common, parties hold undivided shares. Sections 12 and 13 of the Land Registration Act, require the parties to move to the Land Registrar to effect the decree. It is only after a party is aggrieved by the Land Registrar's decision that a party can move to court under Section 94(9) of the Act.

Paragraph 35 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By an application dated 13/3/2026, the court is asked to allow the applicants to create a separate staircase, ablution block, electrical installations, and all other common amenities on a portion of the building to be solely used by their tenants, occupants, and/or visitors, and to establish a permanent partition between Part B and Part C of the building to ensure the physical safety and privacy of tenants, occupants, and visitors, and…

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

The applicant deposes that she has a right to enjoy the benefits of ownership and possession of her portion without hindrance from any other persons and to enjoy the benefits of the orders of the court. The applicant urges that the court finds it in the interest of justice to grant the orders sought.

Paragraph 9 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the court should permit the applicants to construct a separate staircase, ablution block, electrical installations and other amenities for their portion of L.R. No. 209/24/2, and erect a permanent partition between Parts B and C; and whether the prior…

Material facts

The parties were joint proprietors of L.R. No. 209/24/2, a commercial building in Nairobi’s central business district with a ground floor, first floor and first-floor terrace. The applicant asserted that earlier orders required equal, distinct portions,…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC NO. 322 OF 2018

NGUGI AND WAMUYU ADVOCATES ……. 1ST PLAINTIFF

PETER NDUNGU KATHUNGU ……….….. 2ND PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

JOAN NJOKI NDUNGU …………………. 1ST DEFENDANT

PERSIA MUTHONI ……………… 1ST INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

1. By an application dated 13/3/2026, the court is asked to allow the applicants to create a separate staircase, ablution block, electrical installations, and all other common amenities on a portion of the building to be solely used by their tenants, occupants, and/or visitors, and to establish a permanent partition between Part B and Part C of the building to ensure the physical safety and privacy of tenants, occupants, and visitors, and to facilitate good management of their portion separate from the Plaintiff.

2. The application is premised on the grounds set out on the face of the application and in a supporting affidavit sworn by Joan Njoki Ndungu on 13/3/2026. It is deposed that the parties are joint proprietors of L.R. No. 209/24/2, which is a commercial building within Nairobi Central Business District comprising three floors, namely the ground floor, first floor, and the first floor terrace.

3. The applicant states that, through a ruling dated 2/3/2023, and a decree dated 28/11/2023, the court directed that the property be portioned into two equal, separate, and distinct portions to be held independently by each of the parties, save for the common areas and utilities.

4. The applicant deposes that two orders were issued on 23/1/2024 and 28/11/2023 to facilitate the partitioning of the said premises. The applicant deposes that after consulting property managers on the structural integrity of the property, she has been professionally advised that the property has structural defects which require rectification as per the report annexed as JNN 4 dated 12/3/2026.

5. The applicant deposes that she now wishes to fully separate her portion from that of the Plaintiff as proposed, since the co-owners have been interfering with the management and control of her portion by trespassing thereto, both during the day and during the night, thereby interfering with the structural integrity of the steel works, the staircase, broken toilet and ablution block, the water system, and generally blocking her and her tenants from accessing the building.

6. The applicants depose that the plaintiffs have been conducting themselves as if they control and manage the entire premises and as if the orders issued on 23/1/2024 and 28/11/2023 do not exist or were made in vain.

7. The applicant deposes that the proposed developments will enhance security by controlling trespassers from entering her portion and ensure the maintenance of peace and order.

8. The applicant deposes that the structural integrity of the suit property is in such a state that tenants, occupants, and visitors of the premises are in danger; otherwise, their safety is her responsibility; hence this application.

9. The applicant deposes that she has a right to enjoy the benefits of ownership and possession of her portion without hindrance from any other persons and to enjoy the benefits of the orders of the court. The applicant urges that the court finds it in the interest of justice to grant the orders sought.

10. The application is opposed through a replying affidavit of Peter Dongo Gadambi sworn on 14/4/2026, on behalf of the plaintiffs.

11. They contend that the court is functus officio after the ruling of 2/3/2023 and a consent order dated 28/11/2023.

12. The plaintiffs depose that the partition was agreed upon, and rely on expert reports by an unlicensed authority.

13. The plaintiffs depose that another proposed partition would be contrary to the previous one, yet the proposal this time round is not based on any expert report.

14. The plaintiffs depose that the proposed wall affects access to common areas as previously consented to.

15. The plaintiffs state that the building as it stands is incapable of being permanently shared due to its size, noting the proposed construction of an independent ablution block.

16. The plaintiffs depose that the defendant had declined the proposal to have the building extended and upgraded, which would have increased its rental income by constructing a modern building with more shops.

17. The plaintiffs depose that no approvals from the county have been granted for both the renovation repairs and the proposed developments, which are likely to affect the stability of the building, lead to cracks and even the collapse of the building, hence adversely affecting their share of the building.

18. The plaintiffs blame the advocate for the applicant for instigating the conflict for his own selfish gain, as he has been collecting rent of Kenya Shillings 200,000/- for the defendant's share, yet he blames others for interference with management.

19. The plaintiffs say that the advocate is the one who behaves as if he is the owner while threatening, harassing, and ousting tenants and themselves without any right.

20. The plaintiffs term the alleged interference baseless, and singles out the events of 26/12/2025 when the said advocate caused a commotion in a purported attempt to arrest illegal actions.

21. The plaintiffs blame the advocate for interfering with the use of their share of the building through his unbecoming behavior, interfering with the peaceful co-existence of the parties.

22. The plaintiff states that the advocate has refused to release a share of the defendant's rates payable to the county for the last two years, exposing the parties to penalties.

23. The plaintiff states that there is no proof of any danger to any person warranting the grant of the reliefs sought. Otherwise, the defendant is seeking to use the route of alleged repairs to unlawfully evict tenants.

24. The plaintiffs depose that it would be dangerous to carry out separate electrical installations and common amenities without an expert report on how viable the proposal is.

25. A consent judgment has a contractual effect. The variation of a consent judgment or order can only be on grounds that would allow for a contract to be vitiated.

26. These grounds include, but are not limited to, fraud, collusion, illegality, mistake, or if it is against public policy. In Flora Wasike v. Destimo Wamboko (1982-1988) KAR 625, the court held that a consent judgment has a contractual effect and can only be set aside on grounds that justify setting aside a contract, or if certain conditions remain to be fulfilled or have not been carried out, as held in James Mwashori Mwakio v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2010] eKLR, Civil Application No. 11 of 2008 (Court of Appeal at Nairobi), Civil Application No. 28 of 1982 and 69 of 1983, and in Brooke Bond Liebig (T) Limited v Mallya [1975] EA 266 (East African Court of Appeal).In this matter, the parties are co-owners of the suit property, which is subject to partition. Partition in law means the separation by legal instrument of the share of land or a lease held by owners in common so that each owner takes their share free of the rights of others.

27. The law relating to partition in cases of tenants in common is Section 94 of the Land Registration Act, and the Regulations made thereunder of 2017.

28. The division of co-owned property can be done voluntarily by mutual agreement or through a court order in cases of dispute. Parties may do so by executing a partition instrument.

29. The process involves a party commissioning a physical planner, seek the consent of the county commissioner, a land survey to approve the proposed partitioning, fill Form No. LRA 29, and submits the documents and a certificate to the Land Registrar. The Land Registrar then issues a notice to the parties for a hearing using Form LRA 31.

30. The application must be supported by a cadastral map for the partition, a cadastral plan, the consent of the parties, a copy of the registered mutation plan, and a copy of the approved development application from the county.

31. Section 96 of the Act relates to the circumstances where the co-owned land is incapable of being partitioned or where the partition will adversely affect the proper use of the land. In such a case, a tenant shall be entitled to purchase the land or any part of it if put up for sale.

32. A court under Section 94(3)(a) to (f) of the Act has powers to deal with any of such matters as may arise.

33. In this matter, after the consent decree dated 28/11/2023, there is no evidence that the parties moved the court or the land registrar to effect the decree as per the cited rules. There is no evidence that the consent decree has been impossible to implement or has been impeded by the plaintiffs.

34. The proposal for the requested order, according to the respondents, seems to be inchoate and unsanctioned by an architect, the county, or the relevant authorities under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act and the rules made thereunder.

35. In a tenancy in common, parties hold undivided shares. Sections 12 and 13 of the Land Registration Act, require the parties to move to the Land Registrar to effect the decree. It is only after a party is aggrieved by the Land Registrar's decision that a party can move to court under Section 94(9) of the Act.

36. There is no evidence that the severance as proposed in the decree was not capable of implementation. The upshot is that the court finds no merit in the application dated 13/3/2026. It is dismissed with no orders as to costs.

37. File marked closed.

Signed, dated and delivered on this 4th day of November, 2026 at Milimani.

Hon. Justice C.K. Nzili,

Judge.

In the presence of:

Miss Kagucia for plaintiff/respondents

Miss Nasambi for Mr. Mbaabu for defendant

Court Assistant: Julius

Legal Researcher: Bevalyn N.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder