Background
By a petition dated 16.5.2024, the petitioner seeks:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a petition dated 16.5.2024, the petitioner seeks:
Paragraph 1 →The petitioner avers that not only have their property rights, as juxtaposed to the riparian section, never arisen; otherwise, it has a legitimate expectation that the issue of its boundary wall and the property has never been raised by the said authority and/or been subject to any challenge by any other body.
Paragraph 7 →The respondent had a legal and evidentiary burden to show that the public release order under the related directives of 2.5.2024 complied with the Constitution and the law. In the absence of evidence, the court finds that the provisions of Cap 57 are inconsistent with clear provisions of the constitutional architecture on land, the roles of the National Land Commission and the Cabinet Secretary in charge of lands.The court has no…
Paragraph 127 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
ELCEP PETITION NO. E015 OF 2024
MAC’S INVESTMENT LIMITED
T/A MAC’S PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED………..………………PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
THE CABINET SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF INTERIOR
& NATIONAL ADMINISTRATION……………...………..……1ST DEFENDANT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT…………….……2ND DEFENDANT
THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL………….…….3RD DEFENDANT
NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION………………..………….4TH DEFENDANT
JUDGMENT
Pleadings
1. By a petition dated 16.5.2024, the petitioner seeks:
a. Declaration that the Respondent’s actions and conduct in demolishing its property, LR NO. 209/8889 located at Dar es Salaam Road Industrial Area, Nairobi, amounted to denial, violation, and infringement of fundamental rights and freedoms under Articles 27(1), 40(3), 47(1) and 47(2) of the Constitution.
b. Declaration that the action and conduct of the order issued on 2.5.2024 by the 1st respondent are in breach of Article 47 of the Constitution and the Fair Administrative Action Act, and the rules of natural justice, and are therefore null and void.
c. An order of injunction barring the respondents jointly and severally acting through their agents or anyone under their instructions more so the Nairobi Regional and County Security team and the multi-agency team under the auspices of the National Disaster Operation Centre (NDOC) barring them from entering into, destroying, demolishing or in any other way interfering with the petitioner’s property LR No. 209/8889.
d. Order of compensation for breach of fundamental rights & Freedoms.
e. Order of restitution restoring the petitioner’s property LR No. 209/8889 to its current state.
f. In the alternative to prayer (V), order that the respondents do pay the petitioner the total cost for repair of any damage occasioned to LR No. 209/8889 as per a report to be presented thereto.
2. The facts as pleaded to the petitioner, which is a pharmaceutical company, are that the petitioner holds registered title to the real property LR No. 209/8889 before 7.5.1986 and has been in uninterrupted possession and enforcing associated rights ever since having purchased a two-storey building on the suit property, to use it as a warehouse, employing thousands of employees, who draw their livelihood since 1986.
3. The petitioner avers that on 2.5.2024, the respondent, through their employees, agents, or servants, visited the subject property and presented a document allegedly signed by his excellency, the Cabinet Secretary for Interior and National Administration, titled Public Security (Vacation or mandatory) evacuation orders by the Cabinet Secretary for Interior and National Coordination, asserting their intentions to demolish a portion of the building.
4. The petitioner avers that the 2nd respondent never provided an enforcement notice to it to stop any further alleged illegal development and remove any solid structures on grounds of illegal ownership of the aforesaid piece of land or alleging that the aforesaid land is on riparian land.
5. The Petitioner avers that the respondents persistently have interfered with the peaceful possession by threatening to demolish the said building on a nearly daily basis.
6. The petitioner avers that it was never accorded any notice from the National Environment Management Authority, as the plans on record were duly approved and neither has it been summoned to its National Environment Tribunal sitting at Nairobi.
7. The petitioner avers that not only have their property rights, as juxtaposed to the riparian section, never arisen; otherwise, it has a legitimate expectation that the issue of its boundary wall and the property has never been raised by the said authority and/or been subject to any challenge by any other body.
8. The petitioner avers that by a press release order dated 2.5.2024, the 1st respondent said that based on the order and directive, the 2nd respondent through the Nairobi Regional and County Security Team and Multi-agency under the auspice if the National Disaster Operation Centre(NDOC) have proceeded to demarcate the petitioner’s premises for demolition, which demolition has been scheduled to take place in due course.
9. Based on the said directive or orders, the petitioner avers that the 2nd respondent, through the Regional and County Security Team and the Multi-agency team under (NDOC), proceeded to demarcate the petitioner’s premises for demolition
10. It is averred that the imminent demolition, without allowing it to present its case and make submissions on the demolition contrary to article 47, article 27(1) and 40 of the Constitution, despite a binding judgment in National Environment Tribunal case no. 016 of 2018 as consolidated with National Environment Tribunal case no. 017, 018, 019, 022 and 023 of 2018,giving it rights to enjoy the Fundamental right suits of the judgment.
11. The petitioner pleads that the acts of the respondents threaten or infringe on its rights to ownership and protection of land, deprivation of the same without being allowed to be heard, condemnation without being heard or being given written reasons for the adverse decision, and breach of the right to equal protection and the benefits of the law, especially in view of the judgment aforereferenced
12. Further, the petitioner faults the notice of 24 hours for the demolition to take place, which notice amounts to abuse of power and lack of compliance with due process.
13. It states that there is non-compliance with laid down principles by the 2nd respondent as set out in Section 8 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act 2019 as read together with the Physical and Land Use Development Control Enforcement Regulations 2021.
14. The petitioner avers that the actions of the 1st and 2nd respondents in demolishing the subject property amount to arbitrary deprivation of land contrary to Article 40(3) of the Constitution, which guarantees it absolute ownership rights, possession and occupation of the land since 1979.
