Background
The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide the Plaint dated 29/3/2023. The Plaintiffs seek that Judgment be entered against the Defendant in the following terms;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide the Plaint dated 29/3/2023. The Plaintiffs seek that Judgment be entered against the Defendant in the following terms;
Paragraph 1 →According to Black’s Law Dictionary (11th Ed), illegality is “An act that is forbidden by law.” This means that if a transaction violates a written law, it is illegal, irrespective of whether the parties acted with deceptive intent or merely out of ignorance. Having held that the agreement was illegal and void ab initio, the Defendant cannot seek indemnity from Third Parties arising from his own illegal conduct.
Paragraph 67 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. E126 OF 2023
GODFREY WANYONYI MULONGO - 1ST PLAINTIFF
AGNETTA MUENI MUTUNGE - 2ND PLAINTIFF
VS
JAMES KIMANI NJUGUNA - DEFENDANT
AND
OKWACH & COMPANY ADVOCATES - 1ST THIRD PARTY
RODNEY ABEL AMOLLO - 2ND THIRD PARTY
HUMPHREY MULINDI - 3RD THIRD PARTY
JUDGMENT
Background
1. The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide the Plaint dated 29/3/2023. The Plaintiffs seek that Judgment be entered against the Defendant in the following terms;
a) Judgment in favour of the Plaintiffs in the Sum of Kenya Shillings Twenty-Seven Million, One Hundred and Thirty-Nine Thousand, Three Hundred and Eighty-One and Twenty Cents (Kshs. 27, 139, 381.20) along with accrued interests as at the date of Judgment until payment in full;
b) General damages;
c) Cost of this Suit;
d) Interests on a, b and c above at court rates.
2. The Plaintiffs' claim is that they entered into a Sale Agreement with the Defendant on 7/5/2021 for the sale of half an acre piece of land known as Land Reference Number 1160/1034 situated in Karen, at a consideration of Kshs. 27,000,000/=. The Plaintiffs aver that they paid Kshs. 17,400,000/= towards the purchase price and a further Kshs. 1,630,000/= to the Defendant's agent, Humphrey Mulindi, through bank transfers and M-PESA transactions between 10/5/2021 and 30/5/2022, to facilitate the transaction, and that this amount was to be credited towards the purchase price. The Plaintiffs further aver that they agreed to pay an additional sum of Kshs. 7,000,000/= on 21/4/2022 to facilitate the release of the original certificate of title, which was subsequently handed over to their advocate by the Defendant’s advocate. Subsequently, between August and September 2021, the parties renegotiated the transaction and agreed on a purchase price of Kshs. 72,000,000/= for the entire 1.6-acre parcel, pursuant to which two Deeds of Variation were executed on 3/9/2021 and 21/4/2022, respectively, with completion to take place within 90 days of signing.
3. It is averred that upon conducting a further search, the Plaintiffs discovered that although the search results indicated the 1st Defendant as the registered proprietor, a manual search conducted by their advocates revealed that the property belonged to KAF International. The Plaintiffs contend that they immediately brought this information to the attention of the Defendant's agent, Humphrey Mulindi, who undertook to resolve the issue. The Plaintiffs state that they paid stamp duty of Kshs. 3,600,000/= to the Kenya Revenue Authority in connection with the transaction. Further, to secure their interests following the emerging difficulties, the Plaintiffs demanded an alternative parcel of land in Mavoko, being Title Number Mavoko Town Block 3/172, as security, which the Defendant estimated to be worth Kshs. 15,000,000/=. Upon undertaking a valuation of the said parcel, the property was assessed at Kshs. 13,000,000/=.
4. The Plaintiffs contend that, despite their mutual agreement, the Defendant failed to complete the sale within the contractual 90-day period or at all, and that the Defendant’s actions amounted to a breach of clause 9.2 of the Sale Agreement. It is averred that this prompted the Plaintiffs to issue a termination notice on 17/8/2022 and to demand a full refund. The Defendant however failed to heed this demand, necessitating the instant suit. The Plaintiffs aver that they have suffered a total loss of Kshs. 27,139,381.20, comprising payments made, legal fees and accrued interest. On that basis, the Plaintiffs seek the above-stated orders.
Defendant’s Statement of Defence
5. In his Statement of Defence dated 19/1/2024, the Defendant denies the Plaintiffs’ claims regarding the receipt of Kshs. 17,400,000/= and Kshs. 27,000,000/=, putting the Plaintiffs to strict proof. While the Defendant admits engaging the firm of Okwach and Company Advocates, he asserts that he never received the additional Kshs. 7,000,000/= claimed. Furthermore, the Defendant avers that Mr. Mulindi was not his agent and that any funds paid to him were unrelated to this transaction and were intended to settle other contractual debts.
6. Regarding the property in question, the Defendant admits he was the registered owner at the time of the transaction but denies that Title Number Mavoko Town Block 3/172 was pledged as security. Instead, he contends that the title was forwarded to the Plaintiffs because they also intended to purchase the property. The Defendant claims he has suffered irreparable loss because the Plaintiffs continue to retain the title against his will, preventing him from dealing with the property. The Defendant maintains that no demand notice was ever issued to him before the filing of this suit.
7. Third Party Notices were issued to the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Third Parties herein who filed their respective Statements of Defence as hereunder.
1st Third Party’s Defence
8. The 1st Third Party, in its Defence dated 19/1/2024, admits that the Plaintiffs and the Defendant entered into a Sale Agreement dated 7/5/2021 for the transfer of L.R. No. 1160/1034 in Karen. It further avers that, acting as the Vendor’s Advocate, the firm prepared the agreement and conducted a digital land search before taking instruction, which confirmed the Defendant as the registered owner, a fact corroborated by both the Plaintiff and the financing bank. It is averred that, consequently, the transaction was structured to require the Plaintiffs to deposit the purchase price into the firm’s client account at Family Bank, Kilimani Branch, pursuant to the Law Society of Kenya [LSK] Conditions of Sale, 2015.
9. The Advocate avers that following the initial deposit, the Plaintiffs opted to purchase the entire 1.6-acre plot for Kshs. 72,000,000 to bypass delays caused by subdivision. This necessitated two Deeds of Variation dated 3/9/2021 and 21/4/2022. It is averred that the Plaintiffs subsequently made several payments into the client account totaling Kshs. 17,400,000. Pursuant to a fee and authorization agreement dated 10/5/2021, the firm was permitted to retain legal fees, VAT and disbursements. That, upon the Defendant's insistence, funds were transferred to the Defendant or his designee, Mr. Humphrey Mulindi. Accordingly, the firm disbursed the purchase price through bank transfers and cash withdrawals, retaining Kshs. 1,618,224 as legal fees.
10. He avers that on 30/5/2022, the 1st Third Party was notified that a manual land search had returned a conflicting result indicating KAF International Limited as the registered proprietor contrary to the previous digital searches showing the Defendant as the owner. The 1st Third Party asserts that the anomaly was strange since due diligence by both the firm and the purchaser’s advocate had consistently shown the Defendant as the proprietor. That however, the Defendant denied any knowledge of the irregularities. That due to these ownership irregularities, the transaction could not be completed, ultimately necessitating the Plaintiffs' rescission of the agreement.
2nd Third Party’s Defence
11. The 2nd Third Party, in his Defence dated 8/4/2025, categorically denies the allegations levelled against him by the Defendant. He specifically avers that he was never an agent of the Plaintiff, the Defendant, or the 1st Third Party. He asserts that he did not receive any purchase price or other monies from either party and maintains that he is not privy to the averments made therein. While he admits to merely introducing the Defendant to the 1st Third Party, he reiterates that he was not a participant in the underlying transaction and has been wrongfully enjoined in this suit. Consequently, the 2nd Third Party avers that the Plaintiffs’ rightful cause of action lies solely against the Defendant. He argues that the Third-Party Notice issued against him is frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the court process. He prays that the suit be dismissed with costs.
3rd Third Party’s Defence
12. The Third Party filed his Defence dated 27/5/2025, admitting that he acted as an agent for the 1st Plaintiff in the subject transaction and earned a commission therefrom. He, however, denies the assertions levelled against him by the Plaintiffs and the 1st Third Party. He affirms that he entered into a separate loan agreement with the Defendant for a bakery business in Kisumu. It is his contention that the Defendant specifically instructed the 1st Third Party to repay this loan using the proceeds from the sale of the suit property.
13. The 3rd Third Party asserts that he received Kshs. 4,559,000 exclusively from the 1st Third Party, and denies receiving the alleged Kshs. 17,400,000. He further denies liability in the suit, maintaining that he was not a party to the contract between the Plaintiffs and the Defendant. Finally, while the 3rd Third Party admits paragraphs 16 and 17 of the Plaint and paragraph 19 of the 1st Third Party’s Defence, he notes that no demand notice was ever issued to him before the filing of this suit.
Plaintiffs’ Reply to Defence
14. The Plaintiffs vehemently deny the Defendant’s assertions in his Defence, particularly the claims regarding the involvement of Okwach & Company Advocates and the pledging of Title No. Mavoko Town Block 3/172 as security. The Plaintiffs maintain that the Defendant is liable to meet the claim and that they are entitled to the reliefs sought.
Evidence adduced
15. At trial, the 1st Plaintiff, Godfrey Wanyonyi Mulongo, gave evidence as PW1. He relied on his witness statement dated 22/3/2023 as his evidence in chief. He also adduced the documents contained in the list of documents dated 29/3/23, marked as P Ex 1–24, as well as the documents contained in the list of documents dated 9/4/2025, marked as P Ex Nos. 25–26.
16. Counsel for the 3rd Third Party objected to the production of the WhatsApp messages for want of a certificate of electronic evidence pursuant to section 106B of the Evidence Act. Counsel for the Defendant also supported the objection, arguing that the omission to produce the certificate is not a mere technicality that can be cured. He averred that the certificate is a matter of law, not a matter of technicality. In rebuttal, Counsel for the Plaintiff, argued that the objection is curable by the production of a certificate under section 106B of the Evidence Act. He argued that the certificate could be filed before judgement is rendered and that no prejudice will be visited upon the 3rd Third Party.
17. The 3rd Third Party’s counsel, in response, cited the Court of Appeal case of County Assembly of Kisumu & 2 Others vs Kisumu County Assembly Service Board & 6 Others, where it was held that a certificate of electronic evidence is mandatory.
18. Subsequently, the parties agreed that the WhatsApp message be admitted in evidence, but the issue was to be addressed in their respective submissions.
19. In cross-examination by counsel for the Defendant, PW 1 stated that he paid a sum of Kshs. 17.4M to the Defendant. He testified that the 3rd Third Party was his agent in the transaction, and he paid agency fees of Kshs. 1.3M. He averred that his claim is for a sum of Kshs. 27,139,381.20. He stated that James Njuguna received a sum of Kshs. 17.4M. He further stated that he still holds the official title of the said land, as well as the original title Mavoko town/Block 3/172 belonging to the Defendant, which was surrendered to him as security for the transaction. He averred that he also claims a sum of Kshs. 3.6 Million as Stamp Duty to KRA. He further stated that he paid a sum of Kshs. 1.3M to the 3rd Third Party, who was their mutual agent.
20. When cross-examined by counsel for the 1st Third Party, PW1 stated that he knew the 1st Third Party at the beginning of the transaction, as the 1st Third Party was acting for the Defendant. He further gave evidence that he saw the land search conducted by Okwach and company advocates, and that his own search also revealed that the Defendant was the registered owner. He further gave evidence that Okwach was the Defendant's lawyer through whom the purchase price would be paid in instalments.
21. When referred to the 2nd Deed of Variation entered into between the parties, he averred that at no time did the Defendant state that he had not received the money, but he persistently requested more funds. The witness clarified that Mr. Okwach did not request any money directly from him. The witness stated that he was unaware that part of the money would be required for subdivision, as his priority was securing a position for a larger parcel of land.
22. The witness testified that he paid the money through the advocate and that the Defendant raised no objection to the payment. The witness was to pay a total of Kshs. 72 Million, of which he remitted Kshs. 17.4 Million to Advocate Okwach. PW 1 further stated that there were two versions of the agreements, executed by himself, the 3rd Third Party and the Defendant, without the involvement of Mr. Okwach. He further testified that when the manual search showed a different ownership result, he requested the Mavoko title.
23. In cross-examination by counsel for the 2nd Third Party, PW1 stated that the transaction was between himself and the Defendant, and that the 2nd Third Party was not a party to the transaction. He confirmed that he neither paid any money to the 2nd Third Party nor was he instructed by the Defendant to make any payment to him. He averred that he has no claim against him.
24. During cross-examination by counsel for the 3rd Third Party, he stated that the 3rd Third Party was his agent. As his agent, he had the responsibility of negotiating the best deal. He negotiated the land for 27 million, less than what had been offered. He averred that the 3rd Third Party was not a witness to the agreements. He testified that the total agency fees of Kshs. 700,000/= were to be recovered from the purchase price.
25. Referring to the Sale Agreement, the witness confirmed that the purchase price was payable to the vendor’s advocate, not to the 3rd Third Party, and that the said terms were applicable to the deed of variation. He stated that his claim is against the Defendant, not the 3rd Third Party herein.
26. In re-examination, PW 1 stated that he paid a substantial sum to the 3rd Third Party to finalise the transaction at the Defendant's instructions. He reiterated that the Mavoko Title was held as security. He maintained that the Defendant has not transferred the land to him.
27. With that, the Plaintiffs closed their case.
28. James Kimani Njuguna, the Defendant herein, gave evidence as DW1. He relied on his witness statement dated 19/1/2024 as his evidence in chief. He also produced the documents marked DEX Nos. 1-3.
29. During cross-examination by counsel for the 1st Third Party, DW I confirmed that he had not produced any document showing how he acquired the property in question. He testified that his lawyer, Rodney, introduced him to Advocate Okwach, and that the land originally belonged to the lawyers. He acknowledged signing a loan agreement with Muhindi in 2014. The agreement is dated 10/7/2020. Although the actual transaction was in 2014, the funds were refunded in 2020. He further testified that the transaction was primarily negotiated between the Plaintiffs and the 3rd Third Party, with the money to be paid through the lawyers' accounts. The witness asserted that he never communicated directly with the Plaintiffs and that he only received Kshs. 1.0 million out of the Kshs. 17.4 million allegedly received by the lawyer, with the remainder intended for Rodney.
30. The witness further stated that he signed the Deed of Variation but maintained that he was paid only Kshs. 1 million, not the Kshs. 3.1 million claimed. He explained that he provided his Mavoko land title to the Plaintiff solely as security for the transaction, believing it to be legitimate. He testified that he later made a statement to the DCI, noting that although his lawyer recovered Kshs. 18 million from Mulongo, he personally received none of it. Finally, he claimed that the signature on page 1(b) of the 1st Third Party bundle dated 10/5/2021 was not his and told the police it was a forgery.
31. During cross-examination by counsel for the 2nd Third Party, DW1 testified that he entered into a sale with the Plaintiffs, with the agreement drafted by the 1st Third Party. He asserted that Rodney’s name was absent from the agreement and that he was not acting as an advocate in the transaction. DW1 claimed that he received only Kshs. 1 Million. He averred that there was no clause requiring payment to Rodney, and that he did not instruct anyone to pay him. Yet he also stated he sent Kshs. 30 Million to Rodney via the Awala System (a Somali payment system) in 2017 to purchase land, despite having no evidence or payment details before the court to prove that Rodney received the money. He explained that Rodney, who was not the landowner but introduced him to the seller, does not owe him money, and noted that Rodney introduced him to Mr. Okwach and gave him a fake firm. Finally, DW1 confirmed that while DCI investigated the matter and recommended that he and Muhindi be charged, resulting in his own criminal charges, Rodney was not charged. DW1 admitted that his statement dated 19/1/2024 does not include these claims or proof of payment to Rodney.
32. In cross-examination by Counsel for the 3rd Third Party, DW 1 confirmed that Muhindi was known to him. He, however, denied that Muhindi was his agent. That Muhindi was a party to the sale agreement or the variation agreements, and that he had any discussions with the Plaintiffs regarding his money. He confirmed signing the loan agreement dated 10/7/2020, which proved that he owed Muhindi money. He further stated that, whereas the loan was advanced to him in 2020, he had another loan from him in 2014. On that basis, he instructed the firm of Okwach and Advocates to pay Muhindi in satisfaction of the loan. None of the payments were agency fees. He averred that the money was purely a loan repayment to Muhindi.
33. When cross-examined by counsel for the Plaintiff, DW 1 confirmed that he executed a sale agreement with the Plaintiff. He confirmed that the purchase price was Kshs. 70M, which was later increased to Kshs. 72M. He testified that the Plaintiff sent money to Okwach, his advocate. He stated that about Kshs. 17M was sent to his advocate. He averred that Mr. Muhindi, to whom Kshs. 3 million was paid on his instructions, is his friend and that Muhindi was paid by his lawyer. The transaction collapsed because there was no good title. Referring to Clause 9 of the Agreement, DW 1 confirmed that he was supposed to refund the money in the event the agreement failed. He confirmed that he had not refunded any money to the Plaintiffs. He stated that he gave the Mavoko title to the Plaintiff to hold as security. He averred that he never gave the Plaintiff authority to sell the land in Mavoko. He stated that he believed the transaction was genuine.
34. In re-examination, DW 1 confirmed that he pledged the Mavoko title as security for this transaction. He testified that money from the Plaintiff was received by Mr. Okwach. He could not confirm that any money was sent to Rodney. He averred that his instructions to Okwach to pay Mr. Muhindi were oral. Regarding the Letter dated 23/10/2023, he confirmed that he was charged at Ngong law courts regarding the matter and that the charges were dismissed. He stated that he only received Kshs. 1.3M in the transaction. That it was sent to his account at Equity Bank, as evidenced by the bank statement on record. He stated that Muhindi was not part of the transaction. He confirmed that he owed Muhindi a lot of money and that is why he was paid.
35. That was the close of the Defendant’s case.
36. Noel Ngoloma Okwach, an Advocate working with the 1st Third Party, gave evidence as DW 2. He relied on his witness statement dated 28/3/25 as his evidence in chief. He produced the documents on page 1 of the 3rd party trial bundle, marked as DEX Nos. 1–12 and 13–14. DW 2 further averred that the Defendant, who was the Vendor in the transaction, was his Client. He stated that the Vendor agreed that his fee would be deducted from the purchase price. He asserted that he had never received any complaint about the manner in which he handled the transaction.
37. In cross-examination by counsel for the 3rd Third Party, DW 2 confirmed that he acted for the Vendor and that the purchase price was to be paid into his account. He further testified that he paid the 3rd Third Party on the Defendant's instructions and transferred a sum of Kshs. 4.3 M to the 3rd Third Party.
38. During cross-examination by counsel for the 2nd Third Party, DW 2 stated that the 2nd Third Party was not a party to the transaction. He stated that he only later learned that Muhindi was a broker. He stated that Rodney was not an agent and only introduced the vendor to his firm. He denied making any payment to the 2nd Third Party.
39. When cross-examined by counsel for the Plaintiff, he confirmed that he received Kshs. 17.4M from the 1st Plaintiff, paid in instalments by bank transfer. He averred that he disbursed all the money except Kshs 1.6M. He further testified that he advised the Defendant to refund the monies pursuant to paragraph 9 of the Sale Agreement.
40. During cross-examination by counsel for the Defendant, DW2 was referred to the Defendant's Letter dated 10/5/2021. He stated that the signature thereon was the same as that in the sale agreement. He further stated that, in any case, the Letter dated 10/5/2021 was signed in his office in his presence. He confirmed that he received a total of Kshs. 17.4 M from the Purchaser. He also stated that he paid Mr. Muhindi Kshs. 4.359M, transferred Kshs. 1.0595M to the Defendant, and that the Defendant also collected the balance in cash.
41. DW 2 stated that he could adduce a bank statement to show that he withdrew any cash, as the documents were confiscated by DCI in 2022. He stated that he obtained DEX 12 – 14 from the criminal file at Ngong Law Courts. He averred that the Defendant admitted to having received a sum of Kshs. 18M. He averred that the Defendant brought the title to his firm, introduced by Rodney. He averred that he has never testified against the Defendant in any criminal case. He averred that he could only confirm a transfer of 4.5M via RTGS, but he had not tabled any document to show that the Defendant received any cash.
42. In re-examination, DW2 averred that the Defendant signed the documents in his presence and that he was unaware of any complaint by the Defendant that his signature was forged. He further averred that no forensic report was adduced to show that the signatures were forged. He averred that he disbursed monies as per the letter dated 10/5/2021. The money was disbursed in instalments, and each time the money arrived, he would come to my office and instruct him to pay for various items. That the Defendant never demanded or reported that he did not receive any money. He averred that he has tried to retrieve his files from the DCI but has not been successful, as investigations are still ongoing. He reiterated that he received a sum of Kshs. 17.4 M from the purchase and applied the sum as instructed by the Defendant.
43. That marked the close of the 1st Third Party’s case.
44. Rodney Abel Amollo testified as DW3. He relied on his witness statement dated 8/4/2025 as his evidence in chief.
45. In cross-examination by Counsel for the 3rd Third Party, DW3 stated that he did not know the 3rd Third Party. He further averred that he was not an employee of Okwach and Company Advocates.
46. When cross-examined by counsel for the Defendant, DW3 confirmed that he introduced the Defendant, who was known to him, to the 1st Third Party for the sale of the land. He denied receiving any money from the transaction.
47. In re-examination, DW3 averred that his involvement was limited to introducing the Defendant to Mr. Okwach. He asserted that he did not take any instructions, conduct any due diligence, or even be involved in surrendering the ownership of the title. He denied receiving any money in the transaction.
48. That marked the close of the 2nd Third Party’s case.
49. DW 4 was Humphrey Muhindi, the 3rd Third Party herein. He relied on his witness statement dated 27/5/2025 and also produced the document marked DEX No. 1 – 4.
50. In cross-examination by counsel for the 1st Third Party, DW 4 stated that the Defendant was well known to him. He averred that he knew the 1st Plaintiff before the transaction. He stated that he was the Plaintiffs’ agent in the said transaction and that the 1st Plaintiff was to pay him agency fees, which they agreed verbally. He averred that he was summoned by DCI three times when the transaction failed, but he was not charged. That throughout the transaction, he was in direct communication with the 1st Plaintiff, from whom he received money through Mpesa, bank transfers, and sometimes in cash.
51. He stated that he had never visited the 1st Third Party’s offices but had received Kshs. 4.595M from Okwach, wired into his bank account, as a refund for a loan he had advanced to the Defendant. He averred that the Defendant still owed him Kshs. 5.2 M as of August 2025.
52. During cross-examination by counsel for the Plaintiff, DW 4 stated that he introduced the 1st Plaintiff to the Defendant for the purchase of land at Karen. He stated that his fees were Kshs. 2 million. He stated that he received 1.63M from the Plaintiff. He stated that he was not involved in the negotiations over the purchase price.
53. In cross-examination by counsel for the Defendant, DW 4 stated that he received Kshs. 4.5M from Mr. Okwach. He stated that he was not aware of the amount the Defendant received from Mr. Okwach. He maintained that he was the Plaintiffs’ agent and that the money he received was his fees.
54. In re-examination, DW 4 averred that he lent the Defendant a sum $ 7500 exclusive of interest. He stated that Okwach paid some monies.
55. That marked the close of the 3rd Third Party’s case.
Submissions
56. At the close of the hearing, the court directed the parties to file their final written submissions. In compliance, the Plaintiffs filed their submissions dated 4/8/2026, the Defendant’s submissions are dated 25/8/2026, 1st Third Party’ are dated 1/9/2026, 2nd Third Party’s are dated 10/8/2026 whereas the 3rd Third Party’s submissions are dated 30/9/2026.
57. The Court has had occasion to read through the submissions by parties and considered them in its determination. In any event, the filed submissions now form part of the court record.
Analysis and Determination
58. This court has carefully considered the pleadings filed herein, the witness testimonies and the evidence adduced in court. The court has also considered the submissions of the parties, and the issues set out below fall for consideration;
a. Whether the sale agreement in respect of the suit parcel was valid;
b. Whether the Third Parties herein are liable to indemnify the Plaintiffs herein;
c. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the orders sought;
d. Who should bear the costs of the suit and of the Third Party proceedings?
Whether the sale agreement in respect of the suit parcel was valid
59. The Plaintiffs’ case undoubtedly is predicted on the agreement for sale made on 7/5/2021 for the sale of half-acre being that piece of land known as Land Reference Number 1160/1034 situated in Karen at a consideration of Kshs. 27,000,000/=. Subsequently, between August and September 2021, parties renegotiated the transaction and agreed on a purchase price of Kshs. 72,000,000/= for the entire 1.6-acre parcel, pursuant to which two Deeds of Variation were executed on 3/9/2021 and 21/4/2022, respectively. The completion was to take place within 90 days of signing.
60. As per the sale agreement and as pleaded by the Plaintiff, the land the subject of the sale was initially registered in the name of the Defendant. However, upon conducting a further search, it turned out that the subject property was in fact registered in the name of KAF International. The Letter dated 1/2/2023 from the Ministry of Land addressed to the Plaintiffs’ Advocate confirms that KAF International owns the land having acquired it from Hafsa Kassim Sheikh. The Defendant has not adduced any evidence whatsoever to controvert the said evidence and support his alleged ownership.
61. It is evident that the Defendant was not the registered owner of the land that he purported to enter into an agreement to sell a portion of. Under law, one of the necessary requirements of a contract is that the parties must have the requisite capacity to transact. For a sale of land to be valid, the parties to the same must have the requisite capacity to transact in regard to such land. Therefore, before a person sells land, they must be the owners thereof, or have the authority of the owner to sell, for them to pass good title to whoever will purchase such land.
62. It follows therefore the Defendant could not enter into a valid agreement that could be enforced against him in regard to the subject land. The only circumstance under which he could deal with the land, if he was not the registered owner, is if he had a lawful and valid power of attorney from the registered owner.
63. It is therefore my finding that in the absence any proprietary rights over the subject property, the Defendant could not enter into a valid agreement for the sale of a portion of the suit property that was binding. The sale agreement was therefore illegal and null ab initio.
Whether the Third Parties herein are liable to indemnify the Plaintiffs herein;
64. The starting point must be the purpose and limits of third-party procedure. Order 1 Rule 15 of the Civil Procedure Rules permits a Defendant to issue a third-party notice where the third party is, in substance, (a) a person from whom the Defendant claims contribution or indemnity; (b) a person entitled to some relief or remedy relating to or connected with the original subject matter, and substantially the same as some relief claimed by the Plaintiff; or (c) a person against whom a question or issue substantially the same as that between the Plaintiff and Defendant ought properly to be determined.
65. The procedure exists, as the Court held in Kenya Commercial Bank Limited –vs- Suntra Investment Bank Limited [2015] eKLR, to enable a Defendant to bring in, “a third party … enjoined in a suit at the instance of the Defendant”, through the structured procedure of Order 1 Rules 15 to 22, so that liability between Defendant and third party may be resolved once the court is satisfied that a proper question falls to be tried between them.
66. It is, in other words, a mechanism for avoiding multiplicity of suits over genuinely connected claims, not a licence to draw a stranger, or a party with no rational stake in the outcome, into litigation merely because it once had some association with the underlying transaction.
67. According to Black’s Law Dictionary (11th Ed), illegality is “An act that is forbidden by law.” This means that if a transaction violates a written law, it is illegal, irrespective of whether the parties acted with deceptive intent or merely out of ignorance. Having held that the agreement was illegal and void ab initio, the Defendant cannot seek indemnity from Third Parties arising from his own illegal conduct.
68. Even if the court was to consider the third parties’ liability, will indemnity lie? Starting with the 1st Third Party, it is not disputed that the said law firm purported to act for the Defendant in voided agreement. The Defendant argues that the 1st Third Party having received some money from the Plaintiffs, the firm should be held accountable as to how the money was spent. In his submissions, the Defendant argues that the 1st Third Party owed a professional duty of care to the Defendant and that having only sent the Defendant about Kshs. 1 Million, the 1st Third Party ought to be directed to indemnify the Plaintiffs.
69. On its part, the 1st Third Party asserts that he duly performed his duty as an Advocate and no complaint whatsoever has been raised against him. He confirmed that he received a sum of Kshs. 17.4M from the 1st Plaintiff. That the amount was paid in installments through bank transfers. He averred that he disbursed all the money except Kshs 1.6M. It was his testimony that he advised the Defendant to refund the monies pursuant to paragraph 9 of the Sale Agreement.
70. In the Letter dated 10/5/2021, the 1st Third Party sought authorization from the Defendant to release the funds received from the Plaintiffs. The Defendant acknowledged receipt by signing the Letter. Subsequent forwarding letters and Cheques shows transfers to the 3rd Third Party under the instructions of the Defendant. Indeed, the Defendant acknowledges receipt of about Kshs. 1 Million.
71. From the evidence adduced, even if the agreement was to be valid, the 1st Third Party did not breach any duty of care owed to the Defendant. The 1st Third Party acted under the express instructions of the Defendant. He cannot now turn back and purport to renege on his own instructions.
72. As for the 2nd Interested Party, it is evident that he was neither a party to the transaction nor a beneficiary of the monies disbursed by the Plaintiffs. None of the parties accused him of receiving any money or playing any other role other than introducing the Plaintiff to the 1st Third Party. No claim can lie against him.
73. Turning to the 3rd Third Party, the Defendant does not dispute instructing the 1st Third Party to effect payments to him. In fact, the Defendant acknowledged at trial that he owes the 3rd Third Party some money which he borrowed sometime back in the year 2020. Further, the 3rd Third Party also argued that the sums effected to him was his agency fee. In the absence of contrary evidence, I find no basis upon which the 3rd Third Party should be directed to make good the Plaintiffs’ loss.
74. It is therefore my finding that the Defendant’s claim against the Third Parties herein is not merit.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the orders sought;
75. Having found that the agreement for sale dated 7/5/2021 was null and void ab initio for want of capacity on the part of the Defendant, the question that arises is whether the Plaintiff should be left without a remedy notwithstanding that the Defendant and his counsel for the transaction, the 1st Third Party, admittedly received part of the purchase price. The answer must be in the negative. Although the Court cannot enforce an illegal or void contract by granting specific performance, it is equally settled that where one party has received money under a transaction which is subsequently found to be void, the law imposes an obligation to restore the benefit received so as to prevent unjust enrichment.
76. In Karanja Mbugua & Another v Marybin Holding Co. Ltd [2014] eKLR, the Court held that where a contract for the sale of land is incapable of performance or is otherwise unenforceable, the purchaser is entitled to restitution of the purchase price paid.
77. The same principle was expressed by the Court of Appeal in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & Another [2001] eKLR, where the Court observed that although courts do not rewrite contracts for parties, where a transaction fails or is incapable of performance, relief founded on restitution may be available so as to restore the parties to the position they occupied before the transaction.
78. In the present case, the Plaintiffs claim a refund of Ksh.27, 139, 381.20 being part of the purchase price and other costs and expenses incurred towards materializing the transaction. It is settled that special damages must not only be specifically pleaded but must also be strictly proved. In Hahn v Singh [1985] KLR 716, the Court of Appeal held that special damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved before they can be awarded.
79. The Plaintiffs have not particularized the said sum as required in the Plaint. The particulars are however stated in their Witness Statements and corroborated at trial. I note that the Defendant and the 1st Third Party have confirmed receipt of Kshs. 17.4 Million as part of the purchase price. The Plaintiffs have only proved a payment of Kshs. 17.4 Million.
80. Regarding the payment effected to Kenya Revenue Authority for Stamp Duty in the sum of Kshs. 3.6 Million, as evident by the payment slip adduced as Plaintiff Exhibit 12, the Defendant did not receive the payment slip. The same was effected to Kenya Revenue Authority for Stamp Duty in the sum of Kshs. 3.6 Million. The Defendant did not receive the said money he can therefore not be condemned to pay that which he did not receive. Such a refund can only be reclaimed from Kenya Revenue Authority.
81. Addressing the other payments allegedly effected, starting with the monies sent to the 3rd Third Party, PW 1 confirmed that the 3rd Third Party was their joint agent. In absence of contradictory evidence, the court has no basis of directing a refund of the said sum, which payment is anchored on a totally different contract between the Plaintiffs and the 3rd Third Party. I further note that the remaining sums is either incidental costs or the estimated accrued interest. In the absence of receipts, the said sums of money cannot issue.
82. The second relief is an order for general damages. In the case of Hadley –vs- Baxendale (154) 9. Exch 214 where Anderson P. at page 354 stated as follows:
“Where two parties have made a contract which one of them has broken the damages which the other ought to receive should be such as may fairly and reasonably be considered either as arising naturally i.e. according to the usual course of things, from such breach itself, or such as may reasonably be supposed to have been in contemplation of both parties at the time they made a contract as the probable result of a breach of it.”
83. Damages for breach of contract are compensation to the aggrieved party and a restitution of what he has lost as a consequence to the breach. Breach of Contract is defined by the Black’s Law Dictionary 9th Ed. at page 213 as:
“Violation of a contractual obligation by failing to perform one's own promise, by repudiating it, or by interfering with another party's performance.”
84. As a general rule general damages are not recoverable in cases of alleged breach of contract-see Court of Appeal decision in Kenya Tourism Development Corporation Vs Sundowner Lodge Ltd 2018 eKLR. The reason for such was explained by the court in the case of Consolata Anyango Ouma vs. South Nyanza Sugar Co. Ltd (2015) eKLR as follows:
“As a general principle, the purpose of damages for breach of contract is, subject to mitigation of loss, the claimant is to be put as far as possible in the same position he would have been if the breach complained of had not occurred….”
85. From the above excerpt, the purpose of damages for breach of contract is, subject to mitigation of loss, to put the claimant as far as possible in the same position he would have been if the breach complained of had not occurred. Such damages are not damages at large or general damages but are in the nature of special damages and they must be pleaded and proved. This is principle is encapsulated in the Latin phrase restitution in integrum.
86. Parties are bound by their pleadings. It therefore follows that the Plaintiffs’ prayer for general damages for breach of contract fails.
87. It is however settled law that a claimant for damages for breach of contract who does not prove that he suffered loss is all the same entitled to damages, though nominal. In the Anson’s Law of Contract, 28th Edition at page 589 and 590 states that: -
“Every breach of a contract entitles the injured party to damages for the loss he or she has suffered. Damages for breach of contract are designed to compensate for the damage, loss or injury the claimant has suffered through that breach. A claimant who has not, in fact, suffered any loss by reason of that breach, is nevertheless entitled to a verdict but the damages recoverable will be purely nominal”.
88. As already noted, the Plaintiffs herein are entitled to damages for breach of contract subject to mitigation. Did the Plaintiffs mitigate their loss? My answer is in the negative. In any case, I note that the Plaintiffs have not accused the Defendant of fraud. The completion date of the transaction was supposed to be within 90 days from 7/5/2021 when the ‘agreement’ was executed. Noting that the first Deed of Variation was executed on 3/9/2021 way past the set timeline. The Plaintiffs did not adduce any evidence that they took any step towards realizing their rights after the lapse of the completion period but instead continued to effect payments thereof. It therefore follows that the Plaintiffs have not adduced any evidence proving that they tried to mitigate their loss.
89. In Kinakie Co-operative Society vs Green Hotel (1988) KLR 242, cited in the case of Peter Umbuku Muyaka v Henry Sitati Mmbasu [2018] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that; where damages are at large and cannot be quantified, the court may have to assess damages upon some conventional yardstick. But if a specific loss is to be compensated and the party was given a chance to prove the loss and did not he cannot have more than nominal damages – See Nyamogo & Nyamogo Advocates Vs Barclays Bank of Kenya Limited (2015) eKLR.
90. Considering that the subject property herein and in view of the prevailing economic circumstances, I am of the opinion that the Plaintiffs are entitled to nominal damages of Kshs. 2,000,000/=.
91. Lastly the Plaintiffs have sought for costs of the suit and interest thereon. The Court is granted discretion under Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act to award costs. Evidently, costs usually follow the events unless special circumstances present themselves.
92. It is my finding that the Plaintiffs are entitled to costs of the suit with interest from the date of this Judgment till payment in full.
Disposal orders
93. I therefore enter judgment in favour of the Plaintiffs against the Defendant and I issue the following orders:
a. Judgment is entered in favour of the Plaintiffs in the Sum of Kenya Shillings Seventeen Million Four Hundred Thousand (Kshs. 17,400,000.00) Only;
b. Normal damages in the sum of Kshs. 2,000,000/= [Kenya Shillings two Million only]
c. Interest on (a) and (b) above at court rates.
d. The Defendant shall bear costs of the suit to both the Plaintiff and the Third Parties herein.
94. It is so ordered.
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 4TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
1. Mr. Muteti H/B for Mr. Wanjohi for 1st and 2nd Plaintiffs
2. Mr. Seko for the Defendant
3. N/A for the 1st Interested Party
4. Mr. Njuguna for the 2nd Interested Party
5. Ms. Kipruto for the 3rd Interested Party
6. CA – Mr. Eglon