15. The petitioner reiterates that the said actions violate Article 47 of the Constitution, while the actions of the 2nd respondent violate Article 10(2)(d) of the Constitution; otherwise, the said decision is marred by opaqueness and mystery.
16. The petition is supported by an affidavit sworn by Mohamed Munir Chaudhri, a director, on 16.5.2024. The deponent describes himself as an advocate of the High Court of Kenya, aged fifty-four years
17. The deponent states that the petitioner has a title deed for the suit property issued on 7.5.1986, which it has enjoyed undisturbed possession and associated rights. The registered title and a copy of the survey map are attached as annexure MM(11)
18. The deponent says that the applicant is a pharmaceutical company, which purchased the two-storey building on the suit property to use as a warehouse and employs thousands of workers, who draw their livelihood from the company, as per attached photographs marked MM(12)
19. The deponent states that the petitioner on 2.5.2024 received the press release notice a copy attached as MM(13), expressing intention to demolish the building where after the petitioners dispatched a correspondence seeking particulars of the press release and which the respondents acknowledged receipt of but never made a response. A copy is attached as annexure marked MM(14)
20. The deponent states that the petitioner has never been accorded any notice from the National Environment Management Authority or summoned to the tribunal on the issue of the alleged riparian land raised by anybody regarding its boundary wall or property.
21. The deponent states that the petitioner has no knowledge that its parcel of land is on riparian land; more so, going by the deed plan and the survey map attached as annexure MM (15 & 16). The acts of the respondent are malicious.
22. The deponent states that the respondent’s decision and acts to repeatedly threaten demolition on an almost daily basis are not only unwarranted but also oppressive, unjust, and unfair and deny the petitioner the freedom, quiet enjoyment, or possession of legally acquired property, with no clear reasons for the administrative action.
23. The deponent states that the respondent’s acts of trespass are causing anxiety and pose a threat to many employees whose livelihood is at risk and that the respondent possesses no legitimate interest whatsoever in the subject property, other than the sole aim of harassing and extorting them.
24. The petition is opposed by the 1st and 3rd respondents through grounds of opposition dated 17.9.2026 that:
a. The press release dated 2.5.2024 was issued by the 1st respondent in exercise of its mandate under the Preservation of Public Safety Act, Cap 57, Laws of Kenya, to safeguard life and property due to the torrential rains that were being experienced in the country at the time.
b. The right under Article 47 alleged to have been violated by the respondents is not absolute and can be limited in exceptional circumstances, including emergency situations like flooding, where immediate action is necessary to protect life and property.
c. The 24-hour notice issued was proportionate to the imminent emergency caused by flooding in the country at the time, which necessitated the state to decide to protect human life and property.
d. The annexure MM3 attached to the supporting affidavit is evidence of the proximity of the development on the petitioner's parcel to the Nairobi River and the imminent danger to occupants and buildings if the waters broke.
e. Despite the proximity of the development on the petitioner's parcel to the Nairobi River, the petitioner has not adduced an Environmental Impact Assessment from NEMA authorizing the development on riparian reserve.
f. The development encroaches on riparian reserves.
g. The law provides that a riparian reserve is set at a minimum of 6 metres to a maximum of thirty metres from the highest watermark.
h. The law that allows for allocation of public land prohibits allocation of public land that is along watersheds, rivers and stream catchments, public water, reservoirs, lakes, beaches, fish landing areas, riparian and territorial sea.
i. The notice by the 1st respondent did not breach the petitioner's right to ownership, as the riparian land cannot be privately owned by the petitioner.
j. The government has a mandate to restore and reclaim riparian areas, wetland that may have been allocated back to the public ownership to ensure that they revert to the original state.
k. The directive complied with the said mandate.
l. The petition has no merit and is based on a misconception of the law.
23. The 4th respondent opposed the petition through grounds of opposition dated 20.2.2024 that:
a. The petition fails to demonstrate how the respondent acted illegally, arbitrarily, and unjustly, and how the petitioner's rights were violated to warrant intervention of the court.
b. Article 62 (1) (j) and (l) of the Constitution identifies all rivers, lakes and other water bodies together with all land between the high and low water marks as public land.
c. Section 12 (2) (c) of the Land Act prohibits the allocation of public land that is along watersheds, rivers and stream catchments, public water, reservoirs, lakes, beaches and fish landing areas, riparian areas, and the territorial sea.
d. The petitioner cannot acquire ownership rights in respect of riparian land, and any cultivation or development within the riparian land is prohibited; hence, it has no protection under Article 40 of the Constitution.
e. The petition is an abuse of the court process, as no fundamental rights and freedoms were violated.
f. The petition is devoid of merit.
25. The petition is also supported by a supplementary affidavit sworn on 1.10.2024 by the petitioner's director. He deposes that the petitioner obtained the requisite approvals from the then Municipal Council of Nairobi to build the storey building, as evidenced by duly signed documents by the then town clerk as per annexure marked MMC(18). It is deposed that there has never been any objection that the building is erected on riparian ground.
26. The deponent states that the deed plan and the survey map do not show that the suit property is situated on or is close to the riparian land as claimed by the respondents.
27. This petition was directed to be canvassed through written submissions whose deadline to file was 17th October 2026. None was filed by the parties.
28. Having gone through the pleadings, the issues calling for my determination are whether the petition meets the constitutional threshold, whether the respondents had justification under the Constitution to issue the notice of demolition, whether the petition has proved breach of the alleged constitutional rights, whether the petition is entitled to the reliefs sought, and what is the order as to costs.
29. The party seeking constitutional reliefs on alleged breach of the Constitution or fundamental rights and freedoms must meet the constitutional threshold of a constitutional cause of action both in form and substance. In Communications Commission of Kenya v Royal Media Services Limited & 9 others (Civil Application 9 of 2014) [2014] KESC 51 (KLR) (11 April 2014) (Ruling) the court cited Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic (Miscellaneous Criminal Application 4 of 1979) [1979] KEHC 30 (KLR) (Crim) (29 January 1979) (Judgment), on the necessity of precision, specificity, and on the linkage between the aggrieved party, the provisions of the Constitution alleged to have been contravened and the manifeslate of contravention and/or infringement.
30. The court said that such a principle plays a positive role as a foundation of conviction and good faith in engaging the constitutional process of dispute settlement.
31. In Mwakaneno v Registrar of Titles, Mombasa & 7 others (Civil Appeal E104 of 2022) [2026] KECA 296 (KLR) (20 February 2026) (Judgment), the court said it is not enough to plead broadly and generally without distinctly identifying the specific respondent who committed the alleged unconstitutional act. The court said that there must be particulars of how the respondent's conduct resulted in the violation of a specific constitutional article and by whom.
32. The court held that, whilst differentiating the roles, decision or omission attributable to each respondent, or mapping out the alleged violations in accordance with identifiable constitutional provisions, or the particular actor, rendered the petition incompetent. The court also termed the prayers sought as not only far-reaching but also extensive, without being anchored on precisely pleaded violations, demonstrating how the factual allegations satisfied the constitutional standard required to justify such a relief.
33. The court said that although the petition cited numerous constitutional provisions, alleged numerous, multiple forms of violation of rights and sought extensive constitutional and proprietary remedies, it clearly failed to set out with the level of clarity and specificity demanded in constitutional litigation.
34. A constitutional petition must raise constitutional issues or questions. Such a test requires the determination or resolution of the issues or questions to rest solely on the Constitution and not a statute. Courts abhor the practice of parties converting every issue or statutory breach into a constitutional question.
35. The filing of suits disguised as constitutional petitions when, in fact, they do not fall anywhere close to a violation of constitutional rights, as was held in CNM v WMG [2018] KEHC 8434 (KLR) and in Kenyatta v Nairobi Star Publications Ltd (Petition 187 of 2012) [2013] KEHC 6084 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (5 April 2013) (Ruling), and Kenya Bus Services Ltd & 2 others v Attorney General (Miscellaneous Civil Suit 413 of 2005) [2005] KEHC 3187 (KLR) (Civ) (10 June 2005)
36. In Abdulkarim v Arrow Motors (EA) Ltd & another (Petition 367 of 2016) [2017] KEHC 9674 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (14 December 2017) (Judgment), a constitutional question was defined as an issue whose resolution requires the interpretation of a constitution rather than a statute. The court said that when determining whether an argument raises a constitutional issue, the court is not strictly concerned with whether the argument will be successful but whether it forces the court to consider constitutional rights or values.
37. A constitutional petition must also surmount the doctrine of exhaustion, as held in Adega & 2 others v Kibos Distillers Ltd & 5 others (Petition 3 of 2020) [2020] KESC 36 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (4 August 2020) (Ruling)
38. In Benjamin v Attorney General & 55 others (Petition E042 of 2024) [2026] KESC 5 (KLR) (23 January 2026) (Judgment),the court reaffirmed the principles the principles to apply on the doctrine of exhaustion as set out in the Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 others (Sued on their own Behalf and on Behalf of Predecessors and or Successors in Title in their Capacities as the Registered Trustees of Kenya Ports Authority Pensions Scheme) v Munyao & 148 others (Suing on their own Behalf and on Behalf of the Plaintiffs and other Members/Beneficiaries of the Kenya Ports Authority Pension Scheme) (Civil Appeal 38 of 2014) [2016] KECA 160 (KLR) (26 February 2016) (Judgment), as well as Adega & 2 others v Kibos Distillers Ltd & 5 others (Petition 3 of 2020) [2020] KESC 36 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (4 August 2020) (Ruling) (ssupra), and in Nicholas Abitha vs AG and others SC Petition No.E007 OF 2023.
39. The court held that the doctrine of exhaustion is not to be applied by the courts as a blanket principle so as to impede or startle the right of access to the court by applicants for redress of alleged constitutional violations in a manner that frustrates the enforcement of fundamental rights and freedoms.
40. The court emphasized that the availability of an alternative remedy does not necessarily bar an individual from seeking constitutional redress, since the act of seeking constitutional relief is contingent upon the adequacy of an existing alternative means of redress, and that if the alternative forum is inadequate in addressing the issues at hand, then the court is not restrained from providing constitutional relief.
41. The court held that a court must scrutinize the purpose for which a party is seeking relief in court by determining whether the granting of such a constitutional relief is appropriate in the given circumstances.
42. The court said that the overarching consideration must always remain that of safeguarding a party's right of access to justice, while at the same time acknowledging the efficiency and specificity that established alternative dispute mechanisms and other statutory pathways provided by the statutes.
43. In a constitutional petition, the burden is on the petitioner to prove its allegation on a balance of probabilities. In Gwer & 5 others v Kenya Medical Research Institute & 3 others (Petition 12 of 2019) [2020] KESC 66 (KLR) (Civ) (10 January 2020) (Judgment), the court underscored the principle that the burden of proof lies with the party alleging a constitutional violation. The court said that a litigant who would fail in the absence of evidence bears the obligation to place sufficient proof before the court.
44. Further, in Wamwere & 5 others v Attorney General (Petition 26, 34 & 35 of 2019 (Consolidated)) [2023] KESC 3 (KLR) (27 January 2023) (Judgment), the court said that a petitioner bears the burden to prove his alleged threat or violation of fundamental rights and freedoms on a balance of probabilities on the alleged right, deprivation or breach of the right, manner of breach and the loss occasioned by the breach.
45. In Mwakaneno v Registrar of Titles, Mombasa & 7 others (Civil Appeal E104 of 2022) [2026] KECA 296 (KLR) (20 February 2026) (Judgment) [Supra], the court said that without any scintilla of evidentiary support, the trial court was left without a factual foundation upon which it could interrogate or determine the alleged constitutional violation.
46. The court said the failure by the petitioner to adduce sufficient evidence to substantiate the contents of the petition was a substantive defect that went to the root of the petition and was therefore not a procedural technicality.
47. Applying the foregoing binding principles and considerations to this petition, the question is whether the petitioner has surmounted all the above hurdles to be entitled to the reliefs sought. The first issue is whether the petitioner has a disclosed constitutional cause of action, as the respondents argue none has been disclosed.
48. What amounts to a cause of action in a constitutional petition was discussed in Claasen v Commissioner of Lands & 4 others (Civil Appeal 85 of 2016) [2019] KECA 766 (KLR) (9 May 2019) (Judgment). The court said that a cause of action generally denotes a combination of facts which entitle a person to obtain a remedy in court from another person and includes a right of a person violated or threatened with violation by another person.
49. In this petition, the petitioner pleads that it is the owner of LR No. 209/8889, which the respondents earmarked for demolition within twenty-four hours of the release orders, followed by a warning dated 2.5.2024 alleging that the suit land falls within a riparian reserve. The petitioner faults that notice as incapable of meeting the constitutional tests, for it holds a constitutionally protected right which cannot be taken away otherwise than in accordance with the Constitution.
50. To substantiate the same, the petitioner has attached documentary evidence on both ownership and approvals for developing the land, which the respondents have not impeached by way of rival affidavit evidence. Grounds of opposition in law address only issues of law as opposed to facts. In Kennedy Otieno Odiyo & 12 Others V Kenya Electricity Generating Company Limited [2010] KEHC 282 (KLR), the court said that grounds of opposition were general averments. The court said that in the absence of a replying affidavit rebutting the averments in the supporting affidavit, it meant the respondent had nothing to counter the claim brought against it by the applicant.
51. In Mohammed & Another vs. Haidara [1972] EA 166, the court said that since the respondent had filed no replying affidavit to counter the allegations in the supporting affidavit, given any material facts or specifically denied the contents of the supporting affidavit, the content thereof remained unrebutted. Affidavit evidence, if not refuted by way of a replying affidavit, remains uncontroverted. A presumption can also be drawn in law that the facts as pleaded remained unchallenged, as held in Phillip Tirop Kitur v Attorney General [2018] eKLR.
52. That perse does not mean, however, that the court must take the probative value of the averred factual evidence without interrogating its veracity, credibility, and relevance. The petitioner has provided a title to its property, deed plan, and survey maps showing that it was validly issued with a title deed and later on, its development plans were approved by the respondent.
53. Using these annexures, the petitioner pleads, submits, and urges the court that it is the absolute owner of the suit land in the absence of contrary evidence or report to impeach the title and the development approvals determined to be defeasible or invalid by a competent authority, as provided by the Constitution and the statutes, including on the ground that the land falls within a riparian area, as alleged in the demolition notice.
54. The petitioner says that, other than the notice, no lawfully obtained report or basis or justification in law has been laid as evidence by the respondents for the court to make a positive finding not only on the propriety, legality and constitutionality of the said notice, but also to return a verdict that indeed the respondents were constitutionally and statutorily justified in issuing the said notice.
55. In Milimani Splendor Management Limited v National Environment Management Authority & 4 others (Petition 61 of 2018) [2019] KEELC 1225 (KLR) (11 October 2019) (Judgment), the court defined a river to include the bed, the bank, the adjacent land as well as the flood plain. The court said that in determining a riparian reserve, one of the factors is whether the river has a well-defined channel. The court, having reviewed the existing law on what a riparian area or reserve is, held that that finding or determination can only be scientifically established by way of a base map and other cadastral drawings from the relevant government agencies established under various laws.
56. As a demonstration of what the law says of riparian areas, Rule 111 of the Survey Regulations, 1994 provides for a reservation of not less than 30 meters.
57. Rule 6(c) of the EMCA (Water Quality) Regulations, 2006 prohibits certain activities within the full width of a river or stream, from a minimum of 6 meters and a maximum of 30 meters on either side, based on the highest recorded flood level.
58. Section 28 (c), (d), and (h) of the Land Registration Act define overriding interests. Physical Land Use Planning Act prohibit or control use and development of some areas. It is the Director of Physical Planning who can map and document disaster-prone areas, riparian areas, open spaces, parks and river deltas.
59. The respondents have invoked the Preservation of Public Security Act, Cap 57, as the basis upon which it issued the press release order of 2.5.2024 to protect the safety of persons and property. Preservation of public security under Section 2 of the Act includes securing the safety of persons and property, and the fundamental rights and freedoms of an individual. Under Section 3 of the Act, it requires the notice to be published in the Kenya Gazette under the authority of the President or Cabinet Secretary, declaring when it will come into force and in which part thereof.
60. Any notice under Section 3(3) is subject to the provisions of the Constitution. It requires regulations to be made for the preservation of public security. The regulations are not supposed to be inconsistent with any other provision of the Constitution or to amend, modify or suspend the operation of any written law.
61. Under Section 4 of the Act, the regulations may relate to the compulsory acquisition, requisition, control or disposition of any movable or immovable property or undertaking. Section 5 of the Act defines subsidiary legislation to mean any regulation under this Act and any rule or order made under such regulation. Section 6 of the Act requires that such regulation be laid before the two Houses of the National Assembly as soon as it is made.
62. Section 7 of the Act defines the jurisdictional areas of the subsidiary legislation. Section 8 of the Act defines proof of the instrument which must be certified. The Act is silent on riparian land or its recovery measures.
63. Article 62(1)(h) of the Constitution does not define riparian land, land between the high and low water marks, areas, or reserves. It leaves the delineation to an Act of Parliament, as was held in the Kiluwa case.
64. Article 40(2)(a) and (b) of the Constitution provide that Parliament shall not enact a law that permits the state or any person to arbitrarily deprive a person of property of any description or of any interest in or right over property of any description, or to limit or in any way restrict the enjoyment of any right under this article based on any ground specified or contemplated in Article 27(4). Article 27 speaks to equality before the law and equal protection and equal benefit of the law. Article 40(6) states that the rights under this Article do not extend to any property that has been found to have been unlawfully acquired.
65. Security of land rights is one of the principles of land policy under Article 60(1)(b). Article 66(1) refers to regulation of land use and property with a view to the interest of defence, public safety, public order, public morality, public health or land use planning. In this matter, the respondent invokes the safety of human beings and property due to flooding as the basis for issuing the demolition notice.
66. In Kiluwa Limited & another v Business Liaison Company Limited & 3 others (Petition 14 of 2017) [2021] KESC 37 (KLR) (6 August 2021) (Judgment), the court said that Article 62(1)(l) did not refer to the 60 meters above the high water mark. The court said that the Constitution leaves it to an Act of Parliament, hence the relevance of Regulation 110(1) of the Survey Regulations, 1994 and Section 45 of the Survey Act. Section 82 of the repealed Government Land Act.
67. The court said that government would only interfere with or limit such easement only in promotion or protection of the public interest as guaranteed by the Constitution and the law.
68. The court said that Article 47 is in normative terms to provide for efficient administration, and the basis for review of administrative action is on account of expedition, efficiency, lawfulness, and procedural fairness, a right that has been perfected by the enactment of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
69. In this petition, the respondents have not produced any survey report, survey map, deed plan, or scientific report or other evidence conferring riparian status on the parcel of land belonging to the petitioner, or proving that it is part of, or falls within, the riparian area, and to form the basis of the issuance of the demolition notice.
70. More importantly, there is no evidence that the building poses danger, was the cause of, and is likely to cause, any flooding.The burden in law is on he who alleges the existence or non-existence of certain facts to find a right or liability, as provided in Section 107-112 of the Evidence Act. In the Kiluwa case [supra], the court cited Tony Honoré in Responsibility and Fault [Hart Publishing, 1999] at page 101 that the imposition of liability in civil cases requires a judicial determination that the defendant's conduct falls within legally recognized categories of fault applicable in that specific cause of action.
71. Article 47 of the Constitution focuses on the legality, reasonableness, and fairness of government actions to uphold compliance with legality and good governance. The petitioner urges the court to find that the acts of the respondents violated its constitutional rights and freedoms under the cited laws. As held in Gwer & 5 others v Kenya Medical Research Institute & 3 others (Petition 12 of 2019) [2020] KESC 66 (KLR) (Civ) (10 January 2020) (Judgment) [supra] and in Wamwere & 5 others v Attorney General (Petition 26, 34 & 35 of 2019 (Consolidated)) [2023] KESC 3 (KLR) (27 January 2023) (Judgment) (supra), the burden is on the petitioner to prove on a balance of probability that its rights and freedoms were violated, in fact that the acts of the respondents fell short of the constitutional requirements under Article 47 and Article 10, 47 and 25 of the Constitution.
72. In Muriithi (Representative of the Estate of Mwangi Stephen Muriithi) v Janmohamed SC (Executrix of Estate of Daniel Arap Moi) & another (Petition 41 of 2018) [2023] KESC 61 (KLR) (30 June 2023) (Judgment) (with dissent - MK Ibrahim & N Ndungu, SCJJ), the majority held that the Preservation of Public Security Act empowered the Minister responsible for internal security to issue an order on account of public security. The court termed the denial of the right to habeas corpus as a classic case of rule by law instead of rule of law. The court said that the Bill of Rights was a non-derogable covenant which could not be legislated away or ousted by Parliament.
73. The Preservation of Public Security Act, Chapter 57, shows that any such subsidiary legislation to be constitutionally and statutorily valid must be subjected to Parliament as soon as possible. There is no evidence that the press release notice was based on a gazetted subsidiary legislation or presented to Parliament for approval. Other than the notice, the respondents have not shared with the court a certified copy of any order or notice duly gazetted, presented and approved by Parliament in compliance with the law.
74. Article 94(5) and (6) of the Constitution provide that no person or body other than Parliament has power to make provisions having the force of law except under the authority conferred by the Constitution or legislation.
75. Sub-article (6) states that legislation that confers on any state organ, state officer or person the authority to make provisions having the force of law in Kenya should expressly specify the purpose and objects for which that authority is conferred, the limits of the authority, the nature and scope of the law that may be made and the principles and standards applicable to the law made under the authority.
76. A statutory instrument under Cap 2A means, inter alia, any rule, order, regulation, direction issued, made or established in the execution of a power conferred by or under an Act of Parliament, under which that statutory instrument or subsidiary legislation is expressly authorized to be issued.
77. Black's Law Dictionary, 9th Edition, at page 1164, defines a notice as a legal notification required by law or as a result of some fact, imparted by operation of law, intended to reach a particular person or the public, notice that is legally adequate given the particular circumstance.
78. In Matindi v National Assembly & 4 others (Petition E006 of 2025) [2026] KESC 56 (KLR) (17 July 2026) (Judgment), the court said that a legal notice on its part operationalizes broad statutory mandates, made under delegated authority by statute and published in the Kenya Gazette or Gazette supplement through which legally binding rules, orders, exempting regulations or other statutory measures are formally promulgated.
79. Section 5 of the Fair Administrative Action Act provides that administrative action or decisions are executive in character and, where necessary, should be subjected to public participation where any proposed administrative action is likely to materially and adversely affect the legal rights and interests of a group of people or the general public.
80. In British American Tobacco Kenya PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 4 others; Mastermind Tobacco Kenya Ltd (Affected Party) (Petition 5 of 2017) [2019] KESC 15 (KLR) (26 November 2019) (Judgment), the court said that a statutory instrument must be evaluated and interrogated through factual evidence to determine whether it was exempted, required, and published.
81. In Republic v Attorney General; Law Society of Kenya (Interested Party); Moriasi (Ex parte) (Judicial Review Miscellaneous Application 364 of 2018) [2019] KEHC 7013 (KLR) (4 June 2019) (Judgment), the court said that not all the guidelines, orders or directions by the Honourable Attorney General were legislative in character.
82. In Law Society of Kenya versus Attorney General and Others, ELC Petition No. 2 of 2023, the court said that a cabinet dispatch amounted to communication of policy position by the government and could not amount to the exercise of legislative powers.
83. In Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission & another v Ojienda & 2 others (Petition 30 & 31 of 2019 (Consolidated)) [2022] KESC 59 (KLR) (7 October 2022) (Judgment), the court said that an administrative action must promote efficient administration and, as per the Constitution, it relates to the management of affairs of an institution, organisation or agency.
84. In Cabinet Secretary for the National Treasury and Planning & 4 others v Okoiti & 52 others; Bhatia (Amicus Curiae) (Petition E031, E032 & E033 of 2024 (Consolidated)) [2024] KESC 63 (KLR) (29 October 2024) (Judgment), the court said that administrative action is the application or implementation of law to specific factual circumstances, while administrative powers are generally lower-level powers exercised to implement the law, not its creation.
85. Powers of Cabinet Secretaries are generally provided under Article 153(2) and Article 153(2) and (4) of the Constitution. They must act in accordance with the Constitution under Article 153(4)(a) of the Constitution. The powers and functions of the Cabinet Secretary in charge of matters relating to land are set out in Section 6 of the Land Act. Regarding public land management, the Constitution vests such land in the custody of the National Land Commission on behalf of the national and county governments.
86. Section 8 of the Land Act provides that the National Land Commission shall identify public land, prepare and keep a database, geo-reference and authenticate it through the statutory body responsible for land surveying.
87. Section 11 of the Land Act mandates the NLC to take appropriate actions to maintain public land in critical habitats or protected areas, including identifying ecologically sensitive areas to prevent environmental degradation and climate change.
88. Section 12(3)(a), (b) and (c) mandates the National Land Commission to identify land falling alongside watersheds, river and stream catchments, public water reservoirs, lakes, beaches, fish land areas, riparian and territorial seas as may be prescribed by law.
89. Section 12A of the Land Act defines controlled land as land within a zone of twenty-five kilometers from the inland national boundary of Kenya, within the first and second rows from high water marks of the Indian Ocean, and any other land as may be declared controlled land under any law or statute.
90. Transactions involving controlled land must be sanctioned by written approval from the Cabinet Secretary. Gazettement of reserve land is governed by Section 15 of the Land Act. Section 124 of the Land Act relates to powers to obtain temporary occupation of land by the National Land Commission in the public interest, to determine public safety, public order, public morality, public health, urban planning, or for public benefits.
91. Section 124(1)(c) provides that the necessity therefore is such as to afford reasonable justification for the causing of any hardship that may result to persons having an interest or right over the property, and so certifies in writing, possession of such land may be taken for that period under this section.
92. The law provides that the National Land Commission shall serve a seven-day notice on every person interested or who claims to be interested in the land, or on such of them as, after reasonable inquiry, are known to it.
93. Section 131 of the Act relates to service of notices. Section 152(C) relates to eviction notice to unlawful occupants of public land. It is the National Land Commission that is mandated to issue the requisite notice in writing, by notice in the Kenya Gazette and in one newspaper with national circulation, at least those within its environs.
94. Section 152 of the Act allows any person served with a notice to approach the court for reliefs. Section 152(1) of the Act is the law on demolition of unauthorized structures. It is only a competent officer who has the authority to order the person in whose instance the erection or work began or was carried out to demolish the building or works within such a period as may be specified in the order.
95. Section 155 of the Act relates to unlawful occupation of land, including erecting any building on public land. It is the National Land Commission that is mandated to issue a notice in the prescribed form to show cause why the person should not be required to vacate that land within a specified time, giving him a right to be heard.
96. Any person served with the notice should, within sixty (60) days, show cause, in default of which, after the court confirms the notice, the intruder must comply with the notice.
97. Wrongful obstruction or encroachment on any right of way is governed by Section 156. It is an offence to encroach on a public right of way. Under Section 160 of the Act, it is only the Cabinet Secretary in charge of land matters and the National Land Commission who can make regulations generally. In particular it is the National Land Commission under Section 160(2)(b) may make regulations to prevent and manage land-based disasters and to provide for settlement in the event of natural disaster.
98. From the foregoing analysis of the applicable law, it leaves no doubt that the Constitution and the land laws have no provision for the Cabinet Secretary in charge of Internal Security or any other body under its jurisdiction to deal with public land. The framers of the Kenyan Constitution delegated that power to the National Land Commission to deal with and manage public land for and on behalf of the county and national governments.
99. The Cabinet Secretary in charge of land under the Land Registration Act who constitutes, by gazette, areas of land registration units and offers policy oversight. Cadastral maps are under the custody of the Director of Survey.
100. Overriding interests under Section 28 of the Land Registration Act, including canals, aqueducts, weirs and dams, and other rights, fall under the registration of the Land Registrar; alongside the Director of Survey, they can determine boundaries and give cogent reports on what land abuts, falls, or is riparian land.
101. It is the Cabinet Secretary, under Section 79 of the Land Registration Act, who can make regulations on rectification of the title register, regarding rectification of titles, investigation, hearing, and criteria for coming up with a decision. Section 87 of the Act defines the meaning of an opportunity of being heard before a particular thing is to be or may be done under the Act. The minimum notice is seven days.
102. The National Land Commission Act defines the Cabinet Secretary as the one responsible for matters relating to land. The National Land Commission funds are set out under Section 5 of the Act. Section 14 of the Act allows the National Land Commission to review grants and dispositions of land, including on private land initially part of public land.
103. The Presidential Executive Order No. 1 of 2023, dated January 2023, at page 7 sets out the jurisdiction of the Cabinet Secretary for Internal Security, while page 31 sets out the jurisdiction of the Cabinet Secretary for Lands.
104. The said executive order confers no powers on matters of land ownership or the classification, inquiry, or determination of what is private or public land on the Cabinet Secretary in charge of interior and national security generally and in particular during times of natural disasters, emergencies, or catastrophes. The doctrine of regularity of acts of public officers in this case has been disapproved by the law, and the inability of the respondents to file affidavits to justify their actions as within the law and the Constitution.
105. Anything done outside the Constitution remains unconstitutional, and a nullity ab initio.Acting ultra vires includes making a decision or order one has no mandate to make. In Anisminic v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 2 A.C. 14, the court held that where a decision is found to be in excess of or made without jurisdiction, there is strictly no need to quash it, since it is a nullity. In MacFoy v United Africa Company Limited [1961] 3 ALL E.R. 1169, the court said that if an act is void, then it is in law a nullity. It is automatically null and void, and that every proceeding founded on it is also bad; otherwise, you cannot put something on nothing and expect it to stay there without collapsing.
106. In Dande & 3 others v Inspector General, National Police Service & 5 others (Petition 6 (E007), 4 (E005) & 8 (E010) of 2022 (Consolidated)) [2023] KESC 40 (KLR) (16 June 2023) (Judgment), the court said that when a party approaches a court under the Constitution, the court can carry out a merit review of the case. Article 47 of the Constitution.
107. In Judicial Service Commission v Mutava & another (Civil Appeal 52 of 2014) [2015] KECA 741 (KLR) (8 May 2015) (Judgment), Article 47 of the constitution was described as aimed at making an important and transformative development of administrative justice, for it not only lays a constitutional foundation for control of the power of state organs and other administrative bodies, but also entrenches the right to fair administrative action in the Bill of Rights as a reflection of national values and principles under Article 10, such as the rule of law, human dignity, social justice, good governance, transparency and accountabilityThe court said Article aims to subject all administrative actions of public officers, state organs and other administrative bodies to Article 47. The Court said that under Article 47(2), the right to be given written reasons for a decision is a matter of right where a party is likely to be adversely affected by the administrative decision.
108. From the material before the Court, the respondents had no jurisdiction under Cap 57 to deal with matters falling within the jurisdiction of the Cabinet Secretary in charge of land matters and the National Land Commission. Neither the Constitution nor the laws governing land in Kenya grant powers to the Cabinet Secretary for Internal Security to issue such drastic orders that impede the right to property ownership in the name of public security and security of property. It would have been easier if the notice was given by the Cabinet Secretary for Lands.
109. A party alleging breach of constitutional rights and freedoms or violation must do more than cite constitutional provisions. He must identify the specific right, the manner of violation, and provide the material facts constituting the breach by evidence. The petitioner has pleaded and produced exhibits to show that it legally, procedurally, and formally became registered and obtained title to the suit land free from any encumbrance. Once the said exhibits were availed, the evidential burden, as held in Raila Odinga versus IEBC [2013] KLR, shifted to the respondents to point out any specific legal processes which the court can use as a basis that the suit property and the title were irregularly obtained and cannot enjoy constitutional protection under Article 40(6) of the Constitution.
110. He who alleges must prove. When there are two competing interests over the same piece of land, each party has the burden to show a clear root of title without any break in the chain of acquisition. The respondents' grounds, in the absence of evidentiary material, remain mere statements with no probative value. Further, the petitioner, concerning development, has produced exhibits whose authenticity and reliability the respondents have not questioned, to show that it has presented development plans which were formally, legally and procedurally approved by the different authorities under the law.
111. With all these legally obtained ownership and development approvals documents, the petitioner alleges that the acts of the respondents to threaten to demolish its development on the subject property, while lacking fair hearing, fair administrative action and the right to protection of property, undermine Articles 10, 27, 40 and 47 of the Constitution as read together with the Fair Administrative Action Act.
112. Article 47 of the Constitution, as held in Judicial Service Commission v Mutava & another (Civil Appeal 52 of 2014) [2015] KECA 741 (KLR) (8 May 2015) (Judgment) [supra], places an obligation on anyone who undertakes an administrative action likely to adversely affect a legal right of another to give him notice, fair hearing and written reasons for the decision made.
113. The petitioner says that other than the press release order, there was no adequate notice given, opportunity given to make representations before the adverse decision was made, chance given to appeal or seek review, or written reasoning given on the basis that its development fell on riparian land.
114. When called upon to address the allegations, on oath, the respondent opted to file grounds of opposition and a preliminary objection. There is no evidence tendered by the respondent that, before the impugned decision, order or press release was made, the dictates of Article 47 of the Constitution as read together with the provisions of the Fair Administrative Action Act were followed.
115. Article 40(6) of the Constitution provides that the right to protection of property under the Article does not extend to any property that has been found to have been unlawfully acquired. The keywords in this Article are that such a property or title has been found to have been unlawfully acquired.
116. As at the time the notice, order or press release was made, there is no evidence from the respondents, as alleged in the grounds of opposition, that due process was followed, material presented and a fair hearing conducted to reach a finding that the petitioner's development and title formed part of riparian land or area, and a definite notice given under Section 152 of the Land Act to vacate the land.
117. For the acts of the respondents to be justified, there must be proof that the petitioner's building poses a real threat to the environment, danger to human life and health, to fully justify demolition. There must be justification to issue a demolition notice. This could only be demonstrated by the respondents by availing evidence that the title held by the petitioner was irregularly or unprocedurally obtained, the land covers a riparian area, the development approvals were unlawfully obtained, or the developer acted fraudulently and in defiance of the law.
118. Threatening to demolish an approved building on a protected title legally obtained under the law was itself a threat to the rights of the holder of title whose sanctity is protected by law. In Anami & 2 others (Suing as Officials of Rhapta Road Residents Association) v County Executive Committee Member(CECM) Built Environment and Urban Planning, Nairobi City County & 20 others (Environment and Planning Petition E030 of 2024) [2025] KEELC 128 (KLR) (23 January 2025) (Judgment), the court said that demolition is an exceptional and a last resort remedy.
119. The court said that the effects of demolition are permanent and cannot be reversed, for they permanently affect property rights guaranteed under Article 40 of the Constitution and are accompanied by vicious financial effects on innocent third parties.
120. The court said that demolition must be tested against the Constitution on its effectiveness, necessity, rationality, proportionality, justice, equitability and consistency with the rule of law, property and environmental rights.
121. It is the respondents who are invoking the doctrine of public land and security. Eminent domain is a concept in law that provides that the government has the power to take private property for public use, provided they compensate the owners fairly. This principle is based on the notion that private rights are subordinate to the needs of society.
122. The concept is now grounded in Article 40(3) of the Constitution. Property acquired in this sense would be for public benefit. Even where it suits the need, the process is regulated by statute and constitutional provisions that outline how and when the government can exercise such a power.
123. In County Government of Meru v M’Muktha (Civil Appeal 28 of 2019) [2024] KECA 1616 (KLR) (8 November 2024) (Judgment), the court said that there are typically procedural safeguards to ensure the owner receives due process and just compensation to avoid loss from the acquisition.
124. The Preservation of Public Security Act, under which the respondents rely, was enacted on 8.1.1960 to make provisions for the preservation of public security. It defines public security to include the security of the safety of persons and property and the provisions of administrative and remedial measures during periods of actual or apprehensible national danger or calamity, or in consequence of any disaster or destruction arising from natural causes.
125. Section 3 relates to public security regulations, for the preservation of public security, while Section 4 relates to special public security regulations. Section 5 is the interpretation of Section 3, which means subsidiary legislation under the Act. Section 6 states clearly on what the subsidiary legislation must be laid before House of parliament as form as they are made. The subsidiary regulations under section 7 are subject to the Constitution.
126. Proof of the instrument is captured under section 8 of the Act.
127. The respondent had a legal and evidentiary burden to show that the public release order under the related directives of 2.5.2024 complied with the Constitution and the law. In the absence of evidence, the court finds that the provisions of Cap 57 are inconsistent with clear provisions of the constitutional architecture on land, the roles of the National Land Commission and the Cabinet Secretary in charge of lands.The court has no hesitation in finding that the petitioner has on a balance of probabilities proved the petition.
128. Any process of eviction or demolition must comply with constitutional regulations and statutory safeguards protecting the rights and dignity of affected persons. These principles were set out in Kenya Railways Corporation v Bilal & 14 others (Petition E023 of 2025) [2026] (KLR) (23 October 2026) (Judgment). The court reaffirmed the principles in Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v Kenya Airports Authority & 3 others (Petition 3 of 2018) [2021] KESC 34 (KLR) (11 January 2021) (Judgment) that the absence of a formal title does not automatically remove constitutional protection from persons who have established homes and families in public land; since the residents may possess constitutionally protectable interests under Articles 40, 43 and 60 of the Constitution, depending on the circumstances.
129. In Anami & 2 others (Suing as Officials of Rhapta Road Residents Association) v County Executive Committee Member (CECM) Built Environment and Urban Planning, Nairobi City County & 19 others (Petition E044 of 2025) [2026] KESC 78 (KLR) (30 October 2026) (Judgment)the court termed demolition as an exceptional remedy which should be given as a last resort, for it has a poetnial to impact severely upon constitutionally protected property rights under artivel 40 of the constitution, meaning that courts must execise extreme restraint to sanction the same. the court said that there must be clear proof of active defiance of stop orders or an imminent structural peril.
130. As to whether the petitioner has proved justification for appropriate reliefs under Article 23(3), the grounds are broad and discretionary. A court looks at the nature of the violation, impact of the violation on the victim, length of time the alleged violation took, and the broader implication of the case, including the need to deter future violation, to uphold the rule of law and to ensure public authorities respect constitutional rights. See Mohamed Ali Baadi and others v Attorney General & 11 others [2018] KEHC 5397 (KLR) (Petition 22 of 2012), decided on 30 April 2018.
131. The purpose of appropriate reliefs in a constitutional petition is to vindicate the right, the constitutional provisions, and to detr any future breach, as held in Imanyara versus hon attorney general sc petition no 15 of 2017, and in Wamwere and others versus attorney general sc petition no 26,34 and 35 of 2019. It also seeks to influence government behavior to secure strict compliance in the future, which would promote good governance, as held in City of Vancouver v. Canada, (2010) 2 SCR 28.
132. The petitioner has pleaded loss, damage and injury in general terms. It has not led evidence on the nature, particulars, and the manifestation of the loss. No written submissions were filed to address the parameters and the extent of the loss, damage, and injury. Guided by the foregoing case law, the court finds the petitioner is only entitled to prayers (I), (II) and (III). Costs to the petitioner.
133. Orders accordingly.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 4th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
….…………………
HON. JUSTICE C.K NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Mr.Bruno for the petitioner
Mr. Kamau for the 1st & 3rd respondents
Mr. Mbuthia for the 4th respondent
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn N